The drug companies are no saints.
However, stating their shortcomings still does nothing to prove that the alternative therapies have any benefit other than as a placebo. Just because there are problems with one doesn't mean the other one suddenly has real benefits.
Some people get sicker from mainstream therapy, but in general a much, much larger percentage of people still get some benefit. The watered down "pathic" concoctions (I understand how some herbal therapies have been developed/refined into real medicines) never did nor ever will provide any real therapy.
Just because an herbal medicine or an "alternative procedure" hasn't been studied by Science
doesn't mean it doesn't work. . It doesn't mean it does work either, but no sane person debates that.
Homeopathy doesn't have science behind it and has been studied extensively. Great. Junk from a scientific point-of-view. I'm glad Science caught up with it.
I take an herb for a condition I have which works like clockwork. It is in fact almost a lifesaver for me.
Science hasn't studied it. Should I go off of it onto some super powerful prescription drug which have enormous side effects and cost 10X more? No. Only an idiot or worshipper of Big Pharma would.
That's where so many of you shrieking nuts who scream about snake oil lose me and plenty of other people. If it works for me, even if it's a "placebo", why do I need to prove it to you or anyone else? In the realm of free will, it's called "free will walks."
Science is not benign. It is enormously affected by money, political climates and most of all, world views. Never mind how seriously and fully drug companies distort, refute and just plain hide the Science that makes their products look bad.
Cue the enormous lawsuits, the settlements, the absolute human tragedy that barely elicits a word from the snake oil hunters except the severly understated "hey, drug companies aren't saints." Which is proportionately sort of like saying to the parents of the kids who were fucked in the ass by a priest "hey, priests aren't perfect."
Should I mention here also drug companies, despite many silly, clueless comments here, only invest in drugs or "supplements" that can be patented and will provide enormous profits. This leaves many, many tremendously helpful supplements and herbs without the big funding which leads to scientific study. See the loop problem here?
Which is why your health food store is filled with a combination of bullshit tonics, and extremely complex and effective plants and medicines, some of which have had thousands of years of healing behind them. Knowing the difference is a matter of personal bias, research, and in some cases, Science. Writing them all off as placebo just makes you small minded and inaccurate. Giving a pass to all of them, same shit different day.
I took echinacea for years, and then the science showed it to be junk. Great. I'm all for that. Who wouldn't be. I took DGL when there was no Science, and then the Science started saying "wow, this shit works." It's also tremendously cheaper and less toxic than its counter part in the drug world.
I had very bad nighttime sweats for a while, and specific herbs prescribed by my Chinese doctor got rid of them in two days. I had a problem with nighttime vision driving my car. Different herbs, gone. Poof. No Science on those herbs. Should I listen to all the snake oil hunters here or my gut? Should I wait twenty years until Science says "x herbs" get rid of night sweats? I'd like relief now--without drugs that are expensive and have side effects that might only come out in court after the lawsuits
Please read this before you reply that I'm not grateful for modern medicine lol>>>>>
I think modern medicine is dazzlingly good at heroic things, like surgery, life saving, hip replacements and the like. But it's miserably bad at chronic illness, and that's why people seek out "alternative therapies." They are exceedingly safe
if we judged them by the same standard we judge conventional therapies,
which we do not. A variation on the devil-we-know thinking means we look the other way when Big Pharma + doctor mistakes kill 300,000 people a year, but get hysterical when
fifty people die from Ephedra. Proportion much? (For the small minds, not saying ephedra shouldn't be yanked, it's a comment on fairness)
Now do I sound like one of the crazy health food nuts, or someone that mixes art and science, and knows that when my leg is severed by a car crash I want a great surgeon, but when I have heart disease, I'm open to trying a low fat diet, some yoga and meditation rather than blindly putting the Vioxx in my cart because White Coat man told me.
Sometimes smarts gets you only so far. Healing is an art and Science will never catch up fast enough to put its stamp on a potentially valuable therapy. So we all have to parse what's "real" and "not real" depending on our situation and world view. Those who call it all bullshit are just as dumb as those who drink the Kool Aid.
BTW, every time I post one of these posts, I get a torrent of PM's asking me about particular therapies or people to see. Hmm, what might that say?