Osteopathy and Naturopathy

I think both are a total and absolute waste of time and money...and should be prosecuted for misleading people. Many people have died unecessarily by putting their hope and faith in fraudulent medicine.

Here we go again.

More people die from prescription drugs every year than die on the roads in the US. Please show me the stats of people who die from alternative therapies. They are so small as not to be even counted. It is indicative of the incredible brainwashing that supposedly smart people suffer from that people say this shit over and over again with a straight face.
 
I am by no means fully sticking up from naturopathy, osteopathy or homeopathy - but to answer your question, I think much of what these professions "prescribe", if you choose to call it that, is not "patentable". You can't patent "Vitamin B" or "Oil of Oregano" the same you you can patent Lipitor or Viagra.

As mentioned above, I think that there are some naturopaths who actually do good work, and base their approach on as much scientific evidence as possible, but I certainly know others who are quacks.

Very true. It really depends where you draw your line. Additionally, I say this over and over on this board, but many therapies that actually work on people haven't been studied by science either because there's not enough money in them or because they compete with prescription drugs.

Homeopathy is junk science. Naturopathy can work very well if you have a gifted practitioner.
 
Exactly. Why in the world would for-profit drug companies want to patent these wonder drugs instead of trying to suppress? It would only make billions and billions for them. That is, if they actually worked. Which they don't.

Pretty dumb theory.

Of course, no drug company would ever suppress the harmful side effects of a multi billion dollar drug, because.....they like us!
 
And they would never invest millions in inventing diseases so they can sell us the cure.......because they are all about the love.... aND PIZZA IS NOW A VEGETABLE!!!
( because large corporations paid off the appropriate authorities)
 
Here we go again.

More people die from prescription drugs every year than die on the roads in the US. Please show me the stats of people who die from alternative therapies. They are so small as not to be even counted. It is indicative of the incredible brainwashing that supposedly smart people suffer from that people say this shit over and over again with a straight face.

Sick people take prescription drugs, and eventually all of them die from something. Sick people who take useless "medication" no matter what its origin is will also die...just a bit sooner than if they took something that truly helped them.

It's all about effectiveness and safety. Medications that are properly tested have known effectiveness and known risks. You do not have this for most alternative medicine.

Brainless is what best describes your attitude. I hope when you get cancer you go with alternative treatments only. Don't do radiation, don't do chemo, and don't get any surgery. Trust you life to almond extract or hydrogen peroxide or herbs of some kind, or better yet homeopathic medications. Put you money where your mouth is.

The problem is not that homeopathic medications, for example, will kill you. The problem is that pure water will not cure very many things...and for the things that it does cure you don't really need to pay for it.
 
Very true. It really depends where you draw your line. Additionally, I say this over and over on this board, but many therapies that actually work on people haven't been studied by science either because there's not enough money in them or because they compete with prescription drugs.

Homeopathy is junk science. Naturopathy can work very well if you have a gifted practitioner.

I think that the idea that there are effective therapies that haven't been studied by science, or have been and are not patentable, is a stretch. Drug companies search the world for biologically active substances, most of which are extracted from biological sources. These can certainly be patented and researched and eventually licensed if they meet required standards for safety and effectiveness. This is a costly process, and it is possible that there are potential drugs that are not worth pursuing. But this is because they are either not very effective, not very safe, or some such combination.

I also don't know what parts of naturopathy you think work well. My experience with naturopaths is that it is a collection of all of these junk science/no science approaches that they can dabble in. They might have some that are useful or help with pain, etc....but there is no way of guessing which.

This whole area is where society needs and requires government oversight. We have it in Canada and the US...but it is being attacked by those who reject any sort of scientific approach to reality. Certainly drug companies need to be regulated, monitored, and required to prove effectiveness and safety of their drugs and therapies. If we lose this it's back to the wild west medicine shows....and snake oil salesmen.
 
Many health problems are actually psychological, and if a witch doctor convinces you that you are well, you can see real results.
 
Of course, no drug company would ever suppress the harmful side effects of a multi billion dollar drug, because.....they like us!
Totally irrelevant to the point. The point is if they could sell it and make a profit they would. But the products have zero merit so that even the drug companies who are willing to make money off us any way they can, can't be bothered with them.

Your arguments are as ridiculous here as they are in the political forum.
 
Thanks for all the responses so far, on both sides of the issue.


On a related note, does anyone know of a licensed witch doctor that can issue insurance receipts? :)
 
Originally posted by Shack: "Totally irrelevant to the point. The point is if they could sell it and make a profit they would. But the products have zero merit so that even the drug companies who are willing to make money off us any way they can, can't be bothered with them."

Actually, Shack, you would be amazed to know how many of the standard medications now in the pharmacopea actually started out as herbal or "folk" remedies. And if the Western, lab-produced forms are more effective, then it remains true that most of the world still has to get by with "natural" remedies. But then most of the world accepts that we all grow old and die more easily than we are willing to. That's perhaps the crux of the matter: we think everything can be cured and we also think that if a procedure can be performed then it ought to be. Most of the world would not have this luxury.
 
60,000 people died just from the prescription drug Vioxx. That's up there with the number of soldiers that died in Vietnam. If you'd like to read about the truly evil manner in which Merck the drug company hid stuff and lied lied lied to patients and regulators, start here.

60,000 people. Put that fucking number in your head for a sec.

200,000 people die every year from prescription drugs, more than all the motor vehicle deaths in the entire US. Vanity Fair has an interesting piece about why that number will go up, not down, in the future.

Conventional doctors fuck up, make mistakes and kill 100,000 people every year.

But it's alternative therapies that are the threat?

Hmm, proportion much?

People, if you don't believe in any of this stuff, you don't have to. But please take a moment to consider how utterly brainwashed you are about the "dangers" of alternative medicine. It's so damned absurd to be tiring.

If 20 people died from an herb, the news cycle would blow up all day for weeks. But because prescription drugs and conventional medicine are the "accepted system" for most of the population, massive deaths don't even make the evening news.

I'm not going to battle again with all the same characters, because it's simply not worth it. No minds get changed, people say the same bullshit over and over without a trace of irony.

The best part of this is that many of the people that scream about whacknuts who believe in alternative therapies themselves believe in a talking snake, a virgin birth and all the other stories that keep adults children, aka religion. Comical.

Happy Saturday night. :eyebrows:
 
60,000 people died just from the prescription drug Vioxx. That's up there with the number of soldiers that died in Vietnam. If you'd like to read about the truly evil manner in which Merck the drug company hid stuff and lied lied lied to patients and regulators, start here.

60,000 people. Put that fucking number in your head for a sec.

200,000 people die every year from prescription drugs, more than all the motor vehicle deaths in the entire US. Vanity Fair has an interesting piece about why that number will go up, not down, in the future.

Conventional doctors fuck up, make mistakes and kill 100,000 people every year.

But it's alternative therapies that are the threat?

Hmm, proportion much?

People, if you don't believe in any of this stuff, you don't have to. But please take a moment to consider how utterly brainwashed you are about the "dangers" of alternative medicine. It's so damned absurd to be tiring.

If 20 people died from an herb, the news cycle would blow up all day for weeks. But because prescription drugs and conventional medicine are the "accepted system" for most of the population, massive deaths don't even make the evening news.

I'm not going to battle again with all the same characters, because it's simply not worth it. No minds get changed, people say the same bullshit over and over without a trace of irony.

The best part of this is that many of the people that scream about whacknuts who believe in alternative therapies themselves believe in a talking snake, a virgin birth and all the other stories that keep adults children, aka religion. Comical.

Happy Saturday night. :eyebrows:
The drug companies are no saints.

However, stating their shortcomings still does nothing to prove that the alternative therapies have any benefit other than as a placebo. Just because there are problems with one doesn't mean the other one suddenly has real benefits.

Some people get sicker from mainstream therapy, but in general a much, much larger percentage of people still get some benefit. The watered down "pathic" concoctions (I understand how some herbal therapies have been developed/refined into real medicines) never did nor ever will provide any real therapy.

BTW, I don't believe all those religious fairy tales either.
 
The drug companies are no saints.

However, stating their shortcomings still does nothing to prove that the alternative therapies have any benefit other than as a placebo. Just because there are problems with one doesn't mean the other one suddenly has real benefits.

Some people get sicker from mainstream therapy, but in general a much, much larger percentage of people still get some benefit. The watered down "pathic" concoctions (I understand how some herbal therapies have been developed/refined into real medicines) never did nor ever will provide any real therapy.

Just because an herbal medicine or an "alternative procedure" hasn't been studied by Science doesn't mean it doesn't work. . It doesn't mean it does work either, but no sane person debates that.

Homeopathy doesn't have science behind it and has been studied extensively. Great. Junk from a scientific point-of-view. I'm glad Science caught up with it.

I take an herb for a condition I have which works like clockwork. It is in fact almost a lifesaver for me. Science hasn't studied it. Should I go off of it onto some super powerful prescription drug which have enormous side effects and cost 10X more? No. Only an idiot or worshipper of Big Pharma would.

That's where so many of you shrieking nuts who scream about snake oil lose me and plenty of other people. If it works for me, even if it's a "placebo", why do I need to prove it to you or anyone else? In the realm of free will, it's called "free will walks."

Science is not benign. It is enormously affected by money, political climates and most of all, world views. Never mind how seriously and fully drug companies distort, refute and just plain hide the Science that makes their products look bad.

Cue the enormous lawsuits, the settlements, the absolute human tragedy that barely elicits a word from the snake oil hunters except the severly understated "hey, drug companies aren't saints." Which is proportionately sort of like saying to the parents of the kids who were fucked in the ass by a priest "hey, priests aren't perfect."

Should I mention here also drug companies, despite many silly, clueless comments here, only invest in drugs or "supplements" that can be patented and will provide enormous profits. This leaves many, many tremendously helpful supplements and herbs without the big funding which leads to scientific study. See the loop problem here?

Which is why your health food store is filled with a combination of bullshit tonics, and extremely complex and effective plants and medicines, some of which have had thousands of years of healing behind them. Knowing the difference is a matter of personal bias, research, and in some cases, Science. Writing them all off as placebo just makes you small minded and inaccurate. Giving a pass to all of them, same shit different day.

I took echinacea for years, and then the science showed it to be junk. Great. I'm all for that. Who wouldn't be. I took DGL when there was no Science, and then the Science started saying "wow, this shit works." It's also tremendously cheaper and less toxic than its counter part in the drug world.

I had very bad nighttime sweats for a while, and specific herbs prescribed by my Chinese doctor got rid of them in two days. I had a problem with nighttime vision driving my car. Different herbs, gone. Poof. No Science on those herbs. Should I listen to all the snake oil hunters here or my gut? Should I wait twenty years until Science says "x herbs" get rid of night sweats? I'd like relief now--without drugs that are expensive and have side effects that might only come out in court after the lawsuits :)

Please read this before you reply that I'm not grateful for modern medicine lol>>>>>I think modern medicine is dazzlingly good at heroic things, like surgery, life saving, hip replacements and the like. But it's miserably bad at chronic illness, and that's why people seek out "alternative therapies." They are exceedingly safe if we judged them by the same standard we judge conventional therapies, which we do not. A variation on the devil-we-know thinking means we look the other way when Big Pharma + doctor mistakes kill 300,000 people a year, but get hysterical when fifty people die from Ephedra. Proportion much? (For the small minds, not saying ephedra shouldn't be yanked, it's a comment on fairness)

Now do I sound like one of the crazy health food nuts, or someone that mixes art and science, and knows that when my leg is severed by a car crash I want a great surgeon, but when I have heart disease, I'm open to trying a low fat diet, some yoga and meditation rather than blindly putting the Vioxx in my cart because White Coat man told me.

Sometimes smarts gets you only so far. Healing is an art and Science will never catch up fast enough to put its stamp on a potentially valuable therapy. So we all have to parse what's "real" and "not real" depending on our situation and world view. Those who call it all bullshit are just as dumb as those who drink the Kool Aid.

BTW, every time I post one of these posts, I get a torrent of PM's asking me about particular therapies or people to see. Hmm, what might that say?
 
I think both are a total and absolute waste of time and money...and should be prosecuted for misleading people. Many people have died unecessarily by putting their hope and faith in fraudulent medicine.

This comes up over and over with people who witch hunt alternative therapies.

A) People have free will. You can't legislate or prosecute against that. Or should. Education, and yes, Science are the key. But even then, people will choose alternates to stuff they either don't "believe" in, or doesn't have the Science to back it up (many forms of chemo and radiation have miserable success rates but with awful side effects).

B) Do you apply the same standards to "proven" drug therapies that kill hundreds of thousands of people every year? Are you pushing for their prosecution? :)

C) The question of what therapy might save someone or kill them is an enormously complex topic which resists any simplification given the human body as a complicated system of mind, body and emotions. People write all this nonsense about Steve Jobs would have lived longer if he'd ditched the alternative bullshit, which is so utterly un-knowable to be pure hubris. This is a fairly decent article on the subject, even though I don't agree with all of it.

D) By your standard, ad agencies would be prosecuted, since they "mislead people". Oh, and drug companies. Check out this fantastic expose of drug company deception by a former editor of The New England Journal of Medicine.
 
Yes, people do have free will. But we also trust in our government to regulate and control things that are dangerous. It may be an imposition on your free will to drive on the right side of the road in Canada, but as a society we have to have these sorts of rules. And because an individual has no possible way of evaluating every medical or health claim themselves we need some sort of regulation or control on it. The same as choosing one side of the road to drive on.

I don't want to make decisions on what medication to take based on my church leaders, on my mother or my aunt, or on some ancient form of medicine that allowed people to live to the ripe old age of 28 years. I don't really care about your "testimony" of this or that, or anyone else's testimonials. I can get all of that I want on late night TV.

I wasn't aware the Steve Jobs was depending on some form of alternative medicine. That is really sad if true. But I do believe that people should have the right to choose death, and I guess by extension they should have the right to choose or reject any particular medication.

Do drug companies or other corporations sometimes lie and cheat? I'm sure they do. And that is why we have to have oversight and regulation...hence agencies like the FDA in the US, etc.

The one bright spot in all of the new age push to alternative medicine is that there is a lot of drug testing going on - by human subjects on themselves. Hopefully some of that can result in some good data down the road and perhaps even some effective therapies.
 
Yes, people do have free will. But we also trust in our government to regulate and control things that are dangerous. It may be an imposition on your free will to drive on the right side of the road in Canada, but as a society we have to have these sorts of rules. And because an individual has no possible way of evaluating every medical or health claim themselves we need some sort of regulation or control on it. The same as choosing one side of the road to drive on.

I don't want to make decisions on what medication to take based on my church leaders, on my mother or my aunt, or on some ancient form of medicine that allowed people to live to the ripe old age of 28 years. I don't really care about your "testimony" of this or that, or anyone else's testimonials. I can get all of that I want on late night TV.

I wasn't aware the Steve Jobs was depending on some form of alternative medicine. That is really sad if true. But I do believe that people should have the right to choose death, and I guess by extension they should have the right to choose or reject any particular medication.

Do drug companies or other corporations sometimes lie and cheat? I'm sure they do. And that is why we have to have oversight and regulation...hence agencies like the FDA in the US, etc.

The one bright spot in all of the new age push to alternative medicine is that there is a lot of drug testing going on - by human subjects on themselves. Hopefully some of that can result in some good data down the road and perhaps even some effective therapies.

So, using that logic, I guess you now accept that pizza is a vegetable. It's so nice to know the government is looking out for us. And I'm sure you don't care to know if your food is genetically modified, because the government says it doesn't matter. And cell phone radiation? Don't worry...be stupid!
 
Yes, people do have free will. But we also trust in our government to regulate and control things that are dangerous.

I'm sorry to have to break the news to you, but Health Canada and The FDA are simple arms of the drug companies and their lobbies.

A rather stark example: In 2002 Health Canada removed--entirely--the herb kava kava from store shelves based on four (count 'em, four) reports of liver toxicity. No deaths were reported.

By contrast, the single most used drug in the world, Tylenol, which can be found in over 200 different over the counter and prescription medicines, is according to the FDA (not some quack outfit), the single biggest cause of liver failure in The U.S., accounting for nearly half the cases annually. And it's growing: Acute liver failure caused by acetaminophen has risen sharply from 28 percent in 1998 to 51 percent in 2003.

Just to put these stark numbers in perspective: Unintentional overdoses (48%) on acetaminophen outnumber intentional (suicide attempt) overdoses (44%). (!)

Where is Health Canada? Worrying about kava kava? Huh? Is Kava Kava more dangerous than the number one liver failure generator? Irony much?

Tylenol continues to be sold where money is accepted. Kava? Not so much.

This is what happens when you have a culture completely dominated by drugs, corporations and their lobbies.

And what if you have a parent or wife or friend that gets liver toxicity/failure from Tylenol? Will you just shrug and say "hey, the numbers is what the numbers is" and let them suffer? Or might you experiment with....ooooh, "alternatives" (cue the late night informercials!) which might help the liver so your friend or parent could get better. Things like NAC, milk thistle, alpha lipoic acid? Your mainstream doc will just tell you friend or Mom to get a liver transplant, because mainstream doctors only see two states for organs, functioning or failing (no in between?).

And hey, do you think your parent or friend even knows that before they started popping Tylenol on the way to liver problems that there are five or ten natural alternatives that can do the job without zapping your liver? Why do you suppose they don't know about them? Give that some thought.

And so it goes.

See, blanket condemnation and ridicule of "alternative therapies" has a price for you and the people you love, and blind trust in your government will lead to hypocrisy and unfair application of laws. I have rather intimate knowledge of Health Canada's incredibly "arbitrary" (a polite term) application of laws, and can tell you they do not have your freedom of choice in mind, but the drug lobbies' hot breath on their necks.

Stop kidding yourself. Your government doesn't work for you. It works for the drug lobbies.

Should I throw in the revolving door of drug lobbyists working for the FDA and then back again? No wonder people who want natural alternatives have to go to tacky-looking late night scammers selling books. Thankfully, it's "free will" that is changing things, because it's certainly not governments or big business.
 
I am by no means fully sticking up from naturopathy, osteopathy or homeopathy - but to answer your question, I think much of what these professions "prescribe", if you choose to call it that, is not "patentable". You can't patent "Vitamin B" or "Oil of Oregano" the same you you can patent Lipitor or Viagra.

In a way you can. If "Magic Oil of Earwax" actually worked, isolating the active ingredients, modifying them slightly to be unique, and a clinical trial showing increased efficacy would be trivial. They do this with antidepressants and statins all the time.