Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 50.5%
  • No

    Votes: 46 49.5%

  • Total voters
    93
Essentially, the ring is a gift with strings attached.

Your view has no basis in law. It may be your opinion that it has strings attached, but legally it does not, not unless the ring came with some sort of written contract attaching strings.
 
Really? The engagement ring is a promise of financial security and ownership? I think you guys are living in the wrong decade.

Not that I want to take sides with your Uncle's ex, but the engagement ring in contemporary times is a traditional symbol. When you say 'ownership', what are you referring to? Sounds archaic to me (and why would we be living in the wrong decade?). If there's case law that says consummation affects the division of family property, then please advise.
 
http://www.estatelawcanada.ca/who-gets-the-engagement-ring/

Marsha’s met Marc only 3 months ago. When she agreed to marry him she thought he was a wealthy entrepreneur. Instead, she found out that Marc only owned a small store and was barely making ends meet. When Marsha discovered her mistake she immediately started to date other men.

After Marsha agreed to marry him, Marc gave her a $20,000.00 diamond engagement ring. Soon after Marc caught Marsha on a date with another man. He demanded that she give back the engagement ring. She refused. In her mind the engagement ring was a gift. Marc sued. Who do you think should get the ring? Let’s see what the courts say.

In reviewing the case law, it seems that the most important factor for the courts was who broke off the engagement (FN1). Applying this reasoning to our story, if the courts believed that Marsha’s dating other men constituted a breaking off of the engagement they would order her to give back the ring. In some cases the courts did not consider infidelity by the woman to constitute a breaking off of an engagement (FN2). If that reasoning were applied here and the court felt it was Marc who ended the engagement then the court would allow Marsha to keep the ring. Academics criticized these decisions because, in their view, an engagement ring was a gift conditional on a marriage that did not take place and should be returned regardless of fault. That reading of the law is more consistent with section 33 of the Marriage Act which provides “Where one person makes a gift to another in contemplation of or conditional upon their marriage to each other and the marriage fails to take place or is abandoned, the question of whether or not the failure or abandonment was caused by or was the fault of the donor shall not be considered in determining the right of the donor to recover the gift”(FN3).

Whatever the husband’s rights may be to get the ring back the courts have also denied him the return of the engagement ring if he fails to ask for it because the delay seems to mean the ring changed from a gift conditional on marriage to an absolute gift.

In Okahai v. Sharify (FN4) a judge ruled that the woman had to return the engagement ring This case and other like it (FN5) were decided on the assumption that engagement rings were given in contemplation of marriage. Under these circumstances, there is an implied condition attached to the ring that the woman would marry him. The ring has the character of a pledge or something to bring the bargain or contract to marry and was given on the understanding, or the implied term, that a party who breaks the contract must return it. Since the women broke off the marriage she had to return the ring.

This short review of the case law should not be taken as legal advice. Based on my experience in dealing with these cases, they often turn on the specific facts. If you have a legal question relating to something similar, you are best advised to seek out competent legal counsel to determine your best course of action.


FN1. See Marcon v. Cicchelli ( 1993), 47 R.F.L. ( 3d) 403 (Ont. Gen. Div.); Iliopoulos v. Gettas (1981), 32 O.R. (2d) 636 (Ont. Co. Ct.).

FN2. See paragraph 61 of McArthur v. Zaduk 2001 CarswellOnt 2117, 21 R.F.L. (5th) 142, 106 A.C.W.S. (3d) 380

FN3. In an annotation on Marcon v. Cicchelli the late James McLeod who was Counsel, at Mamo & Associates, London, Ontario, and Professor of Law at the Univrsity of Western Ontario expressed the opinion that the Divisional Court of Ontario was wrong. In his view a gift is either conditional or absolute. If the gift is conditional and the condition is not met, then there is no gift and the property should be returned to the donor. He based his view on Hough v. Champagne (1991), 35 R.F.L. (3d) 27, 42 E.T.R. 252 ( Ont. Gen. Div.).and s. 33 of the Marriage Act.

FN4. Okahai v. Sharify [2004] O.J. No. 4186 ( Ontario SCJ).

FN5. Veitch (Trustee of) v. Rankin (1997), 41 O.T.C. 14, [1997] O.J. No. 4642 (Gen. Div.); Marcon v. Cicchelli (1993), 47 R.F.L. (3d) 403 at 407-408 (Gen. Div.): Hough V. Champagne [1991] O.J. No. 1322; 42 E.T.R. 252 (Gen. Div.); Iliopoulous V. Gettas (1981), 32 O.R. (2d) 636 At 639 (Co. Ct.); Seiler V. Funk [1914] O.J. No. 115; 32 O.L.R. 99 ( Ont. Ca); D’andrea v. Schmidt [2005] S.J. No. 290; 2005 Skqb 201; Q.B.G. No. 2166 Of 2002 J.C.R. (Saskatchewan Court Of Queen’s Bench ).
 
thank you for all the hard work, Mervyn. Your post has made me think that my law school recollection of the law in this area may be inaccurate and the gift may not be absolute.
 
Thank you for the references Mervyn.

So the OP's Uncle is SOL, or at least, has an uphill battle, if the same law applies to their jurisdiction.
 
Divorce is brutal. This is just another example.

As long as the whole thing is still in the lawyers' hands, couldn't he just insist on getting the ring as part of the settlement? Making it part of a package deal with the rest of the household might make it possible to buy it back for a lower price than if he cuts a separate deal for just the ring.
 
What a ridiculous question.

The modern engagement ring is a gift given at the time of the proposal. It is not a fee for service or a payment in exchange for matrimony. While it is considered impolite for the lady to keep the ring if she does not accept the marriage proposal, once the deed is done the groom has no moral rights on the ring; he gave it away freely.

In days past, many societies forced women to give up many of their rights and most of their independence upon marrying. In those days, the engagement ring (or other gift, as engagement rings were not as universal as they are now until the last century) were, in part, a form of insurance for the lady should she be left by her husband.

So no. Don't ask for it back and don't expect to get it back.
 
Exactly what the law says. And I know one ex-escort who got a $20,000 ring a few days before she called off the relationship who is very, very happy.

Hope that you learned your lesson:)
 
My uncle's currently going through a divorce, and they've been together only 3 years (married for 2 of them). He's all torn up because the engagement ring was a family heirloom for 8 generations. Well, he's torn up for a lot of other reasons too. He asked for the ring back, but his ex-wife wants to keep it. My grandma's also upset and is laying into my uncle for giving the ring to someone who obviously wasn't in it for the long run.

I know many people consider an engagement ring to be a gift. I believe the law sees it that way too. Personally, I see it as a contract: a token of the love, trust, loyalty and companionship between the engaged. If the love (etc.) is no longer there, that contract no longer exists in my eyes. I'd also like to think that anyone knowing the value the ring has to the one family, would give it back. Just my opinion. I'd like to know what you guys and gals think as my thought process may be biased at the moment.

I would not give a family heirloom to a woman that isn't a blood relative under any circumstances. If I were entrusted with such an heirloom which I am, it would only be given to my daughter (if I had one). If I had a son, he would get my fathers and/or mine. Yes, a spouse is family, but they're not blood relations. The off-spring are blood and that's thicker than water.

It appears that many posters may believe that your uncle is recently engaged as they didn't read your original post. Two years into a marriage the engagement and party is now over. Many moons ago, when I was dating my ex-wife and we started discussing marriage, I asked, "What would you rather have a huge engagement ring and large formal wedding that we won't be able to mingle with everyone or home of our choice with no mortgage? She chose wisely and in the end, I bought her out of the home and had a rental property which I eventually sold to the tenants.

She never picked an engagement ring as I had one made for her! Her maternal and paternal grandmothers and her mother provided me with the diamonds which became the engagement ring which would always be hers and remain in her family, and it ran into the 2 month wage area.

I've been once and will not enter into such a contract again, and I believe in pre-nuptual and co-habitant agreements. In fact, I would rather just reside separately and have sleep-overs occasionally. In fact, I wouldn't leave anything at her place and wouldn't want her to leave anything at mine.

JMHO
 
http://www.estatelawcanada.ca/who-gets-the-engagement-ring/

Marsha’s met Marc only 3 months ago. When she agreed to marry him she thought he was a wealthy entrepreneur. Instead, she found out that Marc only owned a small store and was barely making ends meet. When Marsha discovered her mistake she immediately started to date other men.

After Marsha agreed to marry him, Marc gave her a $20,000.00 diamond engagement ring. Soon after Marc caught Marsha on a date with another man. He demanded that she give back the engagement ring. She refused. In her mind the engagement ring was a gift. Marc sued. Who do you think should get the ring? Let’s see what the courts say.

In reviewing the case law, it seems that the most important factor for the courts was who broke off the engagement (FN1). Applying this reasoning to our story, if the courts believed that Marsha’s dating other men constituted a breaking off of the engagement they would order her to give back the ring. In some cases the courts did not consider infidelity by the woman to constitute a breaking off of an engagement (FN2). If that reasoning were applied here and the court felt it was Marc who ended the engagement then the court would allow Marsha to keep the ring. Academics criticized these decisions because, in their view, an engagement ring was a gift conditional on a marriage that did not take place and should be returned regardless of fault. That reading of the law is more consistent with section 33 of the Marriage Act which provides “Where one person makes a gift to another in contemplation of or conditional upon their marriage to each other and the marriage fails to take place or is abandoned, the question of whether or not the failure or abandonment was caused by or was the fault of the donor shall not be considered in determining the right of the donor to recover the gift”(FN3).

Whatever the husband’s rights may be to get the ring back the courts have also denied him the return of the engagement ring if he fails to ask for it because the delay seems to mean the ring changed from a gift conditional on marriage to an absolute gift.

In Okahai v. Sharify (FN4) a judge ruled that the woman had to return the engagement ring This case and other like it (FN5) were decided on the assumption that engagement rings were given in contemplation of marriage. Under these circumstances, there is an implied condition attached to the ring that the woman would marry him. The ring has the character of a pledge or something to bring the bargain or contract to marry and was given on the understanding, or the implied term, that a party who breaks the contract must return it. Since the women broke off the marriage she had to return the ring.

This short review of the case law should not be taken as legal advice. Based on my experience in dealing with these cases, they often turn on the specific facts. If you have a legal question relating to something similar, you are best advised to seek out competent legal counsel to determine your best course of action.


FN1. See Marcon v. Cicchelli ( 1993), 47 R.F.L. ( 3d) 403 (Ont. Gen. Div.); Iliopoulos v. Gettas (1981), 32 O.R. (2d) 636 (Ont. Co. Ct.).

FN2. See paragraph 61 of McArthur v. Zaduk 2001 CarswellOnt 2117, 21 R.F.L. (5th) 142, 106 A.C.W.S. (3d) 380

FN3. In an annotation on Marcon v. Cicchelli the late James McLeod who was Counsel, at Mamo & Associates, London, Ontario, and Professor of Law at the Univrsity of Western Ontario expressed the opinion that the Divisional Court of Ontario was wrong. In his view a gift is either conditional or absolute. If the gift is conditional and the condition is not met, then there is no gift and the property should be returned to the donor. He based his view on Hough v. Champagne (1991), 35 R.F.L. (3d) 27, 42 E.T.R. 252 ( Ont. Gen. Div.).and s. 33 of the Marriage Act.

FN4. Okahai v. Sharify [2004] O.J. No. 4186 ( Ontario SCJ).

FN5. Veitch (Trustee of) v. Rankin (1997), 41 O.T.C. 14, [1997] O.J. No. 4642 (Gen. Div.); Marcon v. Cicchelli (1993), 47 R.F.L. (3d) 403 at 407-408 (Gen. Div.): Hough V. Champagne [1991] O.J. No. 1322; 42 E.T.R. 252 (Gen. Div.); Iliopoulous V. Gettas (1981), 32 O.R. (2d) 636 At 639 (Co. Ct.); Seiler V. Funk [1914] O.J. No. 115; 32 O.L.R. 99 ( Ont. Ca); D’andrea v. Schmidt [2005] S.J. No. 290; 2005 Skqb 201; Q.B.G. No. 2166 Of 2002 J.C.R. (Saskatchewan Court Of Queen’s Bench ).

None of this has any bearing on the OP's uncle's dilemma. The engagement was not broken; they divorced after two years of marriage.

There is some similarity to a pension that has Joint and Survivor benefits. In those cases, the determination of whom is the spouse is determined at the earlier of the date of pension commencement or the date of the pensioner's death. Once the pension starts, the terms are irrevocable. If the marriage dissolves post retirement, the only way the guy can keep the ex from getting his pension money is to live longer than she does. If the pensioner remarries following the retirement, the Plan has no obligation to pay survivor benefits to a subsequent spouse, and he has no right to designate an alternative beneficiary. This happened with my old man. He had a brief common law relationship which just happened to coincide with his retirement date, (1984), and she's still collecting every month, eight years after he bit the dust.
 
None of this has any bearing on the OP's uncle's dilemma. The engagement was not broken; they divorced after two years of marriage.

Yeah, which means that unless there is a prenup all the property in the marriage is on the table to be divided equally, including the ring.
 
My uncle's currently going through a divorce, and they've been together only 3 years (married for 2 of them). He's all torn up because the engagement ring was a family heirloom for 8 generations. Well, he's torn up for a lot of other reasons too. He asked for the ring back, but his ex-wife wants to keep it. My grandma's also upset and is laying into my uncle for giving the ring to someone who obviously wasn't in it for the long run.

I know many people consider an engagement ring to be a gift. I believe the law sees it that way too. Personally, I see it as a contract: a token of the love, trust, loyalty and companionship between the engaged. If the love (etc.) is no longer there, that contract no longer exists in my eyes. I'd also like to think that anyone knowing the value the ring has to the one family, would give it back. Just my opinion. I'd like to know what you guys and gals think as my thought process may be biased at the moment.

....I've given (thrown) mine back...a few times...
 
Not that I want to take sides with your Uncle's ex, but the engagement ring in contemporary times is a traditional symbol. When you say 'ownership', what are you referring to? Sounds archaic to me (and why would we be living in the wrong decade?). If there's case law that says consummation affects the division of family property, then please advise.

Your previous post said you agreed with BitO when he said:

The ring is like a down payment, showing that the guy has interest in future financial commitment, and it also says "hands off!" to other guys, especially if she's young and attractive. She completed her part of the contract as soon as there was consummation in the marital bed.

Archaic is a good word to describe that line of thinking to me. Men are no longer the only bread winners in the family, so using the engagement ring as a symbol that the man will provide financially for the women is obsolete. Also, using an engagement ring to state your claim on a woman is also outdated. That's what I meant by "living in the wrong decade". Maybe you were just agreeing with that last sentence of BitO's post and if so, then disregard what I said above.
 
What a ridiculous question.

The modern engagement ring is a gift given at the time of the proposal. It is not a fee for service or a payment in exchange for matrimony. While it is considered impolite for the lady to keep the ring if she does not accept the marriage proposal, once the deed is done the groom has no moral rights on the ring; he gave it away freely.

In days past, many societies forced women to give up many of their rights and most of their independence upon marrying. In those days, the engagement ring (or other gift, as engagement rings were not as universal as they are now until the last century) were, in part, a form of insurance for the lady should she be left by her husband.

So no. Don't ask for it back and don't expect to get it back.

I'd hardly consider it a ridiculous question when, after 68 votes, the results are 50/50 either way...and that's after two years of marriage! Not just engagement. What I highlighted in bold in your post is an opinion that many do not share entirely, including the courts. Your referral to "days past" when a woman's engagement ring was a sort of insurance doesn't (or shouldn't) have any bearing on today.
 
I'd hardly consider it a ridiculous question when, after 68 votes, the results are 50/50 either way...and that's after two years of marriage! Not just engagement.
I think this poll is not an accurate reflection on the reality one would see in the general population.
The vast majority of those voting here are likely guys, many jaded whoremongering guys. :wink:
 
What a ridiculous question.

The modern engagement ring is a gift given at the time of the proposal. It is not a fee for service or a payment in exchange for matrimony. While it is considered impolite for the lady to keep the ring if she does not accept the marriage proposal, once the deed is done the groom has no moral rights on the ring; he gave it away freely.
Are you suggesting that it is merely impolite to take the ring, say no, and then keep it? :confused:
 
Yeah, which means that unless there is a prenup all the property in the marriage is on the table to be divided equally, including the ring.
I don`t think the ring should be considered marital property as it was not acquired during the marriage.
An exception to this rule is the matrimonial home but I don`t see why the ring would be treated the same.
 
Under Roman Law, the ring is the man's and it is his way of showing that the woman is his wife. If the marriage ended, the ring was to be returned to its rightful owner, the husband. Sometime within the last 30 years, Canadian law has changed and the ring becomes the property of the woman.

She gets to keep it. Shitty thing in circumstances like this.

Morally, he should offer to buy her a replacement rings and explain how much the ring means to his family.
 
None of this has any bearing on the OP's uncle's dilemma. The engagement was not broken; they divorced after two years of marriage.
Thank you for highlighting the obvious.
The thread evolved and the issue of the ring when the engagement is broken came up and 2 lawyers claimed that the ring is a gift not to be returned in any case.
Mervyn`s post was relevant and informative and hopefully enlightening.

An engagement ring IS a gift. The law accords it no special status. It is not part of a contract in return for the woman actually going through w the marriage.
Oagre is of course absolutely correct.
 
Last edited: