Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 50.5%
  • No

    Votes: 46 49.5%

  • Total voters
    93

rhuarc29

Well-known member
Apr 15, 2009
9,905
1,738
113
My uncle's currently going through a divorce, and they've been together only 3 years (married for 2 of them). He's all torn up because the engagement ring was a family heirloom for 8 generations. Well, he's torn up for a lot of other reasons too. He asked for the ring back, but his ex-wife wants to keep it. My grandma's also upset and is laying into my uncle for giving the ring to someone who obviously wasn't in it for the long run.

I know many people consider an engagement ring to be a gift. I believe the law sees it that way too. Personally, I see it as a contract: a token of the love, trust, loyalty and companionship between the engaged. If the love (etc.) is no longer there, that contract no longer exists in my eyes. I'd also like to think that anyone knowing the value the ring has to the one family, would give it back. Just my opinion. I'd like to know what you guys and gals think as my thought process may be biased at the moment.
 
The ring should be given back if the engagement is terminated, but once their were married, it became her property. It's like a Promise of Performance contract between them. If the ring has such sentimental value, your uncle should offer her something else of greater financial value in the property settlement, in the hope that she would rather have that than the heirloom ring. If she wants to keep it, however, even if just to spite him, He's SOL. He'll just have to tell his mom that he got three magic beans for the cow.

As for the ring being a "a token of love, trust, loyalty, and companionship", you're reading too many books with paintings of Fabio on the cover. The ring is like a down payment, showing that the guy has interest in future financial commitment, and it also says "hands off!" to other guys, especially if she's young and attractive. She completed her part of the contract as soon as there was consummation in the marital bed.
 
I say, NO.

He gave it to her. End of story.

That said, if she had any common decency to her - she would return it.
 
I mean this ring has been in your family for 8 generations, I think she should give it back, especially if she wasn't in for in a long run. If she doesn't give it back, she is a heartless bitch.
 
I am sorry but the uncle has to pony up some responsibility here. 3 yrs together, 2 married means he purposed after how long? 6 months??? 9months??? You need some time to plan a wedding after all. How was he trusted with such a precious family piece to give to a woman after only knowing her so little an amount of time??? My BF didn't even spend the night until after we were together for about 2 years. {note - spend the night does not mean no sex, just means I didn't kick him out right after he preformed his duties for once :eyebrows:}

Being this is mostly a male oriented board - she is of course a heartless piece of shit of not returning it, but we have not heard the whole story. We have not heard why the marriage ended. Maybe she left because he was a secretly abusive SOB, or maybe she found out he was in the closet still and used her to cover the fact that he is gay. We don't know. Maybe there are kids already involved and she wants to pass the ring down to her children and ensure that the dumb uncle doesn't give it to someone else after a night of drunkenness in bar on the way to Vegas to elope. Who knows.....

Bottom-line - the ring was a promise of marriage and marriage happened. The ring is hers. That is the way the law sees it and for good reason.

I think that offering her some money in the settlement to get the ring back is probably the smart thing to try. The uncle was stupid and now has to pay. That is the way of life for everyone. Dumb actions = paying the price. In this case, let's hope not all is lost, but he needs to shut up, pay up and learn to make better choices in life.
 
Normally the guys paid for the wedding ring. You didn't! You should pay now, and this is a smartest move what you can do.
If you lucky, she will say yes for your offer, but if she want to cause pain on purpose(maybe she watched too much brasilian soap opera) to you and your family, you'll never get the ring back.
As I wrote once here: "If you can not solve a problem with money, just solve it with LOTS OF money!"




My uncle's currently going through a divorce, and they've been together only 3 years (married for 2 of them). He's all torn up because the engagement ring was a family heirloom for 8 generations. Well, he's torn up for a lot of other reasons too. He asked for the ring back, but his ex-wife wants to keep it. My grandma's also upset and is laying into my uncle for giving the ring to someone who obviously wasn't in it for the long run.

I know many people consider an engagement ring to be a gift. I believe the law sees it that way too. Personally, I see it as a contract: a token of the love, trust, loyalty and companionship between the engaged. If the love (etc.) is no longer there, that contract no longer exists in my eyes. I'd also like to think that anyone knowing the value the ring has to the one family, would give it back. Just my opinion. I'd like to know what you guys and gals think as my thought process may be biased at the moment.
 
The day you pass it over, it's gone, lol.

It's a gift, would you ask for all the other gifts back??

Exactly what the law says. And I know one ex-escort who got a $20,000 ring a few days before she called off the relationship who is very, very happy.
 
Exactly what the law says. And I know one ex-escort who got a $20,000 ring a few days before she called off the relationship who is very, very happy.

She sounds like a peach.
 
I am sorry but the uncle has to pony up some responsibility here. 3 yrs together, 2 married means he purposed after how long? 6 months??? 9months??? You need some time to plan a wedding after all. How was he trusted with such a precious family piece to give to a woman after only knowing her so little an amount of time??? My BF didn't even spend the night until after we were together for about 2 years. {note - spend the night does not mean no sex, just means I didn't kick him out right after he preformed his duties for once}

This is exactly what has the rest of the family pissed off. He knew her for roughly 9 months before he proposed, and they were married 6 months later. Everyone else thought that was moving too damn fast. Then again, he's getting on in years and he's never been married before, so maybe he was thinking time was getting away from him.

Being this is mostly a male oriented board - she is of course a heartless piece of shit of not returning it, but we have not heard the whole story. We have not heard why the marriage ended. Maybe she left because he was a secretly abusive SOB, or maybe she found out he was in the closet still and used her to cover the fact that he is gay. We don't know. Maybe there are kids already involved and she wants to pass the ring down to her children and ensure that the dumb uncle doesn't give it to someone else after a night of drunkenness in bar on the way to Vegas to elope. Who knows.....

Okay, so she's a heartless piece of shit*

*This statement no longer applies if the reason for the divorce was foul play or maliciousness on part of my uncle ;) jk

Bottom-line - the ring was a promise of marriage and marriage happened. The ring is hers. That is the way the law sees it and for good reason.

I believe marriage is supposed to be "for as long as you both shall live" as well. An engagement ring is a symbol of that commitment.

I think that offering her some money in the settlement to get the ring back is probably the smart thing to try. The uncle was stupid and now has to pay. That is the way of life for everyone. Dumb actions = paying the price. In this case, let's hope not all is lost, but he needs to shut up, pay up and learn to make better choices in life.

That idea kind of disgusts me, but it might be his only recourse. As far as stupidity goes, I've got no argument there. I think he rushed in head first without looking where he was going to land.

Anyway, thanks for your input!
 
The day you pass it over, it's gone, lol.

It's a gift, would you ask for all the other gifts back??

No, just this one. It's no ordinary gift.

Funny enough, once you pass it over, it's not necessarily gone. So long as the wedding hasn't taken place, a judge can rule that it's still the rightful property of the person who proposed. Apparently the wedding has significance with the law. I guess to keep the engagement ring even after the engagement is called off seems too malicious.
 
I'm going to need another poll asking if you think the results of this poll are skewed for being posted on TERB....
 
If little value is put on marriage, who cares about some old ring?

He got the ring for free, fucked a woman every which way until he was tired of her and now probably pays no alimony. Sounds like a lucky guy to me.

Tell grandma to quit bitchin', get in the kitchen and make an apple pie. :eyebrows:
 
I believe marriage is supposed to be "for as long as you both shall live" as well. An engagement ring is a symbol of that commitment.


I believe that marriage is just a contract signed by 2 people. Probably why I will never be married. I think it is an outrageous expense giving a false sense of commitment for a piece of paper that can be dismissed in less 5 mins by a judge.

However, an engagement ring is a promise to walk down the green mile, I mean the aisle to get married. The wedding ring given at the ceremony is the ring that is the symbol of "for as long as you both shall live" Hence the reason the engagement ring is moved the other hand so that the wedding ring can take its' place as the new symbol. Also why that is the time the husband gets a ring that locks him in too.

So clearly there is a difference in the "job" of the two rings. Personally I like the tale of the 9 rings better. I have always said, it is better to cozy up to a good book then a bad partner. In hindsight that idea may have worked better for your uncle. BTW - the library is free too.

In all seriousness because I can see how this could be upsetting. I can tell you that calling the ex names, is not going help. If anything, it is going to make her stand her ground even more. If offering money for the ring is not the way you all want to go, then get someone who she liked in the family to have a heart to heart with about the ring. Say that grandma is now going to the owner if it is returned. That Uncle doesn't deserve it back, but the "family" does. Maybe that will work. I don't know because again, we don't know the whole story.

Anyway, thank god I won't marry and GL to your family in getting the ring back. I hope it comes back to the family in a peaceful and un-costly manner.
 
In all seriousness because I can see how this could be upsetting. I can tell you that calling the ex names, is not going help.

In all seriousness, I don't think anyone in the family actually considers her to be heartless. She has a difference of opinion and considers the ring hers, as many of the posters on here do. On our part, the ring has serious sentimental value that should (a) never have been given away so easily in the first place, and in our opinion (b) shouldn't be in the possession of someone who wasn't in it to be part of our family in the long run.

However, if she won't part with the ring when we've expressed how much it means to our family...that's one thing. But if we then offered her money for it, and she accepted that...that does seem a little heartless.
 
In all seriousness, I don't think anyone in the family actually considers her to be heartless. She has a difference of opinion and considers the ring hers, as many of the posters on here do. On our part, the ring has serious sentimental value that should (a) never have been given away so easily in the first place, and in our opinion (b) shouldn't be in the possession of someone who wasn't in it to be part of our family in the long run.

However, if she won't part with the ring when we've expressed how much it means to our family...that's one thing. But if we then offered her money for it, and she accepted that...that does seem a little heartless.

Heartless - no. Money hungry/opportunistic - yes. {I slashed the latter because that is all a matter of opinion as well}

It sucks. I know. We have lost family things because of idiot family members too. I do truly hope your family gets the ring back where it should be.
 
Was this an engagement ring or a present?
Are you saying that an engagement ring can be kept if the engagement is called off?

An engagement ring IS a gift. The law accords it no special status. It is not part of a contract in return for the woman actually going through w the marriage.
 
I think the ring is hers to keep once the marriage takes place.
It is not fair to say that she was not in it for the long haul just because it didn`t work out.
I wouldn`t say she is heartless unless she is well off and just wants to keep it out of spite.
If she is not well off or just struggling to get by, she should sell the ring.
She should get some quotes, not appraisals, for what she could sell the ring for and she should give the uncle/family the opportunity to buy it.
 
Last edited: