My uncle's currently going through a divorce, and they've been together only 3 years (married for 2 of them). He's all torn up because the engagement ring was a family heirloom for 8 generations. Well, he's torn up for a lot of other reasons too. He asked for the ring back, but his ex-wife wants to keep it. My grandma's also upset and is laying into my uncle for giving the ring to someone who obviously wasn't in it for the long run.
I know many people consider an engagement ring to be a gift. I believe the law sees it that way too. Personally, I see it as a contract: a token of the love, trust, loyalty and companionship between the engaged. If the love (etc.) is no longer there, that contract no longer exists in my eyes. I'd also like to think that anyone knowing the value the ring has to the one family, would give it back. Just my opinion. I'd like to know what you guys and gals think as my thought process may be biased at the moment.
I know many people consider an engagement ring to be a gift. I believe the law sees it that way too. Personally, I see it as a contract: a token of the love, trust, loyalty and companionship between the engaged. If the love (etc.) is no longer there, that contract no longer exists in my eyes. I'd also like to think that anyone knowing the value the ring has to the one family, would give it back. Just my opinion. I'd like to know what you guys and gals think as my thought process may be biased at the moment.

