I have heard that this is the case here but I think it is debatable whether this is proper or not.An engagement ring IS a gift. The law accords it no special status. It is not part of a contract in return for the woman actually going through w the marriage.
I can see it both ways.
The engagement ring is offered along with the proposal and it is accepted along with the proposal.
On the other hand, it is given with the understanding that there is to be a wedding.
If an engagement was called off right after an engagement party, I think it would be proper for the presents and the ring to be offered for return.
This issue has come up several times on Judge Judy.
She says that it could go either way depending on the judge but her position is always that the engagement ring is returned if there is no marriage.
The ring was given with the contemplation of marriage.
And to her it doesn`t matter who called it off or why.

