Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 50.5%
  • No

    Votes: 46 49.5%

  • Total voters
    93
An engagement ring IS a gift. The law accords it no special status. It is not part of a contract in return for the woman actually going through w the marriage.
I have heard that this is the case here but I think it is debatable whether this is proper or not.
I can see it both ways.
The engagement ring is offered along with the proposal and it is accepted along with the proposal.
On the other hand, it is given with the understanding that there is to be a wedding.
If an engagement was called off right after an engagement party, I think it would be proper for the presents and the ring to be offered for return.

This issue has come up several times on Judge Judy.
She says that it could go either way depending on the judge but her position is always that the engagement ring is returned if there is no marriage.
The ring was given with the contemplation of marriage.
And to her it doesn`t matter who called it off or why.
 
I didn't bother reading all the posts so apologies if this has been said already but here's my thoughts on the matter of engagement rings.

If she breaks off the engagement she should return the ring (unless it was because of his actions)
If it's after the marriage has taken place, it's hers.

Now those are just general statements and depending on the specifics there could be different outcomes.

Was there any understanding that the ring was a family heirloom and that if something happened it was expected to come back to him? If so, is there anything in writing?

What lead to the breakup? If it was because of his actions solely then I wouldn't expect it to be given back. No rewards for stupidity.

If it is truly important to the family to have the ring back then the matter should become part of the divorce settlement and they should expect to pay for it as there must be some reason she is not inclined to give up the ring at this time. Could be sentimental, revenge, financial, whatever. But there will be some sort of price that will tip the scales into her giving them the ring.
 
I think the ring is hers to keep once the marriage takes place.
It is not fair to say that she was not in it for the long haul just because it didn`t work out.
I wouldn`t say she is hearless unless she is well off and just wants to keep it out of spite.
If she is not well off or just struggling to get by, she should sell the ring.
She should get some quotes, not appraisals, for what she could sell the ring for and she should give the uncle/family the opportunity to buy it.

Ouch. I can't see that sitting well with the family, especially grandma.

I AM starting to see it the way the majority of posters here do, as there are good arguments. It's just unfortunate business either way. I don't think she intends to sell it, which makes me personally feel better about it.
 
An engagement ring IS a gift. The law accords it no special status.
Oagre is of course absolutely correct. However, engagement rings are an area where the legally correct thing and the moral thing are not necesarily the same.

Certainly in the case of a broken engagement - particularly when the woman is the one who breaks the engagement the ring should be returned.* However, in the case of a marriage of decades the oposite is true and the ring is rather clearly the woman's moraly as well as legally.

This two year marriage is a bit of a grey area, certainly if she knows that the ring has great significance in her husband's family she should return it, however, he should also be willing to "sweeten the pot" for her so that she better sees this as being in her interests as well.

In any event, Rhuarc, I'm sorry to learn of this.


*There is an Australian case that deals directly with this
 
I didn't bother reading all the posts so apologies if this has been said already but here's my thoughts on the matter of engagement rings.

If she breaks off the engagement she should return the ring (unless it was because of his actions)
If it's after the marriage has taken place, it's hers.

Now those are just general statements and depending on the specifics there could be different outcomes.

Was there any understanding that the ring was a family heirloom and that if something happened it was expected to come back to him? If so, is there anything in writing?

What lead to the breakup? If it was because of his actions solely then I wouldn't expect it to be given back. No rewards for stupidity.

If it is truly important to the family to have the ring back then the matter should become part of the divorce settlement and they should expect to pay for it as there must be some reason she is not inclined to give up the ring at this time. Could be sentimental, revenge, financial, whatever. But there will be some sort of price that will tip the scales into her giving them the ring.

From what I know - which admittedly isn't much - they are breaking up due to lifestyle differences. He wants kids, she doesn't. His job has recently required he travel a lot, she hasn't liked that. Difference of opinions related to financial issues. Stuff like that. She was the one who called it off.

No, there was no understanding that the ring return to the family in the case of divorce (that I know of).
 
I am stunned by the response to this. Forget the the law, any decent woman should ABSOLUTELY return the ring.

It is not truly a gift. A guy is obligated to buy her a ring and often has to spend more than he wants on it because she insistes on this size, cut, etc. I'm not saying this for shock value or to be a smart ass, but men are extorted (by society) to a certain degree into buying the ring.

I would much rather have used that same amount I spent and bought a new car or many, many other things that would have been a very nice gift for her. The engagement ring is forced on men if they want to marry the girl they love. They have no choice in that.
 
From what I know - which admittedly isn't much - they are breaking up due to lifestyle differences. He wants kids, she doesn't. His job has recently required he travel a lot, she hasn't liked that. Difference of opinions related to financial issues. Stuff like that. She was the one who called it off.

No, there was no understanding that the ring return to the family in the case of divorce (that I know of).

So regular couple things that could have been figured out before they got married. Seriously - the topic of kids was never discussed before the ring was put on her finger????

Does not seem to me she did anything wrong in the marriage. His job changed, not hers. Finances probably did too. Sadly, if the family wants the ring back, payment is going to have to be made.
 
As for the ring being a "a token of love, trust, loyalty, and companionship", you're reading too many books with paintings of Fabio on the cover. The ring is like a down payment, showing that the guy has interest in future financial commitment, and it also says "hands off!" to other guys, especially if she's young and attractive. She completed her part of the contract as soon as there was consummation in the marital bed.

If you think rhuarc has been reading too many 'Fabio' novels, then you've been reading only accounting textbooks and 'Communist Manifesto', my esteemed colleague. Your statement lacks any sense of humanity or warmth. It harkens back to an antiquated era when a woman was thought of as 'property' and you could trade her for two cows.

Marriage is first and foremost an unselfish exchange of Love, Protection and Respect. You are there to give the other person the best you have in you without expectation of reward. The union of two people with the identical outlook is what creates a successful partnership.

This is rooted in Love. It is not a financial transaction to be bartered and calculated. If that were so, only lawyers and accountants would negotiate love and the human race would be extinct by now.

Those who see it that way are heartdead anyway and have no business trying to comprehend this thing called Love.
 
I am stunned by the response to this. Forget the the law, any decent woman should ABSOLUTELY return the ring.

It is not truly a gift. A guy is obligated to buy her a ring and often has to spend more than he wants on it because she insistes on this size, cut, etc. I'm not saying this for shock value or to be a smart ass, but men are extorted (by society) to a certain degree into buying the ring.

I would much rather have used that same amount I spent and bought a new car or many, many other things that would have been a very nice gift for her. The engagement ring is forced on men if they want to marry the girl they love. They have no choice in that.

Where did he pay for this ring? She met her obligation to marry him. Why should she give it back? Because you are stuck in a marriage with a wife you don't like who won't fuck you and won't shut up? You were as dumb as the uncle. WTF did you get married to be begin with? Clearly you don't love your wife. Where you forced into marrying her?

Give your head a shake bud. Life doesn't work the way you want after you figure out how your screwed yourself over.
 
I am stunned by the response to this. Forget the the law, any decent woman should ABSOLUTELY return the ring.

It is not truly a gift. A guy is obligated to buy her a ring and often has to spend more than he wants on it because she insistes on this size, cut, etc. I'm not saying this for shock value or to be a smart ass, but men are extorted (by society) to a certain degree into buying the ring.

I would much rather have used that same amount I spent and bought a new car or many, many other things that would have been a very nice gift for her. The engagement ring is forced on men if they want to marry the girl they love. They have no choice in that.

Other than providing me with her ring size my wife had no input on the ring I bought her. Other than the very nice lady at the jewelry store all the input was mine. Fortunately I picked one that she loved. Had she tried to dictate to me what the ring was to be and/or the price that I would spend on it she and I wouldn't have gotten married. Should something happen and we separate I would not be expecting her to give it back.


If guys are stupid enough to allow someone, be it their gf or society, browbeat them into spending beyond their means they have no one but themselves to blame.
 


Marriage is first and foremost an unselfish exchange of Love, Protection and Respect. You are there to give the other person the best you have in you without expectation of reward. The union of two people with the identical outlook is what creates a successful partnership.


Wrong. That is not marriage. Marriage is nothing more then a contract. Commitment is the unselfish exchange of love. Marriage is the contract that fucks the other over when the commitment fails.

You can have marriage without love, and you can most certainly have commitment without marriage. There is a difference and the difference is huge.
 
From what I know - which admittedly isn't much - they are breaking up due to lifestyle differences. He wants kids, she doesn't. His job has recently required he travel a lot, she hasn't liked that. Difference of opinions related to financial issues. Stuff like that. She was the one who called it off.

No, there was no understanding that the ring return to the family in the case of divorce (that I know of).

Seriously? They got married before discussing what's likely one of the most important items in a relationship (kids)? Wow.

Unless she is really sentimentally attached to the ring there must be more to the story I'm thinking. If it was just a case of them deciding this isn't working I would expect her to be more amicable about letting go of it.
 
If you decided to leave the marriage then she has the choice to keep the ring however, if she decides to leave then she should give it back.
 
Wrong. That is not marriage. Marriage is nothing more then a contract. Commitment is the unselfish exchange of love. Marriage is the contract that fucks the other over when the commitment fails.

You can have marriage without love, and you can most certainly have commitment without marriage. There is a difference and the difference is huge.

Tomato. Tomatoe.

Of course the difference is huge. That's a no brainer.

It takes a sober realist to know that getting into marriage IS an act of commitment.

If this realization is not present, don't do it at all.
 
An engagement ring IS a gift. The law accords it no special status. It is not part of a contract in return for the woman actually going through w the marriage.

I don't have any evidence of this, but I remember very clearly during a law class in high school that we talked about this issue and we were told that in Ontario, a women is obligated to return an engagement ring if the engagement is called off and asked for it back.
 
Tomato. Tomatoe.

Of course the difference is huge. That's a no brainer.

It takes a sober realist to know that getting into marriage IS an act of commitment.

If this realization is not present, don't do it at all.

Except people are not realist, they are dreamers. They think they are getting married for love, just like you said. People spend more time looking over the fine print when they buy a car or a house, then they do in getting married. Because buying a car or house is financial and contractual in their minds, yet marriage really is the same thing legally.

Don't get me wrong, I am all for love. I am against marriage. I am all for commitment, I am against contracting that commitment. I am all for celebrating love too. You want a big party, etc go for it. I am against the fraud of spending thousands to hundreds of thousands on the celebration of signing a piece of paper.
 
There are Ontario cases which clearly say that the engagement ring is a gift. I think the Judge Judy position is interesting and worth considering, but I have always understood Ontario law to be different.
 
Rhuarc29,

In my opinion the ring is your family's ring. The woman is no longer a member of your family and should therefore have to give the ring back to your family.
 
So regular couple things that could have been figured out before they got married. Seriously - the topic of kids was never discussed before the ring was put on her finger????

Does not seem to me she did anything wrong in the marriage. His job changed, not hers. Finances probably did too. Sadly, if the family wants the ring back, payment is going to have to be made.

Seriously? They got married before discussing what's likely one of the most important items in a relationship (kids)? Wow.

I'm confused on this as well. From my impression, she always seemed interested in having kids. Seems like that's no longer the case, perhaps for health reasons...? She's 41 now, so I guess pregnancy is high risk. Not sure about her views on adoption.
 
Wrong. That is not marriage. Marriage is nothing more then a contract. Commitment is the unselfish exchange of love. Marriage is the contract that fucks the other over when the commitment fails.

That's an unfortunate way to look at marriage. I would think the contractual part of the union would be least on the minds of the bride and groom. Which perhaps is the reason family heirlooms find their way into other families....