Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 50.5%
  • No

    Votes: 46 49.5%

  • Total voters
    93
That's an unfortunate way to look at marriage. I would think the contractual part of the union would be least on the minds of the bride and groom. Which perhaps is the reason family heirlooms find their way into other families....

I think it is a very real way of looking at it. If it was looked at for what it is really is, then maybe the heirloom would not have made into the hands of someone else. If the contract was written out properly, the contract would have ensured the ring came back your family, no?
 
I think it is a very real way of looking at it. If it was looked at for what it is really is, then maybe the heirloom would not have made into the hands of someone else. If the contract was written out properly, the contract would have ensured the ring came back your family, no?

Most folks in the throws of love don't bother giving much thought to what assets should be divided and how if the marriage ends. Many don't see it the black and white way which you seem to see it (though perhaps they should). They don't see the "contract".. They see the joining of families at a big party (the reception), The reciting of vows to one another in front of all their loved ones. The fact that they sign a "contract" at the end is often given far less though than what kind of napkins they want next to the charger plates at the dinner tables.
 
Normally, no...

But in the case of a family heirloom special circumstances apply. Your Uncle played it wrong in asking himself, though - your Grandmother would have had a lot better chance - esp. if she promised that your Uncle wouldn't ever get his hands on it again.
 
I don't have any evidence of this, but I remember very clearly during a law class in high school that we talked about this issue and we were told that in Ontario, a women is obligated to return an engagement ring if the engagement is called off and asked for it back.

I agree, but in this case, the engagement wasn't called off; they divorced after two years of marriage. That's a different situation.

What we don't know is whether the ring has monetary value in addition to sentimental value. If the original owner got it in a Cracker Jack box, and gave it to his betroved as a symbolic token of affection, she ought to give it back. If it has a four carat diamond and would be appraised at $20,000 +, He should make a substantial offer of money or other property to attempt to get it back.
 
Most folks in the throws of love don't bother giving much thought to what assets should be divided and how if the marriage ends.
Well there is the Lawyers/Clerics joke that it takes $20 to marry and thousands of dollars to divorce.
 
Yes is should be returned, it was never given as a gift but as a symbol. Marriage ends, ring returned. That's how I see it.
 
The ring should be given back if the engagement is terminated, but once their were married, it became her property. It's like a Promise of Performance contract between them. If the ring has such sentimental value, your uncle should offer her something else of greater financial value in the property settlement, in the hope that she would rather have that than the heirloom ring. If she wants to keep it, however, even if just to spite him, He's SOL. He'll just have to tell his mom that he got three magic beans for the cow.

As for the ring being a "a token of love, trust, loyalty, and companionship", you're reading too many books with paintings of Fabio on the cover. The ring is like a down payment, showing that the guy has interest in future financial commitment, and it also says "hands off!" to other guys, especially if she's young and attractive. She completed her part of the contract as soon as there was consummation in the marital bed.

^^
What he said Rhuarc29, sorry. (I don't even think there has to be consummation in the marital bed - as long as the engagement wasn't terminated before the marriage ceremony, even tradition would direct that she may keep the ring).
 
I mean this ring has been in your family for 8 generations, I think she should give it back, especially if she wasn't in for in a long run. If she doesn't give it back, she is a heartless bitch.

He then can be a prick in the divorce and make it difficult for her. The ring can become negotiation in a tit-for-tat exchange.
 
I would say etiquette dictate she return the ring , because the loss of the ring not only affect him, it effects that entire family so you are only hurting innocents.
 
if it's an heirloom then yes without question. if it's just some random ring the 2 of you picked out, who gives a fuck.
 
I would say etiquette dictate she return the ring , because the loss of the ring not only affect him, it effects that entire family so you are only hurting innocents.

Given that we do not know all the details of why the marriage breakup occurred it cannot be definitely said whether she should give back the ring. Yes it would be the right thing to give it back as it is an heirloom. But if she thinks he is going to be a dick regarding settling their affairs perhaps she is holding onto it for leverage.
 
I would say pay her off to get it back.

I am also wondering if she keeps it is she ever going to actually wear it? Or is it just going to sit in her jewelry box, drawer or make its way over to Oliver The Cash Mans jewelry shop?

I have heard of women actually wearing rings after the breakup or divorce, which is weird.
 
Given that we do not know all the details of why the marriage breakup occurred it cannot be definitely said whether she should give back the ring. Yes it would be the right thing to give it back as it is an heirloom. But if she thinks he is going to be a dick regarding settling their affairs perhaps she is holding onto it for leverage.

I have no problem with that either, as long as that family gets it back.
 
I have no problem with that either, as long as that family gets it back.
engagement rings are anachronisms. The way family law works now, women should be giving men engagement rings. At the very minimum women should buy their own rings. It seems fundementally unjust for men to give women rings.
 
engagement rings are anachronisms. The way family law works now, women should be giving men engagement rings. At the very minimum women should buy their own rings. It seems fundementally unjust for men to give women rings.

Hmmmm.

I don't know about other cultures, but I got a diamond engagement ring for myself (of course, a masculine one). She couldn't afford one, but in some Italian engagements, the guy can get a ring too from the bride.
 
The ring is like a down payment, showing that the guy has interest in future financial commitment, and it also says "hands off!" to other guys, especially if she's young and attractive. She completed her part of the contract as soon as there was consummation in the marital bed.

^^
What he said Rhuarc29, sorry. (I don't even think there has to be consummation in the marital bed - as long as the engagement wasn't terminated before the marriage ceremony....

Really? The engagement ring is a promise of financial security and ownership? I think you guys are living in the wrong decade.
 
Really? The engagement ring is a promise of financial security and ownership? I think you guys are living in the wrong decade.

Essentially, the ring is a gift with strings attached. The woman can't accept the gift unless she also agrees to the marriage. In this case, she did both, so the ring belongs to her. It's her choice what happens to the ring, not your uncle's, nor your grandmother's. If it means a lot to your uncle to get it back, he should offer more than fair value in exchange, but it's still up to the Ex to accept or decline his offer. Just because your uncle made a mistake in giving the ring to the wrong woman doesn't mean she has an obligation to return it. The wedding ring symbolizes an intent of permanency, not the engagement ring, which typically has greater monetary value. At the moment, the ring is a joint property item, to which she has dibs. If he wants it back badly enough, he'll make her an offer she can't refuse.
 
My uncle's currently going through a divorce, and they've been together only 3 years (married for 2 of them). He's all torn up because the engagement ring was a family heirloom for 8 generations. Well, he's torn up for a lot of other reasons too. He asked for the ring back, but his ex-wife wants to keep it. My grandma's also upset and is laying into my uncle for giving the ring to someone who obviously wasn't in it for the long run.

I know many people consider an engagement ring to be a gift. I believe the law sees it that way too. Personally, I see it as a contract: a token of the love, trust, loyalty and companionship between the engaged. If the love (etc.) is no longer there, that contract no longer exists in my eyes. I'd also like to think that anyone knowing the value the ring has to the one family, would give it back. Just my opinion. I'd like to know what you guys and gals think as my thought process may be biased at the moment.

Just goes to tell you what kind of women he married.I believe anyone with a touch of respect should give the ring back only because it's a family heirloom.Now,if it was bought just for her then your uncle is SOL.
 
I say it depends on how soon after marriage the divorce takes place. Less than five years, yes. Longer than that, no.