God's Law

Status
Not open for further replies.
.


While I understand the US Constitutional definition, I think many people would like to see the church & state separation extend both ways.

Yes, we must be vigilant lest this rather totalitarian sentiment take root. The idea that there is no place for the religious to express their views in our public dialogue is an alarming one.
 
Yes, we must be vigilant lest this rather totalitarian sentiment take root. The idea that there is no place for the religious to express their views in our public dialogue is an alarming one.

they can express their views freely, but if they want to be taken seriously, they had better find a better rationale to back it up than "God says so"
 
they can express their views freely, but if they want to be taken seriously, they had better find a better rationale to back it up than "God says so"
Well said. Rationales based only on religion carry no weight with people who think for themselves.
 
Last edited:
Yes, we must be vigilant lest this rather totalitarian sentiment take root. The idea that there is no place for the religious to express their views in our public dialogue is an alarming one.

Not sure if you're being sarcastic or obtuse.

My point is simply that there needs to be a set of rules and laws that apply to all and are separate from religion. So long as laws (many of which have roots in old religious mores and written beliefs) are not broken, then people can practice and express their religion to their heart's content. As others have mentioned, don't play the "and so it is written in the (insert old religious text) and so it shall be" card and expect others to accept it as their law.
 
so will i go to hell for preferring lemon chicken over sweet and sour pork ?
 
Rationales based only on religion carry no weight with people who think for themselves.
Perhaps but even in Canada "Nothing in this Act affects the freedom of officials of religious groups to refuse to perform marriages that are not in accordance with their religious beliefs."
 
Perhaps but even in Canada "Nothing in this Act affects the freedom of officials of religious groups to refuse to perform marriages that are not in accordance with their religious beliefs."
What’s the problem with that? Within limits, private organizations should be allowed to do what they want. I suppose you could argue that since they get tax subsidizes by not having to pay property taxes, etc. the state has the right to some say in their activities. However, a better way to handle that problem would be to just cut the tax subsidies and let them do what they want (within limits which in my view would not include letting them refuse blood transfusions for their children, deny their children a proper education, etc.). Whether or not, what they want to do is stupid is separate question.

BTW, the point of my post was not whether allowing gay marriage was a good thing or a bad thing. My point was that any argument (on any issue) that is solely based on religious beliefs and not real world evidence/considerations is of zero value. I have heard arguments against gay marriage that don’t refer to religion. Whether I agree with the particular argument or not, I have more use for them as an attempt is made to make an argument not based solely on what people in a less advanced and more superstitious past society believed.
 
Last edited:
Someone, now that is probably unintentionaly funny.

You start off saying "what's the problem with that," but then proceed to basicly argue that John Marshall was wrong when he famously said "The power to tax is the power to destroy."

You then state that no one should be able to make an argument about social policy based soley upon religious belief, which of course is basicly exactly what section three of the Civil Marriage Act provides for.
 
Someone, now that is probably unintentionaly funny.

You start off saying "what's the problem with that," but then proceed to basicly argue that John Marshall was wrong when he famously said "The power to tax is the power to destroy."
I have no idea what you are talking about here. My point is that when the government subsidies a group they get the right to have an influence. As soon as they pick on choose who pays property taxes, they are affecting real economic behaviour and favouring one group over another. Both give them the right to set terms and conditions for the more favourable treatment. Of course, if they stop subsidizing religions, the argument that they should have a say ends.

You then state that no one should be able to make an argument about social policy based soley upon religious belief, which of course is basicly exactly what section three of the Civil Marriage Act provides for.
You are getting to be like Woodpecker in putting words into people’s mouths. I never said “no one should be able to make an argument about ...” What I said was that such an argument “is of zero value”. People have the right to make whatever stupid arguments they want. However, intelligent people place zero weight on arguments based solely on superstition. You have a perfect right to ARGUE (argue as opposed to actually doing it) that you SHOULD be able to sell your daughter into slavery and cite the bible. However, it is an argument that should carry zero weight among people who think for themselves.

Arguments only based on religious superstition are no different than Woodpecker’s arguments in the sense both are based on ignorance. In either case, it does not mean people don’t have the right to make the arguments. It just means they should not be taken seriously.

And no, nothing in the civil marriages act either increases or decreases the right to free speech by religious organizations.
 
I have no idea what you are talking about here. My point is that when the government subsidies a group they get the right to have an influence. As soon as they pick on choose who pays property taxes, they are affecting real economic behaviour and favouring one group over another. Both give them the right to set terms and conditions for the more favourable treatment. Of course, if they stop subsidizing religions, the argument that they should have a say ends.


You are getting to be like Woodpecker in putting words into people’s mouths. I never said “no one should be able to make an argument about ...” What I said was that such an argument “is of zero value”. People have the right to make whatever stupid arguments they want. However, intelligent people place zero weight on arguments based solely on superstition. You have a perfect right to ARGUE (argue as opposed to actually doing it) that you SHOULD be able to sell your daughter into slavery and cite the bible. However, it is an argument that should carry zero weight among people who think for themselves.

Arguments only based on religious superstition are no different than Woodpecker’s arguments in the sense both are based on ignorance. In either case, it does not mean people don’t have the right to make the arguments. It just means they should not be taken seriously.

And no, nothing in the civil marriages act either increases or decreases the right to free speech by religious organizations.

Actually you are now retreating from your earlier position by inserting the word "superstition.". Your earlier comment was:

Rationales based only on religion carry no weight with people who think for themselves.

I trust you understand the difference.

I have no idea what point you are trying to make about taxing churches. None at all.
 
geez are you that thick? That is exactly what YOU are engaging in. Perhaps Dr. Laura was being smug perhaps she was not. That really is immaterial. What I take issue with is how YOU are being smug. If your rebuttal to the smugness is your smugness it really seems to me to be rather shrill and insignificant.:frusty:

Smugness is one thing, Sisyphus, but you are dishonest. I defy you to prove that the biblical passages in question are misused as they say they are.
 
Actually you are now retreating from your earlier position by inserting the word "superstition.". Your earlier comment was:



I trust you understand the difference.
Both my statements are consistent. Religion is a type of superstition. I just moved from the specific to the general. The point would also apply to arguments based on astrology. If you prefer a word with fewer negative connotations, substitute,” arguments not based on fact or evidence”.


I have no idea what point you are trying to make about taxing churches. None at all.
Likely because you were a liberal arts major:)
 
Dr Laura is a bat zona, an adultress, nude pics of her on the internet confirm this. She is an abomintation and her comments which often changed with the wind should be ignored.
 
Both my statements are consistent. Religion is a type of superstition. I just moved from the specific to the general.



Likely because you were a liberal arts major:)


I guess you missed out on the fact that all charities are subsidized in one way or another by our tax code. If you are suggesting that we should tax churches you are suggesting discrimination against religion...but why should I be surprised.

And there is nothing wrong with making an argument based on religious authority, any more than an economist making an argument based on capitalist theory, it is up to the person understanding the argument to accept it and its structure or not. To reject all arguments based on religious authority "en bloc" strikes me as rather closed minded.
 
I guess you missed out on the fact that all charities are subsidized in one way or another by our tax code. If you are suggesting that we should tax churches you are suggesting discrimination against religion...but why should I be surprised.
Since when are charities exempt from property taxes? They are exempt from income taxes (corporate or individual). There are several arguments that can be made in favour of such exemptions for charities but they are not related to churches paying property taxes.

BTW, governments do have a say in how charities can operate if they want to retain their favourable tax treatment.

And there is nothing wrong with making an argument based on religious authority, any more than an economist making an argument based on capitalist theory, it is up to the person understanding the argument to accept it and its structure or not. To reject all arguments based on religious authority "en bloc" strikes me as rather closed minded.
I have never heard an economist making any argument based on “capitalist theory”. Indeed, I have never even heard of the “theory”. Thus, without knowing what “capitalist theory” is I’m willing to accept that it would be just as silly as an argument based on religious authority. If so, it is a good thing that at least in their professional role, economists don’t make the argument.
 
Since when are charities exempt from property taxes? They are exempt from income taxes (corporate or individual). There are several arguments that can be made in favour of such exemptions for charities but they are not related to churches paying property taxes.


I have never heard an economist making any argument based on “capitalist theory”. Indeed, I have never even heard of the “theory”. Thus, without knowing what “capitalist theory” is I’m willing to accept that it would be just as silly as an argument based on religious authority. If so, it is a good thing that at least in their professional role, economists don’t make the argument.


In Ontario since 2001 municipalities are required by legislation to have a property tax rebate program from charities with varying amounts available.

Capitalism is the theory that provides the value judgments for economic approaches. If you want to take an economic direction you need to have common value judgments about the goals. Communism, or a mixed theory, or fascism, etc provide other frameworks and value judgments for economic theory. Religion simply does the same thing for non-economic issues. Economists may not make the argument explicitly, but people who set economic policy have to rely on those value judgments. And you do live in a country where the majority of our laws arose from Christian theory.
 
Capitalism is the theory that provides the value judgments for economic approaches. If you want to take an economic direction you need to have common value judgments about the goals. Communism, or a mixed theory, or fascism, etc provide other frameworks and value judgments for economic theory.
This sounds like some nonsense you got in some liberal arts course taught by someone with no background in economics. First, economics tries as much as possible to be a positive science. Usually, in the very first lecture (if not, shortly afterwards) of a principles course, student are taught the difference between positive and normative statements. This does not mean that an economist’s value judgements don’t enter into analysis but the way it enters tends to be more subtle. E.g. the choice of problems they choose to work on. Economists can tell you what the effects of a given economic policy are. However judging whether those effects are positive or negative and whether the benefits are worth the costs is a different matter (especially if some of the benefts or costs cannot be measured in dollars). Individual economists have opinions on such matters but they are personal opinions. Often (usually?) they are more informed than the personal opinions of others as the economists are more likely to know what the costs and benefits are (although at times, being human, they do offer normative opinions on things outside their personal area of knowledge). However, even an informed opinion on normative issues is not a positive opinion.

I hope I have cleared up your misunderstanding.
 
This sounds like some nonsense you got in some liberal arts course taught by someone with no background in economics. First, economics tries as much as possible to be a positive science. Usually, in the very first lecture (if not, shortly afterwards) of a principles course, student are taught the difference between positive and normative statements. This does not mean that an economist’s value judgements don’t enter into analysis but the way it enters tends to be more subtle. E.g. the choice of problems they choose to work on. Economists can tell you what the effects of a given economic policy are. However judging whether those effects are positive or negative and whether the benefits are greater than the costs is a different matter. Individual economists have opinions on such matters but they are personal opinions. Often (usually?) they are more informed than the personal opinions of others as the economists are more likely to know what the costs and benefits are (although at times, being human, they do offer normative opinions on things outside their personal area of knowledge). However, even an informed opinion on normative issues is not a positive opinion.

I hope I have cleared up your misunderstanding.


Sorry, didn't get it in a liberals arts course, of course there would be nothing wrong with that if I did.

I am happy to watch any academic group, economics included, sit around in the ivory towers and think about theory, but when people have to make economic policy or offer economic guidance, they have to do so based on some belief system as to what the best possible outcome is, or what aspects to emphasize. If they don't they are worthless.

Religion offers one approach to doing the same thing for civic issues and questions of morals.

Many important questions are answered, in areas of economic policy, social policy, legislation, etc, by people making value judgments, and that is the area where religion tries to make its input. For instance, Catholic scholars (generally) don't talk about precisely how to reduce poverty, but seek to remind us that taking care of the poor and disposed is an important priority. In the same vein RC scholars don't try to explain the precise mechanisms behind global warming but do talk about man' stewardship over the earth and our responsibility to care for all of creation.

So, while there may be a group of many economic scholars, who treat it precisely like a historic science, there are many who are called upon to give advice or even set policy. They must either make value judgments or accept value judgments handed to them by others.

In fact the more you talk about it, the more economics sounds like religion in its functioning.
 
Sorry, didn't get it in a liberals arts course, of course there would be nothing wrong with that if I did.
So you are taking full responsibility for your misunderstanding. That is admirable.
I am happy to watch any academic group, economics included, sit around in the ivory towers and think about theory, but when people have to make economic policy or offer economic guidance, they have to do so based on some belief system as to what the best possible outcome is, or what aspects to emphasize. If they don't they are worthless.
At the end of the day a decision has to be made as to whether benefits are worth the costs. However, that has nothing to do with some imaginary “capitalist theory”
Religion offers one approach to doing the same thing for civic issues and questions of morals.
Many important questions are answered, in areas of economic policy, social policy, legislation, etc, by people making value judgments, and that is the area where religion tries to make its input. For instance, Catholic scholars (generally) don't talk about precisely how to reduce poverty, but seek to remind us that taking care of the poor and disposed is an important priority. In the same vein RC scholars don't try to explain the precise mechanisms behind global warming but do talk about man' stewardship over the earth and our responsibility to care for all of creation.
The point is that if the only support they can give for their arguments is based on the beliefs of more primitive societies, I have no use for them. BTW, the fact is that successful religions change their values over time to reflect the societies they are in. If they did not, their religion would disappear. That is why most (all?) current religions ignore the parts of the bible mentioned in the first post of the thread. If they did not, they would have serious problems keeping members.
So, while there may be a group of many economic scholars, who treat it precisely like a historic science, there are many who are called upon to give advice or even set policy. They must either make value judgments or accept value judgments handed to them by others.
Economists rarely set policy. When it comes to advice, they can tell you that when you compare the HST to the old tax system, the HST can collect a given amount of revenue at lower cost to a typical taxpayer. One would hope informed voters would take than into account when voting in a referendum. Indeed, my personal opinion is that voters are idiots if they don’t take that into account. However, at the end of the day it is a personal opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.