God's Law

Status
Not open for further replies.
You quickly jump to conclusions with out knowing the facts. I don't think you should be lecturing anyone on prejudicial thinking.
What facts am I missing? Where did I lecture on prejudicial thinking?

I made a point on how some people inappropriately select and isolate pieces of literature(doctrine) to support an argument. You have presented a non sequitur. It is disingenuous for someone to do that wilfully.
 
Yes.... I would be interested in her rebuttal.

Why? You already know it wouldn't be a logical reply. You already know that she's picking and choosing from the Bible whatever fits her purpose. Someone who doesn't think logically will have many ways to slough off the stuff in there she doesn't agree with.

At the end of the day she's a twit.
 
While there might very well be case for claiming an irrationality to religious beliefs can anyone really make the case that it is any more irrational then utilitarianism?
I should realize that it is usually pointless to ask an extremely religious person anything. However, in this case I cannot help myself. What do you think utilitarianism has to do with anything discussed here? There are plenty of arguments that can be made both in favour and against utilitarianism as a rule for social decisions rather than other possible rules. However, I am curious as to what you think it could possibly have to do with this thread.
 
Interesting interpretation. I found the exact opposite. I think the rebuttal created a straw man rather then address what the passages really said. While there might very well be case for claiming an irrationality to religious beliefs can anyone really make the case that it is any more irrational then utilitarianism?
Leviticus 18 makes many claims. If Dr. Laura had asserted that she opposed sex between a mother and a son because Leviticus says “She is your mother; do not have relations with her.”, Would you be equally critical of her views. Would you make the same accusation of hypocrisy?

I didn't make an allegation of hypocracy. I just fact checked your allegation that any of the passages she specified were used inaccurately. They were not. Not a one.

You just seem to be having trouble following the logic of her critics. Her position (at that time) was that homosexuality is an abomination because the OT says so. She says proposition A is true because it's source is B(bible) says so and it is always right because it is divine law. The critique, in a witty and powerful way asks the question "Do you apply the same logic or do you pick and choose what suits you from this divine law?"

Now the letter may not have been directed to her, and I don't think she wrote a normal rebuttal, but she did later apologize for her comments and tried to explain her perspective a little differently.

Now your logic is even worse. Let's say I have a list of ten laws, nine of them say you should kill innocent children from some ethnic group and the other one says child molesting is bad. Do you think we will all become child molesters because we reject the killing of innocent children?
 
Interesting interpretation. I found the exact opposite. I think the rebuttal created a straw man rather then address what the passages really said.
On her radio show, Dr Laura Schlesinger said that, as an observant Orthodox Jew, homosexuality is an abomination according to Leviticus 18:22, and cannot be condoned under any circumstance.

What she said is clear. The point that the unknown author made is that since Laura is holding up Leviticus 18:22 as an absolute moral doctrine to live by, does it not follow that Leviticus 25:44 (et al) should also be followed religiously(pun intended)? If not, why not?

Your rebuttal was to provide a non sequitur argument that implies that if we don't observe Leviticus 18:22 then family members will start fucking each other en masse. It does not follow.

While there might very well be case for claiming an irrationality to religious beliefs can anyone really make the case that it is any more irrational then utilitarianism?
A different type of non sequitur. Would you like to compare religion to horse training too?

Leviticus 18 makes many claims. If Dr. Laura had asserted that she opposed sex between a mother and a son because Leviticus says “She is your mother; do not have relations with her.”, Would you be equally critical of her views. Would you make the same accusation of hypocrisy?
The answer is, "No." Why? Because nowhere in our society do we view incest as acceptable. We generally agree that mothers shouldn't fuck their kids. Society has changed opinion on homosexuality. Gay marriage is becoming accepted. Daughter fucking, not so much. Straw men? You are bad at making them but make them you do. lol
 
One of the most telling things is that the "Dr" (of physiology) is no longer an orthodox jew and apologized for that particular comment.
 
NOT that I am in any way suggesting it is ok, but speaking of straw men, the same changes in societal norms that made selling your daughter into slavery , homosexual sex unacceptable may give way to incest and allowing menstruating women in public!
True. It might be sooner rather than later. (btw.... I think we already allow menstruating women in public. I could be wrong)
 
The critique, in a witty and powerful way
Since I am critical of the OP and in particular the rebuttal in question, this sort of statement is self serving. It is neither witty, nor powerful. It purports to be written by a serious person, addressing a serious issue but on investigation it can not be contributed to anyone. The sarcasm in question is boring , self serving and only serves to beg the question. I am not trying to defend Dr Laura but rather criticize the rebuttal.
With respect to Orthodox jews, I have no doubt that they accept the tora as it is written and try to live to the standard of the law as it is written. I may not agree with this but I can not accuse them of hypocrisy. I can not be so kind with respect to the anonymous rebuttal.
 
Oy veh!

She lost her high paying job and status.
How do you figure that? Her radio show has been on Sirius XM Radio since January and she has a multi-year contract, just because I wouldn't bother to listen to her, doesn't mean the program isn't highly sucessful.
 
Since I am critical of the OP and in particular the rebuttal in question, this sort of statement is self serving. It is neither witty, nor powerful. It purports to be written by a serious person, addressing a serious issue but on investigation it can not be contributed to anyone. The sarcasm in question is boring , self serving and only serves to beg the question. I am not trying to defend Dr Laura but rather criticize the rebuttal.
With respect to Orthodox jews, I have no doubt that they accept the tora as it is written and try to live to the standard of the law as it is written. I may not agree with this but I can not accuse them of hypocrisy. I can not be so kind with respect to the anonymous rebuttal.

I guess irony is not your strong point. I made that comment to balance your equally, and earlier self serving statement:

Kauffman’s rebuttal is in my opinion neither clever, nor humorous, nor insightful. Furthermore if you look into to the passages he cites it is clear he misrepresent what those passages say.

However you claimed that the author misrepresented biblical quotes. I have called you on it, and all you respond with is silent. I will say it again, each quote refers to the topic that author suggests it does, in the way he/she suggests it does. In your rush to attack this letter you have thrown the facts aside.

I personally have never heard of orthodox jews still keeping slaves...or killing people for working on the Sabbath.
 
Since I am critical of the OP and in particular the rebuttal in question, this sort of statement is self serving. It is neither witty, nor powerful. It purports to be written by a serious person, addressing a serious issue but on investigation it can not be contributed to anyone. The sarcasm in question is boring , self serving and only serves to beg the question. I am not trying to defend Dr Laura but rather criticize the rebuttal.
With respect to Orthodox jews, I have no doubt that they accept the tora as it is written and try to live to the standard of the law as it is written. I may not agree with this but I can not accuse them of hypocrisy. I can not be so kind with respect to the anonymous rebuttal.
Respectfully, you are making no sense. With respect to Orthodox Jews, they most certainly do not live to the standard as written in many cases or they would be in jail....and it is OBVIOUSLY hypocritical. They don't own slaves. They don't sell their daughters into slavery etc. This is the thrust of the witty critique and why it is powerful.

You can certainly opine that the response is boring. Self serving? It very well may be. It is someone's response to illustrate how someone else's position is flawed. It is likely to be self serving (but not necessarily). So?

What question is the response begging? You claim it, "only serves to beg the question." What question?

You are critical of me. Ok.... umm..... any particular reason other than I have challenged you?

You have not critisized the content of the rebuttal other than to write that certain passages have been falsely represented. This has been refuted. You have made some other inane comments but sadly, you have missed the proverbial target. Not even a flesh wound.
 
You are critical of me. Ok.... umm..... any particular reason other than I have challenged you?

You have not critisized the content of the rebuttal other than to write that certain passages have been falsely represented. This has been refuted. You have made some other inane comments but sadly, you have missed the proverbial target. Not even a flesh wound.

certain passages have been falsely represented. I have no doubt that of the 10 passages cited only #5, that is exodus 35:2 is accurately characterised.

That aside sidebanger you continue to miss the point of my rebuttal. I originally posted...

What a relief that you all agree that Leviticus 18 can be ignored. I guess we can all go back to f_*King our mothers and screwing animals. Kauffman’s rebuttal is in my opinion neither clever, nor humorous, nor insightful. Furthermore if you look into to the passages he cites it is clear he misrepresent what those passages say.

I can understand if your opinion is that the entire bible is malarkey and should be ignored. Then you have a point of ignoring everything, chapter and verse. If however your point is, orthodox jews are all in error then it is disingenuous to simply label the target of your attack Dr Laura. It should read dear orthodox jews you are all chumps. This is the problem I have with this flippant approach. I am not Jewish, I don’t eat kosher but I am convinced that the reasons for eating kosher are in the Tora. I might very well say I don’t agree with the Tora or I might say I don’t agree with the literal interpretation of the Tora but I can’t accuse them of hypocrisy.
It does give me pause however in considering what an orthodox Jewish state might look like and whether such a state could respect human rights but that is a side issue not germaine to my criticism.
It is so easy for fools to criticise the moral systems of others yet when asked to justify their own values you see nothing but arbitrary, principle less assertions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.