Legal question

"See that house across the street. Guy who owns it hookers dropped off every Friday and Saturday, almost always new ones and no one stays more than an hour. I've even seen them come out and hand cash to their drivers. The neighbours told me about him after I bought."

Sound like a reputation to me. Like the earlier point about profits, it's reasonable to expect the law to aim at places open to the public, but it's not actually worded that way.
 
I don't see how paying for a hotel room and going through a string of Escorts, would qualify as a crime.

1) "keeper of a COMMON bawdy house".. The common part implies that it was, at least to a certain extent, open to the public. I do believe that a hotel room has similar "reasonable expectation of privacy" protection as a private residence. Not exactley the same, but some.

2) The onus would be on the Crown to prove that anyone other than the escort profited from the acts that have taken place in the room. Paying an escort would be the exact opposite of being a keeper of a common bawdy house, who PROFITS from each transaction.

3) If getting one escort isn't illegal, how can getting three or four be illegal... or is it kinda like a seven cats per household by-law?

4) The Hotel wouldn't have any liability for keeper of a common bawdy house charge unless they also profited from the particular event. If they charge you the same rate as everyone else.... Now, if they charged you the " Hey, there's no way that that hottie is your wife, we don't care if she's only here for an hour, hand over another twenty rate"... then they may have issues with the bawdy house thing..
 
"See that house across the street. Guy who owns it hookers dropped off every Friday and Saturday, almost always new ones and no one stays more than an hour. I've even seen them come out and hand cash to their drivers. The neighbours told me about him after I bought."

Sound like a reputation to me. Like the earlier point about profits, it's reasonable to expect the law to aim at places open to the public, but it's not actually worded that way.

Sounds like a bawdy house to me, but the "common" part implies public access in my eyes--if we are to continue this tack of sidestepping the act itself and just discussing reputation. To me a "common" bawdy house is one that any member of the public can access, provided they stump up the fee. A private home might be replete with lewd acts and prostitution, but it's invitation only by the owner, the general public, no matter how much they might like to join in, is denied entry.
 
I don't see how paying for a hotel room and going through a string of Escorts, would qualify as a crime.

1) "keeper of a COMMON bawdy house".. The common part implies that it was, at least to a certain extent, open to the public. I do believe that a hotel room has similar "reasonable expectation of privacy" protection as a private residence. Not exactley the same, but some.
If you have a string of prostitutes coming to a location, that looks like it's open to the public as much as if you have a string of johns coming to your location. I don't expect many legal cases to hing on this argument. My understanding is that most charges under this section are laid against purveyors of private locations (i.e. you don't see a mall owner, or a pub operator charged for keeping a bawdy house in a public place).
2) The onus would be on the Crown to prove that anyone other than the escort profited from the acts that have taken place in the room. Paying an escort would be the exact opposite of being a keeper of a common bawdy house, who PROFITS from each transaction.
You make it sound like it would be onerous. It's not. Lawyers can chime in but I don't believe the charge requires proving that the accused even knew that it was a place of prostitution (although a conviction would presumably be very difficult if there were no association with the business activity). Simply collecting rent, or an hourly charge for the place could be sufficient to demonstrate such a nexus. Again, though, the charges as known are directed against the one providing the location to the one receiving the money from the sexual transaction (and not to anyone providing a location for the one providing the money for the sexual transaction.

3) If getting one escort isn't illegal, how can getting three or four be illegal... or is it kinda like a seven cats per household by-law?
It's not about the number, but the public nuisance, which is evaluated on a grey scale. But even if it were about the number, the law is allowed to differentiate between different numbers: If it's okay to go 49 km/h, then how can it be illegal to go 55 km/h? (Because the law differentiates between different numbers.) If I'm allowed to build my house 18 feet high, how can it be illegal to build it 25 feet high? (Because the law differentiates between different numbers.) And the law is not just the statues which are signed into law, but also consist of volumes of Case Law, which is much more difficult to sift through.

4) The Hotel wouldn't have any liability for keeper of a common bawdy house charge unless they also profited from the particular event. If they charge you the same rate as everyone else.... Now, if they charged you the " Hey, there's no way that that hottie is your wife, we don't care if she's only here for an hour, hand over another twenty rate"... then they may have issues with the bawdy house thing..

The Hotelier couldn't simply wash his hands of it, either, claiming that they weren't party to the transaction and therefore had no role to play. I'm quite certain hotel owners have been charged (and convicted) in the past, although their method of conducting themselves has changed significantly over the years.
 
Yup. You guys have an argument you could surely make well and sound persuasive doing it. But whether you would actually convince the judge or jury that the place wouldn't qualify as a bawdyhouse, absent actual access and use by actual members of the public as opposed to those involved in the transactions (think about that one for a moment) is open to serious doubt. No one has yet cited an example either way; the only reasonable concusion to draw is: Be careful, know where the radar is and stay under it.
 
If you have a string of prostitutes coming to a location, that looks like it's open to the public as much as if you have a string of johns coming to your location.

Except it's not in any way open to the public. Anyone in Toronto with $150 can visit any incall that offers a $150/30 rate. It is literally open to the public. Any prostitute in Toronto who wants to visit my house cannot do so unless I call her and specifically invite her over.
 
Except it's not in any way open to the public. Anyone in Toronto with $150 can visit any incall that offers a $150/30 rate. It is literally open to the public. Any prostitute in Toronto who wants to visit my house cannot do so unless I call her and specifically invite her over.

You really do seem convinced for some unknown reason that it's in any way relevant whether it meets any definition of a "public place".

It doesn't.
 
Couple of thoughts.

First off, getting arrested and charged is already a huge problem. Even without a conviction, it is expensive for a lawyer and there is a record of the arrest which of itself is a prejudicial mark against someone. The arrest is a pretty big punishment on its own.

Some good arguments over the "common" part of "common bawdy house" and the issues of public invitation versus private place, public nuisance and specifically the rights attached to one's residence.

It is interesting to consider the view of the neighbourhood when considering the intention of the law to protect the neighbourhood from nuisances.

Imagine we are talking about the common gaming house laws instead. Imagine your condo neighbour is from an ethnic group that considers gambling a normal part of their culture and they invite people over to their residence on a regular basis for gambling? People knock on your door by mistake, there is a lot of smoke coming through the walls, noise is not terrible but you know what is going on etc. You could reasonably think that with so many unsavoury characters invited into your hallways that your security may be compromised.

Not a lot different if you had a condo neighbour who won the lottery and was inviting all kinds of CL girls over at all hours with the same issues as above.

Not saying anything either way, just putting out another meaningless argument and POV!
Without looking it up I can tell you that gaming houses are defined in the code quite differently than bordellos. That being said I agree with the nuisance argument. Fuji is way off.

More importantly, I have some news from the trenches. Toronto police does not do sweeps after the court of appeal case, but only responds to complaints re prostitution. York region still does raids and sweeps.
 
What's the word "common" doing in the act then? Superfluous word?

"common bawdy" actually means "come on buddy"
 
What's the word "common" doing in the act then? Superfluous word?
Yes. If it wasn't then there'd be precedents for uncommon bawdyhouses escaping charges. Or maybe we'd call them special bawdyhouses and give them licenses.
 
Does anybody know if your hotel room (or your house) could become a "bawdy house" if you see a lot of escorts in a short period of time (e.g. multiple SPs in a day for a hotel room or once a week if it`s at your house)? Have the courts defined what a "bawdy house" is?
The question came up from this thread: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?317237-Incall-vs.-Outcall

From Canadian Criminal Code:

210. (1) Every one who keeps a common bawdy-house is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years.
Landlord, inmate, etc.

(2) Every one who

(a) is an inmate of a common bawdy-house,
(b) is found, without lawful excuse, in a common bawdy-house, or
(c) as owner, landlord, lessor, tenant, occupier, agent or otherwise having charge or control of any place, knowingly permits the place or any part thereof to be let or used for the purposes of a common bawdy-house,
is guilty of an offence punishable on summary conviction.
Notice of conviction to be served on owner

(3) Where a person is convicted of an offence under subsection (1), the court shall cause a notice of the conviction to be served on the owner, landlord or lessor of the place in respect of which the person is convicted or his agent, and the notice shall contain a statement to the effect that it is being served pursuant to this section.

Duty of landlord on notice

(4) Where a person on whom a notice is served under subsection (3) fails forthwith to exercise any right he may have to determine the tenancy or right of occupation of the person so convicted, and thereafter any person is convicted of an offence under subsection (1) in respect of the same premises, the person on whom the notice was served shall be deemed to have committed an offence under subsection (1) unless he proves that he has taken all reasonable steps to prevent the recurrence of the offence.

R.S., c. C-34, s. 193.

Transporting person to bawdy-house

211. Every one who knowingly takes, transports, directs, or offers to take, transport or direct, any other person to a common bawdy-house is guilty of an offence punishable on summary conviction.
R.S., c. C-34, s. 194.
 
Arguing over the purport of the word 'common' as applied to 'bawdyhouse' is reminiscent of the arguments over the word 'high' attached to 'crimes and misdemeanours' when Nixon's criminality and impeachment were being discussed.

While it is possible the drafters did mean to establish some level of difference by attachment of a weighty adjective, to define the offences in such a way, so as to excuse the perpetrator would mean we'd have to accept criminal Presidents or uncommon brothelkeepers and allow them to continue their undesirable actions. I can't believe even the most corrupt and incompetent legislators would intend such.
 
Arguing over the purport of the word 'common' as applied to 'bawdyhouse' is reminiscent of the arguments over the word 'high' attached to 'crimes and misdemeanours' when Nixon's criminality and impeachment were being discussed.

While it is possible the drafters did mean to establish some level of difference by attachment of a weighty adjective, to define the offences in such a way, so as to excuse the perpetrator would mean we'd have to accept criminal Presidents or uncommon brothelkeepers and allow them to continue their undesirable actions. I can't believe even the most corrupt and incompetent legislators would intend such.

I'm surprised no one has bothered to post how the Criminal Code defines "common bawdy house."

From subsection 197(1):

“common bawdy-house” means a place that is

(a) kept or occupied, or

(b) resorted to by one or more persons

for the purpose of prostitution or the practice of acts of indecency;

Now, continue arguing amongst yourselves. ;)
 
Thanks for that. Now the arguments can get down to the real meat of the matter: Is it 'resorting' if they don't serve drinks with paper umbrellas?