WRT the Sparrow decision - I would honestly be interested to know how many First Nation peoples hunt/fish as their main source of food below the 50th parallel. I personally know a couple of guys on Manitoulin that fish out of season for whatever they can get and sell the fish. Somehow I don't think that is what the SCC had in mind when they rendered Sparrow.
Maybe not to you, but when what you are bring back something that was destined to be sold across a border that we, and the companies that pleaded guilty, recognize, ANYONE facilitating that transfer is a smuggler, IMHO.
And there is the crux of your "problem". It seems that you, personally, feel that you have no identity off "the rez". Why are you letting the government tell you that "to live as who we are, we HAVE to live on reservations"? Can't you be a member of a First Nation and live in the GTA? I know you are proud of who you are and where you come from - many of us are. I just think it's time to stop using the "rez" as a crutch.
I really don't mean to be a hardass but the "not a citizen=not a resident" was just too much. Do you hold a Canadian Passport?
What he said..........my son is half Cree Half me.And I want the treaties to be respected.The ignornace of so many people on this thread is so frustrating!Learn,then talk.Or shut the hell up.
Excuse me, but I'm a native, as were my parents and grandparents, and their parents too. The term you want is First Nations or Aboriginal. Native just means "born here".
Makes sense.If you read the first lines of his post, you will notice he calls himself native, not Aboriginal, and explains the difference. We are all native, because native just means we were born here.
Native Indian seems pretty clear, until you consider all the people born in India.In order to be exempt, you must produce your native Indian status card, it has the band number, name of the tribe, and your ID number.
I'm sorry but ... our world?OK, first of all, I am Mohawk (wolf clan)!
Yes I am native, I work in your world and I pay your taxes.
So what do your treaties say regarding the use of land by native Canadians?Even though our treaties (signed contracts in your world) state that I don't have to. Our treaties guarantee me and my native brothers and sisters certain "freedoms" for allowing the non-natives to use our land (more like destroy it).
I'm sure there are many Canadians who have faced discrimination and abuse throughout their lives. Just saying.If you've never lived as a native in this country, faced the life long descrimination, the abuse and if you're going to post something here based entirely on hearsay, propaganda or something you read somewhere in a textbook (published again by the government) then don't bother. YOUR = non-native
This seems to apply to all people born here, although I'm not sure how often non-indian natives are allowed to live on a reserve. I suppose through marriage they could.Natives pay federal taxes unless they work on the reserve. Natives pay no land tax if they live on the reserve because it's owned by the local band counsel. They pay no gst/pst so they collect none ( buy your smokes on the reserves for $15.00 a bag = 200 cigs). Anyone can shop on the reserve and they won't charge you tax. Natives get 14 cents off per litre of gasoline.
Ancient history. If they want to live in teepees (sp?) and hunt with bow and arrow fine. Otherwise join modern society and pay like the rest of us.
So are you proud of how your ancestors exterminated entire tried 100's of miles away from the nearest europeans purely out of self interest and not at the behest of anyone else.
Funny how you complain about the genocide of a school system, when you are still around. Even the Germans didn't manage to wipe away the Jews in Germany unlike the Erie and the Neutrals.
Uhhh..... what???? Must be a new form of english the kids are taking in school!?
natives pay federal taxes unless they work on the reserve. natives pay no land tax if they live on the reserve because it's owned by the local band counsel. They pay no gst/pst so they collect
none ( by your smokes on the reserves for $15.00 a bag) = 200 cigs. Anyone can shop on the reserve and they won't charge you tax. natives get 14 cents of per litre of gasoline.
I live near a reserve and shop on it all the time.
Look the British invaded many a countries, so did Roman, Huns, , French etc. When invade you are taking over, it up to you to get your land back. I don't think any one should have special taxes. I have friends who are native who feel the same. If they want to go back to their way of life then do not use technology that the invaders have brought with them. We all live on the same planet, we all should be taxes. This is not their land, no one owns the land. Britain was invaded many times, so was French, Poland, pretty well all of Europe at one time or another it is called evolving, it time for them to evolve, just like us.
He's correct. For a long time prior to the arrival of Europeans, and continuing for a long time afterwards, there was an almost perpetual state of war between shifting alliances of tribes. It was not some paradise, it was a bloody hell. They would routinely brutally murder one another. That is not something that the Europeans caused. That is something the Europeans got roped into.
I used to make this argument too. Until I got schooled on it. So now I'll school you...
The difference between your examples and the aboriginals in Canada is that the Canadian aboriginals have treaties with the British whereby the aboriginals were given things in return for their land. The British needed the assistance of the aboriginals in their fights with the French and Americans so they didn't just seize the territory like the Americans did. And in many cases the aboriginals are claiming that the British (and now Canadian government) have not lived up to their end of the bargain. That, combined with British common law, means that the Canadian aboriginals have much stronger land claims than other conquered people have (e.g., people in Quebec).
If you do some research into the credibility of many aboriginal land claims, you won't like what you find out... There's a reason the Canadian governments have continually been stalling on the resolution of aboriginal land claims...
When it gets down to it, the region was getting into agriculture [settlements of 2000 or so people can't be supported by nomads] and agriculture means war. It is universal. If it did not happen with the Indians of the North East, then one can only assume they are not human, and I don't believe that to be the case,
Prior to the Europeans arriving on our land, pretty much everyone got along well as there was enough land to support all the nations that lived on it.