Deepak Chopra is an idiot

gramage

New member
Feb 3, 2002
5,221
1
0
Toronto
found this debate online yesterday and was truly blown away by just how empty everything this guy says is, and how whenever someone points out that there's no scientific substance to his use of scientific buzzwords he just gets louder and tries to interrupt his opponent.

part one of a long piece http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-8-Yxdphsg

My favourite part is when the guy in the audience working on a book with Stephen Hawking offers to teach him about quantum theory since he likes using it so much for things it isn't a part of.
 
He's not an idiot. He's a very smart hustler who has made a lot of money off of gullible people who are looking for easy answers to hard questions. He is proof that H.L Mencken got it right when he said that nobody ever went broke by underestimating the intelligence of the American public.
 
I think they're both idiots if anything. They aren't even arguing the same "God." One side is arguing god the person, the one found in religion with heaven and hell and all that stuff. The other side is talking about god as energy or the universe, which would make us and everything else "God."
 
I don't think Deepak is an idiot. He just got a little emotional from Michael calling this theory, woowoo or woohoo...lol. In the end, they're really all on the same side. At least he's got the balls to put a 'theory' out there (and he admits on many occasions that it's just a theory). Everyone had valid points to make, even Jean, I didn't really understand what she was saying until the end there...lol.
 
I'll watch it later. This stems from an appearance both men made on Larry King a few months ago, and Deepak challenged the other in a debate.
 
I wish I was more of an idiot than Deepak.
 
What I have learned from Chopra is that we do not think in a steady stream of thoughts. There are gaps between our thoughts. If you make a wish to the universe in this gap it will come true. He calls it an endless field of possibilities

But if you cannot think in this gap how can you make a wish ??


Should of had a Buddhist in the debate

Chopra should like Buddhism as it is a science
 
l only wish l could be an idiot like him fame, forutune with numerous books and tapes on the market!! so many people are looking for the meaning of life and he sure cashed in!! good for him!! it's okay, but l sure don't get all hype!!
 
Just watched the film

I thought Chopra handled himself OK and came across as genuine

3 against 1 is not fair

Anyone else actually watch ??
 
Just watched the film

I thought Chopra handled himself OK and came across as genuine

3 against 1 is not fair

Anyone else actually watch ??

3 on 1? Just because the other religious person didn't feel like interrupting to make sure things were incoherent every time Shermer and Harris tried to break down how Chopra uses scientific terms for things everyone who studies them says they don't apply to doesn't mean she wasn't on his side.

Chopra uses tricks of language to manipulate people who are in weakened positions (the injured and the grieving) into making him rich. He's completely full of shit.
 
3 on 1? Just because the other religious person didn't feel like interrupting to make sure things were incoherent every time Shermer and Harris tried to break down how Chopra uses scientific terms for things everyone who studies them says they don't apply to doesn't mean she wasn't on his side.

Chopra uses tricks of language to manipulate people who are in weakened positions (the injured and the grieving) into making him rich. He's completely full of shit.

I agree somewhat

But his followers are not the grieving but new age pseudo intellectuals ( from what I have seen on his PBS lectures )

But I do believe him to be genuine although I believe his arguments to be unproven and dressed in scientific garble

Buddhism is a science and they believe they have discovered scientific truths through meditation

I would much rather have seen The Dali Lama in Chopra's seat

Dali Lama said if science can disprove any of his believes he will change them ( his beliefs not the scientists )

He had the balls to go on the debate, give him credit for that

As I state in my signature "The universe is not only stranger than we imagine, it is stranger than we are capable of imagining."

I am sure all scientists would agree with me yet they are so quick to become an atheist. I can see being an agnostic but not an atheist
 
I agree somewhat

But his followers are not the grieving but new age pseudo intellectuals ( from what I have seen on his PBS lectures )

But I do believe him to be genuine although I believe his arguments to be unproven and dressed in scientific garble

Buddhism is a science and they believe they have discovered scientific truths through meditation

Dali Lama said if science can disprove any of his believes he will change them ( his beliefs not the scientists )

He had the balls to go on the debate, give him credit for that

His new age scientific terms are not accurate scientifically but that does not sink his argument. A rose by any other name ....

It sinks his argument when the scientists who test these things say what he's saying is either untestable or flat out wrong.

As for learning scientific truths through meditation...Actually the neuroscience work Sam Harris does might get somewhere with that at least in terms of cognitive skill, depends what kind of claims they make.

And ok credit for showing up. I am a big fan of debates like this, though Chopra is one of the two or three worst representatives of the pro-god side I've heard speak (Rabbi David Wolpe probably being the best)
 
As for learning scientific truths through meditation...Actually the neuroscience work Sam Harris does might get somewhere with that at least in terms of cognitive skill, depends what kind of claims they make.

Budhism can do remarkable things under scientific testing

There are documentaries on it you can find them on the net

I would love to hear there proof for "God" (for lack of a better term) as I have never heard it
 
I would love to hear there proof for "God" (for lack of a better term) as I have never heard it

There isn't any, but Wolpe makes a better argument then most claiming god isn't a scientific claim and makes smarter case for god being a good thing overall.

Here's part one of a debate he did against Sam Harris which is the only one I've ever seen where I think the religious person (while he doesn't convince me he's right) wins the debate.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fqd4sF1sdb8
 
3 on 1? Just because the other religious person didn't feel like interrupting to make sure things were incoherent every time Shermer and Harris tried to break down how Chopra uses scientific terms for things everyone who studies them says they don't apply to doesn't mean she wasn't on his side.

Chopra uses tricks of language to manipulate people who are in weakened positions (the injured and the grieving) into making him rich. He's completely full of shit.

Although Chopra do 'borrow' many scientific vocabulary to explain his hypothesis, I think he does it because it's his best attempt to communicate to the rest of us about his point of view on the topic of god. There's no doubt that it does sound like fluff and Chopra knows and acknowledges that as well. At least he puts an idea out there, as opposed to Sam and Michael, who doesn't really have any idea to offer but to attack Chopra for using fluff words. Perhaps all Chopra's good for at the time being is to set the stage for someone smarter to come and articulate it in a way that will gain more acceptance from the masses rather than elicit attacks from the scientific community.
 
Budhism can do remarkable things under scientific testing

There are documentaries on it you can find them on the net

I would love to hear there proof for "God" (for lack of a better term) as I have never heard it

There is no 1 'God' in Buddhism, that is not what it's about really. There are many many Buddhas. There is no Bible or certain rules. IE: Bible or God says do this, don't do that. Or follow this rule or that. It's more about Karma
 
Until Deepak levitates on a carpet and circles the conference room three times twelve feet in the air I'm sticking with Chris Hitchens.....ha ha ha.
 
I'm sticking with Chris Hitchens.

Agreed but never let him hear you call him Chris, it's Christopher or he gets bitchy.

On the plus side he also significantly improved the 10 commandments recently, so maybe we start a "Hitchens is god" movement to see if he embraces it or gets mad.
 
What I have learned from Chopra is that we do not think in a steady stream of thoughts. There are gaps between our thoughts. If you make a wish to the universe in this gap it will come true. He calls it an endless field of possibilities.

I thought it was called Disneyland.