Captain Semaru trial

It's a soldier's job to fight and kill, but even for them we have laws against cold-blooded murder of the helpless. You don't make laws just for the fun of it. Once you make them, then you have to enforce them. For that you have police and prosecutors, who enforce laws not decide guilt. For deciding guilt or innocence you have judges and juries who consider all the evidence and arguments brought by the prosecutors and by the defenders of the accused.

Only then can guilt or innocence be properly decided; that's what's going on now. You've read some stories, and seen some talking heads mouthing off in quick little quips on TV and sound like that's all you need to make up your mind, but fortunately you have nothing to do with our legal system.

If and when the court decides, then you might have a case to make about injustice, or disregard of military traditions. But I'm appalled by your assertion—on no real evidence, just media gossip—that due legal process is no more than an 'insane attack'.

Excellent points, OJ. I feel the same way. Instead of considering the process itself a punishment, one could choose to see the court-martial as the mechanism by which his name is cleared of all charges.

This idea some people have that a soldier on the battlefield is somehow above the law is irritating. When you are entrusted to carry arms in defence of your country one must be held to a higher standard. We don't need the world to think that's how Canadians behave.

Maybe he did it knowing it was humane but illegal and accepts this as the consequence, maybe he's completely innocent. Maybe he'll be found guilty but not punished, maybe he'll be back at battalion in 6 months.
 
It's a soldier's job to fight and kill, but even for them we have laws against cold-blooded murder of the helpless. You don't make laws just for the fun of it. Once you make them, then you have to keep them. For that you have police and prosecutors, who only enforce the law, but do not decide guilt. To determine innocence or guilt you have judges and juries who consider all the evidence and arguments brought by the prosecutors and by the defenders of the accused.

Only after all that can guilt or innocence be properly decided; that's what's going on now. You've read some stories, and seen some talking heads mouthing off in quick little quips on TV and sound like that's all you need to make up your mind, but fortunately you have nothing to do with our legal system.

If and when the court decides, then you might have a case to make about injustice, or disregard of military traditions. But I'm appalled by your assertion—on no real evidence, just media gossip—that due legal process is no more than an 'insane attack'.

All excellent points... however... often times "all" the evidence is NOT considered... skilled defense lawyers have an abundance of ways of "hiding" damming evidence to put their client in a more favourable light with jurors...

Just saying...
 
Excellent points, OJ. I feel the same way. Instead of considering the process itself a punishment, one could choose to see the court-martial as the mechanism by which his name is cleared of all charges.

This idea some people have that a soldier on the battlefield is somehow above the law is irritating. When you are entrusted to carry arms in defence of your country one must be held to a higher standard. We don't need the world to think that's how Canadians behave.

Maybe he did it knowing it was humane but illegal and accepts this as the consequence, maybe he's completely innocent. Maybe he'll be found guilty but not punished, maybe he'll be back at battalion in 6 months.

And maybe he didn't do it at all. No one knows until the evidence is in and the decision comes out.
 
All excellent points... however... often times "all" the evidence is NOT considered... skilled defense lawyers have an abundance of ways of "hiding" damming evidence to put their client in a more favourable light with jurors...

Just saying...
I've often wonder what 'just saying…' is meant to excuse. Because it so often follows statements that are difficult to take seriously

You shouted out "often times all the evidence is NOT considered…", suggesting you strongly believe judges (The ones who consider evidence) frequently ignore evidence. You then accuse defence lawyers (whose duty is to bring evidence that favours their client) of hiding damning evidence (which it is the prosecutor's job to bring). The only part of the process you haven't either gotten wrong or disparaged is that the defence exists to put their client in a more favourable light.

So you're "just saying" don't trust the judges, and get rid of the defence lawyers? All that's left are those prosecutors—whom you don't seem to think competent to uncover what the defence hides—and just how are we to be confident they alone will get justice done? Almost as extreme as nottyboi who wants the defence to rule the day.

If each part of the system has a job to do: if it's not up to snuff, or overbalanced we may need to tinker and tweak, not do away with. But I don't think that case has been made yet.

Just saying…. And saying thanks for appreciating my earlier points. I hope I haven't been too overblown responding to your valid concerns.
 
I've often wonder what 'just saying…' is meant to excuse. Because it so often follows statements that are difficult to take seriously

You shouted out "often times all the evidence is NOT considered…", suggesting you strongly believe judges (The ones who consider evidence) frequently ignore evidence. You then accuse defence lawyers (whose duty is to bring evidence that favours their client) of hiding damning evidence (which it is the prosecutor's job to bring). The only part of the process you haven't either gotten wrong or disparaged is that the defence exists to put their client in a more favourable light.

So you're "just saying" don't trust the judges, and get rid of the defence lawyers? All that's left are those prosecutors—whom you don't seem to think competent to uncover what the defence hides—and just how are we to be confident they alone will get justice done? Almost as extreme as nottyboi who wants the defence to rule the day.

If each part of the system has a job to do: if it's not up to snuff, or overbalanced we may need to tinker and tweak, not do away with. But I don't think that case has been made yet.

Just saying…. And saying thanks for appreciating my earlier points. I hope I haven't been too overblown responding to your valid concerns.

Do you always take people's statements and twist them around and presume to fill in blanks (where none exist) to make your point? You sound a lot like a defense lawyer. Hee hee...
tongue0009.gif


I simply disagreed with your statement that "judges and jurors consider all the evidence", when in fact they don't.

Case in Point... Homolka walks free today because "all the evidence" was not presented. Whether or not every one involved with the case did their jobs is not the issue... had the jury heard ALL the evidence she would not be free today.
 
Excellent points, OJ. I feel the same way. Instead of considering the process itself a punishment, one could choose to see the court-martial as the mechanism by which his name is cleared of all charges.

This idea some people have that a soldier on the battlefield is somehow above the law is irritating. When you are entrusted to carry arms in defence of your country one must be held to a higher standard. We don't need the world to think that's how Canadians behave.



Maybe he did it knowing it was humane but illegal and accepts this as the consequence, maybe he's completely innocent. Maybe he'll be found guilty but not punished, maybe he'll be back at battalion in 6 months.

I think they should be held to the same standard as any other Canadain citizen, expecting soldiers to be perfect in terrible situations is not a realistic exercize.

That said , murder is in fact murder, if he shot the PRISONER then yes as a matter of fact he is guilty of murder. He has all the same rights as any other Canadian citizen in court, the difference is in the court martial his jury will be 6 of his peers, as defined by rank, he is a Captain so the Jury PAnel will be Captains and Majors, or above. The question is are the members of the panel combat soldiers or administrators who have never been out of Canada. The defence already brought this issue up a couple of months ago.
 
Case in Point... Homolka walks free today because "all the evidence" was not presented. Whether or not every one involved with the case did their jobs is not the issue... had the jury heard ALL the evidence she would not be free today.

I should take lessons in being a defence lawyer from you, since you seem to know how to do a bunch of stuff that I never learned in either law school or 25 years of legal practice.

First of all, defence lawyers can't "hide evidence". WTF??!! How can we do that?! The whole trial process is built around putting all the evidence before the judge. The only time evidence is excluded is when the prosecution or police infringe the constitution so badly that the court has to sanction them by excluding evidence. And that isn't the defence somehow sleazing a win. In fact, it's the court stopping the prosecution from sleazing a win,

In the Homolka case, she cut her deal before the damning videotape of her participating in the torture killings was discovered. So she was able to sell her self-portrait as a scared little victim and get her soft sentence before anyone knew what a liar she was. That's not a systemic deficiency, but rather a stroke of luck in favour of someone who really didn't deserve it.
 
I should take lessons in being a defence lawyer from you, since you seem to know how to do a bunch of stuff that I never learned in either law school or 25 years of legal practice.

First of all, defence lawyers can't "hide evidence". WTF??!! How can we do that?! The whole trial process is built around putting all the evidence before the judge. The only time evidence is excluded is when the prosecution or police infringe the constitution so badly that the court has to sanction them by excluding evidence. And that isn't the defence somehow sleazing a win. In fact, it's the court stopping the prosecution from sleazing a win,

In the Homolka case, she cut her deal before the damning videotape of her participating in the torture killings was discovered. So she was able to sell her self-portrait as a scared little victim and get her soft sentence before anyone knew what a liar she was. That's not a systemic deficiency, but rather a stroke of luck in favour of someone who really didn't deserve it.[/COLOR]

Oh... so you're a defence lawyer... cool. But please don't take lessons from me... I would never profess to be such a thing. I am far too nice a guy to stoop so low. A guy has standards dontcha know...
tongue0009.gif


Like I said all kinds of ways of excluding, finding inadmissible etc. (e.g. "hiding") evidence. Call it what you want, but it happens.... Guilty people "get off" on technicalities all the time... which is perfectly legal simply because the defence lawyer was able to manipulate the system to the advantage of his client or because some cop didn't have the right paperwork or otherwise screwed up. Just because it is "legally" within the letter of the law, doesn't make it morally correct.

But I guess that's the point of all that law school and 25 years of legal practice...

Oh, and thanks for making my point for me...

(Disclaimer... just my opinion... they are like assholes- everyone has one...)
 
Do you always take people's statements and twist them around and presume to fill in blanks (where none exist) to make your point? You sound a lot like a defense lawyer. Hee hee...
tongue0009.gif


I simply disagreed with your statement that "judges and jurors consider all the evidence", when in fact they don't.

Case in Point... Homolka walks free today because "all the evidence" was not presented. Whether or not every one involved with the case did their jobs is not the issue... had the jury heard ALL the evidence she would not be free today.

You're right, but only if "all the evidence" means ALL the evidence (please pardon the shouting) that exists anywhere. How could we possibly ensure that? There has to be some limit for practical purposes, and that limit is the evidence which is presented to be examined and tested in court. If our police are failing to dig the stuff out, we should talk about that, but better in a thread on the topic.

In the Homolka case, we think we 'know' what the media learned,m and chose to reveal about untested evidence, interrogation and confessions which the Crown had. Their evaluation of that stuff lead them to bargain with Homolka for a guilty plea and testimony against Bernardo. Those would be Crown lawyers, not defence lawyers keeping that evidence out. Hardly a good example of defence lawyers 'hiding' evidence. A charge you originally made but haven't addressed in this post, beyond the sneer. And to be precise the only evidence you or I or the Court or anyone not sworn to secrecy can reliably say exists is what was stipulated in that courtroom; the rest is gossip.

Homolka walks free because she finished the sentence the Crown presumably believed was the best they'd get for what they had. We could make a law tomorrow banning plea bargains and there would be two results: 1) Plea bargains would continue in different ways; deal-making is part of being human 2) Taxes would have to go up a lot to pay for all the new jails, judges, courtrooms, crowns, legal aid and prisons.

I am at a loss to understand how I could fill in blanks where none exist, but as to twisting your words, if your meaning was different from the words I read, I am sorry to have missed it. However, you went well beyond "…simply disagree[ing] with your statement that "judges and jurors consider all the evidence",…. in your post, and I responded to what I found there.

Your original post, the hee-hee sneer about defence lawyers and your subsequent post responding to oagre suggests you might be trying to twist the handlebars of the thread to run down defence lawyers. Would it be going too far to say you consider them one of those naughty technicalities of yours? Or is it only the effective ones?
 
One might hope the jury could return a Morgenthaler verdict and find him not guilty in spite of evidence that might be considered sufficient for the opposite. It is one of the better parts of the jury system I think.
 
One might hope the jury could return a Morgenthaler verdict and find him not guilty in spite of evidence that might be considered sufficient for the opposite. It is one of the better parts of the jury system I think.

That particular type of verdict is not available in a court martial, either he is guilty or he is not. If found guilt he gets sentenced there is no guilty but......
 
It's a soldier's job to fight and kill, but even for them we have laws against cold-blooded murder of the helpless. You don't make laws just for the fun of it. Once you make them, then you have to keep them. For that you have police and prosecutors, who only enforce the law, but do not decide guilt. To determine innocence or guilt you have judges and juries who consider all the evidence and arguments brought by the prosecutors and by the defenders of the accused.
Prosecutorial discretion is there for a reason. However of late, military prosecutors are not infrequently under a great deal of pressure from higher levels to prefer charges. Those higher up are themselves under pressure due to instant television and internet but almost never instant analysis, understanding and comprehension.

As to your larger point. One has to ask - most jurisdictions have laws against euthanasia but which is more moral: A patient is in great pain, has to be heavily medicated and will almost certainly (99.9 percent) develop a blocked intestine within a week, have to be operated on and not survive the surgery OR give the patient rather to much morphine. Should one prosecute the physician should he or she choose the later course of action?
 
most jurisdictions have laws against euthanasia ?

These are difficult and emotionally charged decisions but I think in many cases the patient is allowed to starve to death. That is what usually happens to cancer patients who refuse to eat. That is also what happened to Terri Stavio (check spelling) who was in a vegetative state and her feeding tube was removed.
 
Those higher up are themselves under pressure due to instant television and internet but almost never instant analysis, understanding and comprehension.

It is almost always just pandering to Bob Rae and Jack Layton who never saw a gun fired at them in anger.
 
It is almost always just pandering to Bob Rae and Jack Layton who never saw a gun fired at them in anger.

I highly doubt that Semrau was charged at the urging of Jack Layton or Bob Rae. Let's not make them into the ultimate boogeymen. Semrau was charged by the military chain of command.

Opposition MPs exert very little control over the day to day workings of the JAG.