It's a soldier's job to fight and kill, but even for them we have laws against cold-blooded murder of the helpless. You don't make laws just for the fun of it. Once you make them, then you have to enforce them. For that you have police and prosecutors, who enforce laws not decide guilt. For deciding guilt or innocence you have judges and juries who consider all the evidence and arguments brought by the prosecutors and by the defenders of the accused.
Only then can guilt or innocence be properly decided; that's what's going on now. You've read some stories, and seen some talking heads mouthing off in quick little quips on TV and sound like that's all you need to make up your mind, but fortunately you have nothing to do with our legal system.
If and when the court decides, then you might have a case to make about injustice, or disregard of military traditions. But I'm appalled by your assertion—on no real evidence, just media gossip—that due legal process is no more than an 'insane attack'.
Excellent points, OJ. I feel the same way. Instead of considering the process itself a punishment, one could choose to see the court-martial as the mechanism by which his name is cleared of all charges.
This idea some people have that a soldier on the battlefield is somehow above the law is irritating. When you are entrusted to carry arms in defence of your country one must be held to a higher standard. We don't need the world to think that's how Canadians behave.
Maybe he did it knowing it was humane but illegal and accepts this as the consequence, maybe he's completely innocent. Maybe he'll be found guilty but not punished, maybe he'll be back at battalion in 6 months.

