Canada's International Reputation

The discussions we had with Lancs are considered scholarly by todays standard.:eek:

They are? You guys took a vote on this and didn't tell me?
 
It seems to me that this thread indicates that you are far more interested in arguing that Politicians and General Officers should be prosecuted for various ridiculously minor violations of International Law than seeing terrorists imprisoned.

I created thread for you:

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=265666

Meanwhile on the topic of this thread you need to be told that you are wrong: Knowingly handing over a detainee to be tortured is a very serious violation of the GC, it is in no way "minor".
 
It is in no way, shape, or form strange. It is exactly like the domestic law around criminal negligence.

At least under domestic law, we all play by the same rule book. Afghany is a mess because there is Canadian law, international law, Afghan law, Taliban law, Islamic law, etc.
 
The discussions we had with Lancs are considered scholarly by todays standard.

Alas.....
I also miss Laddie's decidedly con-Blighty perspective on things....:p
 
Anyways you're now just arguing for the sake of arguing and no long offer any rational thought to your argument.

+1.

I used to think fuji was an intelligent and thoughtful poster. But he has lost his reputation due to his lack of perspective on this one, trying to bring down those evil conservatives (who are clearly worse than Hitler. :rolleyes: )

He is now on par with woodpecker so far as being a thoughtless drone - one of the sheep from Animal Farm blathering the same point thoughtlessly and over and over and over. His credibility as a reasonable voice in here is long gone. And, showing the same deafness and ignorance of tboy, he doesn't ever realize how much he's embarrassed himself. Yawn.
 
Canadians the "ENEMY POWER"???? wow --- you're too far gone to deal with. I really wasn't aware that Afghanistan was a Canadian Province because that's the only way Canada can be an Enemy Power in this situation. The Taliban are at war with the current and legal Government of Afghanistan and therefore to the insurgents the Afgan Government is the Enemy.:rolleyes: Anyways you're now just arguing for the sake of arguing and no long offer any rational thought to your argument.

Why not call it what it is: Western powers are occupying Afghanistan
and the afghans are not liking it.
 
... But he has lost his reputation due to his lack of perspective on this one, trying to bring down those evil conservatives (who are clearly worse than Hitler.

Not worse than Hitler....they are more on an equal footing with him!.....;)
 
Why not call it what it is: Western powers are occupying Afghanistan
and the afghans are not liking it.

Exactly!
It's so clear only a fool couldn't see....;)
 
An apt commentary on Canada's reputation

Tribute to competence
Canadian leads U.S. troops in 'enhanced brigade' in Kandahar region

By PETER WORTHINGTON

Last Updated: 14th December 2009, 8:27am

That U.S. troops in the Kandahar region of Afghanistan are under the overall command of a Canadian general is a tribute to the professionalism and competence of Canada's army.

Americans are traditionally wary of anyone but Americans commanding their troops. But in the present Afghan "surge," troops of the 82nd Airborne Division are under the command of Brig.-Gen. Daniel Menard in the Kandahar sector.

Combined with 2,800 Canadian soldiers, the "enhanced" brigade now totals some 5,000 troops to form a proposed "ring of stability" around the provincial capital which is the nerve centre of Taliban operations.

President Barack Obama's commitment of 30,000 more troops to Afghanistan (bringing the total U.S. forces to around 100,000 -- one-fifth of the maximum that served in Vietnam at any one time), indicates there will be serious fighting until withdrawal is scheduled to begin in July 2011. Obama hopes for an additional 10,000 NATO troops.

For three years, Canada's battle group has been stretched thin around Kandahar, but has become adept at both conventional warfare and counter-insurgency.

The fact that the U.S. military, under four-star Gen. Stanley McChrystal, seems not only willing but eager to have his troops under Canadians command is recognition that the Canadians are, arguably, the best allied soldiers in Afghanistan.

Past command

Also significant in the U.S. trusting Canadian command of its soldiers is that Canada's present chief of defence staff, Gen. Walter Natynczyk, was deputy commander of the U.S. army's III Corps both at Fort Hood and in Iraq,- ironically at a time when then-PM Jean Chretien was posturing that no Canadian military people would serve in Iraq.

Natynczyk -- the Canadian with the most experience at high command since the Second World War -- replaced Gen. Rick Hillier as CDS. Although he may share Hillier's philosophic views on military matters, Natynczyk has not been the clarion call that Hiller was in the job.

Hillier's extroverted and outspoken personality rallied the Canadian public into supporting its military and was emotional adrenalin to rank-and-file soldiers. His penchant for expressing his views on practically everything often seemed to catch politicians by surprise.

Not that he was ever disloyal, but once his views on a topic became public, it inhibited government politicians -- including the PM -- from expressing alternate views that the media might exploit as contradictory.

Governments far prefer their generals to shut up. Pity, because today's soldiers are knowledgeable and worth listening to about Afghanistan -if they dare speak up.

Coincidentally, Obama's 18-month deadline (July 2011) for U.S. forces to begin pulling out of Afghanistan coincides with Canada's declared intent to withdraw all its troops -- a polite cut-and-run, if you ask me.

Direct fight

Deadlines are dangerous things in wartime and can give sustenance to the enemy. But they also indicate that for the next 18 months, the U.S. doesn't intend to fool around and will take the fight directly to the Taliban, hopefully with the Pakistani military co-operating. A hammer-anvil strategy, with the Taliban in the middle.

Brig.-Gen. Menard is a VanDoos, and for what it's worth, the VanDoos have been exemplary in carrying the fight to the Taliban. With greater resources in manpower and equipment than in the past and a smaller area to be responsible for, the combined Canadian-American "enhanced" brigade should be well placed to tip the scales.
 
Yup, and life in Afghany was paradise before the West arrived and will be paradise again when the West leaves:rolleyes:.

The point is, that the west will leave, and Afghanistan will again be as it was
before the western powers arrived.
 
The point is, that the west will leave, and Afghanistan will again be as it was
before the western powers arrived.

Well, that's an entirely defeatist attitude, and the wheels are in motion to change that. What you are suggesting is a complete write-off of Afghanistan and its people. Instead, why not give them the tools they need to live a peaceable life, as free from oppression as their culture and geography will allow?

Life was not always war in Afghanistan, it was not always brutal oppression of women, art, education, culture and freedom. In fact, quite the opposite is true. Things were looking up in the 1970's; it was the Soviets who brought war to modern Afghanistan, and the Taliban who brought brutal oppression. All the "West" is trying to do is give the people the opportunity to live as good a life as they can, in as much freedom and security as they can.

It is a shame that selfish people are willing to abandon that shithole country's people back to violence and oppression, rather than give them a hand up. Are you not embarrassed that the so-called compassionate left is willing to abandon the Afghan people back to terror, and that the right wingers are the ones showing true compassion to their fellow human beings? You should be.
 
Why not call it what it is: Western powers are occupying Afghanistan

When did NATO become a "Western power"? I'm pretty sure your fellow Danes (along with citizens of Iceland, Italy, Greece, etc) would find it peculiar to be considered an evil "Western power".


and the afghans are not liking it.

I guess it depends on which Afghans you talk to.
 
Canadians the "ENEMY POWER"???? wow --- you're too far gone to deal with. I really wasn't aware that Afghanistan was a Canadian Province because that's the only way Canada can be an Enemy Power in this situation.

Sorry but you have simply misread the phrase in the GC.

The text you quoted is simply defining a POW as any fighter who has fallen into the hands of the enemy. In this case we are an enemy of the Taliban so they become POW's when captured by us.

It is incorrect to read the phrase "the Enemy" as implying that there is only one official "enemy", the phrase is not meant to be read that way. The GC is explicit that a conflict may involve multiple Powers fighting on one side.

In any case we are clearly "the Detaining Power" to which responsibility for the POW's captured by us is assigned.

The Taliban are at war with the current and legal Government of Afghanistan and therefore to the insurgents the Afgan Government is the Enemy.

That is true that the ANA is an enemy of the Taliban, but in addition, we are also a Power, and also an enemy of the Taliban. In the parlance of the GC there are multiple Powers involved here:

-- The Taliban
-- The Afghan National Army
-- Canadian Forces
-- United States Military
-- British Military
-- etc.

The convention does not envision a conflict as been between only two parties, but as being something into which multiple Powers may be drawn.

Note that the GC is written in neutral terms and does not comment on whether hte war is legal or illegal, just or unjust, or any other judgement.

Specifically it is neither here nor there whether the Govt. of Afghanistan has any particular legal standing, whether it is legitimate or illegitimate, whether it is a State or an Occupation. The GC avoids these phrases and distinctions as they are commonly the subject matter of the war itself.

Instead the GC intentionally uses neutral phrases like "Party" and "Power" so that all sides can agree to the conduct of the rules of war without getting drawn into a dispute about who is or isn't a legitimate government.

What is clear is that multiple Powers have armed forces fighting in the conflict zone, and the GC intends to bind them all to the rules of war, regardless of who is right or wrong, just or unjust, legal or illegal, legitimate government or illegitimate government.

The GC does not give any extra standing to one Power or Party over another simply because some entity in the confliict has declared it to be the legitimate government.

Note that the Taliban most expressly deny that the Afghan government is in any way legitimate and claim that they themselves are the legitimate government of Afghanistan.
 
Last edited: