Denying climate change: a psychological problem?

Climate change is caused by human industry?

  • Yep, I believe the climate change scientists

    Votes: 14 14.0%
  • Nope, we're just in a natural cycle of warming

    Votes: 26 26.0%
  • Yep, I say Option 1 AND deniers are psychologically attached to consumerism

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Nope, it's Option 2 AND saying otherwise is bad science

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Yep, but powerful economic interests are misleading the public

    Votes: 28 28.0%
  • Nope, but idealistic and opportunistic economic interests are duping publics

    Votes: 24 24.0%

  • Total voters
    100
This country is no longer about hard choices or any real sacrifice. The preference by voters for Ronald Reagan over Jimmy Carter (or Ralph Nader, for that matter) was a good example.(

I'm not worried about global warming, but I'm horrified to learn there are people who think Carter would have been a better choice than Reagan.

Jimmy Carter was a fraking disaster. His brother Billy would have been a better president.
 
Thousands of studies confirming these observations and tying it to 90% probability it is human caused (IPCC).

That's just the sort of crap the IPCC puts out there.

There is no mathematical basis whatsoever for claiming "90% probability", based on the evidence presented. And yes, I have read the full report.

The authors made this claim because they felt an emotional connection to the idea of what they think "90% probability" means to them, without any factual basis to their usage of the terminology.
 
The authors made this claim because they felt an emotional connection to the idea of what they think "90% probability" means to them, without any factual basis to their usage of the terminology.

Sounds like you are making this claim because you feel an emotional connection to the idea, without any factual basis to your use of terminology.

Really, are you suggesting that IPCC reports are based on feelings only?

Is this the sum of your argument?
 
sigh.

I know I should just copy and paste Anon1's sig picture here and be done with it, but I'm constantly amazed how people just can't seem to get basic issues.

Its true nothing is 100% proven in the world of the science, but that doesn't stop you from still believing in gravity.

Go on, continue believing those few hacks you like to quote, and meanwhile why don't you go take a stand over there with those who still think cigarette smoke is good for you.

from wiki
Since 2007, no scientific body of national or international standing has maintained a dissenting opinion.



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_opinion_on_climate_change
 
Sounds like you are making this claim because you feel an emotional connection to the idea, without any factual basis to your use of terminology.

Really, are you suggesting that IPCC reports are based on feelings only?

Is this the sum of your argument?

I know that you can read better than that.

But if you don't know Statistics, you might be wise to keep quiet at this point.
 
sadly, I'm a sucker for punishment, Anynym, so here goes.

First, I misquoted, the actual line from the IPCC is that the possibility that the changes we are now witnessing are caused by natural processes is less than 5%.

I'm assuming that they reached this figure by running multiple climate modelings using multiple sourced figures and that this is a figure they are confident about.

On what do you base your argument that there is no math to back this up?
And please, feel free to go deep into your stats knowledge.
 
ok, lurkerjoe.

So you don't believe experts, but do believe evidence like a weirdly bent arm.

So what do you make of (sorry to repeat this, but no denier has a reasonable answer yet):
Increase in CO2 to 387 ppm.
Melting of glaciers.
Melting of permanent ice in arctic.
The fact that 9 of the hottest years on record have taken place within the last 25 years.
Spring comes earlier than it used to.
You don't need snow tires anymore (joke)
Depletion of commercial fishing species (tied to overfishing and change in ocean temperature)
Thousands of studies confirming these observations and tying it to 90% probability it is human caused (IPCC).

There you have numerous real world examples, backed by numerous studies.
Or are you a sheeple who believes a handful of people who tell you what you want to believe (back to original article for thread).


So, is your arm broken?

Again with the ridiculous analogy between a broken arm and climate change.

Let's see, declining fish stocks result of global warming. Yeah, the fact that there's billions of people on this planet eating fish isn't enough to to account for the decline, global warming has to play a roll. It's like a beauty queen answering what her wish is and she gives her answer before tossing in, "... and world peace."

When there's money to be made, and there is a shitload of money to be made on global warming, the "experts" have lots to protect. For me, the tipping point for when I question is when the idea cannot tolerant and begins to demonize any opposition. Because at that time it becomes an ideology and fuck you if you're trying to shove an ideology down my throat.

Back in the 70's and 80's people where concerned about global cooling because of all the crap we put into the atmosphere was supposedly going to reach a point where all the particles will reflect so much sunlight in the upper atmosphere that the world would cool down. Scientists had published studies showing that WWII threw up so much pollution that the hard winters that followed WWII was prima facie proof that pollution was the cause.

meanwhile why don't you go take a stand over there with those who still think cigarette smoke is good for you.

thanks for proving my point. decades ago, cigarette companies trotted out scientists and doctors and any conceivable "expert" to say that smoking is not harmful instead it's healthy. Don't believe me, troll the UofT archives for ads and documents related to cigarette smoking and you'll find plenty of examples. That's why there may still be people who believe its ok to smoke. when China opened its doors, guess what cigarette smoking was advertised much the same way. Well, guess what, they hid evidence and colluded to scam people. And it appears that this may be happening in east anglia. What I'm getting at is that just because it's a popular belief does not mean that it is always correct, facts can be hidden and statistics can be manipulated.
 
Isn't it funny how we used to say, "Global warming"

Since over the last decade, the temperatures have been falling slightly, now it's, "Climate change."


lol. 30 years ago, they were warning us about another ice age.

Over the 4 billion or so years that this planet has existed, the climate has always been changing. We are foolish to believe that we are the sole cause of it.

that's because global warming was an over simplified description.

Yes, we go in cycles but I'm guessing you don't read these climate threads through or you would realize that everyone says agrees we're in a cycle and temperature 'trend' are generally warmer ones. The problem is we have no way of gauging how fast or how far the changes are happening, as we are in unchartered waters. That's the big problem.

I like to see some support for your claim that temperature are getting cooler, certainly not where I go.
 
sadly, I'm a sucker for punishment, Anynym, so here goes.

First, I misquoted, the actual line from the IPCC is that the possibility that the changes we are now witnessing are caused by natural processes is less than 5%.

I'm assuming that they reached this figure by running multiple climate modelings using multiple sourced figures and that this is a figure they are confident about.

On what do you base your argument that there is no math to back this up?
And please, feel free to go deep into your stats knowledge.

Let's start with what the IPCC actually does say.

http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/presentations/20th Anniversary BFM/pres-wg-1-ipcc.pdf

Then let's look at an oversimplification of what it means when someone uses those terms:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistics

In the IPCC analyses, there is no "distribution" over which a CI may be applied. The terminology used by the IPCC is completely incorrect and has no basis in fact.
 
Again, no.

McIntyre published one peer reviewed paper, which has been contested.
His other attempts have been refused.
McIntyres work has only been reviewed by statisticians who said his original work had one valid point, but that it did not change the merit or results of Mann's work.

Please show proof that the data is not the raw data.

Again, Mann's work has been verified by numerous studies using different methods and models. Even assuming there are minor problems in Mann's 1998 paper, since corrected, it doesn't provide enough proof that therefore all scientists are crooked and climate change is not happening.

Do you deny that we now have 387 ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere?
Do you deny that we are in a period of warming?
Do you deny that glaciers the world are thawing?
Do you deny that the north pole is losing permament ice?

I regret spending so much time on one minor point when there is such a vast amount of proof and you can't seem to honestly read both sides of the argument.

Ok I did some research, it seems that the correction to manns graph also has some problems , some major problems actually. More on that later.

McIntyre published one peer reviewed paper, which has been contested.
His other attempts have been refused.
McIntyres work has only been reviewed by statisticians who said his original work had one valid point, but that it did not change the merit or results of Mann's work.



Macityre has published any number of papers all peer reviewed the one that you refer to was refused by Nature's referee for reasons that have not been explained that paper was published in several other accredited journals.

Again, Mann's work has been verified by numerous studies using different methods and models. Even assuming there are minor problems in Mann's 1998 paper, since corrected, it doesn't provide enough proof that therefore all scientists are crooked and climate change is not happening

Every verification of Manns work has been done by people at the center of the storm so to speak. The original data and the computer code used in the models has never been releaesed until just recently. The Royal Society in England required it and it is the only place that it has been release.

Although McIntyre's exposure of the "hockey stick" was upheld in 2006 by two expert panels commissioned by the US Congress, the small group of scientists at the top of the IPCC brushed this aside by pointing at a hugely influential series of graphs originating from the CRU, from Jones and Briffa. These appeared to confirm the rewriting of climate history in the "hockey stick", by using quite different tree ring data from Siberia. Briffa was put in charge of the key chapter of the IPCC's fourth report, in 2007, which dismissed all McIntyre's criticisms.

At the forefront of those who found suspicious the graphs based on tree rings from the Yamal peninsula in Siberia was McIntyre himself, not least because for years the CRU refused to disclose the data used to construct them. This breached a basic rule of scientific procedure. But last summer the Royal Society insisted on the rule being obeyed, and two months ago Briffa accordingly published on his website some of the data McIntyre had been after.

This was startling enough, as McIntyre demonstrated in an explosive series of posts on his Climate Audit blog, because it showed that the CRU studies were based on cherry-picking hundreds of Siberian samples only to leave those that showed the picture that was wanted. Other studies based on similar data had clearly shown the Medieval Warm Period as hotter than today. Indeed only the evidence from one tree, YADO61, seemed to show a "hockey stick" pattern, and it was this, in light of the extraordinary reverence given to the CRU's studies, which led McIntyre to dub it "the most influential tree in the world".

But more dramatic still has been the new evidence from the CRU's leaked documents, showing just how the evidence was finally rigged. The most quoted remark in those emails has been one from Prof Jones in 1999, reporting that he had used "Mike [Mann]'s Nature trick of adding in the real temps" to "Keith's" graph, in order to "hide the decline". Invariably this has been quoted out of context. Its true significance, we can now see, is that what they intended to hide was the awkward fact that, apart from that one tree, the Yamal data showed temperatures not having risen in the late 20th century but declining. What Jones suggested, emulating Mann's procedure for the "hockey stick" (originally published in Nature), was that tree-ring data after 1960 should be eliminated, and substituted – without explanation – with a line based on the quite different data of measured global temperatures, to convey that temperatures after 1960 had shot up.
 
Again, no.


Do you deny that we now have 387 ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere?
No but why is that a problem ? How do you know that is not the normal state of affairs?

Do you deny that we are in a period of warming?

Yes actually I do, the temperature is lower now than it was in the medival warm period , Grape Vines were growing on HAdrians wall them, In the mid to late 1700's temperatures were far colder than they are now. So what is warm what is cold what is normal?

Do you deny that glaciers the world are thawing?
Do you deny that the north pole is losing permament ice?

The ice measurements are have been taken using a baseline from the late 1960's when there was a massive ice buildup in glaciers and the poles. In point of fact I expect that if you actually researched the issue you would find the average amount of ice in the caps and glaciers is pretty much the same.

Regardless, what is normal? can you tell me that 27'C is the normal temperature? or did you ahve a different number in mind.
 
Jeez, talk about oversimplification.

........ and what's your point.

For those who don't believe the research, how about eyrewitnes accounts.

I've seen mountains tops that have NEVER appeared bare, lay clean of any snow before me.

I've seen coast lines on Ellesmere Island west of Alert, approx 500 miles from geographic north pole, that have NEVER been exposed to air, shine dark red from the 60% iron content, in the Arctic sun.

I have seen ground on Wrangel Island, check where it is, that has NEVER been exposed to the sun split wide open and melt because of the afternoon heat.

I have seen glaciers that are miles back from their geological average advance and retreat over ground that has never been laid bare.

I have seen cirques in Bhutan that have never bee devoid of snow, now green with alpine grasses.

I could probably list a half a dozen more but even you hard cases get my point by now.

This is not research. This is not fancy statistics. This is eye witness accounts.

We are in uncharted water and the one thing that has never been here before is 6 billion people and 200 years of industrialization.

So you slam the research especially the stuff that most people understand and you can try and slam the messenger again because you don't understand or don't want to understand the message, but this pure and simple proof of what I and others speak.
 
I've seen mountains tops that have NEVER appeared bare, lay clean of any snow before me.

...

I have seen glaciers that are miles back from their geological average advance and retreat over ground that has never been laid bare.

I have seen cirques in Bhutan that have never bee devoid of snow, now green with alpine grasses.

...

This is not research. This is not fancy statistics. This is eye witness accounts.
So you're saying that this is the hottest those areas have been in 80 years? That's the extent of world history from your perspective?

Sorry, but scientists have finally admitted that 1998 wasn't even the hottest year on record - a tenet of faith for the more radical theorists.
 
So you're saying that this is the hottest those areas have been in 80 years? That's the extent of world history from your perspective?

Sorry, but scientists have finally admitted that 1998 wasn't even the hottest year on record - a tenet of faith for the more radical theorists.

Please show me where you read this in my thread.

....... and where do you get your facts about 1998?

Try;

http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/environment/2005_warmest.html

You might even try the following when making statements like the hottest and coldest .........

http://motls.blogspot.com/2008/01/2007-warmest-year-on-record-coldest-in.html

it goes a long way to explain, what I've often said, 'trends'.
 
No, I'm the type that micro-managers hate because I can think for myself. Nice assumption though, fits in with the proponents of climate change who like to put down everybody who don't subscribe to their views. Next I'll be heretic.

BTW: Division of labour was first developed to facilitate the manufacturing of goods so that goods once made by skilled artisans can be made by unskilled people for a fraction of the cost. Win: big business. Lose: independent artisans. Outside manufacturing its called an integrated, cross-functional team or some other Dilbert-babble.

Evidently, you think that the G&M is an "expert?" You really are a dumbass. I'd like to sell you some land high up in the rockies. It's a good deal, it'll be waterfront property if the experts have it right. And 20 years from now when the experts revise their findings it'll be your own personal island.

Hmmmmm, I smell a union guy.

Division of labour has been around long before that. Try in excess of 1.5 million years.
 
Yes actually I do, the temperature is lower now than it was in the medival warm period , Grape Vines were growing on HAdrians wall them, In the mid to late 1700's temperatures were far colder than they are now. So what is warm what is cold what is normal.
.
Regardless, what is normal? can you tell me that 27'C is the normal temperature? or did you ahve a different number in mind.

I don't know many scientist that use the term 'normal' on a regular basis.

As far as grape vines on Hadrians Wall, that basically a local anomaly. There are palm trees in the south of England. I wouldn't call the climate there comparable to the South Pacific.

I can show you large arctic alpine meadows 1500 miles south of where they should be and they've been their since before I became aware of them 40 years go and evidence shows they go back further than that

The temperature stated and the minimum/maximum are global numbers. Climate doesn't work that way. It's a combination of domino chains and feedback systems.
 
I think it is a "positive conspiracy" it is really there to force investment in renewable energy and increase the energy efficiency of the world. The simple reason is, there is not enough conventional energy to support a high standard of living for everyone. So we need a combination of new sources of energy and greater efficiency. I think pollution is also another problem. The fact is, all the efforts to combat global warming will lead to a) greater efficiency b) alternative sources of energy c) reduced air pollution. So it is over all a good thing to go with this regardless of what you believe. If we cannot solve the need for new sources of energy it will probably lead to even more war. Which is FAR more dangerous then global warming could ever be.