Denying climate change: a psychological problem?

Climate change is caused by human industry?

  • Yep, I believe the climate change scientists

    Votes: 14 14.0%
  • Nope, we're just in a natural cycle of warming

    Votes: 26 26.0%
  • Yep, I say Option 1 AND deniers are psychologically attached to consumerism

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Nope, it's Option 2 AND saying otherwise is bad science

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Yep, but powerful economic interests are misleading the public

    Votes: 28 28.0%
  • Nope, but idealistic and opportunistic economic interests are duping publics

    Votes: 24 24.0%

  • Total voters
    100
I also remember that in the late 70's, after a few severe winters, the media was all over the "coming of the next ice age."
My point is that , yes the climate changes, but I don't know how much my lifestyle contributes to this.

What happened to Bopper1? Anyway, you're absolutely right that in the 70's the media, following scientists, were talking about the possibility of an ice age. But you are not recalling the context for the concern. It was a nuclear winter. With the very real threat of mutual assured destruction, climate research focused on what would happen if the atmosphere was polluted by dust, debris and fallout post-bombing. At about the same time, another problem was also being looked at: supersonic transport and what burned fuel in the upper atmosphere would do to the troposphere. These two disprate fields of research ended up fusing into a common concern with climate change. As data was gathered and models of the climate made, though, an older hypothesis, that human actions would increase the rate of warming, began to be used to explain what was emerging in climate research. What I am saying is that your recollections are correct, but you're not paying sufficient attention to what happened once that ice age effect began to be investigated. Once it was, another possibility emerged as more likely - humans will harm the climate. A little bit of history goes a long way.
 
Climate change certainly is happenning, and it always is happening, with or without man. We may be partially or totally at fault with this one, but the reality is the earth has always warmed and cooled and warmed up again - in cycles which are not totally understood. I think the key is adjusting to change as much as in trying to prevent change. So in that sense the moral indignation and finger pointing around current perceived climate change is, to me, pretty much useless. Time to start building some sea walls, or tearing down some old buildings...if sea levels are really rising. As an example.

Over time carbon takes care of itself. If we are lucky we may not be part of the carbon stores.

I disagree that natural cycles is the explanation for warming, but I will grant that Mencken represents what that hypothesis is claiming very well. Note to others: see how pieces of science CAN be separated off from hyperbolic and unfounded claims of political and economic bias?
 
If I would have thought of the carbon credit scam I would be pushing the sky is falling junk science too.
 
I couldn't vote CG cuz I'm not 100% sure why climate change exists (which I acknowledge).

BTW, thanks for your restaurant referrals for Las Vegas. We ate at Delmonico's Steak House in the Venetian, and enjoyed the buffet at The Wynn as our 'last supper' (it is the best and my friends were pleased).

Glad I could help... I told you about that buffet didn't I. ;) I am not usually a buffet kinda guy, maybe occasionally for breakfast or when I take my kids to Manchurian Garden, but the buffet at The Wynn is an exception.
 
You seem to have done a lot of reading on this subject of GW or CC.

Is there any truth whatsoever that the planets or certain planets in our solar system are becoming warmer too?

I am an uber geek. Trust me, you don't know a bigger geek.

Among the other planets, some are thought to be getting warmer (Mars, Jupiter), others colder (Uranus). Venus has been stuck with a greenhouse effect for a while, so it's not been a comfy vacation for a while. Those claiming natural cycles cause the earth's warming are trying to trick the public with seemingly knock-down arguments. That is, if other planets are getting warmer, and those planets have no industry we know of (invisible aliens?!), then industry is not the cause. Voila! Must be natural cycles there, so here too. Trouble with the whole argument is that it is complete crap. Each planet is warming or cooling for different reasons.

Jupiter appears to be showing long term warming trends, but the explanation is said to be 'perfect storm' conditions, so maybe not really LONG term. Mars is just a dusty bitch and shows seasonal warming effects. Neptune is DEFINITELY getting warmer right now, so wizz bang, let's feed unaware publics that news and they will latch onto it as common sense evidence that there's no industry on Neptune so industry is not the cause here either. Bad news bears, though, because Neptune's orbit is . . . shit, cannot remember actual number, but it's over 150 years, less than 200 though . . . and Neptune is running into SUMMER (other planets have seasons too!). You've got to be real careful of arguments that look too good to be true!
 
Rollerboy, I will not get you started on Al Gore, because you told me you think he is hot and I am done trying to convince you otherwise.
He wishes! LOL!

But . . . this fear mongering and agenda talk is a knife that cuts both ways. You are aware that corporations like Exxon and Mobil are heavily funding the work of scientists claiming climate change is just a natural cycle and nothing to do with fossil fuel use and human industry?

Given a choice between Big Green and Big Oil funding research and telling me what to do, I'll take Big Green any day. Really, a healthy guy like you, with Lance Armstrong tattood on your butt (Mrs Rollerboy told me that), is siding with Big Oil over Big Green?

Yes, I am very aware of it, but I am hardly "siding with Big Oil". I don't dispute that climate change is happening. I am just suspect as to what the effect man has on it is all. I fully support all reduce, reuse, and recycle programs, I have all energy efficient appliances in my home, have an R2000 certified home, drive one of the most fuel efficient trucks on the market, (I need a big vehicle to haul our camper) and promote fitness on a daily basis. Vacations usually include a mix of camping, hiking, cycling, canoeing and/ or kayaking. We do have camp fires though so better get out the cuffs, cuz I am guilty! LOL!

As I have said before, my only issue is fear mongering... Oh and carbon credits. There has to be a better way.
 
As I have said before, my only issue is fear mongering... Oh and carbon credits. There has to be a better way.

Come now, don't lie to us Terbies. You know you have a thing for Al Gore. It's OK Rollerboy, we're all sexually liberated here.:p

Carbon credits, theoretically, are meant to decrease the overall CO2 in the atmosphere by creating an economic environment encouraging of shifts to lower CO2 emissions technologies and practices. Thus, to disagree with carbon credits is to disagree that such economic measures do or could work. It's an economic objection to an economic project. So I can agree with you, but that agreement doesn't touch the basic argument I would venture, that the reason why anyone is bothering with carbon credit ideas is because we need to reduce the CO2 levels.
 
Yes. Climate change happens naturally but the human activity speeds up so fast to a point nature (including human!) does not have enough time to adjust. There will be never 100% proof but you just don't want to the on the problem side if the scientist are right.

A hypothesis that can't be disproved is not a scientific hypothesis,merely an assertion.

CG, even I don't really like Carbon Credits. I just look at it as fancy bookkeeping and it really won't do much good.

It's business' way of making something free into a commodity or commercializing something that no one wants. Carbon Credits are the most stupidest idea since the pet rock but like that "toy" there'll still be suckers out there willing to pay for it.
 
Come now, don't lie to us Terbies. You know you have a thing for Al Gore. It's OK Rollerboy, we're all sexually liberated here.:p

Carbon credits, theoretically, are meant to decrease the overall CO2 in the atmosphere by creating an economic environment encouraging of shifts to lower CO2 emissions technologies and practices. Thus, to disagree with carbon credits is to disagree that such economic measures do or could work. It's an economic objection to an economic project. So I can agree with you, but that agreement doesn't touch the basic argument I would venture, that the reason why anyone is bothering with carbon credit ideas is because we need to reduce the CO2 levels.
Terbies all know, Mrs. CG and I have a 1 dick rule. (That would be ME! LOL)

I know what carbon credits are, and am fully aware of the theoretical concept etc... but when 1 wealthy company or country is able to just buy a few hundred thousand credits and keep on polluting to its hearts content, it kinda throws the concept right in the incinerator doesn't it? Also, when 2 of the top 5 biggest polluters (China and India) on the planet are "exempt" doesn't that ALSO negate the effect of becoming more CO2 responsible?
 
We are definitely fucking up our environment. Is it permanent? My answer is I don't really care about a million years from now honestly, but I do care for the next say 100 years or so and in that time I think we're making a 'permanent' impact. A bad one too. I don't need anyone, expert or quack to tell me that, I can see it.
 
We are definitely fucking up our environment. Is it permanent? My answer is I don't really care about a million years from now honestly, but I do care for the next say 100 years or so and in that time I think we're making a 'permanent' impact. A bad one too. I don't need anyone, expert or quack to tell me that, I can see it.

You are free to reduce the bulk of your impact on the environment. Sell your car(s). Stop heating your house, and stop cooling it in the summer. In fact, you'd better live outside as the construction industry emits a lot of carbon. Eat only the food you grow yourself. Whatever you choose for yourself is your business.

Just don't tell me how to live my own life.
 
You are free to reduce the bulk of your impact on the environment . . . Just don't tell me how to live my own life.

But lots of people and things already have a great influence over the conduct of your own life. Everything defined as a crime is a restriction on the conduct of your life. Indeed, any law pre-structures the parameters of your choices. There are many pieces of scientific advice you follow every day, which like many you might not know where the claim came from or how it was proved or what it's even about, but you obey its strictures. Then there are all the subtle things, such as social conventions and moral codes, which also influence how we talk, think, act, love, decide, and so on. So from where, all of a sudden, comes this inviolable principle that you get to make all your own choices, your castle is yours, and to hell with anyone dabbling in it?
 
in response to the 'don't tell me what to do' crowd...

Here's a, technically speaking, shitty analogy. I extend it as best I can, tongue in cheek but serious at the same time.

Until the mid-1800's, sanitary practices in urban centres were an individual matter. That is, individuals were left to deal with their own sewage. This was fine while the major theory of disease was that miasmas (filth and odors) caused illness.

Once bacteriology took over as the major explanation for disease, well few were happy with individualized solutions, because individual decisions about sewage could breed mass illness through the spreading of bacteria. Sewage became a public works issue, and individuals had to conform. Public sentiment about how their individual practices fittted in with the general well-being changed, as bacteriology as a theory moved from being just a theory to common sense.

Now few think anyone is dabbling in how they live their life when sanitation engineers tell them what to do about sewage. How do you know you're not just on the shitty end of the stick, in the knowledge debate, when you poo poo the knowledge claims of climate change scientists?

Just because you are concerned about someone telling you what to do, that doesn't mean you know what is right. If that were the case, then I challenge all the parents out there, next time their kid throws a tantrum when told what to do, to respond "oh, johnny, I guess you must be right about eating dirt out of the arse of the dog, because not wanting to be told what to do is to know about the health risk of eating shit from a dog's arse".

I challenge anyone to come up with a more shitty series of shitty analogies than that shit. :)
 
I challenge anyone to come up with a more shitty series of shitty analogies than that shit. :)

Okay, here's a rule you should be happy to live with: you are the owner of Nothing. You must hand over all of your money to the State immediately, who will give you none of it back, but will pay for your housing after you're evicted.
 
Okay, here's a rule you should be happy to live with: you are the owner of Nothing. You must hand over all of your money to the State immediately, who will give you none of it back, but will pay for your housing after you're evicted.

Ah a Liberal
 
What happened to Bopper1? Anyway, you're absolutely right that in the 70's the media, following scientists, were talking about the possibility of an ice age. But you are not recalling the context for the concern. It was a nuclear winter. With the very real threat of mutual assured destruction, climate research focused on what would happen if the atmosphere was polluted by dust, debris and fallout post-bombing. At about the same time, another problem was also being looked at: supersonic transport and what burned fuel in the upper atmosphere would do to the troposphere. These two disprate fields of research ended up fusing into a common concern with climate change. As data was gathered and models of the climate made, though, an older hypothesis, that human actions would increase the rate of warming, began to be used to explain what was emerging in climate research. What I am saying is that your recollections are correct, but you're not paying sufficient attention to what happened once that ice age effect began to be investigated. Once it was, another possibility emerged as more likely - humans will harm the climate. A little bit of history goes a long way.

An interesting mix of science and fantasy. Climate research was indeed looking at what would happen if a nuclear winter occured. That had nothing to do with the global freeze theory, that was brought out by the same scientist who eventually proposed global warming as a theory. He was looking at long term temperature variations and found some interesting corelations. The theories began there, and interesting aside the researchers discovered their model did not fit the observed facts and rebuilt their model interesting sustem..

The thoery of global warming has human factors forcing the temperature to rise and dooming us all to death by drowning. The aerosol particulate theory did not really get going uintil the early 90's ( M.O.Andreane 1995, V.Ramanathan 2001) and it is still a thoery based on the concept that the aerosoles are reflective , and there are still questions about if it is good or bad. Just as a note sea salt is considered the number two componant of aerosol particulate and the amount od seasalt and the elevations it can rise to are still unknown. Volcanic eruptions of gases are considerd he largest source of stratospheric gas deposition by several orders of magnetud
 
Okay, here's a rule you should be happy to live with: you are the owner of Nothing. You must hand over all of your money to the State immediately, who will give you none of it back, but will pay for your housing after you're evicted.

Your point is opaque, to say the least. Are you equating Government programs, aimed at carbon emission abatement, and which are based on the research of climate change scientists, with Big Bad State controlling your life? If so, that's shitty reasoning, but hardly harmful to any point I was making.
 
An interesting mix of science and fantasy. Climate research was indeed looking at what would happen if a nuclear winter occured. That had nothing to do with the global freeze theory, that was brought out by the same scientist who eventually proposed global warming as a theory. He was looking at long term temperature variations and found some interesting corelations

The fantasy part of this is the totally inaccurate history. Why do you speak of "the same" scientist, as if there was one dude in a lab somewhere? There were thousands of researchers, my friend. Also, global warming as a theory has been around since the late 1890s, Arrhenius I believe. So you should ask yourself the following: if you're so confused about a detail so readily accessible to a bit of research, what leads you to think you have it right elsewhere in your argument?

The thoery of global warming has human factors forcing the temperature to rise and dooming us all to death by drowning. The aerosol particulate theory did not really get going uintil the early 90's ( M.O.Andreane 1995, V.Ramanathan 2001) and it is still a thoery based on the concept that the aerosoles are reflective , and there are still questions about if it is good or bad.

Are you talking here about things like the greenhouse effect, or maybe ozone depletion? You know, both of those are theories, as you say, but you appear to use 'theory' as a synonym for 'not true yet'. Well, guess what, every claim to knowledge you can poke a stick at is in fact a theory. Science just is a theoretical project, in which laws and hypotheses are always and ever approximations of data. If you're looking for the holy grail of claims to knowledge lacking a theoretical component, convert to religion. But regardless: again, you're wrong about particulate theory (been around since the 70's, and was considered proven by the mid-80s when Chloro Flourocarbons (CFC's) were banned). If you get it wrong on such a detail, be careful about slagging off other theories. That's my message.
 
global warming as a theroy has indeed been around for a long time, the global warming as caused by humans has been around for significantly less time.

The green house effect is not applicable to earths climate it is a different set of processes.

Ozone depletion as caused by atmospheric chlorine particulates has insdeed been verified and acted upon. Again there are two different process at work the ozone layer stops types of UV radiation from penetrating to the surface. The climate change theory is that teh global warming gasses stop the reradiation of heat from the earth from escaping thereby causing a temperature rise.

Stephen Schnieder postulated in the early 70's that the earth was in for an iceage, the publication was based on temperature changes down from the 1930's through the 1970's.

However, Schneider soon realised he had overestimated the cooling effect of aerosol pollution and underestimated the effect of CO2, meaning warming was more likely than cooling in the long run. In his review of a 1977 book called The Weather Conspiracy: The Coming of the New Ice Age, Schneider stated: "We just don't know...at this stage whether we are in for warming or cooling - or when." A 1975 report (pdf format) by the US National Academy of Sciences merely called for more research.

A theory is the estimate is the best way of describing it of what you expect the data you plan to collect to show.

You postulate a theory , you design an experiment to hopefully collect the data that you need to confirm you theory. You collect your data you examine your data and compare your data to your theory. You correct your theory to conform to the observed data. You adjust your experiment to collect more data that is more accurate, you examine your data and adjust your theory to the new data. Repeat until your theory matches the data you collected. You publish your results, the data you used to achieve the results and the methodolgy used to collect the data.

Your peers in the academic world examine the results and attempt to duplicate them using the methodology that you developed for your experiments.

If your results are reproducable and the theories match the results achieved your theory is considered to be "accepted". Meaning it is genberally accepted to be acurate, please note it is not considered to be set in stone it can be changed if new data or theories that explain the results you achieved are uncovered.

That is what I mean by a theory, do you have a different view of what a theory is? If so please feel free to expound