Denying climate change: a psychological problem?

Climate change is caused by human industry?

  • Yep, I believe the climate change scientists

    Votes: 14 14.0%
  • Nope, we're just in a natural cycle of warming

    Votes: 26 26.0%
  • Yep, I say Option 1 AND deniers are psychologically attached to consumerism

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Nope, it's Option 2 AND saying otherwise is bad science

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Yep, but powerful economic interests are misleading the public

    Votes: 28 28.0%
  • Nope, but idealistic and opportunistic economic interests are duping publics

    Votes: 24 24.0%

  • Total voters
    100
how on earth are his gas/electricity bills at $2,400 per month? my house is about the same size and my monthly bill no where close to that. what is the source of the $2,400 figure?
There were numerous reports of this...

http://newsbusters.org/node/11073

But it has also been reported that this home has since undergone massive renovations to make it "greener". (As result of the extreme pressure I would assume...)
 
No worries... I AM a bike riding nut case!

Does he pay a bunch of bicycle riding nuts (just pulling your chain CG) to offset his energy intensive lifestyle?? If the credits come from productive businesses that have cut their own emissions, doesn't using the "credits" for something besides other productive businesses defeat the purpose of the whole thing?

Well, here's the rub... he buys the credits essentially from himself! Did you know he is a chief shareholder in a company that sells carbon credits? He stands to make BILLIONS through Generation Investment Management Inc. A company he co-founded and serves as chairman: through which he and others trade carbon offset credits. In case anyone has been living under a rock these past few years, a "Carbon Credit" is a commodity that environmentalists are using to offset one's carbon footprint. The premise being it is ok to use up and exceed your "carbon footprint" (the so called allotted amount of carbon dioxide emission) provided you "buy" credits from someone that has spare... A company gets in a "positive credit" situation by investing capitol in solar power, wind power and other projects that reduce fossil fuel energy consumption around the globe…

To illustrate the utter BS of this situation, try this analogy (which I read from a favourite columnist in a local newspaper): it would be the equivalent of a fat person claiming he/ she is losing weight by paying a thin person to go on a diet! Or more fitting for this forum, it would be like other TERB's to pay ME to be faithful to my wife so that you can poon all you want while claiming you are still being faithful to your own mates. :rolleyes:
 
Where I am sitting right now was once covered by a sheet of ice several miles thick. This was as recent as 10 to 15 thousand years ago, an eyeblink in geologic terms.
What happened to all that freakin' ice? It melted. Why? The planet warmed. And it did it without any assistance from my incandescent light bulbs or my brothers Chevy pick up.
Therefore, the planet can change its climate without human intervention.
Today, we see evidence of the planet warming once again, and the Ed Begley's of the world are trying to make everyone feel guilty for causing it.
Unless, and until, some resonable scientists, free of political agenda, can show me measurable data that my lifestyle, and not Mother Nature, is the root cause, then this is a battle I will view from the sidelines.

Dinasaurs lived in a really warm time too..... Guess they all drove SUVs......

:)

Bopper and TM, your naive comments are so embarrassing, i find it hard to believe you're serious. If you are, It's clear you haven't a clue of what you're talking about.

I've stood on glaciers that are 'miles' back from where they were only 20 years ago. I've stood on small dunes covering ground that was farmland 40 years ago in sub Saharan Africa. I've stood on lake beds that were 120 ft below the surface 40 years ago. You laugh and smirk and it's clear you know very little about what happening. there's no doubt it's getting warmer and in that downward cycle so bad that we can give accurate measurements of it's rate of change and we are now in a decline so severe we've never seen the same in the past. That's the scary part.

You will always find opposing views by others and that's not a bad thing as it makes the end result more convincing. You still hear theorist saying that 9/11 was a US government, with decoy planes piloted by remote control and the real plane flown into the oceans after the passengers were disembarked (more work courtesy of the TRUTHERS). there are still people who believe the world is flat.

Bopper you keep a relatively low profile on this BB, as opposed to being a newbie and it's hard to really know where you stand, but TM over and over again you shine like a lighthouse beacon to hyperbolic lunacy.
 
Bopper and TM, your naive comments are so embarrassing, i find it hard to believe you're serious. If you are, It's clear you haven't a clue of what you're talking about.

I've stood on glaciers that are 'miles' back from where they were only 20 years ago. I've stood on small dunes covering ground that was farmland 40 years ago in sub Saharan Africa. I've stood on lake beds that were 120 ft below the surface 40 years ago. You laugh and smirk and it's clear you know very little about what happening. there's no doubt it's getting warmer and in that downward cycle so bad that we can give accurate measurements of it's rate of change and we are now in a decline so severe we've never seen the same in the past. That's the scary part.

You will always find opposing views by others and that's not a bad thing as it makes the end result more convincing. You still hear theorist saying that 9/11 was a US government, with decoy planes piloted by remote control and the real plane flown into the oceans after the passengers were disembarked (more work courtesy of the TRUTHERS). there are still people who believe the world is flat.

Bopper you keep a relatively low profile on this BB, as opposed to being a newbie and it's hard to really know where you stand, but TM over and over again you shine like a lighthouse beacon to hyperbolic lunacy.

Ice coverage figures are iffy, the past twenty years is an interesting number, Ice coverage was at an all time high in the late 60's early 70's, as far as recorded ice coverage goes, so in effect the measurements are being taken against a maximum. 10000 years ago Lake Ontario was under a mile and a half of ice, where do you want to measure from?


there's no doubt it's getting warmer and in that downward cycle so bad that we can give accurate measurements

Your statement is inaccurate in that we can not give accurate measurements as to teh extent of the cooling/warming cycle, we do not have enough data to ensure accuracy.

More to the point 600 years ago there were dairy farms on Greenland vineyards in Englands and Scotland. It is to cold for that now so where do we measure from and what do we use as a medium point so there is some scale to the measurments.?
 
Where I am sitting right now was once covered by a sheet of ice several miles thick. This was as recent as 10 to 15 thousand years ago, an eyeblink in geologic terms.
What happened to all that freakin' ice? It melted. Why? The planet warmed. And it did it without any assistance from my incandescent light bulbs or my brothers Chevy pick up.
Therefore, the planet can change its climate without human intervention.
Today, we see evidence of the planet warming once again, and the Ed Begley's of the world are trying to make everyone feel guilty for causing it.
Unless, and until, some resonable scientists, free of political agenda, can show me measurable data that my lifestyle, and not Mother Nature, is the root cause, then this is a battle I will view from the sidelines.

Dinasaurs lived in a really warm time too..... Guess they all drove SUVs......

:)

Ice coverage figures are iffy, the past twenty years is an interesting number, Ice coverage was at an all time high in the late 60's early 70's, as far as recorded ice coverage goes, so in effect the measurements are being taken against a maximum. 10000 years ago Lake Ontario was under a mile and a half of ice, where do you want to measure from?


there's no doubt it's getting warmer and in that downward cycle's so bad that we can't give accurate measurements

Your statement is inaccurate in that we can not give accurate measurements as to teh extent of the cooling/warming cycle, we do not have enough data to ensure accuracy.

More to the point 600 years ago there were dairy farms on Greenland vineyards in Englands and Scotland. It is to cold for that now so where do we measure from and what do we use as a medium point so there is some scale to the measurments.?

My bad! I made the change It's 'CAN'T'

We don't know where it's going as it's new ground being covered. The measurements can only be trends as you are right; where's the beginning, the middle, or the end. We don't know. there still is green pasture in Greenland it's just that the growing season is so short.

There are vines/wines in England but I can't comment on its quality.
 
I have to poin t out on a fairly regular basis that Greenland was not Remax marketing ploy. During the medevial warm period vineyards were a regular thing in England, During the American Revolution they hauled canon across some rivers that never freeze now, there are verifiable reports of the Thames freezing over in a couple of occasions during that period as well.

Measurments are great , the big problem is figuring out what they actually mean
 
there are verifiable reports of the Thames freezing over in a couple of occasions during that period as well.

Yes.

But at the time the Thames was a much wider river and therefore much slower-moving. And it didn't have nearly as much warm effluent being flushed into it as it does today.

Absolutely nothing to do with the average temperature of the stratosphere, but the fact that some still think it has something to do with the topic at hand is testament to how twisted the tales are from the Global Warming fanatics.
 
More to the point 600 years ago there were dairy farms on Greenland vineyards in Englands and Scotland. It is to cold for that now so where do we measure from and what do we use as a medium point so there is some scale to the measurments.?

This indicates you don't even understand what the question is. It's the second derivative that is under consideration, not the absolute number, or even the first derivative.

Specifically the question is this:

What impact has human activity had on the rate of climate change?
 
Crichton points out their is no such thing as a completely objective study in today's research world. I tend to agree.

There should be a mandatory course taught in high school in this country call "Critical Thought". I know that it is part of may university and college programs, but it should be visited earlier. Maybe that way our future generations will take a good look at the message and then consider where the bias lays.

Any reasonable researcher knows that complete objectivity is nearly impossible. The point is to minimize it as much as possible.

There are such courses sneaking into the better school board curricula. Unfortunately usually only to the gifted/advanced students; it's about time.
 
Any reasonable researcher knows that complete objectivity is nearly impossible. The point is to minimize it as much as possible.

Actually, no. The point is to recognize the biases inherent in the data and in one's interpretation thereof, and acknowledge them openly.
 
Actually, no. The point is to recognize the biases inherent in the data and in one's interpretation thereof, and acknowledge them openly.

That's another way, but it skews the findings and make observation kind of like, 'here's my findings and here my conclusions, 19 times out of 20±4%'.
 
Don't get me started on Al Gore again... :rolleyes:

I find it difficult to vote in this poll.

I don't think any reasonably intelligent/ educated person can truthfully say that climate change is NOT happening. It is the nature of things. The weather is affected by so many different factors it is nearly impossible to predict with any degree of accuracy. What is in question is why is it happening or more correctly, to what degree is man responsible, and what can we do now to try and change our course at this point.

What gets me is the utter FEAR mongering tactics that the "green movement" (Al gore, David Suzuki and the likes) use to promote their own agendas and personal gain. They have literally made a business out of it. And don't get me started on carbon credits... **rolls eyes**

Spot on.

OTB
 
CG, even I don't really like Carbon Credits. I just look at it as fancy bookkeeping and it really won't do much good.
 
This indicates you don't even understand what the question is. It's the second derivative that is under consideration, not the absolute number, or even the first derivative.

Specifically the question is this:

What impact has human activity had on the rate of climate change?

Well if you read the posts , that particular conversation was about historical climate , which at the time of the post would in fact make it relavent.

Specifically just for you

Nobody knows if the human race has had a measurable effect on the rate of climate change.
 
I also remember that in the late 70's, after a few severe winters, the media was all over the "coming of the next ice age."
My point is that , yes the climate changes, but I don't know how much my lifestyle contributes to this. Is it a 50% contributing factor, or a .0001% factor. Tell me how much, and I will respond accordingly.
But I am not putting solar panels on my roof, driving a plug in electric vehicle, and turning my thermostat down to 60F just yet.
 
Don't get me started on Al Gore again... :rolleyes:

I find it difficult to vote in this poll.

I don't think any reasonably intelligent/ educated person can truthfully say that climate change is NOT happening. It is the nature of things. The weather is affected by so many different factors it is nearly impossible to predict with any degree of accuracy. What is in question is why is it happening or more correctly, to what degree is man responsible, and what can we do now to try and change our course at this point.

What gets me is the utter FEAR mongering tactics that the "green movement" (Al gore, David Suzuki and the likes) use to promote their own agendas and personal gain. They have literally made a business out of it. And don't get me started on carbon credits... **rolls eyes**

Climate change certainly is happenning, and it always is happening, with or without man. We may be partially or totally at fault with this one, but the reality is the earth has always warmed and cooled and warmed up again - in cycles which are not totally understood. I think the key is adjusting to change as much as in trying to prevent change. So in that sense the moral indignation and finger pointing around current perceived climate change is, to me, pretty much useless. Time to start building some sea walls, or tearing down some old buildings...if sea levels are really rising. As an example.

Over time carbon takes care of itself. If we are lucky we may not be part of the carbon stores.
 
Damn it, been too busy to get back to my own post! But here goes, while dinner is cookin' in the oven . . .

Apart from the factual bias revealed in the poll (such as the debate whether Global Warming is or is not PRIMARILY anthropogenic), there are some key details which you seem to prefer to ignore.

I cannot have ignored anything yet, not even seemingly or preferably, because all I did was cut and pasted a newspaper article for your consideration.

For example, the number of "Climate Scientists" who conspired to defraud the world by "adjusting" their data to support their pre-conceived conclusions - the focus of the article you cited.

That's not the focus of the article. The focus is clearly the fear among scientists that the public is psychologically attached to their consumerist ways, and thus resistant to calls for change, even if the fate of the planet is at stake. I ignored - there, I ignored something now - the blogs and wiki's you cite, because they are for pre-schoolers not adults. But the claim you refer to, about defrauding and cooking the books, is false. It's false because you misunderstand the story. Reports of those 'leaked' reports, etc, are really referring to scientists thinking the public is too stupid to get the message, and complaining they could not get the point across to a stupid public.

It's most certainly not about casting aspersions on those who understand the facts and respect the scientific method.

No idea what you're talking about. I feel like I came into the middle of a conversation between your left hand and your right hand. Please rephrase and try again. By the way, isn't the Terb handle Anynym almost redundant?:p
 
Michael Crichton wrote an excellent novel called "State of Fear" which addresses these issues . . . Crichton points out their is no such thing as a completely objective study in today's research world. I tend to agree.

Crichton also failed out of medical school. He wrote many good fictional works, though. You are correct that there is no such thing as a completely objective study. That's the myth of objectivity getting killed. Again. But ever notice that the myth was always just a convenient way to represent efforts to find out stuff about nature? Just because the myth is dead or should be killed, doesn't mean things don't get found out about nature. By running from "the myth is dead" to "no real science", you display the great need for you to take those critical thinking courses your post referred to. Your logic runs you you perilously close to "no objectivity, thus no knowledge", which is to eat some scepticism for dinner and wake up a nihilist. That's not good. What we have are studies that are not absolutely guaranteed, because any absolute is a myth. We have to look for other indicators of reliability and credibility other than pristine images (myths) of science without any human hands on it. It is a simple fact that, if votes were taken, more scientists in more disciplines claim the rate of climate change is increasing due to human industry, than those that dissent. There are other useful measures of the reliability of climate science, that's just one. But don't ditch the myth of objectivity and run straight to nihilism.

Al Gore makes millions from this and will appreciate your efforts

You can rattle off conspiracy theories until you are blue in the face, indeed blue all over your smurf body, and a conspiracy theory will never make it to the status of an argument. Bye . . . .

Don't get me started on Al Gore again... What gets me is the utter FEAR mongering tactics that the "green movement" (Al gore, David Suzuki and the likes) use to promote their own agendas and personal gain.
Rollerboy, I will not get you started on Al Gore, because you told me you think he is hot and I am done trying to convince you otherwise. ;)

But . . . this fear mongering and agenda talk is a knife that cuts both ways. You are aware that corporations like Exxon and Mobil are heavily funding the work of scientists claiming climate change is just a natural cycle and nothing to do with fossil fuel use and human industry?

Given a choice between Big Green and Big Oil funding research and telling me what to do, I'll take Big Green any day. Really, a healthy guy like you, with Lance Armstrong tattood on your butt (Mrs Rollerboy told me that), is siding with Big Oil over Big Green?
 
I believe in science when it is done objectively & properly.... In addition the fact that we the people are being asked to give up an enormous amount of freedom . . . I think it's VERY fair to demand that they Conclusively PROVE every goddamned thing they claim... Truth is pretty self evident & it can stand openly on it's own & face all challengers. Peer review might have meant something once but it's basically devolved to cronyism, dogma & orthodoxy as of late.

I would wager that if a scientists told you something was true, and that truth was perceived by you as not impinging on your freedom and maybe even increasing it, then all of a sudden you would have found for yourself a proper and objective scientists. That's the cart leading the horse, of course.

That said, I see your point about it being fair to demand a certain level of proof prior to fostering changed practices onto large groups. But the real rub here is whether that just creates a situation where the most intransigent element wins, rather than the best claim to knowledge? I ask this question because you leave unanswered how it is to be decided that soemthing is proved enough for a government to procced on the basis of that proved knowledge. Is it going to be you? is it going to be a referendum? But if so, doesn't that throw out the window your demand for objective knowledge? Isn't the ideal of objective knowledge the idea that a claim is true regardless of what people think? But who makes that judgment? If it is supposed to be publics, with little technical training, then doesn't this just make knowledge whatever it is large groups think it is? have you not just shot yourself in the foot by being so dismissive of some many scientists?