You go, Wal-Mart!

tboy said:
Hence why I've said, and will continue to say, that unions are mainly self-serving now and their main goal is to rape a company in the short term.

Who raped the American economy tboy?

It wasn't the working stiff.

It always make me chuckle how white collar greed is deemed acceptable but if a blue collar worker wants a fair living wage he/she's seen as a villain.
 
dajodo2 said:
Who raped the American economy tboy?

It wasn't the working stiff.

It always make me chuckle how white collar greed is deemed acceptable but if a blue collar worker wants a fair living wage he/she's seen as a villain.

That's just the point, to a T. A FAIR living wage. IME unions don't want a fair living wage, they want that x2. I find it ludicrous that a union will blackmail and or extort to protect their greed. For eg: the policy that the idiots running toronto signed an agreement that stated the city could NOT go outside the union for sub-contracting and pay less than the union rates. That is pure 100% extortion. If there is a company out there that can do the same job cheaper, ANYONE should be able to exercise their right to choose who provides that service.

To put it in comparison:

A company is that an entity unto itself. It had to be started by someone. That someone a) either put up the capital himself or borrowed it b) took the majority of the risks to create the company and c) typically worked his or her ass off to make it happen.

Now with unions, they come in after the fact, and try to get their share of the pie. Why SHOULDN'T someone who invested their life's savings reap the rewards? In most cases if you work at a company long and hard, you get rewarded for your efforts via longer paid vacations, more seniority, higher wages, but unions want that IMMEDIATELY with little or not recourse for poor performance.

Now one of the things the trades unions have going for them is the apprenticeship programs they have in place. Yes, there are non-unionized apprenticeship programs also.

A perfect example of how unions screwed themselves is the manufacturing sector. They priced themselves out of the market and are now paying the price for their greed. Sure, the worker on the floor will blame the management of the company for moving their jobs offshore but will the UNION put up the millions or BILLIONS of dollars to keep a company running at a loss? NOT
 
The Bandit said:
Don't get rediculous now...

Where I work it's 9-5 and get paid for 8 hrs, with 30 min lunch, but no breaks.
The eight hour day is a benefit most people enjoy today, that unions fought long and hard for against bitter opposition from employers who claimed it would bankrupt everyone. Who was right?

Of course WalMart employees work longer than eight hours and some of those hours w/o pay—as revealed in th lawsuit that forced them to pony up. In one state only, because labour law is still state by state and province by province. Guess who stacked that deck.
 
Hmmm employees having to work long hours w/o pay? So, why should the peons be any different than middle management?

I used to work a job where I averaged 60 - 70 hrs a week and was "paid" for 37.5 of those hours. I did that for years and advanced because of it. The reason I left is because instead of trying to form a project manager's union, I PERSONALLY decided my life was more than just working to get ahead.

Why should the peons be any different?

Which brings up an interesting point of discussion: I wonder how many union workers worked their way through the ranks, left the union to become management? See, in most of the non-union companies I worked for, it was possible for a guy to work the floor of the warehouse, work his way up and get a position in the office, and become MORE than just a labourer. In many of the union shops I worked at those that worked the floor, STAYED on the floor forever. If new management was required they brought them in from outside.
 
james t kirk said:
So, you're happy about people losing their jobs?

You support billionaires stomping on guys making 7 bucks an hour?

Oh, I see, you think that because these poor slobs want to make 8 bucks an hour that that will take a piece of pie away from you. Very admirable.

BTW, Bill Gates gave 58% of his profits last year to charity.

The owners of Walmart - less than 1%.

More reasons why I don't shop at Walmart.

The owners of Wal-Mart? Wal-Mart is a publicly traded corporation- that means the "owners" are the shareholders.

If you are talking about the current executives at Wal-Mart, they make WAAAAYYYY less money than Billy Gates.
 
Some employers promote from the floor, and some don't. I fail to see what difference a union would or could make in their decision, tboy.

Unions aren't about individuals getting ahead, and as you illustrated, that's an individual choice. No one and no organization should be able to stop you by putting their priorities ahead of the individuals, though manager's who don't promote from within, and unions w/ rigid seniority systems both fail this test.

What unions are about is the ordinary worker who's just trying to do the assigned work and wants to be treated and paid fairly for it. Not everyone is like you, willing to work for half-pay for a possibility of advancement, and for many who make that choice, the possibility never pans out.
 
Last edited:
jaykraus242 said:
The owners of Wal-Mart? Wal-Mart is a publicly traded corporation- that means the "owners" are the shareholders.

If you are talking about the current executives at Wal-Mart, they make WAAAAYYYY less money than Billy Gates.
Sam Walton is to Walmart as Bill Gates is to MicroSoft, and how much did the Waltons do for humanity? Besides facilitating the exploitation of a large percentage of it so a tiny percentage could buy stuff cheap.
 
Oh what the hell, I think I'll join in despite my better judgment.

I was a union worker for years. I moved to management. (Just so you all know what my history is and why I say the things I do).

First off, lets keep in mind that there are actually TWO different types of unions, (membership and trade). The membership union is the one which most are talking about, where it is the goal of the union to increase membership as there is security in numbers. The more members that the union has, the easier it is to do 'damage' to a company should they be in a strike position. A trade union is the opposite. The keep the membership small to inflate the income of the workers by creating less supply than demand in a specific field. If one needs somebody trained to fix an elevator for example, one can bet they will be paying a premium. Probably most good mechanics could fix one, but the union has denied access to the training required to do this certain type of job.

I for one do not believe that unions are needed, either type of them.

Yes there was a point in the past that they were needed, without a doubt. The unions have done some wonderful things for ALL workers, not just those that are in the unions themselves. I would be hard pressed to argue against the fact that many (if not most) of the labour laws that have been put in place were not in some way due to the pressure of the organized. These laws protect MYSELF as well as my staff. I as much as they have the right to refuse work, and not put my safety in compromise, among many other things.

At this point however, the laws are in place and secure. Whether the company in question is organized or not, these same laws apply. Executives cannot 'force' people to work through breaks, do 80 hour work weeks or work in dangerous conditions anymore. There are severe penalties if a company breaks these laws. This does bring up a few other points...

As an individual employee
-I have the right to choose my employer. If I do not like the pay, atmosphere, company rules, I am free to find employment in a company that suits my needs better.

As a company
-I have a right to make as much profit as I can.
-I have a right to manage my company as I see fit, so long as no laws are broken.
-I must please my shareholders or they will invest somewhere else that gives them higher returns.
-If my company is no longer profitable, I can close the doors so I do not become bankrupt.
-If I have stacks of resume's of people who are willing to work for me for $8/hr., why should I have to pay $12/hr.? I might do this to get the best talent available to me, but that is MY decision.

I can not understand the people who complain about company greed and huge company profits, even when I was a union employee. Why would I want to bite the hand that feeds me? I signed a contract that stated in no uncertain terms that I would provide a certain amount of labour for what I thought was a fair pay. If I did not like those terms I had every right to either find a company who I wanted to work for, or to start a business myself. I still do. I can quit at any time to better my employment conditions.

So, since I am working closely with unions, what do I see them do on a daily basis?
-Fight for the worker who is limiting throughput production, (by the employees choice), and keeping the company from making the greatest profit that they can make.
-Fight for the worker who has chronic absenteeism problems
-Fight for the worker who is continually making mistakes
-Fight for the worker who is breaking safety rules
-Fight for better pay, benefits and holidays which are already far higher than the industry standard
-Fight for a worker to get overtime even if he is not trained, capable of the job that needs to be done.
-Grieve at every opportunity without management having a chance to correct the situation, so an employee can get undeserved 'armchair money'.
-Try to cause a rift between management and labour to increase union solidarity.

You see, union positions are ELECTED positions. The steward has to do SOMETHING to keep himself in the position. With the position comes a greater pay, security, and the chance not to be on the shop floor full time. It is for this reason 'many, not all, but many', union stewards tend to pick fights. They have to keep themselves in the spotlight so they can be re-elected when the next election comes up.

Funny thing... Having talked to many unionized people over the years, (both when I was unionized myself, and as a member of management), the good workers don't seem to want, or need for that matter their union stewards. They come to me personally to get things worked out, and they talk to my superiors as well. They are respected and valuable employees, the ones that management goes to if they need input or help to solve a problem. Many of these people are actually against unions (though they are smart enough to keep their mouths shut), as they do not see any benefit from the membership dues that they are paying. They see that the 'jerk offs' are the people that are putting the company in jeoprady and want those people out of there as much as management does.

But of course, the union has to protect all employees to keep the membership strong...

Am I anti union? No I am not. The unions though could focus on more valuable things that would still benefit all employees... Ergonomics, process improvements, cost reductions, etc. I think that if unions are to survive, they have to change direction and fight for the things that will KEEP jobs, the things that will allow companies to be competative and not stifle their growth.

Ok, flame away.
 
jaykraus242 said:
The owners of Wal-Mart? Wal-Mart is a publicly traded corporation- that means the "owners" are the shareholders.

If you are talking about the current executives at Wal-Mart, they make WAAAAYYYY less money than Billy Gates.

I'm talking about the Waltons themselves who still own the majority of share of Big Wally and they own all voting shares.

And they give fuck all.

Even Walmart as a coporation donated less than one tenth of 1 percent of their total revenue.

Gates donated 58% of his income last year and that is a fact. Gates also pays his people a hell of a lot more than 8 bucks an hour. Now I'm not saying that a woman who works the cash at Big Wally should be making what a computer programmer makes. I realize that the programmer has a valuable skill set and the cashier does not, however, would 10 bucks an hour be a stretch for a full time cashier at Big Wally?

That equates to 21 grand a year (vs. 16 k at 8 bucks an hour)
 
james t kirk said:
I'm talking about the Waltons themselves who still own the majority of share of Big Wally and they own all voting shares.

And they give fuck all.

Even Walmart as a coporation donated less than one tenth of 1 percent of their total revenue.
It is their money and no one has a right to tell them what to do with their stuff, the same way that no one has a right to tell me how much I should donate to charity.

Look at it another way, look at how many people they employ globally, the incomes that they pay out and just by being an employer what they are giving to society.
 
I've been a dues paying member of 2 unions. The rest ofthe positions I have held in my career have been non-union. Having been on both sides of it I would MUCH rather work for a non-union company.
 
james t kirk said:
I'm talking about the Waltons themselves who still own the majority of share of Big Wally and they own all voting shares.

And they give fuck all.

Even Walmart as a coporation donated less than one tenth of 1 percent of their total revenue.

Gates donated 58% of his income last year and that is a fact. Gates also pays his people a hell of a lot more than 8 bucks an hour. Now I'm not saying that a woman who works the cash at Big Wally should be making what a computer programmer makes. I realize that the programmer has a valuable skill set and the cashier does not, however, would 10 bucks an hour be a stretch for a full time cashier at Big Wally?

That equates to 21 grand a year (vs. 16 k at 8 bucks an hour)

Notice how you said "gates donated..."? He himself personally. Not Microsoft.......and for that matter, what'd he make last year personally? $100 BILLION dollars? There comes a point where you just can't have any more money.........shit I believer there was a time before the dot.com crash that he was making $1M an hour....

You cannot compare an extremely wealthy individual's choices with that of a major corporation.

Anyhow, where the hell do you get your info? They gave $157 Million away last year...

http://walmartwatch.com/blog/archives/walton_family_ranks_37th_in_charitable_giving/

And:

Helen Walton, matriarch of Wal-Mart’s founding family, contributed $356.5 million last year,

In addtion, as to the $2.00 an hour increase, sure, for 10 employees, that's nothing. But for the 1,000,000 plus cashiers they employ? That's $10M an hour MORE and what will they get out of it? I bet they won't get a cashier that rings through more customers. Have you never heard of that rule: The only thing that has value to a person is the thing they've worked hard for?

As for the rate, I bet there are already many cashiers that make more than that. If you figure minimum wage is $8.75, add 5% per year, it would take them 3 yrs to make $10.00 and that's if they're just plain old plain old "just doing my job". I have worked retail and while it was a while ago, they operate no differently than any other organization: if you work hard and are a good employee? You get increases.

BTW: A1? That has got to be the best post on the subject so far...Kudos to you!!

I would really appreciate the pro unioners here to try to explain how prices would NOT increase on everything, if everyone was unionized. I mean seriously, if every working stiff in this country realized a 20 or 30 percent incease in wages, where do you think the money to cover that increase would come from?

If you say ANYTHING other than us consumers, they you're out of your fricken tree......
 
tboy said:
I would really appreciate the pro unioners here to try to explain how prices would NOT increase on everything, if everyone was unionized. I mean seriously, if every working stiff in this country realized a 20 or 30 percent incease in wages, where do you think the money to cover that increase would come from?

I know you understand this concept tboy, it is for others benefit.

Economics 101

Increased pay will balance with increased costs so the supply/demand curve will reach an equilibrium at a new level. For example, (with nice easy rounded numbers). (Simplified version)

Average employee makes $10,000/year.
All employees (across the country) get 10% raise, now equaling $11,000 salary.
Company now makes less profit
Company has to raise costs
Big Mac was $10 turns into Big Mac costing $11

We all make more money on paper, but the costs out of pocket remain the same so we are no farther ahead.
 
Exactly Player, and when you factor in the "value" of our wages/cost of goods in the world market, then our exports suffer. If there is any doubt of this just look what happened earlier this year when we beat out the US dollar for the first time in eons......
 
a 1 player said:
I know you understand this concept tboy, it is for others benefit.

Economics 101

Increased pay will balance with increased costs so the supply/demand curve will reach an equilibrium at a new level. For example, (with nice easy rounded numbers). (Simplified version)

Average employee makes $10,000/year.
All employees (across the country) get 10% raise, now equaling $11,000 salary.
Company now makes less profit
Company has to raise costs
Big Mac was $10 turns into Big Mac costing $11

We all make more money on paper, but the costs out of pocket remain the same so we are no farther ahead.
This is the same story with or without unions.
 
oldjones said:
This is the same story with or without unions.

Sorry, no. WITH unions that IS the story. Without unions the quality of work dictates the wages paid. ie: low skill, low knowledge, low intelligence level jobs make low wages. High skill, high knowledge, high intelligence level jobs make higher wages.

With unions, low intelligence, NO knowledge, NO skill jobs make MORE than those requiring a high degree of skill. Which equals an increase in base services like garbage collection, fast food service, retail sales floor help etc.

If you unionize ALL positions everywhere do you really REALLY think those unions will not do like they've done in every other industry and try (and through extortion succeed) in increasing the wage and benefit rates for even the lowest level jobs? WHO is going to pay for that?

CONSUMERS so in effect, what you've done is make the position that requires years of schooling equal to those that require NO schooling.
 
Great post A1. Nice to hear the arguement from someone who has been on both sides of the table.
 
biog said:
Great post A1. Nice to hear the arguement from someone who has been on both sides of the table.

I third that (even though I already first it lol) and I was surprised to see someone actually opt out of the union for a management position. I have worked for a number of union companies and not a one on the floor wanted that. (one of the reasons was they saw how many hours us managers worked and liked their 7:30 - 4 jobs).
 
tboy said:
I was surprised to see someone actually opt out of the union for a management position. I have worked for a number of union companies and not a one on the floor wanted that. (one of the reasons was they saw how many hours us managers worked and liked their 7:30 - 4 jobs).
I might have opted out for different reasons than one would think.

To put it simply, I did not like the union mentality. I was forever in trouble with my co-workers and the union. I have always believed that one EARNS their money. When I got my first union job, it was an increase of about $5 from what I was doing before, and for me at the time, that was a hell of a lot of money. My first day on the job, there were 5 of us working in one area. The others has it worked out that if 3 of us worked steady, we could get the required output needed in 8 hours. If 4 of us worked, one person could always be off and we could finish the job early and leave the plant an hour before the end of shift and still get paid. I was the person who refused to take the breaks and work at a steady speed.

It did not take long before I found ways that the same job could be done by 2 people in the shift if there was a bit of workstation organization done, and some of the bottlenecks were removed, which would cost very little to do. My thought was that if the job could be done with two people, the three others could get things done in other areas of the plant that were falling behind in production. Of course when I brought this up to my co-workers, I was raked over the coals to say the least. One day we, (the group of us), were called into the office and disciplined for always being short one or two people on the job. I got disciplined as well, even though I refused to take those breaks, and never left the plant before the end of shift. (At this point I was working at the factory for about 9 months)

During this time i was becoming friends with an engineer. He was an older British gentleman who was months away from retirement. I told him my ideas in confidence, and the shit that I was going through with my co-workers over a few lunches. A couple of weeks later the Foreman came to the workstation and called me in a stern voice. "a 1 player, get to my office". I was immediately escorted to a boardroom, thinking I was about to be fired. In the boardroom was my friend the engineer, the manufacturing manager and the plant manager. My friend told me to get up to the front and explain to everyone in the room my ideas for cost reduction and process improvements. I was fucking scared as hell, but I got up and I talked and drew diagrams for 40 minutes, all the while people were taking notes and asking questions. I told them what I wanted done, but I did not know how to do it. When I was done there were about 5 people left speechless.

About 3 weeks later I came back from a weekend and saw many of the changes I had brought up put into place, and that the job was not set up for two people. Myself and another of the good workers were asked to run the machinery while a time study was being done. The two of us were able to build about 3 hours of regular production in about 90 minutes just by working at a steady pace, without hauling ass. I was happier than a pig in shit.

At the end of the shift I went to my car and found all four tires slashed, all windows broken, somebody had taken a shit inside my car, and a death threat. Of course I went to the foreman, and the police became involved. This was the time that I decided I was done with the union mentality. I talked to the engineer again, and told him that my ideas were just the tip of the iceberg, and that I could change many more parts of the factory in the same way. By the end of that week, I was a 'junior engineer', the made up title that they gave for me, and walking around the shop floor pointing out areas for cost savings and process improvements.

A year later I was let go by a new management team who came in, once they found that I did not have an engineering background. Yes, at first I was quite upset, but then I thought to myself that if I could do that there, I could do it at other places as well. I continued working at different factories, all the while taking night school and correspondance courses so I could become management. Eventually that was where I landed, as a foreman.

Despite all of this, I still do not hate unions. I have been screwed by both sides, union and management in the past. But I do like being the master of my own destiny, and having the choice of my career, and the employers I choose to work for.

Sorry for the long story, but that is how I changed sides.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Cool but the story I seen talked about Wally breaking Canada labour laws and a lawsuit still pending.

Breaking labour laws is nothing new for Wal Mart, in the USA they have been fine for hiring too young of workers-working them too late, cheating on pay-they work 8 1/2 hours, Wal would pay them for 8 hours.
Pro-union jibberish and myth making. Show us the proof.