Would I be charged if...?

You Sir are welcome in my jury.
Mind you I'm not saying that I don't understand the sentiment. But you tell your client - call the police, do not punch him in the nose. And as a Crown - you should have called the police or had him thrown out of the night club, not punched him in the nose.
 
Anyhow, I'm not talking about going Jihad on the ass grabber, just a quick poke to let him know he's an ass.....(like I said, it turned physical when he went physical, if he had just said something, saying something back would be appropriate).

OK, I see your point. If words are thrown, respond with words. If sparks, sparks. If violence, violence. Respond in kind, in other words.

Where we differ is that I like to think for myself in all cases. I don't want my response determined for me by the nature of the provocation. That way I don't have to be an idiot just because the provocateur is an idiot.
 
The thing that all you "talk first" types are counting on is the fact that you think that cops will automatically charge me (or the nose popper). What you forget is that many (most?) cops are the neanderthal types that you seen to dispise. They too might appreciate the fact that one is standing up for someone important to them.
Different police agencies and different prosecutorial districts treat things differently/ have different "cultures". Perhaps Toronto is indeed as you describe, however, there are vast other areas of both Canada and the U.S. where the police are going to arrest you in half a heartbeat and the prosecutors will prosecute you.
 
More locally: we're being taxed to death and the government wants to tax us more. What do you think would happen if 100 people went to ottawa and carried signs? Not a whole heck of a lot. What if 100 people armed to the teeth went to ottawa? A shitstorm. If the powers that be didn't pay attention to the 100 carrying signs, they sure as hell would if those same 100 were carrying ARs......

I agree with your assessment that the gun-toters would receive more attention.... but would it provide any more resolvement of the dislike of taxes than the sign-toters?

Perhaps if instead of 100, we had a 100,000.... but I guess that would be more of a revolution than a protest. :)
 
I agree with your assessment that the gun-toters would receive more attention.... but would it provide any more resolvement of the dislike of taxes than the sign-toters?

Perhaps if instead of 100, we had a 100,000.... but I guess that would be more of a revolution than a protest. :)

I see your point as well but really, I don't think the politicians pay any heed to anyone who can't get them re-elected. 100,000 is a drop in the bucket and frankly I really don't think they'd think twice about it.