verbalks said:I have not decided but I was given the task to clean up a house for resale (not in gta).
Old people lived in the house and they were at a stage in their lives they no longer cared about things. The old floor smelled and was ruined. I am just looking for a lower cost product with reasonably easy installation. It seems most want some form of wood in their homes over other products.
Since I am not planning long term with this house more expensive solutions are not viable since there is a ceiling as to what the home can resell for.
Well, you will always get 100% ROI when you install hardwood. As long as you don't go wacko and use bamboo in some funky pattern that is lol.
For the record, I can put down about 100 sq ft of click flooring in about 2 hrs and 100 sq ft of nail down in about 2.5. IMO if you want to really get the most bang for your buck, spend a little more on the front end and get either engineered or solid hardwood. Homo Depot has sales on all the time and I've seen asian maple and oak for as low as $2.99 psf. That's about half what you'd normally see and no, they aren't factory seconds. They are select or better quality.
Speaking of factory seconds. Do NOT buy it. It ain't worth it. In fact, I did a job this summer and quoted on it at my usual $3.00 psf install. Then they delivered factory seconds and easily 30% of it was garbage. Total crap. I even found different species in the boxes (I was laying ash and it had maple mixed in). After the job was completed I told the customer that I should have charged $10.00 psf for it because it took me twice as long. I also told the company that I sub to sometimes that from now on, if the job is factory seconds, my rate is $10.00 an hour.
Here's some problems with Factory Seconds:
1) Different species
2) Different stains
3) Different widths (one piece was 3 1/4 at one end and 3 3/8 at the other)
4) One box had what looked like 1 litre of black stain poured on the bottom pieces and the bottom two layers were totally unusuable
5) Large deep knots
6) extreme twisting of longer pieces (if you happen to get any)
7) Majority of the pieces were 16" long or less. Better quality flooring companies guarantee at least 50% of the pieces will be 36" or longer which makes for a nice easy install and a great random pattern.

