Winter Tire Show Down!

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
508
113
The Keebler Factory
I've narrowed down my decision to the following two 3 types of winter tires in no particular order:

1) Bridgestone Blizzak WS70, $230

2) Bridgestone Blizzak LM 60, $275

3) Michelin X-Ice 2 (Xi2), $210

I'll be driving in city and highway conditions in the GTA (no northern/Buffalo driving). Car is rear-wheel drive.

Overall, #1 seems to rate better for slush/snow, #2 for dry/ice, and #3 gets a really good rating (sometimes better than both of the others) but has had complaints about shallow tread depth vs. snow (10.5 mm vs. 11 for #2 and 12 for #1).

Anyone used any of these winter tires before? Comments?
 
I've narrowed down my decision to the following two 3 types of winter tires in no particular order:

1) Bridgestone Blizzak WS70, $230

2) Bridgestone Blizzak LM 60, $275

3) Michelin X-Ice 2 (Xi2), $210

I'll be driving in city and highway conditions in the GTA (no northern/Buffalo driving). Car is rear-wheel drive.

Overall, #1 seems to rate better for slush/snow, #2 for dry/ice, and #3 gets a really good rating (sometimes better than both of the others) but has had complaints about shallow tread depth vs. snow (10.5 mm vs. 11 for #2 and 12 for #1).

Anyone used any of these winter tires before? Comments?

All will to the jobs they're designed for, but I find both brands over priced. There use to be a problem with Blizzaks wearing down their really good tread quickly and becoming just another standard tire but that may have been dealt with. Look at the Toyo line of winter tires, with their micro bits technology. My snow tires are quieter than my all seasons. You very seldom see comparison tests with them, but they haven't disappointed me yet and I have had three sets on various vehicles over the year and drives in all sorts of conditions.
 
Anyone used any of these winter tires before? Comments?
I'm Buffalo area resident reporting in, who has NOT used snow tires in over 25 yrs. The burbs out here plow the roads well. Have no need for snows at all. Decent good tires have served me well to date.
FWIW prior to moving back to the burbs I did use snows while living inside the Buffalo city limits for the few years living there. Buffalo city does not plow their side streets well and snows were a necessity then.

BTW in all that time have NOT had a single snow related accident...;)
 
I've narrowed down my decision to the following two 3 types of winter tires in no particular order:

1) Bridgestone Blizzak WS70, $230

2) Bridgestone Blizzak LM 60, $275

3) Michelin X-Ice 2 (Xi2), $210

I'll be driving in city and highway conditions in the GTA (no northern/Buffalo driving). Car is rear-wheel drive.

Overall, #1 seems to rate better for slush/snow, #2 for dry/ice, and #3 gets a really good rating (sometimes better than both of the others) but has had complaints about shallow tread depth vs. snow (10.5 mm vs. 11 for #2 and 12 for #1).

Anyone used any of these winter tires before? Comments?

DO NOT BUY the Bridgestones. They get their grip from a thin layer of very soft rubber, one season on in Toronto will pretty much wear this down. Go with the Michelins, Nokians or Givslavd
 
I'm Buffalo area resident reporting in, who has NOT used snow tires in over 25 yrs. The burbs out here plow the roads well. Have no need for snows at all. Decent good tires have served me well to date.
FWIW prior to moving back to the burbs I did use snows while living inside the Buffalo city limits for the few years living there. Buffalo city does not plow their side streets well and snows were a necessity then.

BTW in all that time have NOT had a single snow related accident...;)


Sure you can get by without snows, but you know what? If you keep a car for around 100 K km.. Snows will not cost you a dime.. and if you lease, the snows will also not cost you a dime more. So why not have the right tire at the same overall cost?
 
I live a few hours north of the city and can attest to the effectiveness of the Michelin's.
They're very good in everything from pavement, ice to snow.
However snow that is about halfway up the tire does pose some challenges, but patience and good driving helps a lot.
For about 70 per cent (for me even) of the time in winter months the roads are usually bare so overly-aggressive tread patterns are just over-kill in my opinion.
Got them for $70 less so the over-priced nature was offset. Bought 'em and installed 'em at Costco. Good luck trying to get a spot to have them installed. They were fully booked by 10 a.m. on the day I was there.

Note: A brother of mine had the Nokias and they were amazing in deep snow, but lousy on pavement. Noisy too.
I also heard the Blizzaks wear quite quickly.
 
Buffalo city does not plow their side streets well and snows were a necessity then.
Same in Toronto. In fact, many main streets are not plowed either. Also, residents are responsible for clearing their own sidewalks. The snow removal system in Toronto is called "July".
 
I live a few hours north of the city and can attest to the effectiveness of the Michelin's.
They're very good in everything from pavement, ice to snow.
However snow that is about halfway up the tire does pose some challenges, but patience and good driving helps a lot.
For about 70 per cent (for me even) of the time in winter months the roads are usually bare so overly-aggressive tread patterns are just over-kill in my opinion.
Got them for $70 less so the over-priced nature was offset. Bought 'em and installed 'em at Costco. Good luck trying to get a spot to have them installed. They were fully booked by 10 a.m. on the day I was there.

Note: A brother of mine had the Nokias and they were amazing in deep snow, but lousy on pavement. Noisy too.
I also heard the Blizzaks wear quite quickly.

Snow tire technology at this time is less about tread aggressiveness and m ore about rubber compounds that work best in cold weather. the big nobby tires have given way to sipes and inline grove in treads. All seasons start losing the grip advantage as the temperature drop below ~7c.. Then again it really doesn't matter what you're driving on if you don't go out in crappy conditions or never drive above 30kph.
 
Well, Consumer Reports still ranks General Tire's Altimax Arctic's as second only to Michelin's X-Ice XI 2. Substantially cheaper, too.

I bought them last year for both my cars (a Hyundai Tucson and an Acura TL) for that reason. They are an excellent town and country tire and handle extremely well. They feel soft and comfortable until you push them, then they respond with lots of grip ...

Perry
 
I'm a fan of winter tires ... have used Blizzaks (loved 'em), Michelin (loved 'em) and Toy (loved 'em).

Bottom line, you're talking nuances here, the difference between winter tires. Winter and summer is night and day, just get whatever winters make you happy.
 
Same in Toronto. In fact, many main streets are not plowed either. Also, residents are responsible for clearing their own sidewalks. The snow removal system in Toronto is called "July".

What part of the city do you live in. IMHO Toronto is pretty diligent about snow removal... overkill IMHO
 
Snow tire technology at this time is less about tread aggressiveness and m ore about rubber compounds that work best in cold weather. the big nobby tires have given way to sipes and inline grove in treads. All seasons start losing the grip advantage as the temperature drop below ~7c.. Then again it really doesn't matter what you're driving on if you don't go out in crappy conditions or never drive above 30kph.

Your point about tire technology is valid. However when I refer to aggressive tread pattern I speak from experience dealing with conditions and roadways that never see a plow (unless a guy with a tractor comes along). Space between rubber compounds has a greater influence on the volume of snow/slush that can be shed from the tire than sipes and inline grooves in treads.
If you're saying marketing and companies have shifted their focus to the sipes and inline grooves then I'd agree, as most people/consumers live in and around the city where roads do not stay blanketed by the white stuff for more than a few days or week at a time.
Just buy a tire that suits your needs. I drive on all roads, small (unplowed roads), county roads, highways and super highways. That's why I have the X-ice. I know many people in my area who just have the soft-compound, blocky treaded snow tires for passanger cars and trucks. Most people buy the cheap ones that are terrible for the bareroads like Tiger paw (if I remember) and Canadian Tire equivalents. They usually do fine, as many don't leave the county in the winter very often.
Sorry if I pulled this thread off topic slightly. Just felt like my insight would not only defend myself, but give some additional information for the OP to ponder.
 
DO NOT BUY the Bridgestones. They get their grip from a thin layer of very soft rubber, one season on in Toronto will pretty much wear this down. Go with the Michelins, Nokians or Givslavd

Funny you should say that, that was my exact same experience with the set of factory Bridgestones that came with my car. After they were 50% worn (if that) they no longer held the road worth a shit.
 
living quite rurally i have always gone with Nokians and have them studded. Despite being illegal in southern ontario, there are shops around the greater GTA which will install studs and cops, even at seasonal ride checks have never noticed the tapping stud sounds, (because cops are basically stupid in most instances. Take Blackrock for instance who always wanted to be a cop but ended up a security guard,) and i have cat-claw like grip on ice with the studs. why compromise safety?
 
2) Bridgestone Blizzak LM 60, $275

#2 for dry/ice,

For the past couple of years I have drove on the 401/427/QEW highway about 300 km each day. The majority of the time the roads are clear, cold and dry. When they are covered in snow, the traffic is very slow.

I use Hankook tires and have had no problems at all. I keep them on steel rims so it makes switch-overs fairly simple and cost effective.

Snow tires will help you out a lot in vehicle control situations, but the most common thing I have witnessed in regards to winter accidents is aggresive drivers and people with bald tires.
 
The city puts down a half inch layer of salt for every inch of snow instead of removing it. Get yourself a winter beater that you don't mind getting all salted up.