Virgin Mobile unveiled two services yesterday: a pre-paid plan that charges 25 cents a minute for the first five minutes and 15 cents a minute after; and a $25 monthly "pass" billed automatically each month to a credit card that charges 20 cents a minute for the first five minutes and only 10 cents after.
Both plans include free voice mail, call display, call waiting and call forwarding, and in the case of the first plan, minutes don't expire for 120 days.
"It's a pretty good deal, but it's not outrageously low-priced," said Brian Sharwood, a telecom analyst with the Seaboard Group in Toronto.
Yigit had the same reaction. "It's better than other pay-as-you-go plans, but there's nothing earth-shattering here."
Investors, perhaps thinking Virgin Mobile would come out much stronger on pricing, appeared relieved.
Shares in wireless parent companies Rogers Communications, Telus Corp. and BCE Inc. rose in tandem yesterday after Virgin announced its pricing strategy.
"All the wireless stocks are up today because of Virgin," said Dvai Ghose, a telecom analyst with CIBC World Markets in Toronto.
Virgin, in addition to offering simple and reasonable pricing, could benefit by drawing attention to a pre-paid market that other companies have neglected in their attempt to lock consumers into long-term monthly contracts, said Sharwood.
Mark Langton, a spokesperson for Telus Mobility, said history has shown added competition can benefit consumers. "In such a situation, we consistently found that over-all wireless penetration went up."
Virgin's presence has already sparked a price war. Bell Mobility slashed its pre-paid pricing Feb. 18. Instead of charging 35 cents per minute, it now charges 30 cents per minute for the first two minutes and only 5 cents for each minute after.
Analysts considered Bell's move bizarre because of its partnership with Virgin, but Yigit said Bell likely wanted to cannibalize its own market before somebody else did.
John Boyton, vice-president of consumer marketing at Rogers Wireless, commended Virgin for being a good "PR machine" but was underwhelmed by the pricing. Boyton said Rogers will respond "within the next few weeks" to Virgin's offer.