will house prices ever go down?

enduser1 said:
Interestingly that would mean Tboy began investing at the bottom. The big drop was in 1991-1995. So if TBoy has been investing for 12 years it would be true to say he has never seen prices drop. He will learn the hard way that prices do drop, and hard.

Go ahead TBoy. I would suggest you load up on as much real estate as you can. You'll learn.

EU

I never stated that I had been investing for 12 yrs, I said interested....(in learning about it before making my first home purchase).

With that being said however if I ever come across sufficient funds to invest in something the first thing I will invest in is real estate. Yes, I will learn. Learn new ways to count my money and maybe even buy one of those bill counting machines.

Why can I say this? Because right now I know of 4 or 5 people who have investment properties that they are currently renting out. Which, btw, covers all their operating expenses and gives them some money in the bank at year end.

I also know a developer who was almost begging the purchasers to back out of their deals after a few construction delays. Why? Because the value of their purchases had increased by about 35%. Did it cost that much more to build? No......rates have been pretty much stable since the projects began. For eg: 1 unit is going for $100,000.00 more than when the project was first started 3 yrs ago.

So, you naysayers can say and think whatever you want. Bottom line IS the bottom line which is: Real Estate is a safe investment with a great ROI. Trillions of dollars are made every year by people investing in real estate and like I said before: I haven't heard of ONE person who lost money buying and selling homes. Maybe some didn't make as much as they thought, but they never lost.

GB: where was this property? Because I know of some properties west of the golden horseshoe that dropped when it was annouced a new landfill was going to be opened there.
 
21pro, Caledon East and all of Caledon btw has been dropping. That's because prices were driven very high in the last 2 years and now are coming back. The region of Caledon is very desirable because of the relatively low density and close proximity to GTA.

I still think house prices are going to go down soon because of manufacturing closures coupled with a slow down in the US. Also automotive manufacturing is hit hard. It doesn't show up in unemployment numbers as these skilled people usually find new jobs, but at lower wages.
 
Property Value in Ontario has not risen at the same level it has in the US, My friend bought a condo in Florida for 135k. last year similar units where selling for close to 700k, now that is unrealistic considering I bought a conda at king and Bathurst in 1998 for 108k and sold it last year for 185k. look at the difference in appreciation. even though the market seems high Toronto has nor reached international standars when it comes to values.
 
MYSITEONLY said:
Property Value in Ontario has not risen at the same level it has in the US, My friend bought a condo in Florida for 135k. last year similar units where selling for close to 700k, now that is unrealistic considering I bought a conda at king and Bathurst in 1998 for 108k and sold it last year for 185k. look at the difference in appreciation. even though the market seems high Toronto has nor reached international standars when it comes to values.
A good friend of mine bought a an ex-crack house in parkdale just north of queen in 2003, for $205,000 did $15000 in renovations and just sold it for $575,000. Not a bad profit. Im kicking myself for not buying in parkdale a few years ago...
 
excellent discussion everyone!

keep it up.

though keep in mind the topic...
will house prices ever go down?
 
People have been looking for a real estate "correction" since about 2000.

The last big correction was 91 through 94, with prices leveling out in 95 and starting to increase in 96 and they have never stopped increasing.

That said, the prices do seem to be leveling off somewhat. I have also noticed that houses don't seem to sell as quickly as they once were. Though sales traditionally pick up in the spring.

The one major thing that affects housing prices is interest rates. The Bank of Canada had been raising interest rates starting about 2 years ago, however, they had to stop because the dollar was rising too much and hurting manufacturing by doing so. There was a press release today by the bank of Canada which basically ruled out any interest rate cuts in the near future. The result was that the loonie took off. If they were to raise the interest rates, manufacturing would get clobbered.

Since it doesn't appear that the dollar is going to retreat substantially enough (it has risen due to high commodity prices, a good economy, a balanced budget, stability, etc) that means that the Bank of Canada is not in a position at the current time to raise interest rates.

IMHO, it would take a 2 point interest rate spike up to affect the real estate market. 4% would positively throw a bucket of water on it.

In order for interest rates to rise by 4%, you'd need a retreat of the loonie to the 70 cent, or 65 cent level.

What could cause that?

Answer - a major cooling of the commodity sector.

How would that occur?

Answer - China cools off and takes the US with it.

Could that happen?

You bet your sweet ass it could.

Problem:

If China cools off, the dollar drops, interest rates rise substantially, real estate prices are cut by half.

IF real estate gets clobbered, so too does everything else and welcome back 15% unemployment.

No-one wants that.
 
Well James T, that may all be true but historically the way to boost real estate sales is to raise interest rates. What happens is people who have been sitting on the fence make the decision to buy now and lock in at the lower rate before the rates make a mortgage out of their league.
 
An interesting thought however.

When I bought my place in 97, it was roughly 5 times my 97 salary.

It is now 7 times my 2007 salary, but I have 10 years more experience behind me.

A guy who is 10 years younger than me (i.e. the same age I was when I bought my place) doing my same job I was back then might be making 10 or 15 grand a year more than I was 10 years ago.

This place is now 12 times his current salary.

So, in 97, it was 5 times my salary. A similar guy to what I was back then is looking at 12 times his salary.

That's amazing....

and scary.
 
and this is why you see an increase in both defaults and early stage foreclosures.

mind you, not to mention 3 families living in one house... lol..
 
tboy said:
Well James T, that may all be true but historically the way to boost real estate sales is to raise interest rates. What happens is people who have been sitting on the fence make the decision to buy now and lock in at the lower rate before the rates make a mortgage out of their league.

The problem is the renewals. When that happens, and they are always happening, you are dead if you are leveraged to the hilt.

What makes it a vicious circle is if the prices drop substantially, your bank will not renew your mortgage for what you owe if what you owe is less than the current value of your house.

For example, if you buy a house worth 500k and you have 5% down, that means you have a mortgage for 475.

If the interest rates go up even 2 points, you now have to pay almost 10 grand a year MORE in just interest. That's like 800 bucks a month, ON TOP of what you were paying.

Now comes the double edge of the sword....

Say the worth of the house drops to 400 k, i.e. 75 less than you owe. The bank will not renew your mortgage for more than the property is worth. They are going to tell you that YOU have to come up with another 75 cash and even then, they are scared.

The result is that you are out on the street.
 
House prices will go down when we have the same conditions as what occured in 1990-1991:
-Interest rates that peaked at around 14%
-a growing government deficit (which was helping cause the high interest rates and higher unemployment due to budget cuts)
-The two things above caused:
-the stock market to drop
-caused lots of unemployment

Also, back then builders would build new houses before being sold. There was a glut of housing in 1990. Today, the new house gets sold before they even dig the foundation.

As well, tighter rent controls brought in by the NDP in Ontario (and later undone by the Conservatives) helped kill demand even more by scaring away buyers of properties for investment purposes.

I'd say that high interest rates is the single biggest thing that would kill housing prices. But high interest rates won't happen as long as the Canadian government keeps running a surplus and continues to pay down debt (the most recent budget includes a 10 billion dollar reduction in our national debt).

I'm speaking as a home owner, son of a landlord (who helped with the whole property rental thing), stock investor and someone who remembers the 1982 recession, 1987 stock market crash, the 1990-1991 recession and the 1997-1998 "Asian Flu" financial crisis.

Going by what happened in the early to mid 1990s, if there is a correction, the high end stuff takes the biggest hit in absolute dollar terms. And when things recover, activity starts at the lower end first.

But it comes down to needs vs wants. If you need a bigger place, then get one - especially if you can afford it and you plan on staying there for 10+ years. The longer you plan on staying, the less short term price fluctuations matter.

While rising interest rates can cause more real estate purchases to happen, it's only sustainable for a short period until people can't afford to pay the interest... the proof is to just look at what happened in the late 1980s, which led to the decline that started in 1990-1991.
 
james t kirk said:
An interesting thought however.

When I bought my place in 97, it was roughly 5 times my 97 salary.

It is now 7 times my 2007 salary, but I have 10 years more experience behind me.......
That's amazing....

and scary.

I had this same conversation with an ex gf of mine when comparing the situation for her father and what it was like when I was seeing her (it was '88 and she was asking why I didn't have a house instead of renting).

The problem with real estate and why eventually one has to bite the bullet and jump in is that property values grow exponentially faster than salaries. The ONLY way one can keep up is with great leaps in position so your salary doesn't just increase at the COL.
 
ILOVETHIS said:
will house prices ever go down?
Will prices ever go down or crash? Any opinions>
I hope not I just bought a house this week. Moving in May.
 
I currently own 12 rental properties. I paid 20% down on all. Some have several units... Anyway, In about 8more years they'll all be paid for in full by the renters and I'll be a VERY happy camper. Though I'll probably own more properties by then. When I retire, I'll still have an income. If i want a ferrari, I can just sell/mortgage a property. When I pass away, My children will have a substantial monthly income that requires little work to maintain.... Owning property is the way to go.
 
Master_Bates said:
My children will have a substantial monthly income that requires little work to maintain.... Owning property is the way to go.
That's what my Landlord says, but he is wrong. In the mean time, until I move to my new house, I live in a rental dump that needs more repairs than you can name. Houses need upkeep. Things break every season. Make sure your kids know that before they get in too deep and run up against a tribunal that makes them pay for repairs or refund rent.
 
WhaWhaWha said:
That's what my Landlord says, but he is wrong. In the mean time, until I move to my new house, I live in a rental dump that needs more repairs than you can name. Houses need upkeep. Things break every season. Make sure your kids know that before they get in too deep and run up against a tribunal that makes them pay for repairs or refund rent.

While that is true and every property needs upkeep I too know 4 or 5 people that own multiple rental properties and even with the rental situation in toronto they are still turning a small profit per year after all expenses.

The trick to owning rental properties IMHO is to find good tenants that a) don't abuse the place and b) pay on time and when you find them, a good landlord will properly maintain the property to keep those tenants.

As for passing the properties onto children or spouses, I knew someone in Quebec City who died and left his wife everything. After all expenses, and paying someone to maintain his properties, the wife ended up with an income of $30,000.00 a MONTH. I was flabbergasted when I heard that.....(btw, I later found out that wasn't just from the rental properties he had other investments but still....)
 
zekestone said:
House prices will go down when we have the same conditions as what occured in 1990-1991:
-Interest rates that peaked at around 14%
-a growing government deficit (which was helping cause the high interest rates and higher unemployment due to budget cuts)
-The two things above caused:
-the stock market to drop
-caused lots of unemployment

Also, back then builders would build new houses before being sold. There was a glut of housing in 1990. Today, the new house gets sold before they even dig the foundation.

As well, tighter rent controls brought in by the NDP in Ontario (and later undone by the Conservatives) helped kill demand even more by scaring away buyers of properties for investment purposes.

I'd say that high interest rates is the single biggest thing that would kill housing prices. But high interest rates won't happen as long as the Canadian government keeps running a surplus and continues to pay down debt (the most recent budget includes a 10 billion dollar reduction in our national debt).

I'm speaking as a home owner, son of a landlord (who helped with the whole property rental thing), stock investor and someone who remembers the 1982 recession, 1987 stock market crash, the 1990-1991 recession and the 1997-1998 "Asian Flu" financial crisis.

Going by what happened in the early to mid 1990s, if there is a correction, the high end stuff takes the biggest hit in absolute dollar terms. And when things recover, activity starts at the lower end first.

But it comes down to needs vs wants. If you need a bigger place, then get one - especially if you can afford it and you plan on staying there for 10+ years. The longer you plan on staying, the less short term price fluctuations matter.

While rising interest rates can cause more real estate purchases to happen, it's only sustainable for a short period until people can't afford to pay the interest... the proof is to just look at what happened in the late 1980s, which led to the decline that started in 1990-1991.

Yeah but the way in which markets overshoot are always different each time; people are always looking for patterns from the immediate past to repeat, which takes them away from other factors that are the real source of future trouble.....that's just human nature.

I think rising unemployment and poor real income growth is going to cap the rise in real estate prices......the U.S.A is slowing down, that's the fundamental reason for the stock market's recent volatility. We're moving into an era of slowing profit growth.
 
Master_Bates said:
I currently own 12 rental properties. I paid 20% down on all. Some have several units... Anyway, In about 8more years they'll all be paid for in full by the renters and I'll be a VERY happy camper. Though I'll probably own more properties by then. When I retire, I'll still have an income. If i want a ferrari, I can just sell/mortgage a property. When I pass away, My children will have a substantial monthly income that requires little work to maintain.... Owning property is the way to go.

Totally agree with you...it is the way to go. Just curious though. Do you own your rental properties thru a company structure or personally? I have been debating on putting rental properties into a corporate structure versus holding them personally but not sure of the advantages of this.
How do you do it and why did you chose to work it that way?
Cheers,
S
 
james t kirk said:
People have been looking for a real estate "correction" since about 2000.

The last big correction was 91 through 94, with prices leveling out in 95 and starting to increase in 96 and they have never stopped increasing.

That said, the prices do seem to be leveling off somewhat. I have also noticed that houses don't seem to sell as quickly as they once were. Though sales traditionally pick up in the spring.

The one major thing that affects housing prices is interest rates. The Bank of Canada had been raising interest rates starting about 2 years ago, however, they had to stop because the dollar was rising too much and hurting manufacturing by doing so. There was a press release today by the bank of Canada which basically ruled out any interest rate cuts in the near future. The result was that the loonie took off. If they were to raise the interest rates, manufacturing would get clobbered.

Since it doesn't appear that the dollar is going to retreat substantially enough (it has risen due to high commodity prices, a good economy, a balanced budget, stability, etc) that means that the Bank of Canada is not in a position at the current time to raise interest rates.

IMHO, it would take a 2 point interest rate spike up to affect the real estate market. 4% would positively throw a bucket of water on it.

In order for interest rates to rise by 4%, you'd need a retreat of the loonie to the 70 cent, or 65 cent level.

What could cause that?

Answer - a major cooling of the commodity sector.

How would that occur?

Answer - China cools off and takes the US with it.

Could that happen?

You bet your sweet ass it could.

Problem:

If China cools off, the dollar drops, interest rates rise substantially, real estate prices are cut by half.

IF real estate gets clobbered, so too does everything else and welcome back 15% unemployment.

No-one wants that.
If China cools off and takes the US with it no one can predict what's going to happen. The global economy will be in a tailspin. But, before that happens there will be a fight for resources.