will house prices ever go down?

ILOVETHIS

Member
Jun 12, 2006
452
2
18
I'm considering buying a house but I feel like I'm buying at the high end. I live in southern ontario. Will prices ever go down or crash? Any opinions>
 
Some of the bidding going on is crazy. On the CTV news last week they were showing some houses selling for over $100,000 more than it was listed.:eek:
 
Caledon East
a house that i put an offer in for $590k and was looking at purchasing about 6 months ago was asking $689k when i looked at it, dropped to $679, $659, $629... and just sold last week for $605k... (they laughed at my 'lowball' offer 6mths ago, but, i think i helped lower their expectations for another hopefully happy buyer) *the $689 probably wasn't too unrealistic as that was the CMA for that street over the last 18 months.

but, many people are reporting prices going up... (given the contradictory evidence out there, i would say that the real estate market is unstable because of the volatility... much like Nortel's 2-5% daily swings when it was priced above $120 back in '00/'01)

i have since changed my mind and decided to rent for the next 5-7 years.

i rent a 3 bedroom acreage property valued at about $650k and i pay $1800/mth without sharing the house or property with anyone. considering the mortgage payments would easily be about $3200/mth with 20% down and adding on $490/mth in taxes, I consider renting to be a deal.

keep in mind Mayhem and greed always prequels a crash in any market...

and corrections always come before the professionals see it coming.
 
Last edited:
Yup the bubble will have to burst at some point there's going to be a breaking point when there aren't enough people who can afford the prices that people are asking out there. I was killing time at a bank recently and was reading some of the real estate postings and could see that a 2 bdrm townhouse in the downtown area is 1.5 x more expensive than say richmond hill. The difference in free standing homes is even more staggering. When you get into a difference that is a 6 digit number you really have to stop and think about what is important..... not to mention if you had to pay the interest on a mortgage where the difference in principals is over 100 K.
 
Buying property is NEVER a bad idea.... you may purchase a house now for 500k.. have it drop to 450k next year.... but in 20 years it will have risen significantly. How many houses have decreased in value over the last 20 years?

21pro... you also need to consider that if you had put 3200/month for mortgage into a property, you would be able to recoup most if not all or more when you decide to sell and move.... but now you're just throwing away 1800/month. Do you think the owner of the house is losing $1400/month by renting it to you?
 
21pro said:
Caledon East
a house that i put an offer in for $590k and was looking at purchasing about 6 months ago was asking $689k when i looked at it, dropped to $679, $659, $629... and just sold last week for $605k... (they laughed at my 'lowball' offer 6mths ago, but, i think i helped lower their expectations for another hopefully happy buyer)

but, many people are reporting prices going up... (given the contradictory evidence out there, i would say that the real estate market is unstable because of the volatility... much like Nortel's 2-5% daily swings when it was priced above $120 back in '00/'01)

i have since changed my mind and decided to rent for the next 5-7 years.

i rent a 3 bedroom acreage property valued at about $650k and i pay $1800/mth without sharing the house or property with anyone. considering the mortgage payments would easily be about $3200/mth with 20% down and adding on $490/mth in taxes, I consider renting to be a deal.

keep in mind Mayhem and greed always prequels a crash in any market...

and corrections always come before the professionals see it coming.

Dude, I generally agree with you but you're kidding yourself and if that works for you, great!

The flaw in your logic occurs when you say it is cheaper to rent than own. Sure it is cheaper to rent the property you're currently living in, but could you afford your own property at $1800.00 a month? Hell ya....

What you're missing is the fact that the $21,600.00 annually you're paying in rent is gone....never to be seen again. If you had moved into a smaller property and put that towards it, you would come out ahead..in spades when you sold.

As for your example of the property you put an offer in on: that isn't an example of property values dropping, that's an example of a property that was overpriced to begin with. For property values to actually go down, the same property has to be purchased at say $600,000.00 then sold at $590,000.00. Just because it didn't sell at the listed price just indicates that it was overpriced.

Since I began being interested in purchasing property I have NEVER seen prices drop. EVER. The ONLY reason prices drop is a devaluation of a particular property or area due to factors like an airport being built, them finding contaminated soil, opening up a landfill nearby or something similar.

Even condominiums while not realizing the same increase as single family dwellings have historically always appreciated in value. Even if not to the same degree.

Talk to any professional investment councellor and they will tell you the most stable investment is property because like the saying goes: god aint making any more of it.....

Again, with the condo example given that isn't an indicator of prices dropping, that is an individual seller asking too much for their property.

I will give you my example: I bought a loft in 1998 for $75,000.00 including 1 parking spot worth $5,000.00 at the time. My loft was appraised at $249,000.00 2 yrs ago and I found out last week the parking spots are selling for $18,000.00 (and being bought at that price).
 
try buying the same said house and selling it 1 year later for 6% appreciation... less 6% sales commission and less the cost of property taxes, and interest accrued on a 6.1% mortgage over that one year. (and those are just the significant costs)

anyway you slice it... you lose money.

i've been buying and selling real estate for 12 years now. right now, i don't have any real estate on my books... that was planned. i do know what i am talking about.

without going into too much detail, my logic works because i save and invest the difference of what it would cost to own the current house i rent. i am able to put into a stock portfolio the $2200 + my undisclosed normal savings goal away each and every month... if i get even a 7% ror on my money, i'm doing better by renting. in fact, in 7-10 years i'll be able to buy the house i live in for full market value for cash. whereas the average GTA homeowner would have borrowed more money out on their house atleast once by then... i'd only have a mortgage if i wanted one. ie, for the Smith Manoeuvre

but, i don't blame all you real estate lovers. some just feel more comfortable investing in something they can 'touch' (this is terb, right..lol..)
for me, if it isn't saving me money and helping me maximize my returns- i'll quickly clear it from my portfolio. the key being MAXIMIZE- real estate does not do that. and i do remember people praising another asset as the greatest to be had at one time, too. Nortel at $124... real estate is alittle different than stocks, but it can be easier to predict when the top is near, or had passed. look for a time when mortgage brokers advertise the benefits of refinancing or consolidating loans... if a mortgage company advertises on the radio or tv- that, too is a danger sign. if your bank has put a hold on your ABM deposits for no reason, that is a BIG RED FLAG that people aren't making their mortgage payments.... look for the warning signs.

and it's not to say that money can't be made in real estate... loads of it can be made... my realtor has no problem making his $400k/year on commissions, so the market is definitely still active.
tboy said:
As for your example of the property you put an offer in on: that isn't an example of property values dropping, that's an example of a property that was overpriced to begin with. For property values to actually go down, the same property has to be purchased at say $600,000.00 then sold at $590,000.00. Just because it didn't sell at the listed price just indicates that it was overpriced.
*the $689 probably wasn't too unrealistic as that was the CMA for that street over the last 18 months. if the price fell within the rescent CMA's for the area (comparable properties) than it wasn't really overpriced. the market corrected. caledon east is a very desirable neighbourhood, but even now you are starting to see price drops and houses staying on the market for easily over 150 days.

i welcome the price drops and may buy back in sooner than i plan, but not now... i'm not looking to catch a falling knife.
 
21pro knows his stuff. people need to seperate principal and interest and add in ALL expenses when looking at real estate as an investment. Real estate commissions, lawyers fees, property taxes, interest, maintenance...all of these add up to alot of money and will quickly outweigh lower rates of appreciation.
 
Who the hell pays 6%? You should be able to get 4% with one agent doing both sides of the deal. Also, if you're dealing with real estate as an investment, you're playing with money you already have, right? So, no interest. Oh, and if you're that serious about it, you don't NEED an agent.

Yes, *I* needed one when I sold my condo and bought a house, but tell me you couldn't do what the average housewife does and figure out the paperwork involved in selling or buying property...

You're out taxes and maintenance... though if you buy and hold a property you can rent it out - a whole new set of headaches and risks, but you aren't losing sales commission all the time and rental income even covers a mortgage so it can be a zero-cost money move.

The real problem is people playing in real estate with the bank's money. If you can scratch together enough to play with your OWN money, you're golden.
 
alienencounters said:
As one friend of mine keeps saying: You can't make money on a house you live in.
Where I live (Niagara Region) I bought my house 12 years ago paid 140 for it.
It was recently valued at 300. But to find another property like it I'd have to pay......300. net gain? a loss of 40,000 after expenses?

Investments in houses are long term and I mean long. Sell it for retirement funds. I have a 100% gain in mine, also and expect a 150% return for retirement.
 
21pro said:
try buying the same said house and selling it 1 year later for 6% appreciation... less 6% sales commission and less the cost of property taxes, and interest accrued on a 6.1% mortgage over that one year. (and those are just the significant costs)

anyway you slice it... you lose money.

i've been buying and selling real estate for 12 years now. right now, i don't have any real estate on my books... that was planned. i do know what i am talking about.

without going into too much detail, my logic works because i save and invest the difference of what it would cost to own the current house i rent. i am able to put into a stock portfolio the $2200 + my undisclosed normal savings goal away each and every month... if i get even a 7% ror on my money, i'm doing better by renting. in fact, in 7-10 years i'll be able to buy the house i live in for full market value for cash. whereas the average GTA homeowner would have borrowed more money out on their house atleast once by then... i'd only have a mortgage if i wanted one. ie, for the Smith Manoeuvre

but, i don't blame all you real estate lovers. some just feel more comfortable investing in something they can 'touch' (this is terb, right..lol..)
for me, if it isn't saving me money and helping me maximize my returns- i'll quickly clear it from my portfolio. the key being MAXIMIZE- real estate does not do that. and i do remember people praising another asset as the greatest to be had at one time, too. Nortel at $124... real estate is alittle different than stocks, but it can be easier to predict when the top is near, or had passed. look for a time when mortgage brokers advertise the benefits of refinancing or consolidating loans... if a mortgage company advertises on the radio or tv- that, too is a danger sign. if your bank has put a hold on your ABM deposits for no reason, that is a BIG RED FLAG that people aren't making their mortgage payments.... look for the warning signs.

and it's not to say that money can't be made in real estate... loads of it can be made... my realtor has no problem making his $400k/year on commissions, so the market is definitely still active.

*the $689 probably wasn't too unrealistic as that was the CMA for that street over the last 18 months. if the price fell within the rescent CMA's for the area (comparable properties) than it wasn't really overpriced. the market corrected. caledon east is a very desirable neighbourhood, but even now you are starting to see price drops and houses staying on the market for easily over 150 days.

i welcome the price drops and may buy back in sooner than i plan, but not now... i'm not looking to catch a falling knife.


Your theory only works because you have found an idiot who wants to rent a house that is worth 650,000 for only 1,800.00 a month. Either that or you live in the middle of nowhere. A friend of mine is renting his 400,000 condo for 2,400.00 a month. A nice home worth 650K in a decent neighborhood should at least bring 2600-2700 in rent very easily. Also, why would you base your theory on only one year where the 6% commission (waaay too high) conveniently, for your theory takes away the 6% appreciation if your plan is not to buy for 5-7 years. Put in some realistic rent costs and hold the house for 5 years and see how much sense it makes to rent.
 
Sargeant StiffCock said:
Your theory only works because you have found an idiot who wants to rent a house that is worth 650,000 for only 1,800.00 a month. Either that or you live in the middle of nowhere. A friend of mine is renting his 400,000 condo for 2,400.00 a month. A nice home worth 650K in a decent neighborhood should at least bring 2600-2700 in rent very easily. Also, why would you base your theory on only one year where the 6% commission (waaay too high) conveniently, for your theory takes away the 6% appreciation if your plan is not to buy for 5-7 years. Put in some realistic rent costs and hold the house for 5 years and see how much sense it makes to rent.

Sarge, that was the point I was trying to make. The days of flipping houses before you even take possession are almost gone. I knew people in '89 who put $2,000.00 on 3 or more houses "yet to be built" then sold them back to the builder after 3 months realizing a $20,000.00 profit on each. This happened because prices were rising exponentially. It was crazy at that time, starting houses before the boom were going for $79K and by the end they were in the upper end of $100 - 200 K.

As for his renting situation, I know of NO one who is renting anything for less than market value. As you stated, the owner of his property must be an idiot to be renting that property that cheap.

As for comparing real estate to the stock market examples is just silly. Sure you can tout examples like Bre-X, World Com and Enron all you want but please give some examples of someone who had to sell their house and lost on it. (and no examples of divources etc because that is an extenuating circumstance).
 
Why r u wishing that prices of houses in Ontario to go down, because housing & estate is the one and only item available in Canada on whom you get an appreciation annually from 3%~10% or more depending on your location, city, & damand of that place, or else in whatever you invest for your future goes down the drain. Over 75% of small businesses die within the first 12-months, things are pretty despresing, & some of my friends have opted out of this contry due to such reasons, going to oil rich countries to earn their tax-free bread/butter & bacon too. Heavy /Double taxes are killing the middle class in Canada.
 
tboy said:
Since I began being interested in purchasing property I have NEVER seen prices drop. EVER. The ONLY reason prices drop is a devaluation of a particular property or area due to factors like an airport being built, them finding contaminated soil, opening up a landfill nearby or something similar.

Even condominiums while not realizing the same increase as single family dwellings have historically always appreciated in value. Even if not to the same degree.

Talk to any professional investment councellor and they will tell you the most stable investment is property because like the saying goes: god aint making any more of it.....
There was a time when the average home in the GTA was around $280k.
This average went down to less than $200k.
It took a hell of a long time for the average to get back.
The rise in prices in recent years is unsustainable and due for some sort of correction.

I don't think it will be anything like the crash coming to the US their crash will affect us all.
 
There will be a correction. I monitor MLS in the York Region and I'm seeing speculators that are trying to flip houses. There's a good chance they'll get burned. We're starting to reach an over supply situation.

I agree with many of the posters above. You can never loose on realestate if you plan to keep it for a while. I'm on my 7th house.

BTW:- Master Bates, I know your sister, Miss Deal!
 
Malibook said:
There was a time when the average home in the GTA was around $280k.
This average went down to less than $200k.
It took a hell of a long time for the average to get back.
The rise in prices in recent years is unsustainable and due for some sort of correction.

I don't think it will be anything like the crash coming to the US their crash will affect us all.

When was this? I haven't seen the average price in toronto at $200,000.00 since before 1988......

Just one more thing: an average price basically tells you squat. For example, if you build a home for $1,000,000.00 then another home is built for $35,000.00 the average is $517,000.00. Is this a true indicator of property values? ....no.....because someone built a one room shack on a garage property does not an average make....statistics and averages can be manipulated to predict whatever outcome you want it to be by adding or removing variables.

best realestate advice I ever heard was: buy the cheapest property, in the best neighbourhood. (my situation is a perfect example of this because the larger units in my building haven't increased in price by a factor of 3).
 
Guy7 said:
Over 75% of small businesses die within the first 12-months, things are pretty despresing, & some of my friends have opted out of this contry due to such reasons, going to oil rich countries to earn their tax-free bread/butter & bacon too. Heavy /Double taxes are killing the middle class in Canada.

All I can say is, those friends of yours are the lucky ones in a way. Not too many folks are able to to relocate to foreign land and start from scratch, or for all sorts of other reasons.

Anyway, back to original programming.
 
Yours truly purchased a 100 acre piece of land in 1999 for $141K. It had been prievously purchased for $400K in 1991. Prices go up and prices go down.
 
tboy said:
Since I began being interested in purchasing property I have NEVER seen prices drop. EVER.

I will give you my example: I bought a loft in 1998 for $75,000.00 including 1 parking spot worth $5,000.00 at the time. My loft was appraised at $249,000.00 2 yrs ago and I found out last week the parking spots are selling for $18,000.00 (and being bought at that price).


prices do drop, but the overall trend is up. the last real correction in the gta was in 1996-97.
 
the cdn market is different than the us- there really isn't alot of subprime debt and interest only mortgages which drove prices in the US. though I think each market within cda has to be viewed differently- even within the gta