Eight Face Charges in Child Abuse Investigation
UPDATED: Monday, March 21, 2011 --- 9:20 p.m.
Eight members of a Black Earth Church face child abuse charges tonight.
They're in trouble for the type of punishment investigators say a church leader encouraged.
There is no argument about whether these things happened, those charged admit as much to investigators. They say they believe they're doing what the bible tells them to.
The basement of a Black Earth home, one of two locations for the Aleitheia Bible Church, is where Dane County investigators say child abuse not only occurred but was encouraged over and over.
Philip Caminiti, the church's head pastor, made his first court appearance Monday facing 8 counts of child abuse.
According to a criminal complaint Caminiti told detectives he believes the bible dictates the use of a rod over hand to punish children. The complaint says Caminiti shows church members how to use wooden spoons and dowels to hit the bare bottoms of misbehaving children as young as 2 months old.
Church members say children and infants were punished for things such as being emotional, grumpy or crying, not sitting quietly through church, crying when being handed from a mother to another person or for potty training mistakes.
Dane County Sheriff's Office Spokesperson Elise Schaffer says, "I think any time children are involved in this kind of case it's difficult for everyone."
Philip Caminiti is one of 8 church members facing child abuse charges including his brother John Caminiti.
John also faces charges of mental harm to a child.
He told investigators he often shunned his wife and children, sometimes telling them they must stay in their room for weeks at a time.
We stopped at Phil Caminiti's house hoping to do an interview and get their side of the story. We were told by the woman who answered the door they've been told they can't talk to us for legal reasons.
But in interviews with investigators many members of the church did talk.
In a criminal complaint Phil is quoted as saying "the scripture is never wrong" and "pain is a good way to teach children."
The complaint says he also told them "if you spank early and it is done right then kids will be obedient", adding he didn't think bruises were telltale signs of something bad.
All of the victims' parents described redness and bruises as common effects of the spankings.
Schaffer says, "The church beliefs really don't play into account here. We're strictly looking at it from a legal perspective."
The victims in this case include a total of twelve children, ranging in age from infants to six years old.
The investigation began last year when former members of the church contacted authorities.
http://www.nbc15.com/home/headlines...d_Abuse_Investigation.html?storySection=story