Why I Am An Atheist

God sure does get his name mentioned a lot on a hooker board. What's up with that?
 
Off his meds

Not quite what you said, but hey. You don't believe in deity, but you also don't believe in some of RLDs 'authorities'? As if your better informed than so many of them. Just say you're an agnostic and keep it simple. Just like your wishy washy stance on extra terrestrial life; not say there is, but not saying there isn't. You wanted absolute certainty before you stuck your toe in the pond.

Stop being such a Mae West.

Were the hell do you get your shit from..........I never said I don't "believe" in some of RLDs 'authorities', .........I said he claimed he was an authority ......just because he read some books about some one elses "opinions".

AND..........were did I make a comment on "extra terrestrial life".

I AM NOT agnostic........THAT is a label for you and rld,....... talk about being wishy washy.

AND...........you still haven't answered my question !!!!!

OK..........I'm going to help you out ........again...............If a person doesn't believe in the tooth fairy...........what label would asign to that person ?

FAST
 
Were the hell do you get your shit from..........I never said I don't "believe" in some of RLDs 'authorities', .........I said he claimed he was an authority ......just because he read some books about some one elses "opinions".

AND..........were did I make a comment on "extra terrestrial life".

I AM NOT agnostic........THAT is a label for you and rld,....... talk about being wishy washy.

AND...........you still haven't answered my question !!!!!

OK..........I'm going to help you out ........again...............If a person doesn't believe in the tooth fairy...........what label would asign to that person ?

FAST

A grown up.
 
A little self conscious are we.

And..........if you are talking about me, as I have said ...........I am NOT an atheist, I just don't "believe" in myths perpetuated by your so called "authority".



What a bunch of BULL SHIT rld..........how the hell do you know how "science moves forward", are you a scientist,.......oh wait I know ............you read a book by some other self proclaimed "expert".

And .........."some people think that"..........just who ARE these "some people"

FAST

Were the hell do you get your shit from..........I never said I don't "believe" in some of RLDs 'authorities', .........I said he claimed he was an authority ......just because he read some books about some one elses "opinions".

AND..........were did I make a comment on "extra terrestrial life".

I AM NOT agnostic........THAT is a label for you and rld,....... talk about being wishy washy.

AND...........you still haven't answered my question !!!!!

OK..........I'm going to help you out ........again...............If a person doesn't believe in the tooth fairy...........what label would asign to that person ?

FAST

Your words; I'm not an atheist . I'm not an agnostic. hmmmm.
 
Blinders

Your words; I'm not an atheist . I'm not an agnostic. hmmmm.

YEP............that's what I said.

Do you have a problem with that??

Try to help you again...........what label would you use for some one who doesn't believe there are aliens ?

FAST
 
Were the hell do you get your shit from..........I never said I don't "believe" in some of RLDs 'authorities', .........I said he claimed he was an authority ......just because he read some books about some one elses "opinions".

AND..........were did I make a comment on "extra terrestrial life".

I AM NOT agnostic........THAT is a label for you and rld,....... talk about being wishy washy.

AND...........you still haven't answered my question !!!!!

OK..........I'm going to help you out ........again...............If a person doesn't believe in the tooth fairy...........what label would asign to that person ?

FAST

tooth fairy skeptic
 
You are missing the point of religion. Religion is based on faith which is the absence of empirical evidence. It is believing the face of what may appear to be insurmountable contrary evidence. People of religion generally also believe that they cannot necessarily comprehend their god's plan and so when someone say why do bad things happen to good people although we may not understand why the faithful believe that it is nonetheless part of gods bigger plan.
That sounds to me like a life lived in willful ignorance.
 
How about non-overlapping magisterium and the fact that science cannot teach us how to live or what to value?
An interesting point. Do you believe we would be better off without science or without religion? Perhaps the benefits that science has provided have improved our lives more than the benefits of religion.
 
In my opinion …..you are WRONG...... religion only changes when it is forced to.........a good example.........the RCC "attempting" to change its stance on contraceptives.

THAT IS HOW YOU REPLY


I HAVE NOT MADE ANY PRIOR STATEMENTS OF MY OPINION OR OTHER WISE ON THIS SUBJECT.

But you are making profound statements, not opinions, ..........example..........

That’s NOT your opinion..........your making a statement about something you have absolutely no back ground to make.
If you feel that some one can read a book or two about some one elses opinions .........you have suddenly become an authority in that subject ....BULL SHIT.

FAST

I have virtually quoted verbatim from some of the best authors in the field. I even told you where the ideas come from.

All things change when they are forced to change. People did not abandon Newtonian physics until forced to.

It doesn't seem you actually have a counter point to make, or a different idea about how science progresses or how people think about science, you just like to rant and shout, to no end.

And if I have read, less than 10 books on the subject, I think you have read none. So what qualifies you to object? Do you think Gould is wrong on his analysis on how science moves forward.

Can we every expect any substance or analysis from you...or just more childish complaints?
 
An interesting point. Do you believe we would be better off without science or without religion? Perhaps the benefits that science has provided have improved our lives more than the benefits of religion.

I think we are better off with both. I think the loss of either would be a significant set back to human progress.

If forced to chose between one or the other for mankind? Wow, that is a very tough call. I am honestly not sure. Do you have a thought on that?

Great question.
 
Were the hell do you get your shit from..........I never said I don't "believe" in some of RLDs 'authorities', .........I said he claimed he was an authority ......just because he read some books about some one elses "opinions".

FAST

I have never claimed to be an authority, but I am well read in the subject. Gould and most modern historians of science have formulated the approach that is roughly in accord with the long quote in post 180. Y

On the other hand, you have offered nothing on the subject, except whining.

If you think someone's critique of the approach is great, why not share it.

I don't have to be able to do the experiments to repeat the norms of a field. I don't have to be able to do the math or experiments that prove e=mc2, to be pretty sure it is true. It is kind of in the basic nature of non-expert conversations, like this one.
 
can the amazing depths of love, emotion, wisdom, creativity and the living essence all be just accidental byproducts of the chemical coincidence that formed the universe with no intelligent design? Dream on, gentlemen. We are just the science project of an intergalactic space child ( or a million other possibilities).
Could RLD's angry personna ever allow him to contemplate those possibilities without unleashing a barrage of arrogant , foul-spirited bafflegab??? I await your insults....
 
can the amazing depths of love, emotion, wisdom, creativity and the living essence all be just accidental byproducts of the chemical coincidence that formed the universe with no intelligent design? Dream on, gentlemen. We are just the science project of an intergalactic space child ( or a million other possibilities).
Could RLD's angry personna ever allow him to contemplate those possibilities without unleashing a barrage of arrogant , foul-spirited bafflegab??? I await your insults....

Considering these atomic, sub atomic, and biochemical interactions occurred a few million time a second (just a guess, but it's quite a number) and they've been doing this for over ~14 billion years, it's quite possible.
 
Sam is famous for picking the radicals and not recognizing religious views that are harder to deal with. Like for instance the Catholic position that muslims, or jews, etc can all be saved even if they do not convert.

It is like arguing with the Immanuel Velikovsky about physics.

The funniest thing is that I have been reading a lot about evolution lately, and if you were to substitute followers of Gould, Wilson and Dawkins, or gradualists and catastrophists, or gene-operation vs. individual operational vs. group selectionists for the various religions in his argument you would get the same result.

Let's use a quick example:





It works perfectly. They all work from the same fossil record, the same genetic data, the same basic theory, but come to very different conclusions based on their beliefs and analysis. Now many people are lazy about their religious beliefs, but so are atheists, many of whom I know don't understand science well at all.

The Harris approach is just kind of "let's pick the least prepared Christian ideas we can find and fight with them. Then we'll pretend all Christians are like that."

It is really a little sad.

The scenarios you compare are really very different. I think Harris is right in that the only version of Christianity that one has to concern oneself with is the version he refers to. Because the more liberal Christians make no particular claims about one's eternal destiny...generally. Probably similar with moderate or liberal Muslims.

To compare it to a scientific debate is disingenuous. People in the scientific debate will continue to look for evidence to determine which theory is correct. Evidence seeking is totally lacking in fundamentalist religion. Everything possible is done to not look at evidence.
 
Delusional

I have never claimed to be an authority, but I am well read in the subject.

I don't have to be able to do the experiments to repeat the norms of a field. I don't have to be able to do the math or experiments that prove e=mc2, to be pretty sure it is true.

OK............I'm going to kill two birds with one stone......

rld said:
You clearly do not understand the meaning or proper use of the term delusional.

But your position is an excellent example of how modern atheists are arrogant and wish to promote themselves as superior to others. And often don't know what the are talking about.You clearly do not understand the meaning or proper use of the term delusional.

rld............making some of his many grand proclamations.............. BECAUSE....I GUESS.... HE MUST BE WELL READ IN THE SUBJECT.

blackrock............can you FINALLY fathom why I said I am NOT an atheist, as I told you before, but you have conveniently forgotten, the label is a derogatory, COMPLETELY unnecessary, ..........how the hell do you feel you can put a label on people just because they don't accept a bunch of unproven myths.
How the hell would ANYBODY know if a person said they were an atheist, that they just didn't “believe” or some kind of fanatical "religious" wacko?
The term is useless, serves no purpose, except for the religious of course.

FAST
 
can the amazing depths of love, emotion, wisdom, creativity and the living essence all be just accidental byproducts of the chemical coincidence that formed the universe with no intelligent design? Dream on, gentlemen. We are just the science project of an intergalactic space child ( or a million other possibilities).
Could RLD's angry personna ever allow him to contemplate those possibilities without unleashing a barrage of arrogant , foul-spirited bafflegab??? I await your insults....

Sounds like proof to me. Since wig can't accept it, there must be a god .... sorry ... designer.