Why I Am An Atheist

I agree that there is diversity in religion and diversity in science. A BIG difference is that you will never reach consensus in religion, whereas science, with evidence, comes consensus. Furthermore the DEGREE of diversity is not large in science but it is huge in Religion. Science is always testing the hypothesis, evaluating the evidence, rejecting and revising the hypothesis. I don't see that it religion.

I think it is a deeper parallel than just diversity, it is that both institutions (if I can use that shorthand) are both self correcting mechanisms. The RCC now is nothing like what it was 100 years ago. Both institutions are heavily influenced by culture. The pronouncements of both institutions have a huge influence on politics and governance in many places. Both institutions recognize authority and show significant deference to prior figures. Both institutions make mistakes that can have serious consequences. To use a loaded term, both institutions evolve both in the way they think about themselves and the way they relate to the outside world. Both institutions have their fair share of irrationality and downright fraud. The parallels never cease to amaze me.

Religion, (well at least the Abrahamic faiths anyways, I can't speak about the others because I am not well educated on them), goes through a very similar process. A new problem or issue comes along...say the invention of the birth control pill. They then go back to their guiding principles and try to figure out what it means, and how it should change their conduct. Somewhat like science. But that is more of just fine tuning. Science and religion both only change fundamentally when someone comes up with a significant new theory or approach, and then compare that to the already existing data (ie data or scripture etc) and then see how it fits in with coherent other parts. Some people think that science moves forward through the never-ending accumulation of new data forcing new ways of thinking, but most historians of science suggest that it is a myth. Scientific leaders make a "great leap forward" in theory, and then try to see if the data fits.

In fact, if you believe that the beginning of protestantism, perhaps the most significant moment in the history of the christian religion, it was Martin's Luther's posting of the 95 theses for debate that got the whole ball rolling. Very akin to proposing a new scientific theory.

Now there are fundamental differences in religion and science. Religion is about "how to live" while science is about understanding the world around us. Religion is not really evidence based, it is authority based and then moves to pure reason, while science adds a great reverence for reproducible evidence into the mix. There is also almost no role for faith in good science.

The odd thing is though, that atheists, who are really hostile to religion will spend forever listing the mistakes religion made historically almost never do the same thing for science. Science made huge mistakes in the past on every level, they tons of crap just plain wrong. Radical atheists seem to have a double standard they apply to looking at the two institutions, as much as perhaps a fundamentalist in religion would bring the same double standard to their view of religious history.
 
Thats far to logical dude, never be accepted by a certain bunch here !!!!

FAST

Thanks for your helpful and insightful contribution. You sure help me make my point about the ignorance and double standard of the radical atheist crowd.
 
I write it.......so therefor I am

Thanks for your helpful and insightful contribution. You sure help me make my point about the ignorance and double standard of the radical atheist crowd.

A little self conscious are we.

And..........if you are talking about me, as I have said ...........I am NOT an atheist, I just don't "believe" in myths perpetuated by your so called "authority".

rld said:
Some people think that science moves forward through the never-ending accumulation of new data forcing new ways of thinking, but most historians of science suggest that it is a myth.

What a bunch of BULL SHIT rld..........how the hell do you know how "science moves forward", are you a scientist,.......oh wait I know ............you read a book by some other self proclaimed "expert".

And .........."some people think that"..........just who ARE these "some people"

FAST
 
A little self conscious are we.

And..........if you are talking about me, as I have said ...........I am NOT an atheist, I just don't "believe" in myths perpetuated by your so called "authority".



What a bunch of BULL SHIT rld..........how the hell do you know how "science moves forward", are you a scientist,.......oh wait I know ............you read a book by some other self proclaimed "expert".

And .........."some people think that"..........just who ARE these "some people"

FAST

Nice dance.

You're not an atheist, but you don't believe in the myths(stories) about something(someone) who may or may not exist by others who dobelieve?
 
Nice dance.

You're not an atheist, but you don't believe in the myths(stories) about something(someone) who may or may not exist by others who dobelieve?

So are you saying you can only be a believer if you accept every story, parable, miracle, teaching that your respective religious texts put forth?
 
So are you saying you can only be a believer if you accept every story, parable, miracle, teaching that your respective religious texts put forth?

Nope, not at all. There are others that expect that, but I'm not one, nor did I say that.
 
What a bunch of BULL SHIT rld..........how the hell do you know how "science moves forward", are you a scientist,.......oh wait I know ............you read a book by some other self proclaimed "expert".

And .........."some people think that"..........just who ARE these "some people"

FAST

Most of my knowledge of the history of science comes from reading Stephen Jay Gould, a very well regarded historian of science. I have also read a couple of books about Gould's legacy that thoroughly discuss the subject. I also just enjoyed this course:

http://www.thegreatcourses.com/tgc/courses/course_detail.aspx?cid=174

I have also read Popper, Waert (though he is not as methodolgical as some of the others), Raup, and some others on the subject. And that is just what I remember off the top of my head.

Feel free to tell us about your explorations of the history of science.

The point I am making is well illustrated by this exercise:

A recent generation of historians of science, far from portraying accepted scientific views as objectively accurate reflections of a natural world, explain the acceptance of such views in terms of the ideological biases of certain influential scientists or the institutional and rhetorical power such scientists wield. As an example of ideological bias, it has been argued that Pasteur rejected the theory of spontaneous generation not because of experimental evidence but because he rejected the materialist ideology implicit in that doctrine. These historians seem to find allies in certain philosophers of science who argue that scientific views are not imposed by reality but are free inventions of creative minds, and that scientific claims are never more than brave conjectures, always subject to inevitable future falsification. While these philosophers of science themselves would not be likely to have much truck with the recent historians, it is an easy step from their views to the extremism of the historians.
While this rejection of the traditional belief that scientific views are objective reflections of the world may be fashionable, it is deeply implausible. We now know, for example, that water is made of hydrogen and oxygen and that parents each contribute one-half of their children’s complement of genes. I do not believe any serious-minded and informed person can claim that these statements are not factual descriptions of the world or that they will inevitably be falsified.
However, science’s accumulation of lasting truths about the world is not by any means a straightforward matter. We certainly need to get beyond the naive view that the truth will automatically reveal itself to any scientist who looks in the right direction; most often, in fact, a whole series of prior discoveries is needed to tease reality’s truths from experiment and observation. And the philosophers of science mentioned above are quite right to argue that new scientific ideas often correct old ones by indicating errors and imprecision (as, say, Newton’s ideas did to Kepler’s). Nor would I deny that there are interesting questions to be answered about the social processes in which scientific activity is embedded. The persuasive processes by which particular scientific groups establish their experimental results as authoritative are themselves social activities and can be rewardingly studied as such. Indeed, much of the new work in the history of science has been extremely revealing about the institutional interactions and rhetorical devices that help determine whose results achieve prominence.

While I have no claim to be a scientist, I am well read in the area and feel informed enough to offer an opinion on the process. It is well studied and you can read lots about it in the english language.

On the other hand you seem to be quite willing to spout opinions about things you have very little knowledge of at all. IT is actually quite ironic that you have tried to take me to task on this point by suggesting I am not informed enough to have an opinion within the mainstream of the field. Please, tell us about how you have come to your conclusions about how the process of science moves forward?
 
That's the only conclusion I come to. Where am I off?

It's not that difficult.

There are many believers who don't believe or follow 'all' the teachings/guidelines of the various church, yet I consider them good believers. At least they're trying hard.
 
It's not that difficult.

There are many believers who don't believe or follow 'all' the teachings/guidelines of the various church, yet I consider them good believers. At least they're trying hard.

But I think that's what Fast said. He didn't believe in the myths perpetuated, meaning stories that he thinks are bogus. You're making a little bit of jump as to what
and how much he believes and doesn't believe.
 
But I think that's what Fast said. He didn't believe in the myths perpetuated, meaning stories that he thinks are bogus. You're making a little bit of jump as to what
and how much he believes and doesn't believe.

I don't remember him claiming he believed anything in the Bible or in any of the churches' doctrine, but I could be wrong, so it's not much of a jump
 
I don't remember him claiming he believed anything in the Bible or in any of the churches' doctrine, but I could be wrong, so it's not much of a jump

Why does he need to tell you any of that? Anyway how does that preclude him from being a believer? Why are you splitting hairs?
He said he's not an atheist, what's he hiding?
There's this constant nipping at the heels...and for what?
 
Why does he need to tell you any of that? Anyway how does that preclude him from being a believer? Why are you splitting hairs?
He said he's not an atheist, what's he hiding?
There's this constant nipping at the heels...and for what?

He doesn't 'need to' and no one demanded he do so, but it's common sense that if you are neutral and have reservations both side you tend to show it in your posts. I'm not the first to make note of this.

If you think he's possibly a believer, then ask him and revel in his answer. It will be entertaining. Something tells me you won't get a straight answer.
 
Read a book.......become an authority

Science and religion both only change fundamentally when someone comes up with a significant new theory or approach, and then compare that to the already existing data (ie data or scripture etc) and then see how it fits in with coherent other parts. Some people think that science moves forward through the never-ending accumulation of new data forcing new ways of thinking, but most historians of science suggest that it is a myth. Scientific leaders make a "great leap forward" in theory, and then try to see if the data fits.

In my opinion …..you are WRONG...... religion only changes when it is forced to.........a good example.........the RCC "attempting" to change its stance on contraceptives.

THAT IS HOW YOU REPLY


I HAVE NOT MADE ANY PRIOR STATEMENTS OF MY OPINION OR OTHER WISE ON THIS SUBJECT.

But you are making profound statements, not opinions, ..........example..........
Some people think that science moves forward through the never-ending accumulation of new data forcing new ways of thinking, but most historians of science suggest that it is a myth.

That’s NOT your opinion..........your making a statement about something you have absolutely no back ground to make.
If you feel that some one can read a book or two about some one elses opinions .........you have suddenly become an authority in that subject ....BULL SHIT.

FAST
 
Thick

But I think that's what Fast said. He didn't believe in the myths perpetuated, meaning stories that he thinks are bogus. You're making a little bit of jump as to what
and how much he believes and doesn't believe.

Give up JAZZ, the meaning of my statement about NOT being an atheist is WAY over his head, ..........he will never get it.

FAST
 
Tell that to the 9/11 and moon landing conspiracist.

Who have exactly as much evidence for their views as religious types?

I will state a difference though since conspiracy people believe despite evidence while the religious believe in the absence of evidence.
 
Give up JAZZ, the meaning of my statement about NOT being an atheist is WAY over his head, ..........he will never get it.

FAST

What did I tell you JP, he won't answer it plainly. He tries to be cute.

Where exactly did you make apparently clear statement?
 
A little help

What did I tell you JP, he won't answer it plainly. He tries to be cute.

Where exactly did you make apparently clear statement?

Post #175.

A simple question for you.........If some one says they are NOT an atheist..........in your opinion, what do YOU think that means?????

FAST
 
A little self conscious are we.

And..........if you are talking about me, as I have said ...........I am NOT an atheist, I just don't "believe" in myths perpetuated by your so called "authority".



What a bunch of BULL SHIT rld..........how the hell do you know how "science moves forward", are you a scientist,.......oh wait I know ............you read a book by some other self proclaimed "expert".

And .........."some people think that"..........just who ARE these "some people"

FAST

Post #175.

A simple question for you.........If some one says they are NOT an atheist..........in your opinion, what do YOU think that means?????

FAST

Not quite what you said, but hey. You don't believe in deity, but you also don't believe in some of RLDs 'authorities'? As if your better informed than so many of them. Just say you're an agnostic and keep it simple. Just like your wishy washy stance on extra terrestrial life; not say there is, but not saying there isn't. You wanted absolute certainty before you stuck your toe in the pond.

Stop being such a Mae West.