Who makes your clothes?

The Fruity Hare

Well-known member
Dec 4, 2002
5,110
33
48
I was recently doing a little shopping for some clothes, and noticed that many labels stated that they were made in China.

I just saw a news item regarding Bangladeshi garment workers rioting for higher wages. It states they were supposed to receive a raise this month, the first since 2006 when wages went from $25 Cdn a month, to $45 Cdn a month.

http://news.ca.msn.com/top-stories/cbc-article.aspx?cp-documentid=25043062

I read a few articles regarding workers in other parts of the world including one factory that was closed down as ... the cost for cutting and sewing a shirt (including putting on collar and buttons) is about $0.10 per piece. That's right. Ten cents (the clothing line provides the fabric).

She closed down her operation a while ago, because the price of $0.10 per piece turns out to be too high as compared to other cheaper countries like Vietnam.


http://www.neatorama.com/2009/01/12/meet-the-people-who-made-your-clothes/


At what point are these companies breaking even or making a profit? At one time manufacturers left Canada to go to Mexico because of the cheap labour, but it seems that now they are even moving from Mexico and going to Asia. When does it end?

Do they move into a country, somewhat bring up the the living conditions, minimum wage etc, then when it becomes too competitive, desert them and find somewhere else to exploit? What happens to the workers who were just making enough to get by, when the manufacturers pull up and move on?

It's not like we are paying peanuts for these name brands, and although there are built in costs, how far will they go to keep wringing out each last penny of profit?
 
Sad but true. We consumers must shoulder a large part of the blame since we are always looking for the best deals regardless or origin.
 
nature of the beast.

You want to fix it, first you will need to bring HUMAN RIGHTS to most of the world.
 
I just saw a news item regarding Bangladeshi garment workers rioting for higher wages. It states they were supposed to receive a raise this month, the first since 2006 when wages went from $25 Cdn a month, to $45 Cdn a month.
What's the problem? That's an 80% raise.
 
Sad but true. We consumers must shoulder a large part of the blame since we are always looking for the best deals regardless or origin.

I don't quite see the problem. Whether they work for a dollar a day or a dollar a week, why should I give a fuck?
 
Sad but true. We consumers must shoulder a large part of the blame since we are always looking for the best deals regardless or origin.
Not really. The shirts are being made overseas for 10 cents a piece but we're still being charged $49.99 or more. We're not getting any bargains and we don't control the price or the wage. The distributors and designers are making all the money.
 
Pure greed and avarice. Plain and simple. The prices have gone up for many, if not most, brand names.

Plus, I noticed that the quality has gone down terribly. Just a couple of wearings and washings and my dress shirts are shit, compared to Canadian made shirts about 20 years ago that only lost their quality after a couple of years of good and honest wearing.
 
I was recently doing a little shopping for some clothes, and noticed that many labels stated that they were made in China.



At what point are these companies breaking even or making a profit? At one time manufacturers left Canada to go to Mexico because of the cheap labour, but it seems that now they are even moving from Mexico and going to Asia. When does it end?

Do they move into a country, somewhat bring up the the living conditions, minimum wage etc, then when it becomes too competitive, desert them and find somewhere else to exploit? What happens to the workers who were just making enough to get by, when the manufacturers pull up and move on?

It's not like we are paying peanuts for these name brands, and although there are built in costs, how far will they go to keep wringing out each last penny of profit?

You are missing a few things.
Companies are always making a profit. They just want more because you in US/Canada are not making anymore. So if they jack up the price here there will be less sales. But if they maintain the price say 1% per year increase they will make money off us.

MFG left Canada back in the mid 80's.
They are moving from MEx to Asia and after that Africa, then lastly South America.

Everyone gets exploit other people. Canadians/GOV't should have protested this practice back then and it is not to late to do so right now.
As for the workers in these places, they were not making any money before P&G (protact and gamble) moved in or nay MFG. They only made money for a decade and they will have to step back to the way they used to live. IF they were smart they would have used the MONEY to build/update their own Infrastructure for living and MFG.

MFG will keep on doing what they are doing once or until you stop buying their HIGH FAKE GLOSSY product.

For example why do people go see a movie then go buy the DVD/BR disc?
Why can't they just go buy a book or go to the public library?

Life is full of surprises.
 
Everyone gets exploit other people. Canadians/GOV't should have protested this practice back then and it is not to late to do so right now.
I don't get it. Why don't you want other people to be exploited?? If not for exploitation, would we not, among other things, have to fuck people who are just as old, fat and ugly as we are? Isn't the whole purpose of life to exploit as much shit out of others as possible?
 
How does $25 wages for a months' worth of labour, which likely amounts to thousands of garments per worker, plus the cost of raw materials like cotton translate through the market to $50 for a branded T Shirt?
 
This is not a simple subject. As consumers we all want less expensive clothing and we vote with our dollars, not our hearts. As a result Walmart, Zellers, Nike etc all source their clothes in low cost countries.

Some but not all of these companies have ethical sourcing practices because they would get killed in the press if they didn't. This is especially the case around sourcing clothing for something like Canadian Olympic athletes.

Their position is that they pay competitive wages in the local economy and don't buy from sweatshops, thereby creating jobs where there were none before. Here's a link to HBC's policies if you're interested.

The good news is that we live in a free country where you can read labels and choose where you buy from. Just be prepared to pay a lot more for clothing made in developed countries.

http://hbc.com/hbc/socialresponsibility/sourcing/