Who is the better actor?

superstar_88

The Chiseler
Jan 4, 2008
6,643
1,849
113
Between
Stallone the Italian Stalion,
Dwayne Johnson the Rock,
Arnold the Terminator,
Travolta the Dancing Queen, or
Jason Statham the Transporter

Who would be the closest to ever win an Oscar?
 
Last edited:
Stallone put a tear in my eye in Rocky II hospital scene where he is seeing his wife for the first time in a coma
 
My head says The Rock, he's worked very hard at his acting, but my heart says Arnold.

He was very, very good in Terminator Genisys, he had to overcome bad acting from Emilia Clarke - she no Sarah Connor.
 
Tough one here.....

I'll go with Stallone...Copland was a solid role for him as was the Rambo 4 and First Blood.

I'm interested to see what the insidious one has to say here though.
 
Gotta go with Stallone, when he loses it it on Mickey and then chases him onto street to hug him, powerful scene in Rocky and he was pretty good in Cop Land.
 
Not to minimize the popularity of the others being mentioned, my personal choice would tend to lean towards Stallone!
 
Between
Stallone the Italian Stalion,
Dwayne Johnson the Rock,
Arnold the Terminator,
Travolta the Dancing Queen, or
Vin Diesel the Fast and Furious?

Who would be the closest to ever win an Oscar?


That is like asking who is the most learned Judge? Wapner, Judy, Pirro or a hot rod Pontiac GTO!

And which one should have been nominated to the Supreme Court!
 
None of them. None.

Entertainers or "Film Stars", occasionally. However, ACTOR, the word does not apply.

Daniel Day-Lewis, Jeon Do-Yeon, Sean Penn, Meryl Street, these are actors.
 
That is like asking who is the most learned Judge? Wapner, Judy, Pirro or a hot rod Pontiac GTO!

And which one should have been nominated to the Supreme Court!

Precisely why I asked.
The Oscar was in jest but I really did feel it's close who the better actor is amongst this class aside from Vin Diesel who is being left in the dust.
 
Actors that can do both action and character studies are at the top of the mountain. Shia LoBeouf has matured - and he's doing Tom Hardy's workout routine. Tom played out the scenario that Shai actually punched him. If you want to know the truth about "the incident" go to 17:40.

 
Shia earned my respect in Lawless, before that I thought he was a punk. It was his project, he wooed Hardy to be in it and he had the most thankless role.

 
Unfortunately we may not get a S2 of Taboo. Sony is paying him a boatload of money to develop the Venom franchise in a three picture deal. Except Spiderman to appear in the third installment, Tom Holland had faith in his maestro that he could make it happen. Andy Serkis is directing Venom II.

Taboo has an audience score of 8.5/10.

 
Definitely Travolta is the closest of the word actors.

You misspelled “closet”.

Seriously, Travolta was nominated twice for Best Actor but I’d say Stallone is a better actor overall. He was nominated Best Actor, Best Supporting Actor and for Best Screenplay.
 
You misspelled “closet”.

Seriously, Travolta was nominated twice for Best Actor but I’d say Stallone is a better actor overall. He was nominated Best Actor, Best Supporting Actor and for Best Screenplay.

Then it's not out of the realm of possibility that an Oscar can come out of this group.
 
I’ve gotta go Stallone because of Rocky, but I have to say, Conan the Barbarian (the original, not the godawful reboot) is one of my favorite movies of all time, and a huge part of why it’s so good is because of Arnie. The movie was a pretty big departure from the books, and Arnold didn’t play the character at all like book Conan, but he still managed to make the character incredibly compelling in his own way. No one else could’ve done with the character what he did. He had just the right mix of charisma and physicality to pull it off. They tried it with Momoa, and although he definitely had the right physique for the role, he just couldn’t carry the movie the way Arnold did. I really do hope the King Conan movie gets made eventually. So far, it seems to have stalled out in development hell.