Which carrier has the cheapest basic home phone service?

GPIDEAL

Prolific User
Jun 27, 2010
23,294
21
38
I have new phones with digital voice messaging service for my home land line. Have my cell phone too. My TV is already with Rogers (partly paid via my monthly condo maintenance fee). My internet is with Telnet (formerly Look communications).

So I just wanna strip down my existing home Bell line for basic service with visual call waiting only, for the best discount without having to go elsewhere. Called Bell customer service but eventually got transferred to their Loyalty Department.

Bell can't do anything better than $5 off for eliminating voice mail messaging, call forwarding and conference call services. They can save me $10 but only if I get internet which I don't want because it will force me to change email addresses.

I don't know about the rest of you, but if I were to give measly discounts to my customers for a substantial portion of services that are eliminated, they would accuse me of price fixing. Guess the CRTC legitimizes this.

I can bundle with Rogers, but will they give me a basic service? In case of a power failure, phone service via cable won't work (I keep an analog phone handy for such emergencies).

There's ComWave, Primus and Allstream.

Any others or pointers?

I just want to get a basic service with visual call waiting only for my home land line, and not pay more than $40/mo.

Thank you.


P.S. It's not the money now but the principle. Fuck Ma Bell.
 
I switched to Primus through a deal with Costco for $69 that included the Internet and long distance calling to 50 odd countries anytime, with all the features such as voice-mail, call display etc. With taxes and such stuff as 911 charges the actual bill was $80. That was a few years ago. Today it is around $95, because these conn artists puts up the rate every year claiming that their costs are increasing. The only reason I have stuck with them is because of unlimited internet data. So the moral of the story is that you should be prepared for increments in your bill every year whether it is Bell, Primus or Rogers for home phones and internet. Bell and Rogers are offering me fantastic unbelievable deals to switch back, including stuff like a free PVR and the Internet for around $ 50. Tempted to switch but again there is a lot of fine print to consider.
 
Thanks gents but I only want basic phone service with at most visual call waiting (or just call display). I already have cable and internet. Looks like I have no choice but to order a VOIP-based home phone service. Can they use my existing DSL? I will not a sign a contract either. This is to 'tell' Ma Bell to F.O.
 
I'm with Primus, yes cheap to start but like bver_hunter says it keeps getting higher and higher all the time, but like him I also keep it for the unlimited data with internet. I'd like to switch if I can find somewhere that can offer the same but I don't want to go with one of the "big three".

I switched to Primus through a deal with Costco for $69 that included the Internet and long distance calling to 50 odd countries anytime, with all the features such as voice-mail, call display etc. With taxes and such stuff as 911 charges the actual bill was $80. That was a few years ago. Today it is around $95, because these conn artists puts up the rate every year claiming that their costs are increasing. The only reason I have stuck with them is because of unlimited internet data. So the moral of the story is that you should be prepared for increments in your bill every year whether it is Bell, Primus or Rogers for home phones and internet. Bell and Rogers are offering me fantastic unbelievable deals to switch back, including stuff like a free PVR and the Internet for around $ 50. Tempted to switch but again there is a lot of fine print to consider.
 
Thanks gents but I only want basic phone service with at most visual call waiting (or just call display). I already have cable and internet. Looks like I have no choice but to order a VOIP-based home phone service. Can they use my existing DSL? I will not a sign a contract either. This is to 'tell' Ma Bell to F.O.
Careful with that reasoning. I switched cell phone carriers in order to tell one of the big players to "fuck off". Ended up costing me money and a shitload of time (mostly on hold to their customer service) in the end. "FO" is a powerful motivator, but it is really for your own sake since any individual customer is a mere gnat to them. Be sure you aren't making things worse for yourself above all.
 
Thanks gents but I only want basic phone service with at most visual call waiting (or just call display). I already have cable and internet. Looks like I have no choice but to order a VOIP-based home phone service. Can they use my existing DSL? I will not a sign a contract either. This is to 'tell' Ma Bell to F.O.

You can get a dirt cheap VoIP service from any number of companies. VoIP.ms and Callcentric are popular. You can likely get your monthly bill down to about $2 to $5 with those services. Yes, cheaper than a cup of coffee for a month including typical long distance usage.

But note what you give up: direct access to the 911 operator. When you dial 911 on most VoIP services your call hits their call center, their operator confirms your location, then forwards the call to the correct regional 911 center.

Also you get "basic 911" rather than "enhanced 911" meaning the 911 operator has to type in your address, it doesn't automatically pop up on their dispatch computer screen as with most modern 911 service in Canada. That slows the dispatch process and creates the possibility of a typo sending the call to the wrong location.

This is all because with a VoIP service you might have taken the device out of region and plugged in anywhere so they won't automatically connect your call to local 911 since you might not be in that region and for the same reason they have to verbally relay the address.

If you feel comfortable with that it is a LOT cheaper, but if you ever need 911 the extra seconds may matter. Personally I think that level of service suits a business customer better than a home user. Makes a great second line for a business, or for phone service in an office but home users should pay for fast reliable enhanced 911.
 
teksavvy you don't need a contract works fine. once in a blue moon I have to unplug to reset phone modem usually associated with a power outage happened twice in 6 months maybe longer

audio quality is fine cant tell difference to rogers or bell
 
Further to fuji's 911 points, VoIP is as powerline-dependent as the modem that delivers your internet to your computers. If it's handling the WiFi signal your portable devices use, they'll be as ineffective as your desktop at maintaining VoIP telephone connectivity in a power failure. If that failure is widespread, actual cellular service may also become iffier than just keeping your phone charged.

For that sort of 'lifeline' connection, nothing much beats a simple landline powered telephone, as GP implied in his original post.
 
What's the one Tie Domi keeps pushing? It's supposed to be cheap, 15 a month or something.
 
A friend told me that Rogers is not "true" landline. Is he correct?
If he meant 'there's no line over the land', he's clearly wrong, as Roger's signal comes into every customer's home via cable—a line. But Bell's landline also supplies all the electrical power required to operate a simple telephone, even an elderly one with many moving mechanical functions, while every Rogers' cable device I'm aware of—(and all sorts of contemporary telephones that plug into wall jacks, BTW)—require additional house power. I'd suspect that extra power requirement is what he meant by not 'true' landline.

Perhaps Ms.FemmeFatale could offer more details about her phone.
 
Teksavvy has TekTalk which is their VoIP service and a traditional home phone service which I posted the link for.
 
If he meant 'there's no line over the land', he's clearly wrong, as Roger's signal comes into every customer's home via cable—a line. But Bell's landline also supplies all the electrical power required to operate a simple telephone, even an elderly one with many moving mechanical functions, while every Rogers' cable device I'm aware of—(and all sorts of contemporary telephones that plug into wall jacks, BTW)—require additional house power. I'd suspect that extra power requirement is what he meant by not 'true' landline.

Perhaps Ms.FemmeFatale could offer more details about her phone.

From a technical standpoint Rogers Home Phone is a closed VoIP solution, in as much as the calls are digtised and transmitted across their cable network as IP traffic. When I had it several years ago they provided a box to plug your phones into that did need external power. the box did have a backup battery so you were not without phone service in the case of a power outage... assuming you hadn't gone completely wireless for your handsets which a lot of people do...

In this case the definition of a true landline is the ability to plug a phone straight into the line and place a call with no additional hardware requirement with all power requirements provided by the exchange rather than the consumer premises.
 
I have a rogers landline and it works when the power is out.


As a further update in my research, Rogers' website says $35 for basic service as an add on to my existing CATV.

If I can twist their arm and get them to include call display (I can live without call waiting), that would be great.

So you've been able to use it even with the power failures we've had?
 
From a technical standpoint Rogers Home Phone is a closed VoIP solution, in as much as the calls are digtised and transmitted across their cable network as IP traffic. When I had it several years ago they provided a box to plug your phones into that did need external power. the box did have a backup battery so you were not without phone service in the case of a power outage... assuming you hadn't gone completely wireless for your handsets which a lot of people do...

In this case the definition of a true landline is the ability to plug a phone straight into the line and place a call with no additional hardware requirement with all power requirements provided by the exchange rather than the consumer premises.


All my phones are cordless except one old wall-mounted touch-tone, analog phone (which served well during the last black out).

So will they send me these so called 'boxes' with battery backup for each cordless phone that requires a power source?

Does a technician come to your phone or is it easy self-serve?
 
What's the one Tie Domi keeps pushing? It's supposed to be cheap, 15 a month or something.

Com Wave.

Like Fuji says, VOIP lines are the cheapest but I was hoping to avoid that route.

You can get a plan for $9 and change per month with a 2 year contract.