where are the geniuses?

261252

Nobodies business if I do
Sep 26, 2007
1,307
1,099
113
I have a really good observation, I think.

We have more educated people today than ever in history, by far and away, and we have had for well over two hundred years. As well, our level of education should be better, by far, then ever before.

Why then, when we talk of genius, whether science or art, do we almost always refer to past genius? It seems to me the greatest geniuses, by far, and the greatest number of them, by far, must be within the last two hundred years or so with the greatest number, by far, walking amongst us. Indeed, most highschools should have a genius in them that is comparable to anyone from the past.

Here is a potential list of all time top eleven geniuses that I made up ( in random order). If the ages of these geniuses were wine, only the last four would still be drinkable, and only the last one still drinks.

1. Nicolaus Copernicus
2. Johannes Kepler
3. Leonardo da Vinci
4. Galileo Galilei
5. Sir Isaac Newton
6. Rene Descartes
7. Mozart
8. Marie Curie
9. Albert Einstein
10. Nikola Tesla
11 George Bush (the second)
 
genius today doesn't compare as well as it did back then. The art today is great but there are so many great artists one doesn't stand out like a Mozart. Scientists today need to be geniuses to even wrap there heads around the theories enough to advance them an inch, so they don't look as groundbreaking as Newton.

You can't compare an era where there is so much knowledge out there being advanced to one where only a handful had access and were able to stand out.
 
I would add Picasso to that list. Because they are so often years ahead of their time, I think it takes a while for true genius to be recognised. Often, genius' are thought of as fools by their contemporaries.
 
Actually, now that I think of it, my all time list is all time white list.

This is a result of cultural and educational influence.

Some of the greatest mathematicians were Chinese, East Indian and Muslem, for example.

If they were included the only one left on my original list woul be Da Vinci, Mozart and Bush.

And only Bush would still be drinkable.
 
Sukdeep said:
George Bush?!?! you mean W ?!?!

This, of course, is my attempt at humour.:D

The double meaning here is that G W Bush is an alchoholic (the only one who still drinks) who claims to be on the wagon.
 
snowleopard said:
I would add Picasso to that list.


I saw a thing on sixty minutes about a female child in the USA whose art sells for thousands and it is comparable to Picasso .

When shown some of his work she said she never heard of him but was glad to see that someone could see what she saw.

She said she paints what things look like on the inside.

I understand this concept actually, and if only for the reason that I understand it, I would not put him on the list.
 
261252 said:
Actually, now that I think of it, my all time list is all time white list.

This is a result of cultural and educational influence.

Some of the greatest mathematicians were Chinese, East Indian and Muslem, for example.

If they were included the only one left on my original list woul be Da Vinci, Mozart and Bush.

And only Bush would still be drinkable.

He who rules the world gets to write history.
 
There is a fine line between being a genius or mentally challenged. Most of these geniuses were considered mentally deprived in their day, except Bush of course, he will leave a legacy of being the most mentally challenged leader of the the most powerful nation in the world, when he's sober that is.

btw, who invented the dildo, bastard took away a lot of my business.
 
Our education system discourages creative geniuses. You only excel in school if you know the "correct" answer to the teacher's specific questions. Plus most inventors or innovative thinkers are sucked up by corporations and don't get singular credit for their ideas, rather corporations get rich off them.

Nevertheless, what about the dude that invented the computer, or the internet? For the arts, what about George Lucas or the Jonas Brothers?
 
261252 said:
I saw a thing on sixty minutes about a female child in the USA whose art sells for thousands and it is comparable to Picasso .

When shown some of his work she said she never heard of him but was glad to see that someone could see what she saw.

She said she paints what things look like on the inside.

I understand this concept actually, and if only for the reason that I understand it, I would not put him on the list.
As always, that's a matter of opinion. No doubt there are many children who also intuitively understand the theory of relativity ... but they didn't create it in 1905. Picasso was the first to break out of the traditional art mode that was considered acceptable in his day ... and he was loudly and publicly condemned for it, by the 'critics' at the time. Genius' are usually ground breakers. There are children who can write symphonies ... does that exclude Mozart?
 
gramage said:
genius today doesn't compare as well as it did back then. The art today is great but there are so many great artists one doesn't stand out like a Mozart. Scientists today need to be geniuses to even wrap there heads around the theories enough to advance them an inch, so they don't look as groundbreaking as Newton.

You can't compare an era where there is so much knowledge out there being advanced to one where only a handful had access and were able to stand out.

I think Gramage makes a good point but does not explain why such a list is, at least potentially, skewered to the past IMHO

Consider that throughout history not only is there , by far, less people, a smaller percentage, by far, of an already smaller number actually were educated to the point they were even literate.
 
Mia.Colpa said:
btw, who invented the dildo, bastard took away a lot of my business.

The dildo has been around for ever. It is not a modern invention.

It is my understanding that even puritans accepted their use when their men where away fishing or fighting or doing whatever Puritans did as some of the objects dug up by archeologists have no other ready explanation.

The "but plug" was invented by the Bushes, however. From this they made millions. This is why I put Bush on the list.

Bush then reinvested his "butplug" fortune and bought up all the Texas oil fields. When the oil ran out he decided to expand to Iraq.

Iraq already had the "but plug" and were at first intriqued by the Bush design so they welcomed the troops as "but plug" liberators. However, when they found the Bush "but plug" was inferior they got mad as they realized Bush was really after their lubricant.

This is a little know fact, but a fact it is.
 
I think the obvious answer is that all those people on your list were people that thought radically differently from the conventional norms of the time.

. The education system prepares people to function in society within their chosen field. University promotes conformity.

The great geniuses of history were non-conformists. They were people who often didn’t do well within society because they don’t think like others. Usually such people either are not well educated or they didn’t do well in school because school tries to make them like everyone else.
 
Artistic vs practical aside (and thats tough because I think Shakespeare, Picaso, Lennon, etc deserve the moniker)

It is history that has allowed us to truly analyze these peoples accomplishments and label them with genius status. IQ's aside, many struggled and or were actually ridiculed in their time. It is through later analysis we have annointed genius status upon them. Any amazing minds amoungst us today have yet to withstand the scrutiny of time versus accomplishment(s).

We don't see them today but perhaps they'll be annointed in times to come....Hawking, Jobs, Gates, Kissenger, Lennon, Rayfinkel...okay maybe not theat last one. Point is I.Q's and overall access to education/knowledge might be increased but imo genius is assesed in hindsight. Best we can hope for is a nice long list of contenders.
 
snowleopard said:
As always, that's a matter of opinion. No doubt there are many children who also intuitively understand the theory of relativity ... but they didn't create it in 1905. Picasso was the first to break out of the traditional art mode that was considered acceptable in his day ... and he was loudly and publicly condemned for it, by the 'critics' at the time. Genius' are usually ground breakers. There are children who can write symphonies ... does that exclude Mozart?

Just because he was the first to think of it does not make him a better genius then those who thought of it after he thought of it. I suspect Picasso was not the first even. He was only the first to be recognized because of fate.

Perhaps it does exclude Mozart, although I doubt any child can write in their brain what he did, but WTF do I know?

Mozart is particularly interesting to me because he had a brain that could multi task. He could carry on a conversation and at the same time not be distracted from his brain writing a symphony, which is a lot more complex than writing a folk song with one guitar in mind. Which is why I put him on the list.

I think my point is either societies list of geniuses is a bad list or something bizarre is going on here.
 
With so many smart people walking around to-day, one can be a genius and still not be a shining star. Much easier in the Dark Ages when there were less smart or educated people. Also, many medical and scientific breakthroughs to-day is the result of teamwork and not the genius of one person. For example, the success of the Manhattan Project was the result of teamwork.
 
Rockslinger said:
With so many smart people walking around to-day, one can be a genius and still not be a shining star. Much easier in the Dark Ages when there were less smart or educated people.


Good point.

Therefore, the list is a bad list?

They are on the list simply because they were the big fish in a small pond and we still falsely percieve them as all time all stars.

They should not even be on the list of the top million list of all time thinkers?

This must be the answer or we have gotten dumber somehow, IMHO.
 
Cycleguy007 said:
LMAO! I don't think anyone else got that? :D
Sorry 'Deep Thought' but computers don't count ... wait, I guess they do count ... in any case, seven and half million years to arrive at 42, does not qualify as genius!