When Citing US Laws in Canada Goes Horribly Wrong

Thanks. I didn't necessarily mean intoxicated as I almost never drink more than one or two at a time, but your response caused me to look into it some more. I had thought that being at a private residence would negate care or control laws but apparently not.

"Even sitting in a parked car to listen to the radio can land you a conviction for and impaired or over 80. The accused in R. v Baboolall [2004] O.J. No. 2878 (S.C.J.) had been drinking at a party when he decided to get into his car in the driveway and listen to the radio with a friend. He turned the radio on by putting the keys in the ignition and put the parking brake on. The Ontario Superior Court upheld the trial judge’s finding that the accused was in care or control of the vehicle, as there was a risk of the accused putting the vehicle in motion unintentionally. Crucial to this finding was the fact that the accused had accessed the ‘operating apparatus’ of the vehicle, thereby increases the risk of setting the car in motion."

Just in case this helps anyone here.
So if one is sitting in a car, intoxicated, but the car is not turned on in any way, no auxiliary, nothing, it is ok? In the case you cited, the key was in the ignition.
 
Not a lawyer, but my understanding that if you are in a motor vehicle, the police can ask for your license, registration and insurance at any time. We have different protections from the police in Canada. But, again, I admit that I might be wrong.
You are correct - I'm not a lawyer either though, like you, I just read things.
People in Canada forget that police can stop your vehicle for, in essence, any reason. Throwing aside infraction purposes, you can be stopped for:
- License;
- Insurance;
- Registration;
- Ownership;
- Sobriety; and,
- Mechanical fitness/safety.

But you can’t be drinking in your car in the Tim’s parking lot.

I don’t know but I believe they can still ask you for your ID if on private property. But I don’t know for fact.
They can ask for ID if you're behind the wheel of a MV - see above. You are very much correct.
They can also ask you for ID if engaged in a criminal investigation to which you are a subject of.
The investigation in the video is a bit on the weaker side, as you can film where someone ought reasonably be expected to be filmed (such as surveillance, etc.). But in a weird, creepy, random person just filming people from their car on private property way, you are now stemming into the grounds of Mischief - see s.430(1), with a view to the charging section of (4), on the basis that said filming is interfering with the lawful enjoyment of the property by others.
Not saying you could be convicted of said mischief, or even charged in relation to the filming, but there's enough to 'investigate' by the police.

If you are in “care and control” of a car, you cannot be drunk/ drinking. Full stop. Doesn’t matter where you are.

In Ontario, HTA offences may not apply on private property, but criminal code offences apply everywhere.
And it isn't even strict "care and/or control" anymore. The legislative changes in December 2019 led to changes in the Criminal Code, such as the definition section of 320.11.

Further fun fact:
I'm going to guess that the gentleman in the video, like many on the road, fail to realize that driving is a privilege, not a right. Parliament reminded of this in the same legislative changes when they created 320.12 - and this circles back to above about reasons they can stop, let alone provision of ID for investigative purposes:
(a) operating a conveyance is a privilege that is subject to certain limits in the interests of public safety that include licensing, the observance of rules and sobriety;
 
So if one is sitting in a car, intoxicated, but the car is not turned on in any way, no auxiliary, nothing, it is ok? In the case you cited, the key was in the ignition.
To put it simply, if you have the keys within a few meters of you, you're in trouble.

There are certain exceptions. Such as long-haul truck drivers. They have ways to disengage certain portions of the operability, and the back area operates as their (temporary) 'domicile'.
But if you think you're being smart by pounding a 26'er of Jack Daniels on the premise you simply have the keys in your pocket and not in the ignition, you're poised for an issue.
 
So if one is sitting in a car, intoxicated, but the car is not turned on in any way, no auxiliary, nothing, it is ok? In the case you cited, the key was in the ignition.
Also, if you're sitting in the car intoxicated, you best not have 'operated' (see above about definition-changes over the last five years) said car within two hours.
320.14 (1) Everyone commits an offence who
(b) subject to subsection (5), has, within two hours after ceasing to operate a conveyance, a blood alcohol concentration that is equal to or exceeds 80 mg of alcohol in 100 mL of blood;
 
We used to get that from the yanks visiting Oz. "You can't do that! It's against the constitution!!" Uh..not here mate, wrong constitution. Lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
So if one is sitting in a car, intoxicated, but the car is not turned on in any way, no auxiliary, nothing, it is ok? In the case you cited, the key was in the ignition.
If the car can be set in motion, and key whether in ignition, or readily available to driver, such as the key is on his person or in footwell then it is called care and control of a motor vehicle. Don't take a chance, take a taxi or Uber is way cheaper than blowing 25000.00 for five years of getting high risk insurance, plus fees to get driver's licence reinstated along with costs of having an ignition interlock installed to your car or not driving for two years.
 
I think the narrator of this video is out to lunch. We don't always have to surrender our "papers", we have basically the same rights as provided by the US Constitution. In Ontario at least, you do have to surrender driver's license etc if you are driving a car, however in this video it appears as though he is parked on private property, I don't think the cops can enforce documentation laws on private property.
I believe the law says "operating" a vehicle which in DUI cases means being in the car with possession of the keys.

Passengers don't have to id themselves though unless they are suspects in a crime.
 
Last edited: