What's wrong with the educational system today?

LordLoki said:
...... I do know that the handful of people we hired from that type of school were fired within a few months. They displayed an utter lack of basic skills and were unwilling to actually complete tasks.

....


Almost forgot... fired one and next day his mother shows up and demands to know why little Johny was fired. She told me it was bad for his self image.
 
Questor said:
Now we are getting to the very core of the issue! The schools are not meant to teach critical thinking. They are meant to churn out compliant little consumers and workers. Of course once the question of what we want the schools to do, then we must address what structure the school must have in order to accomplish this.

There are so many educational initiatives out there that the teachers themselves don't even know about them all but they are expected to participate in them, report on them, be accountable for them... Let's invoke the goold old KISS rule - keep it simple stupid. Teachers are people too.

How's this for a future solution: Teach children to be good parents so when they grow up, their kids won't have so many problems to begin with!?
 
Hank250 said:
How's this for a future solution: Teach children to be good parents so when they grow up, their kids won't have so many problems to begin with!?
For sure this could be an important part secondary education in Ontario.
 
Sukdeep said:
As I tell my students, "Statistically, most of you are average", get over it and don't expect As...."

That is what my prof told my class during my first class at university. Best to get it out there as lots of the students came in expecting a "A" for handing in a paper on time that was the correct length and on topic - it served them well in high school, but university was a whole new ball game. Only the top 10% got an "A", as it should be. Getting an "A" is nothing special if they give it to everyone.
 
CapitalGuy said:
Same idea. The problem is that the barista's kids are fucked...
Don't worry. I bet most of the Barista's won't be having kids. Thankfully we have poor teens getting pregnant and immigrants to keep the population up.

tired old perv said:
See what happens when you let Liberals run your province and your country?
...

Funny thing is this everyone passes attitude was solidified by the Mike Harris government (education is a provincial matter).
 
basketcase said:
Don't worry. I bet most of the Barista's won't be having kids. Thankfully we have poor teens getting pregnant and immigrants to keep the population up.



Funny thing is this everyone passes attitude was solidified by the Mike Harris government (education is a provincial matter).

I am sorry to disagree with you, basketcase. To be quite honest, I believe that Harris started to get rid of Destreaming, by trying to introduce standardisation testing and teacher accountability. However, he was not as successful as he should have been.

The 'destreaming' was initiated by Bob Rae and was an idea of Radwanski. As a student teacher in the early nineties, I lived through it and saw the nonsense of the 'every body passes' mentality, and the way that the seasoned vetran teachers were bemoaning the existant state of affairs.
 
the problem seems to start in grade school. nowadays, when children are taught to read, phonics is no longer part of the process. with respect to mathematics, no child is taught long division nor do they memorise the "times tables" from one up to 12. very sad, indeed.
 
emacs said:
with respect to mathematics, no child is taught long division nor do they memorise the "times tables" from one up to 12. very sad, indeed.

They don't make kids memorize "times tables" or long division anymore? :eek: That is bad...what do they get them to learn in place of those basics?
 
Try working in a private school where the teachers are told that " Parents pay a lot of money and they dont want to see a failing grade."

These kids expect everything to be handed to them. This attitude has been fostered by the parents and then the administrations. Hey people face the facts that maybe your kid is an idiot. We don't need these kids becoming engineers, the world needs ditch diggers to!

Start holding them accountable for their actions and their grades. That includes the parents to. To many of them can't be bothered to set limits for their kids.

Like I said I work in a private school and it's pretty bad when a kids weekly allowance is more than what our receptionist gets paid weekly. What are you showing your kids.
 
Every generation says: "Kids today are clueless and lazy."

IMHO, there are problems in our society, and certainly the education system is a reflection of it. We have undermined excellence in favour of equality. This is the case in government and in anything that the government administers.

Were we are going to have an huge problem is in tax collection. We have an hideously complex tax system that the average percon cannot understand, this includes the tax payers and the tax collectors. I have seen it now several times over the last few years: workers who can actually do a job, like fix a car, or properly shingle a roof but cannot do the administrative work that comes with it.

As for coasting, our entire society is coasting straight over a cliff. We have become so used to the "Good Life" we can't see that our most basic systems are corroding: infrastructure, garbage collection, water, power generation, education, training, even agriculture.

EU
 
celest said:
and on the subject of math...

this is an article i read sometime ago take it with a grain of salt, its from their literature but...

basically these kids learned 6 years math curriculum in 20 weeks, 20 contact hours.

its about a teacher at one of these schools and the kids that come to him to learn math, of their own accord.
they agree to a time, show up for all their classes (which they only have to because its part of the agreement they made with the teacher in continuing math classes, not because they will be punished if they dont), help one another, sat peacefully.

the teacher thought it was nothing short of a miracle until talking with a long time elementary school teacher who said this:

"Because everyone knows," he answered, "that the subject matter itself isn't that hard. What's hard, virtually impossible, is beating it into the heads of youngsters who hate every step. The only way we have a ghost of a chance is to hammer away at the stuff bit by bit every day for years. Even then it does not work. Most of the sixth graders are mathematical illiterates. Give me a kid who wants to learn the stuff -- well, twenty hours or so makes sense."


the whole article can be found here:
http://www.mountainlaurelsudbury.org/Rithmetic.asp

You can't force kids to truly want to learn something. This is the challenge for most teachers. I discussed this with a french teacher once. You cannot force kids to learn french. They have to want to learn it. Its later on in life, when they're in college that they decide to pursue to learn french. Same goes with math, kids later on in life decide to pursue math because genuinely they realize they have a true love for the subject. I know its a necessity for most professions to learn the basics. But beyond the basics, a person has to enjoy it enough to want to pursue learning it. Otherwise, the kid is better of learning another subject/field that he truly wants to learn.
 
You have to ensure that kids learn the basics of Reading, Writing and Math so that they can handle the more complex problems later. You can do that through a combination of "old fashion" discipline at home and at school, plus automated teaching tools that fully engage a childs mind. Yes, I know it's difficult to instill a childs love of reading, so you as a parent need to get off the chouch, turn off the TV or your computer and put in the time with your child.

When little Johny or Janey come home from school with that new math or science textbook, YOU need to pick it up and read it from cover to cover so YOU can answer their questions. Yes for some of you it could be 10, 20 or 30 years since you've pick up a childs textbook, but YOU are their best resource for learning. They want you to approve of them, to be proud of their accomplishments. Be a PARENT to your kid.
 
emacs said:
the problem seems to start in grade school. nowadays, when children are taught to read, phonics is no longer part of the process. with respect to mathematics, no child is taught long division nor do they memorise the "times tables" from one up to 12. very sad, indeed.

Phonics is stupid and discredited. Phonics is how you teach someone to read whose brain is not ready to learn reading: generally a 6-8 year old boy. If you wait until they are ready, they can learn without phonics, and they end up with higher reading speed, better comprehension and more enjoyment of reading. A lot of the worst things they do in primary school are because they are trying to force the boys to keep up with the girls, when their brains develop differently.
 
Ok this ought to shut up the older generation that thinks it knows what is wrong with the kids today and the education system:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMcfrLYDm2U

Like the presentation says - teachers are trying to teach children to use technology that hasn't been invented yet to solve problems that aren't even problems yet.

Scream about "back to basics" all you want. Fact is we don't live in a basic world with the global economy and that if the government doesn't pour massive amounts of $ and research into education we are going to be sunk by India and China in 15 yrs.

Whine all you want about how untrue that is and then watch your manufacturing jobs continue to slip away overseas. The ostrich defence is no defence at all.

Education is the lighting of a fire, not the filling of a bucket.
 
C Dick said:
Phonics is stupid and discredited. Phonics is how you teach someone to read whose brain is not ready to learn reading: generally a 6-8 year old boy. If you wait until they are ready, they can learn without phonics, and they end up with higher reading speed, better comprehension and more enjoyment of reading. A lot of the worst things they do in primary school are because they are trying to force the boys to keep up with the girls, when their brains develop differently.

you so sound bitter; strange :confused:

anyways, when i was a child phonics was only taught in grade 1. from this we developed the skill to sound out words and, hence, build our word identification, fluency and text comprehension into grade 2 and beyond.

nowadays, the approach is more about memorising words by sight. their vocabulary is essentially a 'stack of flash cards'. but when you show them a brand new word, they have difficulty in even attempting to pronounce the word because they lack the fundamental skill of deconstructing words into vowels and consonants.
 
alexmst said:
They don't make kids memorize "times tables" or long division anymore? :eek: That is bad...what do they get them to learn in place of those basics?

long division has been replaced by something called 'estimation'. i have seen the estimation in action and i call it 'really, really long division' because the chosen divisor is so far off that you often get these relatively huge remainders.
 
celest said:
its pretty radical i guess but there are a fair amount of other educational philosophy that are coming to similar conclusions.

of course you influence your children.

but not by manipulating them and frightening them, you teach by setting an example and giving them some trust. treat children differently and they will act differently, its miraculous.

you give them freedom to explore their full potential, and believe in their ability to do so. you nurture their natural curiosity for life, support their process as best you can, instead of trying to fit them in to narrow slots.

dont teach them just to do what they are told, not to question authority. teach them to be responsible for them selves. teach them how to operate on mutual respect and consideration because thats how you treat them.


and i absolutely agree

'If you can't handle the responsibilities of being a parent, then do the fucking world a favor and don't have children who will end up being irresponsible like you."

if only more people really considered if they were fit to be parents.

Actually, there is a lot of research that is beginning to show that parental influence on kids is actually a minor factor. Some think that the effects are :
genetic - 50 percent
family upbringing 0 - 5 percent
peer pressure 45 - 50 percent

I know this is discomforting - it is to me as a parent - but if you think about yourself and what has influenced you, your parents might check in with a low score. Of course in the extreme cases there is obviously an effect - child abuse and filthy rich life style but even then its not the whole show.