What's wrong with the educational system today?

tired old perv said:
See what happens when you let Liberals run your province and your country?

Liberals like Bill Davis and Mike Harris -- they were the ones who set the standards and policies give us to today's resutls.


Mind you their an example of one generation giving up in dispair about the coming generations -- the quote was attributed to Socrates
 
guelph said:
Liberals like Bill Davis and Mike Harris -- they were the ones who set the standards and policies give us to today's resutls.


Mind you their an example of one generation giving up in dispair about the coming generations -- the quote was attributed to Socrates

Yeah, no kidding. Look at Greece now. Hardly rules the roost in EU living standards.

If I ever have kids, they're going somewhere else for high school. Maybe Hong Kong.
 
Interesting responses so far. But one factor that I haven't heard suggested is the issue of gender.

My brother started noticing this. He has a stepson who has always bright, and loved to read. But now he's slipping. He's seen this with other young boys too. Then he looked at the statistics of female vs male teachers and noticed there is steady decline. It's at the point now where a boy can go right through high school without ever having a male teacher. Yet, when he looked back at the teachers who most inspired him, they were almost all males. I have to agree, as that was my experience too.

Coincidentally he just discovered a book that's been published called "Boys Adrift: The Five Factors Driving the Growing Epidemic of Unmotivated Boys and Underachieving Young Men."

I borrowed the book and have just started reading it. It makes some interesting points. It seems like a good starting point for those interested in this topic.

(I also notice there are a few other books on the topic such as "Why Gender Matters: What Parents and Teachers Need to Know about the Emerging Science of Sex Differences." This gender stuff does seem to warrant attention)

EDIT: I just noticed "C Dick" already raised the issue of gender. Yes, the disparity in male/female brains is indeed one of the points raised in the book.
 
enduser1 said:
...
Were we are going to have an huge problem is in tax collection. We have an hideously complex tax system that the average percon cannot understand, this includes the tax payers and the tax collectors....
Actually, I don't see a problem here. With all of the computer programs, the average person just has to enter the info from their t4's in the box where the computer tells you to. Filling out taxes is damn easy. The only complex parts are when it comes to deductions etc. Even then, there are dozens of tax services, including many for free. If people can't figure out that part, it means others are paying more tax than needed - good for the country.
 
When I used to do all nighters in university, I used to listen to Larry King on the radio from 12 midnight to 5:00am, when he was truely great. He had this high level education administrator, a really brilliant thinker, on the show and he said (paraphrasing), "It's as simple as this. Show me the parents in a given district and I'll show you the kind of school you're going to have."
 
Parental Involvement...

As a father of a 13 year old and an 11 year old, nothing can help a kid or hinder them like parent involvement. I'm not talking about riding them from dawn until dusk about school work, but as one poster said: "read what they wrote for school." Help them. Let them get their ideas across, but guide them a bit. When you are excited at what they're doing, they get excited and it reflects in performance. I've never cared what "grades" my kids got. I read the comments that state whether they're TRYING or not, and how well they work on their own and deal with conflict.

I want my kids to WANT to learn and to TRY hard, and for one reason: two summers ago I was in Germany for the World Cup. A waitress at a bistro serving us spoke very good English (as most Europeans do) so we struck up a conversation. She was gorgeous! She was from Romania. She had a degree from a University in San Francisco. She'd travelled the world, and was now finishing another degree in Munich before heading to the states to start her career in Engineering.

These are the kinds of people on their way to NA that our kids will be competing with. "Getting by" isn't going to cut it and our kids need know it. They need to understand that there's a lot of competition and if they want something they're going to need to work very hard for it, and I'm going to be there to encourage and help them as much as I can! Can't expect the education system to do that!

OP
 
guelph said:
Liberals like Bill Davis and Mike Harris -- they were the ones who set the standards and policies give us to today's resutls.


Mind you their an example of one generation giving up in dispair about the coming generations -- the quote was attributed to Socrates

Harris is one of the few that gets it.

You can't tax a society into greatness, nor can government force them to learn.

There are no medals for trying, thats what your supposed to do.

The real issue is the fact that there are too many kids that have only one overworked parent looking after them, and that parent probably does not have the time nor energy to devote to helping little Sally with her schoolwork. I wonder how many single parents ever go and even meet the teachers anymore?

If I was minsiter of education, kids would be failing left and right, and parents would have no choice but to be involved in their education.

To all the mothers and fathers out there, you had the little buggers, they are your responsibilty to educate, not mine nor my tax dollars. If they are failures at life and life skills, look in the mirror, cause your the ones that truly failed them.
 
emacs said:
you so sound bitter; strange :confused:

anyways, when i was a child phonics was only taught in grade 1. from this we developed the skill to sound out words and, hence, build our word identification, fluency and text comprehension into grade 2 and beyond.

nowadays, the approach is more about memorising words by sight. their vocabulary is essentially a 'stack of flash cards'. but when you show them a brand new word, they have difficulty in even attempting to pronounce the word because they lack the fundamental skill of deconstructing words into vowels and consonants.

Yes, I thought later that my post was a little harsh. I hated school, the stupidity of it all, I am just not someone who likes to accept the authority of others just because they say so. It certainly bothers me that the whole education system is so tilted towards the learning styles and readiness of girls, at the expense of boys.

As far as reading is concerned, the system where you read the whole words instead of sounding them out is called "whole language". It is proven to be more effective in the long term as a reading strategy. It is indeed handy to know enough phonics to be able to sound out a new word, after you know how to read, but it should not be taught until later.
 
C Dick said:
It certainly bothers me that the whole education system is so tilted towards the learning styles and readiness of girls, at the expense of boys.

honestly, this is the first time i have heard anyone mention the education system is tailored for girls. i think the real issue is the set of teachers you had back in school

the system where you read the whole words instead of sounding them out is called "whole language". It is proven to be more effective in the long term as a reading strategy.

although Chomsky, a respected academic, is a proponent of the whole language system i have yet to read any reliable and overwhelming consensus that whole language is the better method.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/08/070801091500.htm
http://www.onlineopinion.com.au/view.asp?article=6995

i believe alphabetic languages like English lends itself to phonics-based teachings. ideographic languages, particularly in Asian (i.e., Chinese, Japanese, Korean, et cetera) countries would be more attuned to the 'whole language' system of teachings.
 
C Dick said:
It certainly bothers me that the whole education system is so tilted towards the learning styles and readiness of girls, at the expense of boys.

honestly, this is the first time i have heard anyone mention the education system is tailored for girls. i think the real issue is your experiences in school.

the system where you read the whole words instead of sounding them out is called "whole language". It is proven to be more effective in the long term as a reading strategy.

although Chomsky, a respected academic, is a proponent of the whole language system i have yet to read of any reliable and overwhelming consensus that whole language is the better method.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/08/070801091500.htm
http://www.onlineopinion.com.au/view.asp?article=6995

i believe alphabetic languages like English lends itself to phonics-based teachings. ideographic languages, particularly in Asian countries would be more attuned to the whole language system of teachings.
 
emacs said:
honestly, this is the first time i have heard anyone mention the education system is tailored for girls. i think the real issue is your experiences in school.

It is not really based on my experiences. I was really into academics, and had no interest in sports. I could already read when I went to kindergarten, so I had the opposite problem, of being bored out of my mind.

My belief that the primary school system is totally geared towards girls is based on my experiences since then, with my kids and others, and with teaching and coaching kids. And reading a bunch of books about it, etc. Most 6-8 year old boys would choose to be physically active almost all the time, and not have any interest in reading, or crafts, or things like that (though I was an exception). Most 6-8 year old girls, in my experience, are relatively less interested in active play, and more interested in school work.

But the school system reflects this in no way, all the students are expected to get to the same place in exactly the same way, at the same time. There are so many things that are easy to learn when you are ready, and torture when you are not. Reading is a good example. Phonics is the way you teach someone to read who is not ready, if you wait a little, it is not neccessary, as long as the child does not have other learning issues.
 
I agree with your comments to a certain extent. I think kids who can't read before they get to school are a result of parents who don't read and/or don't read to their kids. I think boys are just as ready as girls to read (i have two boys and two girls- all of whom could read before starting school)- though I do think the primary years are more girl-oriented than boy-oriented. some of that is because with very few exceptions the primary age teachers are female and they have their own biases (as do we all).
 
emacs said:
honestly, this is the first time i have heard anyone mention the education system is tailored for girls. i think the real issue is your experiences in school.

Well, if you notice, I mention it in my post too. Lots of people are noticing the gender imbalance. Especially therapists and psychiatrists, who are now writing books about the phenomenon (some of which are listed in my earlier post).
 
BigBear7 said:
Well, if you notice, I mention it in my post too. Lots of people are noticing the gender imbalance. Especially therapists and psychiatrists, who are now writing books about the phenomenon (some of which are listed in my earlier post).

Yes, that's why more women than men make it to university now. There are about 55 girls to 45 men in a freshman class of 100. Must be awesome to be in university now.
 
As a matter of fact if you want to snoop thru statistics lately - 70% of those enrolled in post secondary education are female; 65% are Ontario Scholars our of highschool and the secondary system has classes and resources geared towards femalecentric activities ie: "Math for girls" or helping them to return to school after dropping out. In fact 80% of girls that drop out of highschool return to finish compared to 80% of boys that drop out never return. Lets not even talk about all the aprenticeship programs that were axed by the Harris government in the late 90's and all the Tech programs that were shut down.

Boys are destined to be slugging it out in menial labour jobs for the next century if we don't do something to help them.