What would you have done?

asshat deserves to be fired!
you did absolutely nothing wrong..wished some of my bosses were as generous.
 
tightfit said:
asshat deserves to be fired!
you did absolutely nothing wrong..wished some of my bosses were as generous.

You would be inviting a lawsuit for firing someone after making a complaint.

He is likely untouchable for awhile.
 
hunter001 said:
You would be inviting a lawsuit for firing someone after making a complaint.

He is likely untouchable for awhile.



Thats why I said wait. nice cold revenge served out at the right time is very satisfying. The bastard will never know and that makes it even better.
 
SPQR said:
In the spirit of the season I asked their that team to join my team for an evening out, on me on top of it, to celebrate the holiday season and share a bit of good fun.

They were very happy as their previous manager was a bit of scrooge apparently, but a little later on one of the guys come to me and says he would like that no one drinks alcohol for the evening.

I think you found out why the previous manager was a bit of a scrooge.

This is a total no-win situation. In the end, all that can really happen to resolve these situations is to either:
a) Have a Christmas party and live with the complaints, or
b) Cancel the Christmas party.

HR has been struggling with these situations for years. These are some of the issues:
Christmas Party - doesn't work with other faiths. Delete Christmas.
Gift Giving / Christmas Trees - delete that too, same reason.
Alcohol - Two drink max. Not fair to alcoholics (no drinks for them). Cancel Alcohol.
Food - No Beef. Everyone gets chicken or turkey. Not fair to Vedgetarians. Cancel food.
Get-Together - People see each other at work all day. Don't even try getting them to meet socially without food. Food seems to calm everyones nerves in a social situation. No food = Cancel Social Get-Together

Eventually, the situation boils down to: either you have a Christmas party and take responsible precautions, or you don't even try.

HR didn't bother you because this situation reads like an HR case study. You can't make everyone happy. You will make 95% of your workforce happy with a Christmas party. For most companies, the Christmas party buys a great deal of goodwill, so they hold one. Just warn HR before hand, so HR is ready for the complaints.
 
SPQR said:
Ok,

I try to accomidate my staff as best I can. I try to respect their beliefs and preach tolerance and understanding. This has wroked for me very well in the past, and so far no one has felt they anyone has gotten favouritism because of that.

So I am subbing for a manager who recently left. In the spirit of the season I asked their that team to join my team for an evening out, on me on top of it, to celebrate the holiday season and share a bit of good fun.

They were very happy as their previous manager was a bit of scrooge apparently, but a little later on one of the guys come to me and says he would like that no one drinks alcohol for the evening.

I understood why, but stated I could not do that. I respected the fact the he couldn't but I could not enforce that on the others. The only thing I could do, was enforce that they drink responsibly and maintain decorum as well as to ensure they took the appropriate means of getting home, but that would where my influence stops.

I said that I could ask that they take his feeling into consideration but that the decision was ultimately theirs.

I offered that if he would feel uncomfortable attending because of that, that he can just excuse himself from the evening, and then he and I can go out seperately and I would be happy to observe the no drinking or give him some petty cash and he could take his family out. (hindsight being 20/20 I probably should have not offered that)

He seemed to understand and left my office in the same mood he came in.

So the next thing I know I get a call from HR and now have a meeting scheduled with them tommorrow because apparently he complained that I was discriminating towards him because of his beliefs and that I even bribed him to stay quiet about it.

Did I do anything wrong? My thoughts are to just walk in there and say it like I explained it to him and let fate fall where it may.

Thoughts?


I think you did it all right *bythe book* im sure HR will see this and everything will be fine
Good luck hun :)
 
Well That was an ugly day...

I thought it was over early this morning, but it went right to the end of the day.

He was obviosuly unhappy that HR supported me in the decision, so then proceeded tp esclate it to our VP.

My VP comes into my office and asks me "what the hell happened." With this totally shocked look on his face.

I give him the speil, he talks to HR they gave him the speil, then finally calls the guy into the office, and tells him he agrees I acted appropriately on behalf of my department and that HR solution was acceptable and basically told him the buck stops here. He also reminded him that perhaps he should reread the code of ethics and focus on the chapter on equality in the workplace. Wow.

So they annouce to the team I was subbing as manager for, that as of Monday they will be reporting directly to my VP until such time they find an appropriate replacement.

So they asked the question why, since my tenure was short. He stated that due to the volume of my teams activities and the importance of their role that he wanted to be involved.

I got the authority from my VP that I expected from HR.

The only unfortunate part was that a few of the others from the other team asked if they can still come out with us. Before I would have said yes without thinking twice, but in this case I had to consult my VP.

He said that it was best that I didn't and to take some of the burden off my shoulders, say to them that I don't have a problem with it, but to check with him to get his ok. If he approves, then they are more than wlecome

He told me later that no one approached him.

It's over but I feel bad that one person ruined things for the others. At the same time happy to know my VP has taken ownership and will deal with the team as necessary.

Thanks again to all for the support!!
 
I've been managing people for awhile, and my take on this is, like everyone else said, that you said the right things. In fact you overdid it. It would have been enough to offer to make any special food/drink arrangements he required for his OWN food. You didn't need to offer him an alternate night out with you.

Anyway, there is a larger point here, that you, your VP, and HR are missing:

In every culture there are reasonable and unreasonable people. This guy is one of the unreasonable ones. He is either just a shit disturber, in which case he is ALWAYS going to impact morale in a negative way; or else he is worried about his competence and he is trying to establish a pattern of prejudice so that he can use that as an excuse if his job is ever threatened.

This is unacceptable.

Plainly you can't fire this guy over this incident, but it'll be important to carefully track his performance against objectives, and measure the degree to which he contributes to a positive team environment. You'll need a paper trail, over time, but I would make sure you're working on it.

If you let people like this fester in your organization that is exactly what they do: they fester. Everything around them starts to rot. It hurts your team in every possible way.

I don't envy you because this guy is going to place the race card when the day of reckoning comes, and it's going to be ugly. However it might just be worth your company's while to let him go and pay the costs of whatever unjust dismissal case he brings later. If you document everything carefully I don't think he can prevail; his lawyer will tell him that too. In reality, though, you'll settle out of court because going to trial over it would be more expensive than whatever dollar figure shuts him up.

ps - Don't underestimate how destructive a guy like this can be to your organization. If he poisons the work environment you will start to have churn, good productive people will quit, it'll just get worse. You'll lose critical people maybe at critical times. Costs will rise. Productivity will fall. Morale will plummet. If you don't get this situation under control eventually he'll do a lot of damage to your company.
 
fuji said:
Plainly you can't fire this guy over this incident, but it'll be important to carefully track his performance against objectives, and measure the degree to which he contributes to a positive team environment. You'll need a paper trail, over time, but I would make sure you're working on it.

Actually that's why I believe my VP has take ownership of the team. He would not come out and say that, but I sense that's what his motives are.

However when talking to HR this person's past performance has been either acceptable or above average, so there is no negative history to go by. That could just be because the former manager didn't want to deal with him and pushed all issues under the rug.

But I agree, he could be very distructive and personally if this were to continue I would addressed this overtime through coaching and when things didn't turn a positive corner, take corrective action.

I'm sure my VP will do what needs to be done. He's always been a fair individual but can also have a firm hand when required.

Thanks for the feedback, it's greatly appreciate as I'm still getting the hang of this manager gig.
 
I think the guy just used religion as a political tool to get you from leading their department. You need to be careful of this guy. He knows how the game is played.
 
Fascinating thread.
Let's all just hope that the VP, the HR manager, and the complainant aren't members of Terb.
But I thought you handled it better than most.
 
seymore said:
Let's all just hope that the VP, the HR manager, and the complainant aren't members of Terb.

Yeah... which of you guys is this dick who ruined the party? Speak up and defend yourself. We want to hear your side of the story.
 
I don't think arabgay posts anymore and scroll seems to have gone into hiding so if they were the complainant all is safe.
 
I can guarantee you that the reason the VP took over the team is to make sure that it does not get out of hand and he will probably drive them all a little harder in an effort to insure that the individual doesn't have a negative effect on the rest of the team.

I commend him for his swift and decisive action that he took. This shows why he made VP very clearly. The individual probably feels that he deserves the job of team leader, but call it a hunch but I suspect he won't be around long enough to kiss enough ass to get it. Then the fur will fly again, but your VP and possibly the new team leader will be well versed in his tactics by that time and will be ready.

When a new team leader is announced I am willing to bet that he will be having a long sit down with the VP prior to taking over the team.
 
You're lucky you have a VP who has the balls to take charge. He's obviously a person who understands that leaders have to lead. Good on him!

You've touched on the fact that you probably shouldn't have offered to take asshat's family out separately. Lesson learned there I suppose. But it strikes me that you probably should have at least run the night out by your VP in the first place. If nothing else, it's a courtesy to the VP just to let him know that you're taking your folks out for a bit of seasonal fun and who knows - the VP might just want to come out himself for a bit.

One other thing to keep in mind, this is ultimately a company-sponsored event. Even if everyone pays for their own drinks, it's still viewed as being a workplace event. As such, prevention of drinking and driving falls to the company. You should be prepared to provide cab chits and if necessary, take keys away from individuals should the need arise.

In any case, this asshat is just like that Rabbi who complained about the Xmas trees in Seattle's airport. No matter what you do, people like that will always find some point of contention. If this guy's religion / personal beliefs prevent him from drinking, that's fine. But he has no right to impose those beliefs on anyone other than himself. Clearly he doesn't understand this.

Anyway, go out with your crew, eat, drink, be merry, keep things somewhat under control and have fun!