SPQR said:
In the spirit of the season I asked their that team to join my team for an evening out, on me on top of it, to celebrate the holiday season and share a bit of good fun.
They were very happy as their previous manager was a bit of scrooge apparently, but a little later on one of the guys come to me and says he would like that no one drinks alcohol for the evening.
I think you found out why the previous manager was a bit of a scrooge.
This is a total no-win situation. In the end, all that can really happen to resolve these situations is to either:
a) Have a Christmas party and live with the complaints, or
b) Cancel the Christmas party.
HR has been struggling with these situations for years. These are some of the issues:
Christmas Party - doesn't work with other faiths. Delete Christmas.
Gift Giving / Christmas Trees - delete that too, same reason.
Alcohol - Two drink max. Not fair to alcoholics (no drinks for them). Cancel Alcohol.
Food - No Beef. Everyone gets chicken or turkey. Not fair to Vedgetarians. Cancel food.
Get-Together - People see each other at work all day. Don't even try getting them to meet socially without food. Food seems to calm everyones nerves in a social situation. No food = Cancel Social Get-Together
Eventually, the situation boils down to: either you have a Christmas party and take responsible precautions, or you don't even try.
HR didn't bother you because this situation reads like an HR case study. You can't make everyone happy. You will make 95% of your workforce happy with a Christmas party. For most companies, the Christmas party buys a great deal of goodwill, so they hold one. Just warn HR before hand, so HR is ready for the complaints.