What would you have done?

You handled it well, I hate shit like this, PC crap.

Stand up for yourself with the HR people, I'm willing to bet that at least one of them will be the same religion as him though, this being Canada and all, but remain calm and don't back down. They always hope that we will fold once they lay on the descrimination card.

Stay calm now and find a way to really screw the bastard over in 6 months or so. Best served cold, no trail and pausible deniability.


Good luck with it and MERRY CHRISTMAS.
 
I don't want this to deteriorate into an anti-immigration thread. So far, everyone has been relatively restrained. Don't let one asshole of an immigrant make it seem like all immigrants are like this. :(
 
stang said:
Well lets just get it over with and eliminate all holidays, parties and fun. Perhaps then the world will be great.


so sad but true ....elimination of public holiday decor probably will be a thing of the past like paper chip bags .Holidays will become private and never public the rate its going at now .The only thing as a decoration that wouldnt be offensive is if we displayed globes .
 
SPQR I have run a business for the last 30 years and had to deal with many different religions and ethnicities. You have handled this in a manner that I would be proud of.

This type of situation always appears when you have a group of people and sometimes it has nothing to do with the beliefs of that person as well. I have had the discrimination card layed and my feet a few times over the 30 years and let me tell not once have I backed down from a decision based solely on the thoughts of one person. I have usually taken the time to go and try and understand where they are coming from, which you have done, and then I try to educate them on where I am coming from.

If all else fails I have even gone so far as to leave the phone number for the Human Rights Ministry for them. Needless to say I have never gotten a letter or a call from them.

An old saying is when you have one employee you have one problem. When you have two employees you have three problems and so on and so on.

You sound like you use good old fashioned common sense when making your decisions. Stick with it you are doing a good job.
 
Well its been an interesting morning..

I have to admit that I may be a bit naive when it comes to managing people. Afterall this is my first time actually in a managers role.

It start out very much subbing like this situation and then found they wanted to leave me in the position. I figured that if I was honest and straight shooter and treated them like people vs employees I might do ok.

Today completely surprised me and showed me how naive I was.

So esstentially, he didn't share all the information with HR.

He stated that I made the selection of the event without consulting anyone and then when he discussed his objection based on his religious beliefs I dismissed it.

So thanks to the advice I received from some terbites, I played out the facts as they unfolded and in detail of the scenario, at the same time sounding apologetic for not having done more to ensure that he understood why the decision was made.

So what was HRs feedback.

1) They felt perhaps I should have checked with them before planning the event. ( I explained that I have done these in the past and that I have members of my team of similar faith and its never been an issue)

2) Pehaps cancel the event ( I said no as then bad feelings would exist with the team versus this individual, and I wasn't going to make up anything to tell them of why it would be cancelled.)

So essentially bottom line is, no action to be taken against me at all. They found that I dealt with it in an appropriate manner and the event can go on as planned.

They also agreed that this may linger on especially when they throw support for me in giving him feedback.

How are they going to handle that? Well they decided that they would tell him that they understand that he does not feel comfortable working in my team, and that since I am only temporary that the team would be reassigned to another manager for the time being. Which means no outting for them.

I dunno. I guess I'm off the hook and even if he continues to talk about this to others, people who know me would dismiss this, but overall I can't see this ending good.

I'm trying really hard not to change because of this, but it does make you think.

Thanks for the support everyone.
 
Enforcing a no alcohol rule is akin to banning the consumption of meat, loud music, or unmarried couples dancing. Your coworker is a self-absorbed self-important socially incompetent chowderhead. If you cannot commit to this opinion and stand by it then upon disclosing this situation to your superiors you will likely be held partially responsible for the problem. That's how corporate politics work. If he is qualified to contribute to the company then his opinions must be treated with some merit. It is your perogative to discredit crackpots. But don't stop with the party. Why not go on to extend your opinion to this employees quality of work, attendance habits, social relationships with his coworkers or lack thereof. Let them know you don't think this guy is going to work out. They probably won't fire him but the next manager that takes over when you finish subbing will probably ask and likely share your opinions down the line.
 
Dodger said:
If all else fails I have even gone so far as to leave the phone number for the Human Rights Ministry for them. Needless to say I have never gotten a letter or a call from them.


We have a Human Rights Ministry now? Are we paying for this? Good God.
 
SPQR said:
I have to admit that I may be a bit naive when it comes to managing people. Afterall this is my first time actually in a managers role.

It start out very much subbing like this situation and then found they wanted to leave me in the position. I figured that if I was honest and straight shooter and treated them like people vs employees I might do ok.

Today completely surprised me and showed me how naive I was.

So esstentially, he didn't share all the information with HR.

He stated that I made the selection of the event without consulting anyone and then when he discussed his objection based on his religious beliefs I dismissed it.

So thanks to the advice I received from some terbites, I played out the facts as they unfolded and in detail of the scenario, at the same time sounding apologetic for not having done more to ensure that he understood why the decision was made.

So what was HRs feedback.

1) They felt perhaps I should have checked with them before planning the event. ( I explained that I have done these in the past and that I have members of my team of similar faith and its never been an issue)

2) Pehaps cancel the event ( I said no as then bad feelings would exist with the team versus this individual, and I wasn't going to make up anything to tell them of why it would be cancelled.)

So essentially bottom line is, no action to be taken against me at all. They found that I dealt with it in an appropriate manner and the event can go on as planned.

They also agreed that this may linger on especially when they throw support for me in giving him feedback.

How are they going to handle that? Well they decided that they would tell him that they understand that he does not feel comfortable working in my team, and that since I am only temporary that the team would be reassigned to another manager for the time being. Which means no outting for them.I dunno. I guess I'm off the hook and even if he continues to talk about this to others, people who know me would dismiss this, but overall I can't see this ending good.

I'm trying really hard not to change because of this, but it does make you think.

Thanks for the support everyone.
In true HR fashion they have wimped out totally. Not a surprise. Well done for sticking to your guns and i really hope that your promtion becomes permanent, despite HR's best efforts!!!
 
Don't forget, wait an appropriate period of time, study weak points this guy has then torpedo the fuktard in 6 to 8 months.:D
 
It is good to hear it worked out for you.

I still don't get where he gets off using his religion to try to dictate what others can do.

It is funny that he complained about lack respect when he clearly has no respect for the views of the larger group.
 
Let us know how this turns out although I can't imagine it being anything other than " we investigated and found mgr spqr acted appropriately and your complaint was found to be baseless".
 
That guy sounds like a total asshole. I'm glad you didn't mention his religion/background because that's really not the issue. Some people in this world are just assholes.
 
WhaWhaWha said:
Why not go on to extend your opinion to this employees quality of work, attendance habits, social relationships with his coworkers or lack thereof. Let them know you don't think this guy is going to work out. They probably won't fire him but the next manager that takes over when you finish subbing will probably ask and likely share your opinions down the line.

The problem is I haven't worked with this individual long enough to critqiue his work ethic or quality of work, and I would never use that as a method of retaliation.

Even if it were the case I would have addressed it directly with him and coach him to improve in the areas where required. HR is an "if all else fails" team in my view.

But it seems he won't be my problem soon, and hopefully this situation will just be an experience to look back on and learn from.
 
JohnC said:
In true HR fashion they have wimped out totally. Not a surprise. Well done for sticking to your guns and i really hope that your promtion becomes permanent, despite HR's best efforts!!!

I have to admit I was a bit dissappointed on how they handled this. I was hoping for a clear message to either me or this individual and it doesn't look like that's going to happen.

But thank-you for the kind words.
 
hunter001 said:
It is funny that he complained about lack respect when he clearly has no respect for the views of the larger group.

Well I don't hold that completely against him. I understand that these beliefs are very important to him, and I respect that, and people sometimes have trouble seeing the other side.

I thought I showed him the other side of the coin. It was obvious that while he may have listened to what I said he wasn't listening to what I was saying.
 
SPQR said:
I have to admit I was a bit dissappointed on how they handled this. I was hoping for a clear message to either me or this individual and it doesn't look like that's going to happen.

But thank-you for the kind words.

In my experience HR departments will never send a clear message and will never take sides. They will find the most politically correct way possible to make the situation go away and appease everyone involved.
 
SPQR said:
Well I don't hold that completely against him. I understand that these beliefs are very important to him, and I respect that, and people sometimes have trouble seeing the other side.

I thought I showed him the other side of the coin. It was obvious that while he may have listened to what I said he wasn't listening to what I was saying.

I get that.

I bet that are a lot of things in the office he is against and he may have to learn to deal with it instead of pulling the religious believe card.
 
Reverse Racism

As I see it the only one that is trying to enforce their particular brand of religion on anyone it's him. Have you considered filing a human rights complaint? He is obviously messing with the free will of the you and the others on your team. I have often wondered why no one turns the tables on these types of people. As soon as you play a race or religion card you are in effect practicing a unique form of workplace intimidation/harassment. At the very least, please don't succumb to guilt over this situation. It's not your fault.