I have to admit that I may be a bit naive when it comes to managing people. Afterall this is my first time actually in a managers role.
It start out very much subbing like this situation and then found they wanted to leave me in the position. I figured that if I was honest and straight shooter and treated them like people vs employees I might do ok.
Today completely surprised me and showed me how naive I was.
So esstentially, he didn't share all the information with HR.
He stated that I made the selection of the event without consulting anyone and then when he discussed his objection based on his religious beliefs I dismissed it.
So thanks to the advice I received from some terbites, I played out the facts as they unfolded and in detail of the scenario, at the same time sounding apologetic for not having done more to ensure that he understood why the decision was made.
So what was HRs feedback.
1) They felt perhaps I should have checked with them before planning the event. ( I explained that I have done these in the past and that I have members of my team of similar faith and its never been an issue)
2) Pehaps cancel the event ( I said no as then bad feelings would exist with the team versus this individual, and I wasn't going to make up anything to tell them of why it would be cancelled.)
So essentially bottom line is, no action to be taken against me at all. They found that I dealt with it in an appropriate manner and the event can go on as planned.
They also agreed that this may linger on especially when they throw support for me in giving him feedback.
How are they going to handle that? Well they decided that they would tell him that they understand that he does not feel comfortable working in my team, and that since I am only temporary that the team would be reassigned to another manager for the time being. Which means no outting for them.I dunno. I guess I'm off the hook and even if he continues to talk about this to others, people who know me would dismiss this, but overall I can't see this ending good.
I'm trying really hard not to change because of this, but it does make you think.
Thanks for the support everyone.