What would you have done?

SPQR

Circling My Maximus
Jul 18, 2005
594
0
0
Colosseum - 3rd Fl. Apt 12.
Ok,

I try to accomidate my staff as best I can. I try to respect their beliefs and preach tolerance and understanding. This has wroked for me very well in the past, and so far no one has felt they anyone has gotten favouritism because of that.

So I am subbing for a manager who recently left. In the spirit of the season I asked their that team to join my team for an evening out, on me on top of it, to celebrate the holiday season and share a bit of good fun.

They were very happy as their previous manager was a bit of scrooge apparently, but a little later on one of the guys come to me and says he would like that no one drinks alcohol for the evening.

I understood why, but stated I could not do that. I respected the fact the he couldn't but I could not enforce that on the others. The only thing I could do, was enforce that they drink responsibly and maintain decorum as well as to ensure they took the appropriate means of getting home, but that would where my influence stops.

I said that I could ask that they take his feeling into consideration but that the decision was ultimately theirs.

I offered that if he would feel uncomfortable attending because of that, that he can just excuse himself from the evening, and then he and I can go out seperately and I would be happy to observe the no drinking or give him some petty cash and he could take his family out. (hindsight being 20/20 I probably should have not offered that)

He seemed to understand and left my office in the same mood he came in.

So the next thing I know I get a call from HR and now have a meeting scheduled with them tommorrow because apparently he complained that I was discriminating towards him because of his beliefs and that I even bribed him to stay quiet about it.

Did I do anything wrong? My thoughts are to just walk in there and say it like I explained it to him and let fate fall where it may.

Thoughts?
 
i think you handled that situation appropriately. telling the staff not to drink for their holiday party would offend them. this is canada, where we have the right to live our lives as we choose. if the gentleman was aginst alcohol use, then he should not have participated. I cant believe he complained over such a thing!
 
The guy is such an ass he should try and get over himself.
I think the HR thing will go your way for sure, it sounds to me like he is ramming his religious practice down everyone elses throat.
You handled it decently and this guy better have a bigger beef than this, can you get him canned somehow?
S
 
mention the offer of money was because you felt bad that he could not partake, and that you tried to make a kind gesture. What could a bribe even be for under those circumstances, to make sure he didn't speak of the party ?
 
It sounds like you handled yourself with respect and class. I am sure once you explain it to the HR people they will understand and give you tips on how to do things differently in the future (if you made an error in protocol).
 
He obviously is a SHITDISTURBER

You invited him to the party .

You did not allow him to dictate non drinking to the group .

You offered him money or a dinner privately to cater to his NEEDS as a consolation .

he turns down the party ,reason the alcohol being there ,he turns down the private dinner no alcohol ,turns down the family offer ,then he TURNS ON YOU WHAT A JERK !

The more accomadating and generous you became (most people would think that was a fantastic offerof accomodation) the less appreciative he was

Sounds like he wants your job !!!!!!!


This is a type of individual where they are never satisfied !!!!!!!!!

good luck with working with this winner !
 
No, you did nothing wrong if your story is accurate. I used to work in a big corporation and ran across many people who were looking for reasons to bitch and complain. More often than not when you try to do something good, you end up getting screwed by SOMEONE.

I have also found that the old adage rings true: there IS one in every bunch and unfortunately you found him. Just remember this old adage that applies to your situation: The needs of the many, outweigh the needs of the few, or the one......

Now me being the dick that I am, if there was a worker that I trusted explicitly I would cancel the evening entirely and have this worker let it be known that it was because of this idiot.....either that or I would call each group together in the board room and annouce: Sorry folks, the christmas night out is cancelled because I could not abide by X's request that it be an alcohol free evening.

I remember many times my department went out for special occasions and more than once they went somewhere like Hi's that specializes in steaks...I don't eat meat and the smell of burning meat makes me gag...did I bitch and moan? no, I either went and endured it or didn't go, no fuss no muss....
 
I'd offer the entire staff a Xmas bonus and leave him out. If your gonna be accused of discrimination, might as well make him pay for it....he had it coming anyways :)
 
Thanks for the advice folks. The chances of me being let go are pretty slim but I could potentially get a letter put in my record if they find any fault at all.

I will also point out to HR that I didn't consult them before answering him because I didn't want to delay my response so that it looked like I was "handling him".

Damned if you do and damned if you don't I guess.

If anything I found this situation a bit emotionally draining as I was shocked that anyone ever would feel that way towards me, especially when one of my sayings is "take a look at it from the other side."

I just hope he doesn't go around spreading this to other staff, especially my guys, as I don't want any bad blood in the department.

But thanks for the support and the kind words.

Wish me luck.
 
tboy said:
Now me being the dick that I am, if there was a worker that I trusted explicitly I would cancel the evening entirely and have this worker let it be known that it was because of this idiot.....either that or I would call each group together in the board room and annouce: Sorry folks, the christmas night out is cancelled because I could not abide by X's request that it be an alcohol free evening.

My fear is that this may happen at his own hands. The rumour mill begins. My guys are pretty loyal to me, and he being an outsider some of them may take it personal, and the last thing I want is to diffuse another situation.

What is it about the holidays?

I had a similar situation where on of my guys came to me and told me he would like some time in the afternoon for private prayer. It had to occur at the saem time every day. I said abolsutely, and even book him a meeting room so he could have some privacy.

Some of the other got wind of this and when he left during a meeting, I had a revolt on my hands.

But I explained to them that if it were anyone one of them I would never deny that request. I also reminded them that I have never questioned doctor's appointments or when they were going through tough family situation I let them go home and never penalized them with using their vacation time or their family days for that matter. I would send them home even if they didn't ask to.

When I expressed it to them that way, they agreed that I was fair and agreed I always say your life and the life of your family come first. Work will always be there. Don't take advantage of that and we'll be alright.

It's worked up until now.
 
SPQR said:
My fear is that this may happen at his own hands. The rumour mill begins. My guys are pretty loyal to me, and he being an outsider some of them may take it personal, and the last thing I want is to diffuse another situation.

What is it about the holidays?

I had a similar situation where on of my guys came to me and told me he would like some time in the afternoon for private prayer. It had to occur at the saem time every day. I said abolsutely, and even book him a meeting room so he could have some privacy.

Some of the other got wind of this and when he left during a meeting, I had a revolt on my hands.

But I explained to them that if it were anyone one of them I would never deny that request. I also reminded them that I have never questioned doctor's appointments or when they were going through tough family situation I let them go home and never penalized them with using their vacation time or their family days for that matter. I would send them home even if they didn't ask to.

When I expressed it to them that way, they agreed that I was fair and agreed I always say your life and the life of your family come first. Work will always be there. Don't take advantage of that and we'll be alright.

It's worked up until now.


Are you hiring ? :) LOL


Merry Xmas
 
This is Canada. All immigrants are welcome to practice their own beliefs, but no one should press their practices on others. He has some nerve filing a complaint.
 
Esco! said:
Just wondering but is the guy in question a Muslim?????

Well I would prefer not to say as I don't want to single out any one religion as being problematic to deal with.
 
Well lets just get it over with and eliminate all holidays, parties and fun. Perhaps then the world will be great.
 
I was in this situation before and no I am not hiring.

HR has to cover the corporate ass whenever a complaint is made.

This guy obviously sounds like a sour apple ... remember dealing with difficult people ... this is one of them, religion aside. This is not a religious matter and yet he is trying to make it one.

If the tabs on you, as you say, it shouldn't matter as long as it is not on company time or property ... it is your invite and your rules. You were nice enough to invite everyone.

If it is however on the companies tab, then you have to do what is best for the group but in the end you have to make the final decision.

Tell HR exactly what you said above ... eveything should be okay. Even if they are anal they wouldn't dare put a letter in your file, if they did I would threaten then with legal action ... trust me you would win before you speed dialed your lawyer.

Bribing with dinner ... I am sure that you have a whole staff of people who are good character witnesses.

VBB :D