What would Jesus do?

You also said this: "What is your first principal for unification of a people beyond
pure blood lines and tribalism"

Once again my answer was appropriate. Be more precise with your questions next time.
 
Have ti agree with Arc here, DQ. Our prime motivator for coming together was that it made our ability to sustain ourselves easier. The development of farming did more to set us on a course for the creation of a nation-state than anything else.
 
DonQuixote said:
No, this discussion has to do with the formation of today's Europe
out of the bloodshed of nearly 500 years commensing with the
collapse of the HRE, continuing with the many wars that transpired
from that point to the early '90s. My thesis is that the Christian
peoples and nations of Europe have a bloody history and
criticizing the Middle East Muslims is hypocritical since
we've killed more in the name of God and country than
they ever could imagine or accomplish.

Stay on point.

Why stop at 500 years ago? Wasn't that all set up by what preceeded it 500 years before? And that was preceeded by 500 years of history, etc., etc.

Its like when supporters of the IRA talk about William of Orange, as if that really has anything to do with why they blow up buildings in London....
 
ocean976124 said:
Why stop at 500 years ago? Wasn't that all set up by what preceeded it 500 years before? And that was preceeded by 500 years of history, etc., etc.

Its like when supporters of the IRA talk about William of Orange, as if that really has anything to do with why they blow up buildings in London....

The IRA wants a free and untited Ireland. But the only way that will ever happen is if something of value was found in Southern Ireland and those in the North wanted it. But blowing shit up is no longer the answer for anyone.
 
In my post, I mentioned mythology and the role of religion in a development of society. I just don't see it as the prime motivating factor. After all, you have no time to ponder existance if you spend your day trying to get enough food.
 
basketcase said:
In my post, I mentioned mythology and the role of religion in a development of society. I just don't see it as the prime motivating factor. After all, you have no time to ponder existance if you spend your day trying to get enough food.

But you do have time to give thanks for the things you have
 
Unless you have taken develop and buy into a mythology, you know that the only thanks that need to be given are to yourself for doing the hard work.
 
basketcase said:
Unless you have taken develop and buy into a mythology, you know that the only thanks that need to be given are to yourself for doing the hard work.

Can a man with an empty soul be satisfied in life? Or does he constantly seek more and when achieved does he crave even more?
 
DonQuixote said:
I agree with that but sustanance is one thing.
Self-actualization is another. Merely having
a sustaining economy does not build a clulture.

My opinion is shaped by Maslow's heirarchy of needs.
The first priority isn't food, clothing or shelter.
It is 'self-actualization'. My interpretation of the
first priority is that there must be more than
the necessities to develop a culture that will
transcend several generations.

The old cultures all contain considerations
about issues that go well beyond food, clothing
and shelter.

The ones that did not survive may have been based
on a weak economic base, suffered military defeats
or were absorbed into a more viable culture.

I think you have it backwards. The first priorities are food, oxygen, water, etc... After all other life sustaining priorities and a few other miscellaneous “needs” have been met, self-actualization comes into play. [Psychobabble Alert!]
 
DonQuixote said:
My thesis is that the Christian
peoples and nations of Europe have a bloody history and
criticizing the Middle East Muslims is hypocritical since
we've killed more in the name of God and country than
they ever could imagine or accomplish.

Stay on point.

Are you joking? Are you implying that because it is hypocritical, the West shouldn't criticize Muslims for their exceedingly bad behavior? Do the sins of our fathers prevent us from pointing out any atrocities? Are we to blind our eyes to the genocide occurring in Darfur because we participated in WWI and WWII? What exactly are you saying?
 
DonQuixote said:
Why do you continue to diminish the discussion to the
lowest common denominator? Should I suggest you
go stuff your face with your favorite food and drink?
If you do, then understand that food and libation you
indulge yourself with is the result of a custom and
tradition that is the fruit of a viable society that cares
more about culture than do you. By the way, listen
to music of your flavor and you will experiencing what
you disregard.

The Jewish culture goes back to Mesopotamia, the
city of Ur, Abraham's birthplace and home town.
Self-actualization? What a joke! I thought you were one of those evo true believers. Self-actualization by meat machines? Come on DQ you are starting to sound like one of those I.D. creationist wackos.
 
DonQuixote said:
Yes, our fathers sins are our sins. Darfur and others are all terrible tragedies.
What do you suggest as the answer? The world we live in is imperfect and
tragic. So, what's your issue? :confused:

I suggest we shine a beacon of light on atrocities and not worry about hypocrisy.
 
DonQuixote said:
Isn't self actualization what you personally strive for?
Or, are you a robot living in a totalitarian society where
inhumane laws and rules govern your behavior? :eek:

I thought you were a Republican who prizes your liberty,
happiness and a free life? Fact is, that's the result of
a succession of ideals that is rooted in the Judeo-Christian
tradition. A culture based on religious values that have
morphed into a political and cultural tradition.

You believe that there is a ghost in the machine?
 
papasmerf said:
The IRA wants a free and untited Ireland. But the only way that will ever happen is if something of value was found in Southern Ireland and those in the North wanted it. But blowing shit up is no longer the answer for anyone.
The only reason "blowing up shit is no longer the answer" for the IRA is that Lybia has cut them off and in a post-9/11 USA even the Irish-American population has shyed away from funding and arming them. They've lost their two biggest sources of money and arms, of course they're suddenly going to find peaceful solutions...
 
ocean976124 said:
The only reason "blowing up shit is no longer the answer" for the IRA is that Lybia has cut them off and in a post-9/11 USA even the Irish-American population has shyed away from funding and arming them. They've lost their two biggest sources of money and arms, of course they're suddenly going to find peaceful solutions...
I am not sure if thats the only reason. the population has changed. The south is booming econimically, the in the north, the catholics are now the majority again, and people really are tired of the violence. also if you look at the demographics- the average age has increased as in most western countries- terrorist acts tend to be done by those who are younger- as people age- the sense of rage gets termpered by experience
 
DonQuixote said:
I understand dualism to be the Cartesian theory of the separate entities of the
mind and body. I've never read Ryle. But, no, I'm not taking the issue of
self-actualization into that realm.

Self-actualization as I use it here has more to do with liberty.
By that I mean we are free agents to so choose our course in
life. To be unrestrained and unchained from repressive governance.
Where the rulors are not privileged and immune from accountability.
Total freedom is an ideal; there has to be a relative degree to allow
us to pursue goals we determine to be in our best interests. Another
way of coining it is 'self-determination' and 'self-ownership'.

Damn, I had mate in seven moves!