What went wrong with Boeing 737 Max 8

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
There was nothing more the pilots could have done.

As alarms sounded in their cockpit, the captain and first officer struggled to regain control of their stricken aircraft.

They were far too close to the ground, and needed to gain altitude. Yet when Capt Yared Getachew tried to guide the nose of the Boeing 737 upwards, an electronic system forced it down again.

Simply pulling back on his control column wasn’t enough. So he used a thumb switch as well, to adjust the aerodynamic balance of the plane, and encourage it to climb. But a few seconds later, those adjustments were automatically reversed.

The column was shaking in his hands, a mechanical warning that the aircraft was in danger of stalling and falling out of the sky. A harsh robotic voice called out “don’t sink” three times, indicating that the plane was losing height.

Together, he and First Officer Ahmednur Mohammed Omar worked quickly to find a solution. They flicked switches on the centre console to disable part of the electronics, and began using manual controls instead, in an attempt to make the plane fly normally.



Regaining control was difficult. By now the aircraft was gathering speed, and aerodynamic forces were building rapidly; it’s likely they had simply become too great for the pilots to fight against using manual controls.

Whatever the reason, they turned the electronics back on and Capt Getachew tried once more to raise the nose of the aircraft, using the thumb switch on his controls. With power assistance restored, the aircraft responded. Briefly it began to climb.

But then, inexorably, the process was reversed as the computers intervened yet again. Another alarm was now chirping urgently, warning that the speed of the plane had become dangerously high, as it began to dive towards the ground.

In desperation, Capt Getachew called on his co-pilot for help. Together, they hauled back on their control columns, using their combined strength, in a last-ditch effort to overcome the forces arrayed against them with sheer muscle power.

The dive became steeper and steeper, and the aircraft fell faster and faster, until it slammed into the ground at more than 500mph, just six minutes after taking off.

One hundred and fifty seven people from 35 different countries died.

They included 49-year-old Anthony Ngare, deputy director of communications for the UN's cultural agency, Unesco; Ethiopian flight attendant Sara Gebre Michael, a mother of three children; and retired Nigerian diplomat Abiodun Bashua.


From Canada, there were three generations of one family.

Kosha Vaidya and her husband Prerit Dixit were travelling with their two teenage daughters, Ashka and Anushka, as well as Kosha’s parents, Pannagesh and Hansini.

All had boarded the plane for an early morning flight from the Ethiopian capital Addis Ababa to Nairobi, in Kenya.

The weather was good, and the visibility was clear. The aircraft, a Boeing 737 Max 8, was new.
 
What went wrong?

Greed, US deregulated the FAA oversight "trusting" the companies to ensure the safety of the planes they were selling themselves.

Boeing sold planes with OPTIONAL safety features that airlines had to buy.

100% greed
 
A message revealed that a top pilot knew of the problem before the 2 crashes...

It all began around 2010 when Boeing was trying to catch up to Airbus who was flying high with it's 320 and 320 neo. AA had then ordered it's first Airbus. Boeing came up with the Max in 2016 which proved to be very fuel efficient. A great plane to beat Airbus...

From business insider: "But the new engines were further forward and higher up on the wings. It could cause the nose of the plane to pitch upward in some situations, like low-speed flight, or flight with a high angle-of-attack, when the plane is being flown manually. To compensate Boeing designed MCAS which would automatically activate to stabilize the pitch and nudge the aircraft's nose back down so that it feels and flies like other 737s."

Now the question is will the Max ever fly again? Will they have to reposition the engines on the wings to bypass MCAS? This could be very costly but probably the only thing to do to restore passengers confidence. I mean if in 6 month they bring the plane back saying MCAS is fixed. Would you fly on it?
 
Now the question is will the Max ever fly again? Will they have to reposition the engines on the wings to bypass MCAS? This could be very costly but probably the only thing to do to restore passengers confidence. I mean if in 6 month they bring the plane back saying MCAS is fixed. Would you fly on it?

You will not have any choice if the airplanes are re certified. Airlines can substitute equipment at will.
 
I read a few weeks ago Boeing is now having cracks show up in the 787 carbon fiber. That can't be good.
 
You will not have any choice if the airplanes are re certified. Airlines can substitute equipment at will.

Hum you mean we will have no choice to fly it if they do not make significant changes? Not sure. I fly a lot like 12 times per year and I do book according to my planes of choices. Pretty sure passengers, and mostly airline companies, will note be happy with just a software fix as it seems to be physical design problem.

Cheers,
 
According to a report on a site called Air Current right after the two plane crashes, Boeing decided to replace all their engines on 737s with more fuel efficiency saving cost of fuel for the company. However, the new engines were much heavier and larger and they found that the nose gears had to be lengthened but that caused the problem of planes being difficult to control. They then added the Manoeuvering Configurations Augmentation System (MCAS) to correct the problem but never trained their pilots to properly operate it causing these crashes. So basically, this was all about the company trying to save money at the expense of safety.
 
Hum you mean we will have no choice to fly it if they do not make significant changes? Not sure. I fly a lot like 12 times per year and I do book according to my planes of choices. Pretty sure passengers, and mostly airline companies, will note be happy with just a software fix as it seems to be physical design problem.

Cheers,

Any airline can substitute any aircraft they have if they want to. What I am trying to say is that you have no way to be sure what aircraft you will be flying in on any particular flight.

Of course, you can refuse to fly, if the airline substitutes an 737MAX for the A320 on the schedule. But that will ruin your day.

The 737MAX airplanes should all be dismantled. I am sure the engines and parts of the fuselage can be reused.
 
The 737 Max frame is still largely based on a 60's era design with all of its strengths and weaknesses. The A320 is a much newer design.