What transit idea do you support?

What transit plan do you support?

  • Rob Ford's plan

    Votes: 46 51.1%
  • Transit City

    Votes: 24 26.7%
  • A combination of Transit City and Subway

    Votes: 16 17.8%
  • Something Entirely Different (please specify)

    Votes: 4 4.4%

  • Total voters
    90
I support their current plan for Eglinton. But instead of diverting any money toward Finch or Sheppard, they get moving on a DRL.
 
I voted "Something entirely different", however, if it is a choice between Transit City and Rob Ford - I will pick Rob Ford in a heart beat.

Subways:

Eglinton
Queen (from Sherway to Victoria Park)
Extend Bloor to Sherway Gardens

LRT:

Jane
Victoria Park
Finch
 
I voted four: Something Entirely Different. The question isn't what's the best transit, or even what transit do we want. The real question is what transit will we pay for? And how?

Ford couldn't figure out how to pay for a centimetre of subway, and Council finally stopped waiting and told him it was stupidly wasteful to spend what little money had been promised just to bury some tracks along Eglinton and ignore the rest of the City.

We know what the best transit is, and we know we want it. The question is: What will we pay and how selfish will we be about it?
 
I voted four: Something Entirely Different. The question isn't what's the best transit, or even what transit do we want. The real question is what transit will we pay for? And how?

Ford couldn't figure out how to pay for a centimetre of subway, and Council finally stopped waiting and told him it was stupidly wasteful to spend what little money had been promised just to bury some tracks along Eglinton and ignore the rest of the City.

We know what the best transit is, and we know we want it. The question is: What will we pay and how selfish will we be about it?

Actually the question isn't "what's the best transit".. It's "what transit plan do you support"?

I suppose the question would have been better if it were "Do you support Rob Ford, Karen Stintz, both equally, or neither, when it comes to our transit plans?"
 
I'd support subways if people were willing to pay for them. But they are not willing to pay. An underground LRT line on Eglinton is way too little too late. Someone posted this link in another thread, showing a map of the subway system proposed in 1985. This comes close to bring our transit back up to speed. Except that I would support a line along Queen St rather than farther south to link with Union Station.

However, that is all pie-in-the-sky. Ain't going to happen. So I support Transit City, with the Eglinton line buried if they can get the funding.
 
Actually the question isn't "what's the best transit".. It's "what transit plan do you support"?

I suppose the question would have been better if it were "Do you support Rob Ford, Karen Stintz, both equally, or neither, when it comes to our transit plans?"
If 'support' means 'pay for', as in I support my kids, the clear answer is the Stintz Plan, and even that's iffy, as large-scale public works always are. Rob never put a plan forward to be approved, although he talked enough that we all sorta got the gist. However he never found anyone to 'support' the Sheppard subway, and failed to find the votes to 'support' the magical thinking that burying the Eglinton LRT at the cost of transit everywhere else in the city would somehow made it a subway.

I would and happily do 'support' transit all over the City. I'll happily pay 'better support' for better transit, and subways in general are better in general. But we're talking here and now and Rob never put forward a plan to support. Although someday he was gonna have to ask us to 'support' some sort of underground Eglinton foolishness in the sense of taking all the money we had for transit elswhere in town, he never actually did. So in fact, there's nothing to actually 'support' from him except that will-o'-the-wisp that 'subways are better'.

So's Motherhood.
 
The problem as I see it with regards to transit overall here in Toronto is that there doesn't seem to be any vision or plan for transit in the city. I also think there has not been enough discussion on a plan for public transit that takes into account the demographic shifts across the city, nor has there has been any discussion or consultation (as far as I am aware of) with experts such as urban planners, civil engineers, and computer scientists and applied mathematicians specializing in simulation/modelling of traffic patterns to determine the implications of various transit plans on city traffic (and the broader economics of the city).

Therefore, it's difficult for me to determine whether investing in either of the plans currently on the table (Ford's subway extension plan or the Transit City plan currently supported by Stintz and others in City Council) make sense for Toronto.
 
I see nine people voted for "Rob Ford's Plan". Perhaps one of you could share with the rest of us what his plan is? To date I haven't seen anything resembling a plan from him.

I would like to see subways built, paid for with road tolls and parking taxes. That would give people an incentive to ride the subway AND pay for it, all at once, ensuring both that the new subway had adequate ridership, and providing money to pay the debt. The fees should not come in until the subway is actually opened, and they should be set at a level adequate to pay the interest on the debt building the subway would generate.

That does not seem to be in the cards though. Failing that both the original Stintz plan and Transit City seemed reasonable to me. Transit City LRT's become feeders to the main subway system, boosting ridership, and eventually justifying the creation of new subway lines. The most sensible one, post Transit City, would be the Downtown Relief Line, connecting from somewhere between Pape and Victoria Park on the Danforth heading south and across to Queen Station. Later it could be extended north to join up with the existing Sheppard line, and then West along Queen and up to Dundas West Station.
 
The basic problem is too few resources ($$) to solve the entire problem (transit) properly. So the question becomes.. do you concentrate on a subset of that problem, and do it properly.. or do the entire thing, but do it half-assed.

Surface LRT is a poor solution. For all involved (both transit and car commuters), it's slower. It's less comfortable for transit riders (who likes waiting outside in the snow/rain/cold?). The only advantage is (relatively speaking) it's cheap and quick.

My preference is for subways. Underground LRT is OK.. but I get the impression that it's more the result of circumstances (we've already signed contracts..) than something anyone would rationally come up with as a solution in and of itself.

Personally, I happen to like Ford's original plan - which was to extend Sheppard and B/D to Scarborough Town Centre.. because that would work really well for me.
 
Personally, I happen to like Ford's original plan - which was to extend Sheppard and B/D to Scarborough Town Centre.. because that would work really well for me.

I haven't seen that plan. Do you have details? I've heard he wants to do this, but I have yet to see any sort of plan for getting it done. How would it be paid for?
 
The basic problem is too few resources ($$) to solve the entire problem (transit) properly. So the question becomes.. do you concentrate on a subset of that problem, and do it properly.. or do the entire thing, but do it half-assed.

Surface LRT is a poor solution. For all involved (both transit and car commuters), it's slower. It's less comfortable for transit riders (who likes waiting outside in the snow/rain/cold?). The only advantage is (relatively speaking) it's cheap and quick.

My preference is for subways. Underground LRT is OK.. but I get the impression that it's more the result of circumstances (we've already signed contracts..) than something anyone would rationally come up with as a solution in and of itself.

Personally, I happen to like Ford's original plan - which was to extend Sheppard and B/D to Scarborough Town Centre.. because that would work really well for me.
Just a wee note from the point of view of someone waiting for transit in the cold. I'd rather walk from where I did my business to a nearby stop, wait whatever minutes and get on, then when the vehicle gets me to where I'm going, get off and make the short walk to my destination, all way time enjoying the scenery as I ride.

That's far preferable to walking up to 3/4 of a kilometre along the subway route to get to the nearest station, after alreadywalking however far toget to that route then enduring the crowded escalators, platforms and trains, and waiting longer—unlikely whole subway trains will be plentiful enough to run more frequently than streetcars—only to have to walk another 3/4 km along the route to get to where you're going. All that extra walking's in the cold, and all that overlong ride was in the dark.

But no car drivers were incommoded by the sight of street transit during that trip. Hallelulia!. Neither however, were any of the other transit users all over the City served in any way at all. Burying a streetcar line under Eg that would have been more useful and comfortable at grade did nothing for their wait in the cold. Those folks can't get on the jammed, inadequate buses that are all they have today, and Rob's plan to cut services—had it sailed through last month's Budget Committee—would have cut their service even more. Everyone of them would still be waiting in that oh so goshdarn unexpected Toronto Cold everyone's suddenly so concerned about.

But now there's a plan to improve their lot as well as the folks using Eglinton. No thanks to the subway folks And when we can afford a subway, let's build one. The Stintz plan, unlike the Fords' actually has big bucks to do just that. He should thank her.
 
I see nine people voted for "Rob Ford's Plan". Perhaps one of you could share with the rest of us what his plan is? To date I haven't seen anything resembling a plan from him.

I would like to see subways built, paid for with road tolls and parking taxes. That would give people an incentive to ride the subway AND pay for it, all at once, ensuring both that the new subway had adequate ridership, and providing money to pay the debt. The fees should not come in until the subway is actually opened, and they should be set at a level adequate to pay the interest on the debt building the subway would generate.

That does not seem to be in the cards though. Failing that both the original Stintz plan and Transit City seemed reasonable to me. Transit City LRT's become feeders to the main subway system, boosting ridership, and eventually justifying the creation of new subway lines. The most sensible one, post Transit City, would be the Downtown Relief Line, connecting from somewhere between Pape and Victoria Park on the Danforth heading south and across to Queen Station. Later it could be extended north to join up with the existing Sheppard line, and then West along Queen and up to Dundas West Station.

I would also support road tolls or special taxes to pay for subway construction.

Ford doens't even want to consider this - which makes his ideas pointless.
 
I know very little about the best plan for Toronto's future transit. I suggest that everyone on this board is in the same boat. Having said that, a few points to consider.

Density... build it and developers will come. A subway will attract high-rise development assuming the city will allow SPA for density.

Cost - it is common in other cities to impose a cost to developer's on the subway line to pay for development of subway stations. The cost is passed to the consumer in the higher price of the condo.

Subways are superior to other modes of transit. I have lived in Calgary, Vancouver and used the LRT in these and many US cities such as Portland etc. I now drive a car to work. Given a choice of driving and subway, I will use subway if I am able. Given a choice of driving or LRT etc., I will drive. Do I represent a large group? I don't know but believe so.

If the poll reflects the opinion of Toronto citizens in general, the people overwhelmingly want subways and support Rob Ford. It would appear that the extremely vocal minority is out to lunch and perhaps should can the vitriolic rhetoric.
 
Where by "overwhelmingly" you mean about 40% of people, who haven't said they would support it if they actually had to PAY for it.
Presumably the people on this board are intelligent enough to understand the rudimentary implications of building a subway. Your grasping at straws is simply an indication of you being a bull-headed, mouthy naysayer that hates Ford and will take an opposing view at all costs. Your opinion is not worthy of consideration unfortunately.
 
They should build monorails... but that is more of a Shelbyville idea.
 
Presumably the people on this board are intelligent enough to understand the rudimentary implications of building a subway. Your grasping at straws is simply an indication of you being a bull-headed, mouthy naysayer that hates Ford and will take an opposing view at all costs. Your opinion is not worthy of consideration unfortunately.

I think a Sheppard Subway would be a fantastic thing, but the word "plan" implies you have figured out how to get it done, which would mean, how it's going to be paid for. I haven't seen any evidence of a plan whatsoever. Just saying "I like subways" does not count as a plan.

Transit City is a plan, it says what will be done, for how much money, and by when. Stintz submitted a plan, saying what would be done, for how much money ,and by when. Ford has not provided any sort of plan whatsoever.

For the record if I were mayor I would impose road tolls and build a Sheppard Subway line. I suspect, though, that Ford would not support road tolls and I don't believe he has any better idea at all how to build a subway--he has no plan.