What transit idea do you support?

What transit plan do you support?

  • Rob Ford's plan

    Votes: 46 51.1%
  • Transit City

    Votes: 24 26.7%
  • A combination of Transit City and Subway

    Votes: 16 17.8%
  • Something Entirely Different (please specify)

    Votes: 4 4.4%

  • Total voters
    90
That is reality!
What? That Rob never had a plan to build a subway? That is certainly the reality he and we face now. If you'd rather talk about what previous Mayors did or didn't do that may be entertaining, but it's history.

But speaking of history, and blaming instead of fixing, you do know we've only had two other Mayors? Mad Mel who did nothing much, and Miller who actually came up with a workable, fundable transit plan that had been on the books in one form or another since 1985. A plan that Rob almost destroyed just so he wouldn't have to look at streetcars on Eg. Do you really imagine it's useful complaining about Mayors in a different city and a different time? What's your fix?

Anyway, we are fortunate to live in a democracy, not a Dictatorship by Mayor. The question you should be asking is why was Rob's Excellent Transit Plan so unattractive he couldn't get seven more votes? And you only get to play the Lefty Prejudice card after you show it wasn't just Righty Prejudice that got him the few he did have. Doesn't matter, he says they're all irrelevant anyway. Or is that only the ones who don't think like him, and you that are irrelevant. See the definition of 'prejudice', and do remember I used the word 'think' very loosely in that last sentence.

But for the history buff you seem so keen to be: Just why was it that Oh so Right Mike Harris didn't just stop or postpone the real, live subway a-building at Eg West in '94 but filled it in? A sudden attack of Leftyness?
 
Last edited:
At this point, I'm willing to support whatever the hell has the most chance of actually getting done - even if it's Ford's plan.


I still can't believe we had the beginnings of an Eglinton subway as far back as '95, until that imbecile Harris shut it down.
 
At this point, I'm willing to support whatever the hell has the most chance of actually getting done - even if it's Ford's plan.

I lean towards investing in a subway system based on the future growth of the city and having the capacity to manage the population.

My big concern is about the city officials re-elected who were active followers of the former Miller administration - I do not believe they have the management skills, experience and leadership needed to handle a project this big. My biggest fear would be excessive cost over-runs, missed deadlines and `Friends`receiving lucrative contracts and spin-off deals (future headline - all of a sudden the cost effective LRT is a financial boon-doggle coming in at a higher price than the original subway plan). In the last decade or more Toronto has over-spent on numerous large projects (housing, computers, etc.) and I do not trust them to manage this project any better, save for the fact that with Ford, I believe there will be some accountability (whether he will be able to maintain or contain control is the big question).
 
What I said was "If it was Miller proposing the same plan as Ford supports I'll bet the lefty councillors who voted no would've given it the thumbs up."

Sure, but Miller would have had a plan. I don't think ANYONE is against subways. The only difference between the two sides is realism. One side is being realistic about what we can afford, and looking carefully at the numbers. The other side is blowing hot air and trying to sign us up to outrageously expensive projects that have no clearly demonstrated value and no sign of how we could pay for them. Oddly, this time around, it's the left that is standing on the side of financial realism.

Well, but that was the point--it's not only the left. The reason why the likes of Stintz are on board with Transit City or modifications of it is because it's realistic and affordable.
 
OK, then. Let's just put it in objective terms. Transit City was supported by nearly 60% of the votes, with roughly 40% more Councillors supporting Stintz than supported Ford.

well if we are going to be objective if 4 councillors voted the other way we would not have this crap...
if stintz had not stabbed the mayor in the back that would be 1 (not unreasonable as he gave her the job) if she had backed the mayor and not baisically reintroduced transit city i am pretty sure at least three of those right wing councillors would have sided with the mayor.....just saying in business i sure would not want someone like her around.....
 
well if we are going to be objective if 4 councillors voted the other way we would not have this crap...

But they did vote that way, and presumably did so after spending some time to figure out what their constituents wanted. I don't believe that Stintz has any special power to brainwash people--she simply came along and said what everybody already knew was true.

if stintz had not stabbed the mayor in the back that would be 1

The mayor is a fuckup. He has been rambling on about subways for a year and he STILL has no plans. The city simply cannot wait for him to take his pants off his head. Council had to act. The mayor wasn't acting. Somebody had to.

I think she has now got a reasonable shot of being Toronto's next mayor. She did the right thing, and she did it boldly, and it's catapult her from being just another barely heard of councillor, to currently the driving force in Toronto politics. Unlike Rob Ford, Stintz has shown that she can actually lead council. Ford's chances of re-election appear to be pretty dim, so I can't see him winning another term. Stintz draws support from both the left and the right. I think she can probably unseat him next time out.
 
i was and still am in favour of subways over LRT because of weather/traffic concerns,but what happen yesterday to me and alot of others on king west around 815-845am is the clincher for this is project to go underground.

a streetcar broke down before shaw st and it took 30 minutes for it to get it moved out of the way leading to a back-up of streetcar and fucking up traffic,wait for an accident to happen in the middle of an intersection blocking a future LRT line---can u say fucked

that cunt Stinz and the rest of the lefty commies of council should be shot
 
that cunt Stinz and the rest of the lefty commies of council should be shot

LOL, Stintz is a right wing member of the "Responsible Government Group" on council. You're hilarious.

The left do not have a majority of votes on council. Your snarling darling is losing votes because he's alienated the center and many on the right as well.
 
commies of council should be shot

You know.. There was another man who once had a very similar point of view..

His name was Adolph Hitler..

BTW, I love how common sense is becoming synonymous with "left-of-centre" politics... And "piss away what little money we have" is becoming the new slogan for the right.
 
Too many posts to read them all. I would suggest neither surface nor underground but ABOVE SURFACE like they have in Chicago.