IF it's real (and that's a big IF), the guy is a tooi and got what he deserved.
He might think it's romantic or cool to propose like that, and that it will make for a great story to tell the grand kids, but I'm sure that most women would think the exact opposite. It's a college basketball game for crying out loud. At least make it personal.
I'm speculating (based on him saying that he knew at the first date that he was going to marry her - come on buddy, grow up), but he's probably too young and he's definitely too stupid, and he's just chomping at the bit to get married, have mommy and daddy front him a lot of money to buy a house in the suburbs, buy a mini van, and start squeezing out rug rats between running to Costco and Walmart for disposable diapers.
She on the other hand wants to do some living before she gets into all that shit and the last thing she feels like doing is getting married at her age to a dipshit with his whole life planned out like it's a shiny brochure from the Coalition of the American Family. Hell, she's probaby half afraid of his glassy eyed Christian zeal.
Good for her. Go out and sew your wild oats baby. Marriage and diapers can wait. That dipshit is probably half way into his next proposal.