Water Heaters

Ringworld

Banned
Jun 29, 2013
91
0
0
Sorry for the boring question, but my water heater is leaking and must be replaced. Choices are gas tank, electric tank, or gas tankless. Currently have a power vent gas tank. Considering a gas tankless as they seem to be an emerging technology. Anyone have any experiences here? It's a small bungalow is short water pipe runs. Currently just a single occupant (me).
 
where is the best place to buy one and have it installed, from a price point of view? thinking of getting
gas tank ( tankless more expensive, gas is reasonably priced now)
 
While gas tankless are great, it is IMPOSSIBLE to justify financially. That was with a conventional flue type tank. A vented tank is more expensive so you may be closer to payback.
 
Before you go buy a tank, check to see if it is just the gasket at the heater element that is leaking. This may delay the need for a new tank for years. If you do need a tank the new three element tanks are a better choice than the 2 element tanks. Check to see if there are subsidies to purchase a new tank, ask at the big box hardware store. If you have a little knowledge of electrical and soldering you can install your own electrical tank like I did. I did check into the electrical tankless water heater, They are about three times the cost of a new three element tank.
 
is your electrical panel large enough to feed a tankless heater.... a lot of people do not go tankless because many people have to upgrade their service to accommodate it

I have the standard 100A residential service, and it's a small house with an unfinished basement. That shouldn't be a problem.

Everyone I know with gas tankless swears by them, always hot water and fast.

Yeah, I've read good things about the models currently on the market, which is the reason I'm considering it.

where is the best place to buy one and have it installed, from a price point of view? thinking of getting
gas tank ( tankless more expensive, gas is reasonably priced now)

No matter what I choose, I'm going with Home Depot. I don't know if they're the cheapest, but I'm confident that the pricing will be fair.

A gas tank is what most people in urban areas of southern Ontario have, mostly because a tank is cheaper than tankless and gas is cheaper than electricity. Thing is, I'm looking at all the costs involved, and gas tanks have to be replaced every 10 years on average, versus 15 or 20 for an electric tank or gas tankless. Installation cost is also a factor; gas tankless > gas tank > electric tank.
 
Before you go buy a tank, check to see if it is just the gasket at the heater element that is leaking. This may delay the need for a new tank for years. If you do need a tank the new three element tanks are a better choice than the 2 element tanks. Check to see if there are subsidies to purchase a new tank, ask at the big box hardware store. If you have a little knowledge of electrical and soldering you can install your own electrical tank like I did. I did check into the electrical tankless water heater, They are about three times the cost of a new three element tank.

Thanks, this is good info, but I currently have a gas tank. I agree that installing an electrical tank is probably the easiest (or cheapest) way to go from the non-recurring cost point of view.
 
Go with the tankless. It's about 500 bucks more than a direct vent water heater. Takes up less space, saves energy, constant water supply. The size you need depends on the number of showers in your home. If you have any HVAC work needed, the best time are in the spring or late summer because it's their slow period and it's reflected in their prices. Unfortunately you can really wait sometimes.
 
Stick with another gas powervent. You can buy another that will be a identical fit from places like lowes or home hardware and have a qualified person install it in half an hour. YOur savings with a tankless are not going to make up for the large cost and unless you have over 3 users you,ll have all the hot water you need and rarely run out.
 
Go with the tankless. It's about 500 bucks more than a direct vent water heater. Takes up less space, saves energy, constant water supply. The size you need depends on the number of showers in your home. If you have any HVAC work needed, the best time are in the spring or late summer because it's their slow period and it's reflected in their prices. Unfortunately you can really wait sometimes.

Does this cost also include the cost of installing the exhaust to the outside? three years ago, when I was faced with having to replace my power-vented heater, it would have been an extra $1500 to install the new vent system for the tankless heater.
 
Does this cost also include the cost of installing the exhaust to the outside? three years ago, when I was faced with having to replace my power-vented heater, it would have been an extra $1500 to install the new vent system for the tankless heater.

Yes, the difference between a 40 gallon power vent and the tankless water heater 2 years ago was 500 dollars. The tankless has to be located on an exterior wall, so the gas line has to be re-routed about 8 feet. I installed an electrical outlet for the tankless. It was 2200 all in.My tankless was sized for 2 showers/5 gallons per minute.
 
Stick with another gas powervent. You can buy another that will be a identical fit from places like lowes or home hardware and have a qualified person install it in half an hour. YOur savings with a tankless are not going to make up for the large cost and unless you have over 3 users you,ll have all the hot water you need and rarely run out.

I fully agree.
 
Thanks for all the replies. I probably won't go tankless due to placement issues with having to put it on an outside wall, costly new venting scheme, etc. These are the kind of unforeseen gotchas I was looking for.

A replacement powervent gas tank isn't just a drop-in replacement as it will require me to change the ABS exhaust ducting with PVC due to code changes since the house was built. An electric tank just requires a new 240V outlet. I'll probably do the latter.
 
A lot of misinformation here. I have a power vented tankless and will see my money back in 5 years. Mine has a life expectancy of 18 years. My only complant is not so instant but I got use to it. Your keeping a 40 gal container full of hotwater 24/7 for a couple showers and some dishes. Not sure about the electrical requirements mine just plugs into 110 volts. Cost up front is large but yoy will save.
 
is your electrical panel large enough to feed a tankless heater.... a lot of people do not go tankless because many people have to upgrade their service to accommodate it

I've never heard that one before. The power draw of a gas tankless is minimal. Probably no more power draw than a standard power vented water heater. It has a small 115v venter motor and 24v control circuits.
 
Your keeping a 40 gal container full of hotwater 24/7 for a couple showers and some dishes.QUOTE]

If any heat seeps out from a traditional tank heater it isn't a huge waste. The heat is just escaping into your house. Yes the furnace is more efficient.