Warren Kinsella is a moron. Bought rape???

krazyplayer

Member
Jun 9, 2004
484
1
18
Dying to comment but it won't let me.
This guy is an idiot!

http://www.torontosun.com/2014/01/10/prostitution-isnt-sex-its-bought-rape

Prostitution isn't sex, it's bought rape

It isn’t the world’s oldest profession. The world’s oldest profession is apathy.

Those who, when confronted with wrongdoing or injustice or abuse — and prostitution can be any one of those things, or all of them — just, you know, shrug.

“It’s been around for a long time,” they say. “There’s got to be a good reason for that.”

And then they go back to sleep.

The recent Supreme Court of Canada decision is just that: Apathetic (and pathetic). It’s dressed up in all sorts of legal finery and high-sounding words, to be sure. But, when distilled to its base elements, it just sort of gives up. Young girls being coerced into trafficking their bodies? Women being traded like commodities, and beaten and battered and worse? Innocence being lost to dirty old men, who care nothing for anything except their own grimy desires?

Who cares. The highest court in the land certainly doesn’t seem to care. If you pore through its 132-page collective shrug, the reasoning effectively comes down to this: Prostitution has been around a long time, so deal with it. In the very first sentence on the very first page, no less than the chief justice intones: “It is not a crime in Canada to sell sex for money.”

And it goes on from there.

But, as in a lot of legal reasoning, the problem lies with definitions. Is what is being sold really, truly “sex”?

Not according to a lot of people who would know. The U.S. National Centre for Missing and Exploited Children — who do, dare I say it, God’s work — think that what is being bought and sold isn’t actually “sex.” It’s something else. Says the centre’s experts: “Prostitution creates a setting whereby crimes against women and children becomes a commercial enterprise.”

When a pimp or circumstances compel a girl to sell her body, that isn’t sex, says the centre. When forced to submit “to sexual demands as a condition of employment, it is exploitation, sexual harassment, or rape — acts that are based on the prostitute’s compliance rather than her consent.” Noticeably absent from the centre’s assessment: That it is, in the benign language of the high court, “sex for money.” It’s a lot, lot less than that.

Unconvinced? Melissa Farley is a Ph.D, and the founding director of Prostitution Research and Education. She doesn’t really define it as “sex,” either. Nor is she as indifferent to prostitution as Canada’s highest court seems to be.

“Prostitution is extremely dangerous for women,” she says. “Homicide is a frequent cause of death.”

Farley goes on: “It is a cruel lie to suggest that decriminalization or legalization will protect anyone in prostitution. It is not possible to protect someone whose source of income exposes them to the likelihood of being raped on average once a week.”

Finally, the Coalition Against Trafficking in Women — because, really, that is what we are talking about, trafficking in human beings — doesn’t define this age-old commercial enterprise as “sex” either. They are much more blunt, and therefore (to me) closer to the truth.

“Prostitution cannot eliminate rape when it is itself bought rape. The connection between rape and prostitution is that women are turned into objects for men’s sexual use; they can be either bought or stolen. A culture in which women can be bought for use is one in which rape flourishes.”

So say the experts, so say former prostitutes themselves. It isn’t “sex.” It is a business. It is coerced submission. It is bought rape.

There are many, many people who, when confronted with a problem that has been around for a long time, say that it cannot be solved. Drug addiction or prostitution or myriad other social problems have been around for centuries, they say. So, ipso facto, they can’t be eliminated.

That may be. And it may be that those like me — a left-leaning type, who aspires to a better and more equal world for his daughter — will ultimately lose this debate.

But don’t you think it is better to try to make things better than to be apathetic and to simply shrug?
 
. . . This guy is an idiot!
Judging by the drivel in that newspaper column, you're quite correct.


. . . Melissa Farley, Ph.D, and the founding director of Prostitution Research and Education: “Homicide is a frequent cause of death.”
To which we might add: Death is a frequent result of homicide.
 
Warren seems to have jumped the shark a while ago with the liberal ndp merger rumour.

But on this one, I think he may have a little sneakier agenda. It will be interesting to see.
 
It would have been nice to see Warren Kinsella also come out against a form of rape that he and his Liberal Party buddies seem to approve - that being "Legalized Rape". I define legalized rape as what occurs in Canada probably thousands of times each night as women who have been forced into marriages by their families are then "forced" into having sex with their husbands. A simple marriage licence is not consent for sex.

Warren should also be looking at protecting women who allow men to spend lavishly on them when on a date and then sleep with their date later that night. Paying for sex is not just an exchange of loonies is it? Would it not be defined as any exchange of a benefit to the woman by a man?

Also if Warren Kinsella's wife is making a lower annual income than Warren could we not conclude that she is also selling her body for money. Would Warren consider her to be a prostitute and in need of protection by the state. Just asking
 
Dying to comment but it won't let me.
This guy is an idiot!

http://www.torontosun.com/2014/01/10/prostitution-isnt-sex-its-bought-rape
Warren Kinsella said:
It isn’t the world’s oldest profession. The world’s oldest profession is apathy.
I was going to make apathy my profession but couldn't be bothered to put in the effort. :confused:
No really what the hell does that even mean. How is apathy a profession one can make money from. Or better question, how can someone who is a professional writer put that sentence in an article?
 
Assuming Olivia Chow runs for mayor, Kinsella is already on record as saying he will be part of her campaign team.

I wonder if this could create a problem for Chow, given her late husband's forays into the Dundas/Spadina area. :eyebrows:
 
It would have been nice to see Warren Kinsella also come out against a form of rape that he and his Liberal Party buddies seem to approve - that being "Legalized Rape". I define legalized rape as what occurs in Canada probably thousands of times each night as women who have been forced into marriages by their families are then "forced" into having sex with their husbands. A simple marriage licence is not consent for sex.

I am having a little trouble following this....
 
Assuming Olivia Chow runs for mayor, Kinsella is already on record as saying he will be part of her campaign team.

I wonder if this could create a problem for Chow, given her late husband's forays into the Dundas/Spadina area. :eyebrows:

If he stays quiet and well in the back, he will be invaluable.
 
Warren seems to have jumped the shark a while ago with the liberal ndp merger rumour.

But on this one, I think he may have a little sneakier agenda. It will be interesting to see.

He used to be a partner in a law firm, so he is not just an idiot as one might think. Therefore he is a villain.
 
I find interesting the quoting of U.S. (feminist) sources, but never seeing any correlation between the ills they cite and that prostitution is illegal in the U.S. and hence lives in a world of shadows.
 
I don't get it. Wouldn't that make any kind of consensual sex rape?

Lets shed light on the industry, allow it and regulate it. We'd have better protection for both providers and clients, more tax income and less abuse. The only reason not to do so is an old-fashioned idea that buying sex for money is somehow immoral.
 
I don't get it. Wouldn't that make any kind of consensual sex rape?

According to feminists, all hetero sex is rape, the theory being that men always have more power, so women can never consent as long as there is inequality.
 
ig- There were 22 feminist groups that came out in support of the charter challenge. Only 5 were against decrim. Most feminists are on the harm reduction side.
It is only a small portion of the radical feminist community that is rabid. Most feminists and feminisms are at odds with radical feminists.
_____________________________________________

Warren Kinsella is an odd one to be out to damn paid sex.
Did he not dump his longterm wife (mother of his 4 kids) becuz he knocked up his much younger employee Lisa Kirby????? Now THAT"S paid sex - aka "bought rape" - but it's all good cuz now they're engaged. He also got her a spot on SUN (shit) TV!
 
According to feminists, all hetero sex is rape, the theory being that men always have more power, so women can never consent as long as there is inequality.

The world must be one big exploitation then, as there is always a balance of power swinging for or against one class of people or another.