War with Iran

gonna be a fun time for the foreseeable future people gonna have to take out second and third mortgages just to afford gas
US taxpayers give money to Israel, fund wars for Israel, and in return get hit with higher gas prices. Lets see how long they keep paying tribute.
 
I've never made such claims. I claim what is fact. AIPAC acts on behalf of a foreign country, and rhat foreign country is a massive liability to the US.

That's a perfectly legitimate criticism.
"This is a lobby i disagree with, I would like to counter them."

So why is it so hard to not go into apocalyptic rhetoric about them?
 
So your position is that the U.S. should ignore the strategic priorities of its allies because you don't think they're important?

Funny how you say it's "of no concern to the West," yet every U.S. administration for the last 45 years has disagreed.

Maybe you're smarter than every President, Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, and military planner over the last four decades.

Wait... better idea. Run for President. Make Franky your Vice President, Shaq your Secretary of State, Klatuu your Secretary of Defense, and Butler your Secretary of the Treasury. Then you can finally straighten out 45 years of American foreign policy or create a global disaster à la TrumpShart? LOL

When the strategic priorities appear to look a little like genocide, ethnic cleansing and expansionism yes they can be not just ignored, but cause to break off from them.

Isreal is no longer a good nation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
When the strategic priorities appear to look a little like genocide, ethnic cleansing and expansionism yes they can be not just ignored, but cause to break off from them.

Isreal is no longer a good nation.

And this leaves everyone with a question - what next?

There are three regional powers there - Saudia Arabia, Israel, Iran.
The USA has for decades held Israel close, been at a sort of fraught arms-length entente with Saudia Arabia, and been antagonistic to Iran.
Breaking off with Israel changes that dynamic - what does the US do to replace it?

(This is not an argument for keeping Israel close, this is a question to both you and @squeezer about how you see the situation.)
 
And this leaves everyone with a question - what next?

There are three regional powers there - Saudia Arabia, Israel, Iran.
The USA has for decades held Israel close, been at a sort of fraught arms-length entente with Saudia Arabia, and been antagonistic to Iran.
Breaking off with Israel changes that dynamic - what does the US do to replace it?

(This is not an argument for keeping Israel close, this is a question to both you and @squeezer about how you see the situation.)

Why does america need to replace Israel or maintain empire control there?
Its a bit like trying to argue who Putin should replace Ukraine with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: southpaw
Why does america need to replace Israel or maintain empire control there?
Its a bit like trying to argue who Putin should replace Ukraine with.

That is your answer for replacing, presumably.
So what does that look like?
Complete disengagement from the region?
Hostility to all three?
Treat everyone like Saudia Arabia?
What?
 
And this leaves everyone with a question - what next?

There are three regional powers there - Saudia Arabia, Israel, Iran.
The USA has for decades held Israel close, been at a sort of fraught arms-length entente with Saudia Arabia, and been antagonistic to Iran.
Breaking off with Israel changes that dynamic - what does the US do to replace it?

(This is not an argument for keeping Israel close, this is a question to both you and @squeezer about how you see the situation.)


That's exactly the question, and I don't think there's an easy answer.

If the U.S. were to distance itself from Israel, what fills the vacuum? It's not as though Saudi Arabia suddenly becomes a democratic, militarily capable replacement, nor is Iran likely to become a strategic partner.

Like it or not, Israel is one of the few countries in the region that is militarily capable, technologically advanced, politically stable (relative to the region), and consistently aligned with U.S. strategic interests. That's one reason successive administrations—Republican and Democrat alike—have maintained the relationship.

People often say, "Just abandon Israel." Fine. Then what? What regional security architecture replaces it, and who takes on the intelligence sharing, missile defense cooperation, and deterrence role that Israel currently provides?

It's easy to argue against the status quo. It's much harder to explain what a better alternative actually looks like.
 
People often say, "Just abandon Israel." Fine. Then what? What regional security architecture replaces it, and who takes on the intelligence sharing, missile defense cooperation, and deterrence role that Israel currently provides?
Now I understand what you and Valcazar are up to. You can't make a case for Israel on moral grounds, because, really, at this point, who can?

So you've turned to this "strategic asset" BS. Israel isn't an asset. Its a strategic liability. Deterrence? Against what? Its the opposite of a deterrent. It provokes Islamist blowback against the US.

To answer Valcazars question, treat them like Saudi Arabia. Sell Israel all the weapons they want. But they must buy them, not get them for free. And they don't get to dictate who the US can or cannot sell weapons to. Or who the US can make nuclear deals with. Or who rhe US goes to war with. How's that?
 
That is your answer for replacing, presumably.
So what does that look like?
Complete disengagement from the region?
Hostility to all three?
Treat everyone like Saudia Arabia?
What?

What does it look like?

End of empire.
Israel is now a liability.
Empire weapons building is a liability.
End state capitalism is a liability.
The AI bubble is a liability.

america loses control of the global oil market just as it starts to lose value.
Israel is useless as an ally except for police state gear.
Saudi Arabia is already funding their own transition.
Iran comes out in control of the Hormuz and can fund a rebuild.

The gulf will have to figure out what to do, if they can get past the Shia/Sunni issue on their own.
But america comes out like Russia right now, they tied up too much of their resources into empire armies. How much can they afford to keep them running?
The states are a mess.

I'd also suggest that what happens next is likely out of america's hands.
 
That's exactly the question, and I don't think there's an easy answer.

If the U.S. were to distance itself from Israel, what fills the vacuum? It's not as though Saudi Arabia suddenly becomes a democratic, militarily capable replacement, nor is Iran likely to become a strategic partner.

Like it or not, Israel is one of the few countries in the region that is militarily capable, technologically advanced, politically stable (relative to the region), and consistently aligned with U.S. strategic interests. That's one reason successive administrations—Republican and Democrat alike—have maintained the relationship.

People often say, "Just abandon Israel." Fine. Then what? What regional security architecture replaces it, and who takes on the intelligence sharing, missile defense cooperation, and deterrence role that Israel currently provides?

It's easy to argue against the status quo. It's much harder to explain what a better alternative actually looks like.

All true, but that bipartisan consensus about Israel's value has been eroding for several decades, mostly due to Israel's own behavior.
As the consensus frays and becomes more partisan, it changes the dynamic.

I like the idea of putting all three at the sort of arms-length area Saudi Arabia occupies, since they are all bad actors.
That does result in much more limited intelligence, but I think there is a lot to the argument that Israel hasn't been a reliable intelligence sharing partner for some time, so is it even that big a loss?

I think completely withdrawing from the region isn't too feasible and I think declaring all three hostile is insane. Elevating the other two to the level of priority Israel had in the past is a terrible idea as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
Now I understand what you and Valcazar are up to. You can't make a case for Israel on moral grounds, because, really, at this point, who can?

So you've turned to this "strategic asset" BS. Israel isn't an asset. Its a strategic liability. Deterrence? Against what? Its the opposite of a deterrent. It provokes Islamist blowback against the US.

To answer Valcazars question, treat them like Saudi Arabia. Sell Israel all the weapons they want. But they must buy them, not get them for free. And they don't get to dictate who the US can or cannot sell weapons to. Or who the US can make nuclear deals with. Or who rhe US goes to war with. How's that?

Got it, so you are in my camp - treat them all like Saudi Arabia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: southpaw
What does it look like?

End of empire.
Israel is now a liability.
Empire weapons building is a liability.
End state capitalism is a liability.
The AI bubble is a liability.

america loses control of the global oil market just as it starts to lose value.
Israel is useless as an ally except for police state gear.
Saudi Arabia is already funding their own transition.
Iran comes out in control of the Hormuz and can fund a rebuild.

The gulf will have to figure out what to do, if they can get past the Shia/Sunni issue on their own.
But america comes out like Russia right now, they tied up too much of their resources into empire armies. How much can they afford to keep them running?
The states are a mess.

I'd also suggest that what happens next is likely out of america's hands.

So you want a sudden and dramatic collapse of US Hegemony, then?
No managed decline?
 
Got it, so you are in my camp - treat them all like Saudi Arabia.
Yes, and you are in mine. Treat them all the same means no special treatment for Israel.
 
Yes, and you are in mine. Treat them all the same means no special treatment for Israel.

As rough as that transition would be (and bringing Iran up to that level of trust will be extremely difficult) it's the only one of the paths that seems not to lead to disaster in my view.
maybe you can do two at arm's length and stay hostile to Iran, but I don't think that's as stable.
 
As rough as that transition would be (and bringing Iran up to that level of trust will be extremely difficult) it's the only one of the paths that seems not to lead to disaster in my view.
maybe you can do two at arm's length and stay hostile to Iran, but I don't think that's as stable.
What need would there be for hostility to Iran, if the US no longer did Israel's bidding? Iran did not start this war. Bibi, on the other hand, was agitating for it for 30 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal