War with Iran

For decades, the U.S. has maintained military bases and alliances around the world because policymakers have viewed a forward military presence as serving American strategic interests
Serving America's strategic interests, not Israel's. Their bases in Japan, South Korea, and Germany are of no use to Israel. That's why they haven't fought any wars in those regions for the past 50 years. Pax Americana vs. Pax Judaica.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Serving America's strategic interests, not Israel's. Their bases in Japan, South Korea, and Germany are of no use to Israel. That's why they haven't fought any wars in those regions for the past 50 years. Pax Americana vs. Pax Judaica.

There were no american bases in Lebanon, Syria or Yemen.
You take the cash, a base and you're safe from Israel.
 
The Israeli alignment started at the Camp David accords, before the revolution. And that is proven by the Marine barracks bombing in Lebanon in the 80's. And the arms transfers that occured as a result of the Accords.

The US animosity occured because of support for the Shah.

The US presence exists to keep the oil flowing. Thats it. They could give a rat's ass about the politics there.


I don't think those points are mutually exclusive.

Yes, protecting energy supplies has been a major U.S. strategic objective in the Gulf for decades. The U.S. also backed the Shah before 1979. I don't think anyone disputes that.

But that still doesn't explain why so many Gulf Arab governments continue to view Iran as their principal security threat today. If it were only about oil or Washington pulling the strings, we'd expect those concerns to disappear whenever U.S. policy shifted. They haven't.

The Iranian Revolution, Tehran's stated goal of exporting it, support for regional proxy groups, missile and drone programs, and attacks by Iranian-backed groups have all reinforced those concerns over the past four decades.

The U.S. has interests in the region, and so do the Gulf states. It's overly simplistic to suggest they're merely passive actors doing whatever Washington tells them. They have their own reasons for viewing Iran as a threat.

Serving America's strategic interests, not Israel's. Their bases in Japan, South Korea, and Germany are of no use to Israel. That's why they haven't fought any wars in those regions for the past 50 years. Pax Americana vs. Pax Judaica.


I don't think anyone is arguing that every U.S. military base exists because of Israel. Of course they don't. The U.S. has global strategic interests that extend far beyond the Middle East.

But that doesn't really answer the question I've been asking. If Israel is supposedly the root of the region's instability, why have so many Arab governments, especially the Gulf states, chosen to cooperate, openly or quietly, with Israel against Iran?

That's not "Pax Judaica." That's those governments making their own strategic calculations about what they see as the greater threat.

The fact that the U.S. pursues its own interests and the fact that many Gulf states view Iran as a bigger security concern than Israel are not mutually exclusive. Both can be true at the same time.

This being said, Trumpshart is making CACA out of it all. This has to be said.
 
But that still doesn't explain why so many Gulf Arab governments continue to view Iran as their principal security threat today.

This statement is not true, this is only your personal opinion.

Todays word: Debasification
This is Iran's strategy, destroy all american bases one by one in the gulf so they have to move further and further away for attacks.
Kuwait was first, Bahrain next and now Jordan is almost wiped out.
Which means america is stuck launching attacks from Israel and Iran will hit them next.


 
This statement is not true, this is only your personal opinion.

Todays word: Debasification
This is Iran's strategy, destroy all american bases one by one in the gulf so they have to move further and further away for attacks.
Kuwait was first, Bahrain next and now Jordan is almost wiped out.
Which means america is stuck launching attacks from Israel and Iran will hit them next.


Sure, Franky. So while Iran and Iranian-backed groups have launched missile and drone attacks against Gulf states or their interests over the years, you think those governments still view Iran as a friend? :rolleyes:

Actions speak louder than words. Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain, Jordan, and others have repeatedly strengthened their security cooperation with the U.S. because they view Iran as a significant regional security threat. They may disagree with Israel on many issues, especially the Palestinian question, but that doesn't change the fact that they've consistently treated Iran as a major security concern.

That's not my personal opinion; it's reflected in their foreign and defense policies over the past several decades.
 
Sure, Franky. So while Iran and Iranian-backed groups have launched missile and drone attacks against Gulf states or their interests over the years, you think those governments still view Iran as a friend? :rolleyes:

Actions speak louder than words. Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain, Jordan, and others have repeatedly strengthened their security cooperation with the U.S. because they view Iran as a significant regional security threat. They may disagree with Israel on many issues, especially the Palestinian question, but that doesn't change the fact that they've consistently treated Iran as a major security concern.

That's not my personal opinion; it's reflected in their foreign and defense policies over the past several decades.

Prove its not just your personal opinion, back this up.

Iran hit Kuwait because 70% of the first round of attacks came from bases in Kuwait and Kuwait themselves joined in the fight.
Otherwise they are hitting american bases, not the gulf countries.


 
I don't think those points are mutually exclusive.

Yes, protecting energy supplies has been a major U.S. strategic objective in the Gulf for decades. The U.S. also backed the Shah before 1979. I don't think anyone disputes that.

But that still doesn't explain why so many Gulf Arab governments continue to view Iran as their principal security threat today. If it were only about oil or Washington pulling the strings, we'd expect those concerns to disappear whenever U.S. policy shifted. They haven't.

The Iranian Revolution, Tehran's stated goal of exporting it, support for regional proxy groups, missile and drone programs, and attacks by Iranian-backed groups have all reinforced those concerns over the past four decades.

The U.S. has interests in the region, and so do the Gulf states. It's overly simplistic to suggest they're merely passive actors doing whatever Washington tells them. They have their own reasons for viewing Iran as a threat.




I don't think anyone is arguing that every U.S. military base exists because of Israel. Of course they don't. The U.S. has global strategic interests that extend far beyond the Middle East.

But that doesn't really answer the question I've been asking. If Israel is supposedly the root of the region's instability, why have so many Arab governments, especially the Gulf states, chosen to cooperate, openly or quietly, with Israel against Iran?

That's not "Pax Judaica." That's those governments making their own strategic calculations about what they see as the greater threat.

The fact that the U.S. pursues its own interests and the fact that many Gulf states view Iran as a bigger security concern than Israel are not mutually exclusive. Both can be true at the same time.

This being said, Trumpshart is making CACA out of it all. This has to be said.

Here, I will use your language. Viewing Iran as a security concern DOES NOT MEAN they side with Israel. They can view BOTH as security concerns due to their animosity with eachother. And in fact that has now proven to be the case. Israel started a war the Gulf States didn't want. Is costing them billions and is placing the security of all their infrastructure and ability to govern at risk.

The ONLY readin they have not attacked Israel imo is the USA. Thats it. In other words, as you say, viewing both as shitty are not mutually exclusive either.
 
Prove its not just your personal opinion, back this up.

Iran hit Kuwait because 70% of the first round of attacks came from bases in Kuwait and Kuwait themselves joined in the fight.
Otherwise they are hitting american bases, not the gulf countries.


Sure Franky. The evidence isn't my opinion; it's the historical record.

The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) was created in 1981, just two years after the Iranian Revolution. One of the principal reasons was that the Gulf monarchies feared Iran's revolutionary ideology, its calls to export the revolution, and the threat it posed to their own regimes. That's documented by the U.S. Institute of Peace's Iran Primer.


The same source documents that Ayatollah Khomeini called for the overthrow of the pro-Western Gulf monarchies, that Iran was implicated in unrest in Bahrain and Kuwait, and that the Gulf states largely aligned against Iran during the Iran-Iraq War.

So no, concern about Iran didn't suddenly begin because of a U.S. base or because of Israel. Those concerns predate any open Gulf-Israeli security cooperation by decades.

As for Kuwait, you're arguing Iran struck it because it was supporting U.S. operations. Fine, that still proves my point. If a country is being targeted by Iran for its policies and security alignment, why wouldn't it regard Iran as a security threat?
 
Here, I will use your language. Viewing Iran as a security concern DOES NOT MEAN they side with Israel. They can view BOTH as security concerns due to their animosity with eachother. And in fact that has now proven to be the case. Israel started a war the Gulf States didn't want. Is costing them billions and is placing the security of all their infrastructure and ability to govern at risk.

The ONLY readin they have not attacked Israel imo is the USA. Thats it. In other words, as you say, viewing both as shitty are not mutually exclusive either.


You're proving my point.

Nobody said they have to like Israel. They can dislike both Israel and Iran.

The question is: Which one do they see as the bigger threat?

Their actions answer that. They host U.S. bases, buy American weapons, cooperate on missile defense, and several have normalized or quietly expanded ties with Israel. They haven't aligned with Iran.

Governments vote with their actions, not their slogans.
 
But that doesn't really answer the question I've been asking. If Israel is supposedly the root of the region's instability, why have so many Arab governments, especially the Gulf states, chosen to cooperate, openly or quietly, with Israel against Iran?
And you repeatedly disregard my answer. It is of no concern to the west. Lets accept your assumption. Iran is a far greater threat to the Arabs than Israel. SO WHAT?

Let the Arabs cooperate, openly or quietly, with Israel against Iran. Do you think the US would have gotten involved if it weren't for Israel?
 
You're proving my point.

Nobody said they have to like Israel. They can dislike both Israel and Iran.

The question is: Which one do they see as the bigger threat?

Their actions answer that. They host U.S. bases, buy American weapons, cooperate on missile defense, and several have normalized or quietly expanded ties with Israel. They haven't aligned with Iran.

Governments vote with their actions, not their slogans.

I think, again, its Israel. Who started the war? Who is derailing peace talks? Who has government officials discussing Greater Isreal that includes gulf state territories? Who invaded Lebanon, Gaza, took the Golan Heights, ethnic cleansing in the West Bank?

I'd say those constitute actions, not words.

The strait was open before. There was a Nuclear deal. Now there isn't. Thats directly on the USA and Isreal.
 
Sure Franky. The evidence isn't my opinion; it's the historical record.

The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) was created in 1981, just two years after the Iranian Revolution. One of the principal reasons was that the Gulf monarchies feared Iran's revolutionary ideology, its calls to export the revolution, and the threat it posed to their own regimes. That's documented by the U.S. Institute of Peace's Iran Primer.


The same source documents that Ayatollah Khomeini called for the overthrow of the pro-Western Gulf monarchies, that Iran was implicated in unrest in Bahrain and Kuwait, and that the Gulf states largely aligned against Iran during the Iran-Iraq War.

So no, concern about Iran didn't suddenly begin because of a U.S. base or because of Israel. Those concerns predate any open Gulf-Israeli security cooperation by decades.

That's an american policy think tank.
That's a bit like pointing to AIPAC and saying Israel is well liked.

As for Kuwait, you're arguing Iran struck it because it was supporting U.S. operations. Fine, that still proves my point. If a country is being targeted by Iran for its policies and security alignment, why wouldn't it regard Iran as a security threat?

Kuwait is not being targeted for policies, its being targeted because they joined the fight.
Jordan is just hosting bases and only bases have been hit.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
And you repeatedly disregard my answer. It is of no concern to the west. Lets accept your assumption. Iran is a far greater threat to the Arabs than Israel. SO WHAT?

Let the Arabs cooperate, openly or quietly, with Israel against Iran. Do you think the US would have gotten involved if it weren't for Israel?




So your position is that the U.S. should ignore the strategic priorities of its allies because you don't think they're important?

Funny how you say it's "of no concern to the West," yet every U.S. administration for the last 45 years has disagreed.

Maybe you're smarter than every President, Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, and military planner over the last four decades.

Wait... better idea. Run for President. Make Franky your Vice President, Shaq your Secretary of State, Klatuu your Secretary of Defense, and Butler your Secretary of the Treasury. Then you can finally straighten out 45 years of American foreign policy or create a global disaster à la TrumpShart? LOL
 
Maybe you're smarter than every President, Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, and military planner over the last four decades.
Maybe their voters are smarter. Why not do what their voters want? Because thats not who they really answer to.