War with Iran

Yes.
So therefore not owned.
They are very influential and powerful, no one has argued against that point.
Yes.
Which is proof that you are all overstating the case when you say "owned".

Its like arguing that because some slaves were freed they were never owned.

The only change is the equation.
AIPAC direct cash, advertising money and media influence isn't worth more than taking a stand against Israel.
Prior to the last few months, refusing AIPAC backing was political suicide in america.
You know this.

This is the first time in 30 or so years that american politicians can make that move.
Interesting how much this is upsetting you, isn't it?
 
Yes.
Unless you just think the idea of war crimes is weak woke bullshit and wars are better conducted without any pretense of war crimes.
Which seems to be your position here.

So you support taking all of Israeli leadership to the ICC over apartheid, illegal wars, occupation and genocide.
Or does this again only apply to the victims of Israeli aggressions.
 
So what personal gain do you think trump was after here?
Did someone tell him he could take all their oil as easily as Venezuela?
Or is there some other reason he decided to go against the advice of almost everyone around him?

What transactional reason was their for starting this war 3 times?


I think it's a lot simpler than people are making it.

I think Trump believed it would be easy with some coaxing from BIBI of course. A quick in and out, declare victory, take a victory lap, and move on. Kind of like how he talked about Venezuela, even though people around him were warning it wouldn't be that simple.

Trump has a long history of believing his instincts are better than the experts'. Sometimes that works for him but most of the time it doesn't.

He's going to have more problems now....

 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
No, he’s got it right. Vote the wrong way and lose your money. It happened.

It did.
They voted against the group who gave them money and endorsed them.
That group no longer supports them.

So by your definition, every politician is owned by every donor they have ever accepted money from.

They might hang on to their seats. It’s a lesson to those still receiving genocide funds. Fortunately, reporters like Ryan exposed the lobby and its sycophants in Congress - voting according to AIPAC to receive AIPAC genocide funding is often becoming re-election suicide. This kind of reporting changed the landscape.

ROTFL!

No one knew about powerful lobbyists until Ryan Grim ?

Holy shit that's funny.

These politicians don’t want to sacrifice themselves for POS Nation and it‘s foreign agent - AIPAC.


OMG, these politicians weren't owned?
How shocking. :rolleyes:
 
Influence isn't ownership.
Semantics.
Nobody thinks politicians are literally property.
"Owned" is common political shorthand for politicians who consistently do a lobby's bidding instead of representing their own country's interests.
Question, Shaquille.
Is the war going on now exactly the same as it would have unfolded with Biden in charge?
If so, why did Netanyahu express a clear preference for Trump?
I don't know. If I remember correctly Biden was apparently given options to strike Iran's nuclear facilities when he was in power.
While it didn't happen, I don't have any confidence that Biden would have acted much differently if elections weren't around the corner.
He would have also kept Israel funded and armed and continued to enable the genocide in Gaza.
While both parties have slightly different approaches to enacting foreign policy, the overarching policy is to be pro-Israel, no matter what.
I don't see that as any materially significant shift in foreign policy towards Israel.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Oh god, you're still trying to blame the voters for Harris losing the election over AIPAC and support of the genocide.
Why aren't you blaming Israel for screwing over america?
They put trump in office and they drove him to war in Iran and they are driving the destruction of america.

Oh, they put Trump in office?
So they did have a policy difference with Biden and worked against him to remove him?
Interesting.

trump targeted desalination plants.

Have I ever implied Trump's administration isn't committing war crimes?
He campaigned on "Do more war crimes because our enemies are savages and don't respect the rules of war. War crimes make wars faster and less awful."
 
So now you are arguing you can never 'own' a politician because they could always just do what they want.
That's a very naive argument coming from you, val.
Do you think anyone's going to buy it?

The interesting part of this debate is that you've mostly moved on from whining about why Harris lost to now defending AIPAC.
You must understand how threatened Israel now are with AIPAC becoming as toxic as I warned you would happen, with you know, genocide.

And here we see how deformed your thinking is.

I am objecting to the use of the term "owned" since it is imprecise and unhelpful.
You have turned this into "You are defending AIPAC".

This is fundamental to the Frankie experience.
You are so incapable of thinking clearly, that any pushback is turned into a caricature argument you make up to contend against.
 
Yes.
Unless you just think the idea of war crimes is weak woke bullshit and wars are better conducted without any pretense of war crimes.
Which seems to be your position here.
Sometimes I feel like the idea of “terrorism” and “War Crimes” are ideas invented by those in power to shame efforts of resistance by those they are oppressing.

☹️
 
You're mixing up a few different things in my humble opinion.

AIPAC is an American lobbying organization. It's not registered under FARA because it argues it isn't acting as an agent of a foreign government. Whether people agree with that is a separate debate, but that's the legal distinction.

Yes, it is a legal distinction, but there is a strong argument that AIPAC shouldn't be classified as domestic.
It's been a back and forth legal argument for decades.

Simply dismissing it out of hand isn't really appropriate.

And no, foreign governments can't directly donate to U.S. campaigns. That doesn't mean Americans who support a particular foreign policy position can't organize, lobby, or donate through U.S.-based political action committees. That's true whether the issue is Israel, Taiwan, Ukraine, Cuba, or anything else.

There are other domestic lobbying groups that consider themselves linked to foreign countries.
I do think it is fair to say none has the power or influence of AIPAC, but the structure isn't unique from what I understand.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
You're moving the goalposts.
Your original claim wasn't that AIPAC is influential. Now it's that U.S. politicians are completely "owned." Those are two different arguments.
No. My original claim was that U.S. politicians are bought and owned by AIPAC. Again, semantics.
Nobody thinks politicians are literally property.
"Owned" is common political shorthand for politicians who consistently do a lobby's bidding instead of representing their own country's interests.
As for policy differences, there have absolutely been disagreements between Washington and Israeli governments over the years. The Obama administration publicly opposed settlement expansion and allowed U.N. Security Council Resolution 2334 criticizing settlements to pass by abstaining.
Oh, big whoop.
They issued statements criticizing settlements and abstained on a UN vote.
Meanwhile, they continued funding and arming Israel while settlement expansion continued unabated.
That's not a meaningful change in policy.
It's empty statements, rhetoric accompanied by policy continuity.
Talk about setting an extremely low bar lmfao.
You may think those measures were weak or insufficient.
Everybody thinks they were weak and insufficient.
But I was challenging your assertion that these disagreements resulted in meaningful shifts in U.S. foreign policy.
They didn't. A genuine foreign policy shift would look like conditioning or suspending military aid, imposing consequences, or consistently voting against Israel in international forums.
If your actions don't fundamentally change policy and all you have are statements of disagreement, you cannot credibly call that a shift in foreign policy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
It did.
They voted against the group who gave them money and endorsed them.
That group no longer supports them.

So by your definition, every politician is owned by every donor they have ever accepted money from.



ROTFL!

No one knew about powerful lobbyists until Ryan Grim ?

Holy shit that's funny.



OMG, these politicians weren't owned?
How shocking. :rolleyes:
Amateurish
 

And right there we see the subtlety and I'd really like a native speaker to translate.

The tweet makes sure to say that Netanyahu says “We own the senate, the congress [...]"
The actual clip translation says "USA is not a unified block. We have the senate, the congress, [...] "

Which is closer to the truth of what he said?
 
So what personal gain do you think trump was after here?
Did someone tell him he could take all their oil as easily as Venezuela?
Or is there some other reason he decided to go against the advice of almost everyone around him?

What transactional reason was their for starting this war 3 times?

Very likely people did tell him it would be as easy as Venezuela.
He also likes to feel strong and powerful.
And, once started, he can't admit he is losing or made to look bad.
 
Its like arguing that because some slaves were freed they were never owned.

No.
Not really.
But cool for you to go straight to the slavery angle.

The only change is the equation.
AIPAC direct cash, advertising money and media influence isn't worth more than taking a stand against Israel.
Prior to the last few months, refusing AIPAC backing was political suicide in america.
You know this.

So AIPAC had a 100% success rate until the last few months?
No one AIPAC endorsed against ever lost?

This is the first time in 30 or so years that american politicians can make that move.
Interesting how much this is upsetting you, isn't it?

It isn't upsetting me at all.
That's all in your head.
It's long overdue, in fact.
I've been calling for a realignment with the relationship with Israel since the early 2000s.

But since you can't think past your obsessions, you have invented another me in your head.
 
So you support taking all of Israeli leadership to the ICC over apartheid, illegal wars, occupation and genocide.
Or does this again only apply to the victims of Israeli aggressions.

Why on earth would I be opposed to Israeli leaders being brought before the ICC?
 
Semantics.
Nobody thinks politicians are literally property.

Apparently Frankie does.

"Owned" is common political shorthand for politicians who consistently do a lobby's bidding instead of representing their own country's interests.

And it is chosen deliberately because it overstates the case and implies things that aren't necessarily true.
Since you, yourself here are coming out and admitting it is just a bit of hyperbole, you won't die on the hill of insisting it must be the term used.
Since neither you, I, or squeezer object to pointing out the very obvious fact that AIPAC is very influential, you won't fight us on this since using "owned" only matters as a piece of political rhetoric.

I don't know. If I remember correctly Biden was apparently given options to strike Iran's nuclear facilities when he was in power.
While it didn't happen, I don't have any confidence that Biden would have acted much differently if elections weren't around the corner.
He would have also kept Israel funded and armed and continued to enable the genocide in Gaza.
While both parties have slightly different approaches to enacting foreign policy, the overarching policy is to be pro-Israel, no matter what.
I don't see that as any materially significant shift in foreign policy towards Israel.

So you disagree with Netanyahu, and the Israeli right wing who did see that difference and worked very hard to get Trump elected?
 
Sometimes I feel like the idea of “terrorism” and “War Crimes” are ideas invented by those in power to shame efforts of resistance by those they are oppressing.

☹

Terrorism can feel like that pretty often. (While obviously not invented for that reason, it does get used that way a lot.)
War crimes less so.