Vitamin E, Selenium, and Prostate Cancer

jwmorrice

Gentleman by Profession
Jun 30, 2003
7,133
2
0
In the laboratory.
http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/10/28/disappointing-news-on-vitamin-e-and-selenium/?hp

October 28, 2008, 2:45 pm
Disappointing News on Vitamin E and Selenium


A major trial studying whether simple nutritional supplements could lower a man’s risk for prostate cancer has ended amidst worries that the treatments may do more harm than good.

The SELECT trial, which stands for the Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial, was studying whether selenium and vitamin E, either alone or in combination, could lower a man’s risk for prostate cancer. More than 35,000 men were taking part, making it one of the largest and best studies of a vitamin or supplement.

But the National Cancer Institute announced Monday that the trial, which was scheduled to end in 2011 after seven years, is being halted early. A review of the data shows no benefit in using the supplements to prevent prostate cancer. In addition, slightly more users of vitamin E were getting prostate cancer, and slightly more selenium-only users were developing diabetes.

The findings are a major setback in the effort to prevent prostate cancer, which is diagnosed in about 200,000 men in the United States each year. While most men diagnosed with the disease are cured, treatments can be debilitating, rendering men incontinent and impotent.

“We were hoping something simple like this would be helpful, but it wasn’t,” said Dr. Eric Klein, national study coordinator for SELECT and vice chairman of the Glickman Urological and Kidney Institute at the Cleveland Clinic. “Everyone believes things that are natural are good for you. That’s not always the case.”

The study results are particularly disappointing because the evidence suggesting a benefit had been so promising. An earlier trial of beta carotene and vitamin E use in smokers had produced disappointing results: the smokers receiving beta carotene had a higher risk of cancer. But the data also showed that vitamin E users had one-third the risk for prostate cancer. Another study of selenium and skin cancer also showed the supplement group had higher rates of skin cancer — but that study also suggested a 50 percent lower risk for prostate cancer among selenium users.

But neither of those studies was designed to directly measure prostate cancer risk. That means a number of variables, such as the men’s age, how they were screened and their family histories, could have influenced the results. Because the SELECT study was a randomized controlled clinical trial, it presents a truer picture of the real effects of the supplements on prostate cancer risk.

While the SELECT results are disappointing, the study shows how important it is that vitamins and supplements be well studied before consumers use them as preventative agents, Dr. Klein notes. In recent years, several major studies of vitamins and supplements have produced disappointing results, showing that the treatment didn’t help and sometimes appeared to cause harm.

“We asked a scientific question, and we had a hypothesis about these agents,” Dr. Klein said. “It’s a great trial. Men were equally randomized, compliance rates were incredibly high. The agents simply don’t work to prevent prostate cancer.”

The trends for higher prostate cancer rates and diabetes among the vitamin E and selenium users aren’t statistically significant and could be due to chance. However the men in the study will continue to be monitored to determine any additional effects.

The dose being studied in SELECT was 200 micrograms of selenium and 400 international units of vitamin E. By comparison, most multivitamins contain about 50 micrograms of selenium and 30 to 200 international units of vitamin E. To learn more about the trial, go to the National Cancer Institute’s Web site.
 
I've read that zinc is supposed to be good for one's prostate. I wonder why they didn't include it in the test.
 
I bet they were taking synthetic vitamin E and Selenate.
Stay away, far far away from synthetic vitamins unless you absolutely have to

The best vitamins and minerals are the ones extracted from natural food, fruits or herbs
 
Esco! said:
I bet they were taking synthetic vitamin E and Selenate.
Stay away, far far away from synthetic vitamins unless you absolutely have to

The best vitamins and minerals are the ones extracted from natural food, fruits or herbs
side note....is the Vitamins and supplements any good in quality at the Costco!? i'm fearful it isn't good.
 
herames said:
side note....is the Vitamins and supplements any good in quality at the Costco!? i'm fearful it isn't good.
I'm not sure, I dont shop at Costco

Best brands IMO are:

Natural Factors
Optimum Nutrition
Swiss
Sisu
 
Esco! said:
I'm not sure, I dont shop at Costco

Best brands IMO are:

Natural Factors
Optimum Nutrition
Swiss
Sisu
AOR, NOW, and FACTORS seems to be most Naturopaths picks....Some how, many years i was told by N-paths Swiss brand was BS quality
 
Esco! said:
The best vitamins and minerals are the ones extracted from natural food, fruits or herbs

A molecule is a molecule is a molecule - unless it's a mirror-image molecule.

jwm
 
jwmorrice said:
A molecule is a molecule is a molecule - unless it's a mirror-image molecule.
jwm
Not true!!

Some synthetic vitamins can start to be rejected by the body after long-term use.
Natural vitamins are never rejected unless you take more than recommended dosages. Even then its still hard to reach toxic levels.

Link: http://www.organicconsumers.org/nutricon/qa.cfm


Here's another article: http://www.buzzle.com/editorials/8-8-2006-104916.asp
Some claim that synthetic vitamins are just as good as all-natural vitamins made from whole-food sources. Of course, the manufacturers of synthetic vitamins want you to believe this, while distributors of natural vitamins (like myself) do not. Both sides have an agenda. If synthetic vitamins really are just as good as natural vitamins, there is no logical reason to take natural vitamins because synthetic vitamins are much cheaper.

Since I am a distributor of natural vitamins, you might assume that I am biased. Nevertheless, I sincerely believe the weight of evidence is on my side. Numerous studies conclude that synthetic vitamins are simply not as effective. In fact, they may even be dangerous.
 
More studies: http://www.buzzle.com/editorials/8-8-2006-104916.asp

Two Independent Studies Conclude: Taking Synthetic Vitamins is Worse Than Starvation

Two independent studies on synthetic vitamins both reached the conclusion that taking synthetic vitamins is worse than starvation. One was a recent Finnish study published in the New England Journal of Medicine; the other was the result of experiments performed at the University of California in Berkley.

Why Silver Foxes Don't Take Synthetic Vitamins

As early as 1940, a Scandinavian Veterinarian Journal detailed a vitamin experiment performed on Silver Foxes. The first group was fed synthetic Vitamin B while the second group was given all-natural sources of B complex. Three things happened to the first group:

1) They did not grow.

2) The quality of their fur deteriorated. And

3) they died prematurely.

(The Scandinavian Veterinarian Journal, 1940, Volume 30.)

Meanwhile, everything was normal with the second group.

Synthetic Vitamin D Causes Complications In Pregnancy

Another report involved synthetic Vitamin D and human pregnancy. Vitamin D was given to 500 pregnant women. Some were given synthetic Vitamin D, others were given natural Vitamin D. All the women given synthetic Vitamin D developed diseased kidneys. None of the women given natural Vitamin D had any problems with their kidneys.( Dr. Weston A. Prince, Nutrition and Physical Degeneration.)

Synthetic Vitamin B Causes Sterility in Pigs

Another report involved pigs and Vitamin B. This study was done clear back in 1939. The first group of pigs was fed synthetic Vitamin B. The second group was fed natural Vitamin B. All of the offspring from the pigs fed synthetic Vitamin B were sterile. None of the offspring from the parents fed natural Vitamin B were sterile. (Study by Dr. Barnett Sure, Jol. Nurt., Aug., 1939)

So unless you're a nutritional masochist, getting your nutrients from whole food sources is your best option because whole foods provide complete vitamins and minerals rather than fractions of them.
 
You've cited a couple studies from before the middle of the last century. Surely if you're going to go out on a limb and claim that identical molecules do not behave identically, you need to provide some studies a little more current and some sources a little more credible. I throw it back to you since vitamins and supplements are obviously things you find interesting. Me? Not so much. However, I'm no longer going to take my Vitamin E pills.

Incidentally, here's more info on the supplements that were provided to the subjects in the SELECT cancer study:

http://www.cancer.gov/newscenter/pressreleases/SELECTQandA
15. How much selenium was being used in SELECT? What risks were involved with taking selenium?

The amount of selenium (provided as l-selenomethionine) was 200 micrograms (µg) daily. Although the initial results of the Nutritional Prevention of Cancer Trial showed an overall decrease in cancer incidence from selenium, a 2003 update reported 17 percent more new nonmelanoma skin cancers in the selenium group compared with the placebo group (7). It is not clear how these results would apply to men who did not already have skin cancer when they enrolled in SELECT, or to men who are not at increased risk for skin cancer.

Since the start of SELECT, four studies have been published looking at the effect of selenium on blood glucose and risk of diabetes: two studies suggested that higher levels of selenium taken from supplements or received naturally were associated with an increased risk of diabetes. One study showed no association between the two, and one showed that people with higher levels of selenium in their blood had a reduced risk of diabetes (8-11). Starting in early 2007, the SELECT DSMC was specifically asked to review the study data for cases of diabetes because of these findings.

16. How much vitamin E was being used in SELECT? What risks were involved?

The amount of vitamin E (provided as dl-alpha-tocopherol acetate) was 400 milligrams (mg), which is equivalent to 400 International Units (IU) per day. This dose of vitamin E can thin the blood somewhat. Men with uncontrolled high blood pressure were not eligible to take part in SELECT because taking this much vitamin E might have increased their risk of stroke.

Vitamin E has been shown to increase the risk of some cardiovascular conditions. In a 2005 study, men and women with vascular disease or diabetes who took 400 IU of vitamin E daily for 7 years had a 13 percent increased risk of heart failure compared with participants taking a placebo (12). Heart failure is a condition in which the heart's ability to pump blood is weakened. A 2005 analysis of several studies in which people with various medical problems took vitamin E suggested a link between high doses of vitamin E (400 IU or more) and increased mortality (13). The continued follow up of SELECT participants will provide more information about this possible risk.


jwm