$USD: your opinion

There was lots of debt in the late 80s and early 90s, yet gold went nowhere.

"...during the 1970s, gold's valuation rose at significantly faster rates than money supply. Neoclassical economists explain this with the inherently volatile nature of gold. However, volatility simply cannot explain this 10-year trend. Volatility relates to variability in prices around the trend, not to the direction of the trend.

Neoclassical economists have no meaningful explanation here, except to resort to volatility of gold and irrational behavior of gold "bugs". On the other hand, the explanation by Austrian economists is straightforward and logical: As inflation accelerated throughout the 1970s, the discounting mechanism of the Gold Market resulted in accelerating price of gold from the rising inflationary expectations.

The third fundamental observation is the clear possibility of a long-term divergence between the value (or "price") of gold and global money supply. This divergence is obvious for the period of 1980-2000. The neoclassical school has not offered a satisfactory explanation for this phenomenon except to point out disparagingly that gold is a "barbarous relic", "irrelevant" or "dead".

The Austrian explanation, however, is again quite straightforward. The period was generally characterized by disinflation, driven by productivity gains from industry and agriculture, so the discounting mechanism produced lower Gold Prices due to the falling inflationary expectations that more than offset increases in money supply.

This analysis leads us to speculate that while divergences caused by inflationary expectations can last for a very long time, even decades, the long-term price of gold is driven by global money supply."

So the money supply/debt theory is actually pretty useless for determing the direction of gold IMO, uless you have a 25 year time horizon. I think really gold just gets the attention of the world every few decades, they run the price up, everybody jumps in, the gold bugs 'explain' why it is going up, then it settles down again.
 
I am afraid that I too have no idea how bubbles from. Maybe they bahahahah from LET ALONE?

How you can you find it offensive and fucking hilarious at the same time? I thought being offended made one predominantly angry. Then it wouldn't be a fun fact, let alone.
 
The US$ is in absolute freefall now. Which means Canada is FUCKED. There is NO WAY we can compete with the yankees with a 108 loonie.. this could be utter devastation for Canadian manufacturing and retail.
 
The US$ is in absolute freefall now. Which means Canada is FUCKED. There is NO WAY we can compete with the yankees with a 108 loonie.. this could be utter devastation for Canadian manufacturing and retail.

That is the least of our troubles. The savings of the middle class will be wiped out as the fiat money loses much of its value.
 
That is the least of our troubles. The savings of the middle class will be wiped out as the fiat money loses much of its value.

Hard to say, ultimately the govts are sovereign. And fiat currency is a LARGE part of their sovereign power. If they act in concert they can significantly slash back money supply, wipe out commodites and alternative currencies. Imagine if, for example, they eliminated investment status for silver and commodities ETFs and taxed transaction of commodities ETFs the SAME as the underlying? Wanna buy a Silver ETF? 13% HST please....selling? 13% thanks.. If the Euros did that it would WIPE OUT commodities speculation. What about the economic carnage? Sure it would be major.. but how devastating would fiat currency failure be in comparision?
 
Hard to say, ultimately the govts are sovereign. And fiat currency is a LARGE part of their sovereign power. If they act in concert they can significantly slash back money supply, wipe out commodites and alternative currencies. Imagine if, for example, they eliminated investment status for silver and commodities ETFs and taxed transaction of commodities ETFs the SAME as the underlying? Wanna buy a Silver ETF? 13% HST please....selling? 13% thanks.. If the Euros did that it would WIPE OUT commodities speculation. What about the economic carnage? Sure it would be major.. but how devastating would fiat currency failure be in comparision?

Correct. I believe margin requirements were increased on silver futures this week.
 
Correct. I believe margin requirements were increased on silver futures this week.

Are they increasing the margin req daily now..lol...wow.. A warning shot across the bow of the USS Speculator? Also. a MAJOR change in Euro direction and rumors Greece may bail out of the Euro.
 
Exchanges increase margin when volatility gets high enough that a one-day move could cause underfinanced participants to be wiped out. It's not that they want to protect those people: they want to protect the exchange itself. In a futures market your counterparty risk is the exchange itself, not the individual you transacted with, so the exchange will set margins at whatever level they need to to protect themselves. Firms do the same thing, and often wil require their clients to post higher margins than the minimum mandated by the exchanges for the same reason.

So no 'warning shots'.
 
Exchanges increase margin when volatility gets high enough that a one-day move could cause underfinanced participants to be wiped out. It's not that they want to protect those people: they want to protect the exchange itself. In a futures market your counterparty risk is the exchange itself, not the individual you transacted with, so the exchange will set margins at whatever level they need to to protect themselves. Firms do the same thing, and often wil require their clients to post higher margins than the minimum mandated by the exchanges for the same reason.

So no 'warning shots'.

Except that exchanges do not raise margin requirements when volatility gets high. They do it when the price of the commodity gets high.
 
If the commodity price gets high, than the volatility measured in dollars increases as well on averge. So the margin should be raised along with it.

They do it whenever they want for whatever reason they want. Of course if the commodity price has tripled and the margin has doubled, the margin is in fact less than it was before in percentage terms.

But my reasons stand. What is the PURPOSE of margin? To ensure their protection form sudden swings wiping out participants so that there is a shortfall that the exchange is responsible for.

Here is a quick look at the initial margin requirement for spec traders (legitimate hedgers/members have a lower requirement) over several dates they were increased:

Date: November 10th, 2010
Spot Price: $27.18
Contract Value: $135,900 (5000 x $27.18)
Margin Requirement: $8,775 (6.5% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 15:1

Date: November 16th, 2010
Spot Price: $25.40
Contract Value: $127,000 (5000 x $25.40)
Margin Requirement: $9,788 (7.7% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 13:1

Date: December 17th, 2010
Spot Price: $29.15
Contract Value: $145,750 (5000 x $29.15)
Margin Requirement: $10,463 (7.2% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 14:1

Date: January 21st, 2011
Spot Price: $27.45
Contract Value: $137,250 (5000 x $27.45)
Margin Requirement: $11,138 (8.1% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 12:1

Date: March 24th, 2011
Spot Price: $37.26
Contract Value: $186,300 (5000 x $37.26)
Margin Requirement: $11,745 (6.3% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 16:1



Notice how the leverage remains within a fairly small range? As you can see while the margin requirements have increased quite significantly over the last 6 months the amount of leverage available is still relatively similar.
 
Except that exchanges do not raise margin requirements when volatility gets high. They do it when the price of the commodity gets high.

I think you are 100% dead worng - this is from the CME itself:

At CME Group, we’re intently focused on risk management. In over a century, we have not experienced a default. In more than a century, there has never been a failure by a clearing member to meet a performance bond call or its delivery obligations; nor has there been a failure of a clearing member firm resulting in a loss of customer funds. As part of our overall risk management program, margins are adjusted frequently across all of our products based on market volatility. When daily price moves become more volatile, we typically raise margins to account for the increased risk. Likewise, when daily price moves become less volatile, margins typically go down because the risk of the position also decreases.

Margins are set as part of the neutral risk management services we provide. They aren’t a means to move a market one way or another, or to encourage or discourage participation from one kind of market participant or another. Rather, margin is one of many risk management tools that help us assess overall portfolio risk to protect market participants and the market as a whole.

There are two main margin philosophies that clearing houses can have. First, a clearing house could set margins sufficiently high to cover all possible volatility environments. Changes are less frequent, but margins are higher. Second, and the CME Clearing approach, is to ensure that margins are set to cover 99 percent of the potential price moves. Margins then are lower in less volatile periods and higher in more volatile periods. Changes are often made when the volatility environment experiences a sustained change.

http://openmarkets.cmegroup.com/clearing/understanding-margin-changes/
 
As to the OP...speculating on currency moves has got to be the closest thing there is to an absolute coin toss type gamble. You have absolutely no clue what the US versus Canadian dollar will be in years from now...nor does anyone else.

Speculate on something with a few less variables if you want to speculate.
 
As to the OP...speculating on currency moves has got to be the closest thing there is to an absolute coin toss type gamble. You have absolutely no clue what the US versus Canadian dollar will be in years from now...nor does anyone else.

Speculate on something with a few less variables if you want to speculate.

Agreed. Pick something with an underlying trend and if you stay invested for the long term you should expect to capture some gains.

D.
 
If the commodity price gets high, than the volatility measured in dollars increases as well on averge. So the margin should be raised along with it.

They do it whenever they want for whatever reason they want. Of course if the commodity price has tripled and the margin has doubled, the margin is in fact less than it was before in percentage terms.

But my reasons stand. What is the PURPOSE of margin? To ensure their protection form sudden swings wiping out participants so that there is a shortfall that the exchange is responsible for.

Here is a quick look at the initial margin requirement for spec traders (legitimate hedgers/members have a lower requirement) over several dates they were increased:

Date: November 10th, 2010
Spot Price: $27.18
Contract Value: $135,900 (5000 x $27.18)
Margin Requirement: $8,775 (6.5% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 15:1

Date: November 16th, 2010
Spot Price: $25.40
Contract Value: $127,000 (5000 x $25.40)
Margin Requirement: $9,788 (7.7% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 13:1

Date: December 17th, 2010
Spot Price: $29.15
Contract Value: $145,750 (5000 x $29.15)
Margin Requirement: $10,463 (7.2% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 14:1

Date: January 21st, 2011
Spot Price: $27.45
Contract Value: $137,250 (5000 x $27.45)
Margin Requirement: $11,138 (8.1% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 12:1

Date: March 24th, 2011
Spot Price: $37.26
Contract Value: $186,300 (5000 x $37.26)
Margin Requirement: $11,745 (6.3% of full contract value)
Resulting Leverage: 16:1



Notice how the leverage remains within a fairly small range? As you can see while the margin requirements have increased quite significantly over the last 6 months the amount of leverage available is still relatively similar.

While your math is correct, this is not the way they increased it. They increased the MINIMUM deposit for margins I believe. When you buy a contract and it appreciates yoru margin actually DECLINES as your purchase price is unchanged. In this case, by increasing the minimums, they forced liquidations on many contract holders.
 
Margin always is a 'minimum'.

Sure, they raise margins, participants who are leveraged to the hilt have to liquidate if they can't come up with more margin. With the moves we've seen in silver they would have been forced out anyhow. And no, it wasn't the margin increase in silver that brought silver down - it was the fantastic runup combined with a sell-off in all commodities.
 
Margin always is a 'minimum'.

Sure, they raise margins, participants who are leveraged to the hilt have to liquidate if they can't come up with more margin. With the moves we've seen in silver they would have been forced out anyhow. And no, it wasn't the margin increase in silver that brought silver down - it was the fantastic runup combined with a sell-off in all commodities.

Possibly with a slight nudge from the margin increases.